Actual Budget

Actual Budget is a free, open-source, local-first personal finance app built around envelope budgeting methodology. Originally created by developer James Long as a commercial product, it was open-sourced in 2022 and is now maintained by a community of contributors. The app emphasizes privacy, data ownership, and offline functionality, with optional self-hosted sync across devices using end-to-end encryption.

3/ 100
Healthy
1No Decay↑Improving

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-30. Score revised 2026-10-30: 5 → 3.

Score History

Milestone← Announced Actual (2017)CriticalMajor
Commercial Launch (2019–2022) · 7/100Commercial LaunchVolunteer Open Source (2022–2025) · 4/100Volunteer Open SourcePaid Contributor Model (2025–present) · 3/100Paid ContributorModel10075502502020202220242026-10Commercial Launch (2019–2022) · 7/100Volunteer Open Source (2022–2025) · 4/100Paid Contributor Model (2025–present) · 3/100743MilestonesProduct Hunt Launch (2019)Open-Sourced Under MIT (2022)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Commercial Launch
7/100
2019-01-29 – 2022-04-29

James Long launches Actual publicly on Product Hunt as a closed-source, local-first budgeting app with CRDT sync, sold as a $4/month subscription. A 2019 API let users script against and export their local data, but the code and sync service stayed proprietary. Built part-time alongside a full-time job, it reached about 800 paying users and roughly $3,200/month, which Long judged unsustainable.

Volunteer Open Source
4/100-3
2022-04-29 – 2025-06-08

Long open-sources Actual under the MIT license. The code is now open, but the legacy hosted subscription keeps running until it shuts down in 2024. A volunteer core team recruited from active community members clears a backlog of unreviewed pull requests and ships monthly releases: European bank sync in 2023, SimpleFIN for the US and Canada in 2024, then stable dashboards and multi-user support. The product improves quickly, but all maintenance rests on unpaid volunteers.

Paid Contributor Model
3/100-1
2025-06-08 – present

In June 2025 the project proposes paying core maintainers from community donations. The trial starts in July, becomes permanent in October 2025, and in January 2026 the pool doubles to $2,000 a month. Monthly releases keep adding features, including new bank-sync providers after GoCardless closed to new users, a stable command-line tool and in-app notifications. A cluster of multi-user security flaws in 2026 was patched and disclosed publicly.

Alternatives

YNAB20/100

The commercial envelope budgeting app that inspired Actual Budget. Hosted interface, built-in reporting, and bank syncing — but costs $14.99/month after a free trial. Actual’s built-in YNAB importer supports moving from YNAB to Actual. YNAB increased its annual price to $109 in 2024.

Modern personal finance dashboard combining budgeting, net worth tracking, and investment monitoring, with bank syncing. $14.99/month subscription. CSV import of transactions and balances is available. Better for users who want a hosted experience without self-hosting.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Actual is still improving under community development, with monthly releases through October 2026. Recent ones added mobile schedules and Flathub packaging (26.1.0), Enable Banking sync and stable custom themes (26.6.0), a stable command-line tool and New Zealand bank sync (26.7.0), and in-app notifications (26.10.0). Removals are occasional and announced: 25.8.0 removed mobile running balances for performance and 25.12.0 restored them, and 26.6.0 deprecated rule action templating in favor of formulas. The main setback came from outside: GoCardless stopped taking new bank-data accounts in July 2025, which hit new European users. A January 2026 forum user calls Actual 'Basically like YNAB but cheap and open source.'
How It Got Here
Actual has improved substantially under community development, though features are occasionally removed or deprecated. James Long built a solid local-first budgeting app from 2017 to 2022, but as a solo developer he could only add features slowly. After the 2022 open-source transition, a community maintainer team formed and development sped up. The March 2023 release (v23.3.0) added European bank sync. By September 2023, mobile transaction entry, privacy mode and dark theme had shipped. In 2024, SimpleFIN bank sync arrived for North American users (v24.2.0), and dashboards and tracking budget mode became stable later that year. The 2025 releases added multi-user support (v25.1.0), internationalization via Weblate, transaction tags and a financial independence report. Version 25.8.0 removed mobile running balances for performance, and 25.12.0 restored them. From July 2025, GoCardless stopped accepting new bank-data accounts, which hit new European users. Later releases added Enable Banking (26.6.0) and Akahu (26.7.0) as experimental providers. Releases in 2026 brought mobile schedules, Flathub packaging, a stable CLI, customizable transaction tables and in-app notifications; 26.6.0 deprecated rule action templating in favor of formulas. Users regularly compare Actual favorably with YNAB, especially since it is free.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2019Commercial Launch2022Volunteer Open Source2025Paid Contributor ModelUser Value111Biz Exploit000Shareholder100Lock-in211Algorithms100Dark Patterns000Advertising100Competition000Labor/Gov121Regulatory000
Timeline (44 events)
major2017-11-28

James Long Announces Actual Budgeting App

Developer James Long, known for creating Prettier and working on Firefox DevTools at Mozilla, publicly announces Actual as a personal budgeting system he has been developing. The announcement signals an interest-gathering phase before a full product launch.

major2019-01-29

Actual Launches on Product Hunt

Actual launches publicly on Product Hunt, achieving #4 Product of the Day. The app uses CRDT-based sync with local SQLite storage. In a June 6, 2019 retrospective, James Long reports approximately 35 paid subscribers.

minor2019-08-08

James Long Builds API for Local-First Budget Access

James Long announces a public API for Actual, allowing users to run scripts against their local budget data. The API enables importing transactions, exporting data, and building custom integrations, with changes syncing live across all devices.

minor2021-03-11

James Long Presents Building Actual Budget at Fission

Fission hosts James Long for a Building Actual Budget event. The listing identifies him as Actual’s creator and highlights his work porting the desktop app to the web. Fission’s report describes Actual as a local-first app using SQLite and CRDTs to synchronize across web, mobile and desktop apps, and says Long explained how and why he built it and how it evolved.

minor2021-08-24

absurd-sql Enables SQLite in Browser for Actual

James Long releases absurd-sql, a library enabling persistent SQLite in web browsers by using IndexedDB as a storage backend. The technology achieves up to 10x read performance gains over raw IndexedDB and becomes a key enabler of Actual's local-first web experience.

critical2022-04-29

James Long Open-Sources Actual Under MIT License

James Long announces that he is open-sourcing Actual under the MIT license. He says he was 'sad that I couldn’t make it work as a sustainable company.' The announcement opens the codebase to community development; it does not immediately shut down the original hosted service.

D3D4D5D7D9
X (Twitter) ↗
minor2022-07-01

James Long Discusses Open-Source Transition on Changelog

James Long appears on Changelog podcast episode #495 to discuss the open-sourcing decision. He explains the challenges of running Actual as a one-person business while holding a full-time job, and expresses hope that the community will carry the project forward.

major2023-03-09

Community Release Adds European Bank Sync

Version 23.3.0 ships as a community-driven release. It introduces experimental Nordigen bank sync for European bank accounts, editable transaction filters, server auto-configuration, update notifications, and Safari compatibility fixes. The release demonstrates the community's ability to ship substantial features.

minor2023-06-13

Project Consolidates Under actualbudget.org Domain

The open-source project moves its website, documentation, demo instance and other project URLs from actualbudget.com to actualbudget.org. The change establishes the community project’s own domain while the original hosted subscription service continues separately.

minor2023-07-04

Nordigen Bank Sync Graduates to Stable Feature

Version 23.7.0 moves European bank sync via Nordigen (later GoCardless) from experimental to stable status. The integration supports free bank connections for EU/UK users, providing a key feature that previously required commercial alternatives.

minor2023-09-01

Mobile Transaction Entry and Privacy Mode Added

Version 23.9.0 adds the ability to enter transactions from mobile devices, a privacy mode to mask balance amounts in public settings, category spending reports, and the first phase of dark theme support. These features address long-standing user requests.

minor2023-12-15

Community Guide Explains Goal Templates

A community guide explains Actual’s existing goal templates, which allow users to automate budget allocation using #template syntax in category notes. Templates support fixed amounts, percentage-based allocation, and schedule-linked budgeting, reducing the manual effort of monthly budget setup.

major2024-01-01

Legacy Hosted Subscription Service Shut Down

Actual's original hosted subscription service, which had kept running for paying users after the 2022 open-sourcing, was shut down in 2024. The project FAQ gives only the year. Users still on the old Actual Budget Desktop App are pointed to a migration guide for moving to the open-source edition, which leaves no paid first-party Actual service.

major2024-02-01

SimpleFIN Bank Sync Added for US and Canada

Version 24.2.0 introduces experimental SimpleFIN bank sync integration for US and Canadian bank accounts at $15/year. This fills a major feature gap for North American users who previously had no automated bank sync option in the open-source version.

minor2024-07-01

Actual Publishes Direct YNAB Comparison

Actual Budget publishes a detailed feature comparison against YNAB on its blog, positioning itself as a viable alternative for users unhappy with YNAB's price increases to $109/year. The comparison highlights Actual's data ownership, open-source code, and zero-cost model against YNAB's advantages in polish and bank sync.

minor2024-10-03

SimpleFIN Officially Released and Dashboards Added

Version 24.10.0 officially releases SimpleFIN bank sync as a first-party feature and adds text widget support for dashboards. Users can now save filters and time ranges on cash-flow and spending widgets, creating customizable financial overview pages.

minor2024-12-06

Dashboards and Tracking Budget Become First-Party Features

Version 24.12.0 officially releases the dashboard reporting system and tracking budget mode as first-party features after months in experimental status. Context menus are added across transactions, budget, schedules, payees, and rules pages, improving UX consistency.

major2025-01-02

Roadmap Recounts Volunteer Community Takeover

Matiss Janis Aboltins recounts joining Actual after YNAB raised his legacy subscription price by nearly 100%, helping obtain repository access to review roughly 50 open pull requests, and recruiting a larger core maintainer team from active community members. These maintainers volunteered their time without salary or benefits.

major2025-01-05

Multi-User Support and OpenID Authentication Added

Version 25.1.0 introduces experimental multi-user support with OpenID Connect authentication, allowing families to share a single Actual instance with role-based access (Basic and Admin users). The release also adds a calendar report card and budget duplication.

minor2025-03-01

Internationalization Expands With Additional Languages

Version 25.3.0 expands translations across many UI components and starts the application in the browser’s default language. Actual uses Weblate and i18next for translations. Languages are included once at least 50% of strings are translated; individual suggested translations require at least two up-votes. Experimental interface-language switching had already launched in version 25.2.0 on February 5, 2025, with support for the nl, pt-BR, uk and en-GB locales.

minor2025-04-01

Pluggy Bank Sync Adds Brazilian Bank Support

Version 25.4.0 introduces experimental Pluggy.ai bank sync integration for Brazilian banks, expanding Actual's bank sync coverage beyond North America and Europe to Latin America. The integration uses Pluggy's free developer tier.

minor2025-05-03

Transaction Merging and Non-Docker Deployment Added

Version 25.5.0 adds the ability to merge different transactions into a single transaction, download custom reports as images, and run Actual outside Docker without building from source. Cloudflare Access tunnel support is also added.

minor2025-06-03

Desktop Sync Server Simplifies Bank Sync Setup

Version 25.6.0 highlights the ability to run the sync server from within the desktop Electron app, simplifying access to features such as bank sync without a separate Docker installation. Embedded-server support had appeared experimentally in version 25.4.0; accessing this local server from other devices still requires network configuration.

major2025-06-08

Community Approves Maintainer Stipend Program

Actual Budget publishes a proposal for a three-month trial to compensate core maintainers for administrative work, starting July 1. An update on the post records subsequent community approval. The monthly stipend pool is $1,000 (or $500 in quieter months), distributed via a points system through OpenCollective. The 2026 roadmap confirms that maintainer stipends began in 2025.

minor2025-07-01

Command Bar and Auto-Hold Income Features Added

Version 25.7.0 adds a command bar for quick keyboard navigation, the ability to automatically hold funds in income categories for future months, and context menus across the application. These features improve power-user workflows.

major2025-07-01

GoCardless Stops Accepting New Bank Account Data Sign-Ups

Actual's GoCardless setup documentation says that from July 2025 GoCardless stopped accepting new Bank Account Data accounts, the free service behind Actual's European bank sync. Existing users' accounts should keep working, but the sign-up instructions are now outdated for new users.

minor2025-08-02

Dedicated Tags Page and Currency Display Added

Version 25.8.0 introduces a dedicated page for managing transaction tags with user-defined colors, experimental currency symbol display in some areas of the app, and an upgraded keyboard shortcut help menu. Tags become a first-class organizational feature.

minor2025-08-02

Mobile Running Balance Removed for Performance

Release 25.8.0 removes the mobile running balance feature, citing performance for large accounts. The feature was added back in release 25.12.0 in December 2025.

major2025-10-06

Contributor Payments Made Permanent After Trial

Actual announces that its three-month trial paying core contributors from community donations for reviewing pull requests, triaging issues and preparing releases succeeded, and makes the payments permanent. Stipends continue under the transparent points system, and the project says it plans further rewards such as bug bounties.

minor2025-11-15

Project Closes Fully AI-Generated Pull Requests and Issues

Actual says it has started receiving pull requests and issues generated entirely by automated systems, which take as much triage and review time as genuine contributions. It will close submissions that appear 100% AI-generated with no human oversight, while still accepting AI-assisted work that a person has reviewed.

minor2025-12-03

Financial Independence Tracking Report Added

Version 25.12.0 adds an experimental crossover report for tracking financial independence progress, restores the mobile running balance display that 25.8.0 had removed, and adds the ability to create schedules directly from the ledger. The feature set expands beyond basic budgeting into financial planning.

minor2025-12-20

2026 Roadmap Confirms Stipends and 8,000+ PikaPods Users

The 2026 roadmap reports over 8,000 PikaPods users and confirms that donation-funded maintainer stipends began in 2025. It targets a plugin framework, mobile feature parity, and a transaction table rewrite.

minor2026-01-04

Mobile Schedules, Flathub Release and Shared-Budget Fix

Release 26.1.0 makes full schedules functionality available on mobile, shows currency symbols in the budget view, and is officially released on Flathub for Linux users. Its fixes include an authorization bypass that had let non-owners delete shared budgets.

major2026-01-17

Contributor Funding Pool Doubled to $2,000 a Month

Actual extends its contributor rewards beyond core maintenance: merged pull requests, code and docs reviews and issue triage all earn points, and monthly payouts are proportional to each person's share. To cover the wider scope, the project raises its monthly funding pool from $1,000 to $2,000. It declines targeted per-feature donations for now, citing the risks of available third-party tools.

minor2026-02-02

Multiple Dashboard Pages and Custom Themes Released

Version 26.2.0 adds support for multiple dashboard pages, allowing users to create separate views for different financial perspectives. Experimental custom themes and a budget analysis report for tracking category balances are also introduced.

minor2026-02-22

Security Fixes for SimpleFIN and Multi-User Features

Version 26.2.1 releases two critical security fixes affecting SimpleFIN, Pluggy and multi-user features: missing authentication on SimpleFIN and Pluggy, and unauthorized file access in multi-user setups. The release identifies affected users and says users without those features can skip this version.

minor2026-03-02

Important Sync Server Security Fix Released

Version 26.3.0 includes an important security fix for all users of the sync server, along with improvements to bank sync UX, API support for tag management, and custom theme enhancements. The release is recommended for all sync server users.

major2026-04-23

Advisory Discloses Admin Escalation on OpenID-Migrated Servers

A GitHub security advisory discloses that on servers migrated from password authentication to OpenID Connect, any authenticated user, including a basic user, could escalate to admin through a missing authorization check on the change-password endpoint. Versions up to 26.3.0 are affected; release 26.4.0 had listed a fix for a password-change privilege escalation.

minor2026-05-20

Actual Bans Advertising in Its Discord Community

Actual bans advertising in its Discord server, covering paid products, closed-source apps and services built on top of Actual regardless of who promotes them. The project says it cannot verify how such products handle users' data.

minor2026-05-26

Advisories Disclose OpenID Secret Exposure and Path Traversal

Two GitHub security advisories disclose sync-server flaws: the OpenID configuration endpoint in versions up to 26.4.0 exposed the OAuth2 client secret to anyone holding the bootstrap password and lacked rate limiting, and several endpoints contained a path traversal vulnerability. Release 26.5.0 had added authentication rate limiting and a file-upload path traversal fix.

minor2026-06-01

Enable Banking Sync Added; Rule Action Templating Deprecated

Release 26.6.0 adds Enable Banking as an experimental bank-sync provider, makes custom themes and the Crossover report stable, and adds an experimental interface for budget automations and a Balance Forecast report. It also deprecates rule action templating in favor of formulas, with removal planned for a future release.

minor2026-06-12

Three Advisories Disclose Multi-User Authorization Flaws

Actual publishes three GitHub security advisories for OpenID multi-user servers: disabled users kept access through existing session tokens, shared users could perform owner-only file actions such as marking another user's budget deleted, and non-admin users could learn which bank-sync secrets were configured, though not their values.

minor2026-07-02

Command-Line Tool Goes Stable; New Zealand Bank Sync Added

Release 26.7.0 releases the Actual CLI as stable, adds Akahu as an experimental New Zealand bank-sync provider, makes failed bank-sync status persist across devices, and adds tag visibility and bulk tag controls.

minor2026-10-02

Faster Editing, Sturdier Sync and In-App Notifications

Release 26.10.0 speeds up transaction editing, makes syncing more resilient between devices running different versions, adds an in-app Notifications page, and introduces an experimental redesigned sidebar with account groups.

Evidence (44 citations)

D6: Dark Patterns

D7: Advertising & Monetization Pressure

Scoring Log (7 entries)
regrade2026-10-30RESCORED

5→3. Since Feb 2026: monthly releases continued (26.2–26.10: Enable Banking and Akahu bank sync, stable CLI, custom themes, notifications); contributor pay made permanent (Oct 2025) and pool doubled to $2,000/month (Jan 2026); 2026 run of multi-user/OpenID security flaws patched and disclosed via GitHub advisories (Apr–Jun); Discord advertising ban (May 2026); no lawsuits, regulator actions or monetization changes. D6 1→0 (recalibration: no dark pattern in the record; sync-server setup is a usability limit, not manipulation), D8 1→0 (recalibration: no anticompetitive conduct in the record; importers, MIT license, no acquisitions). Others unchanged. Eras: 'Commercial Launch' re-dated 2019-01-01→2019-01-29 (Product Hunt launch), re-scored 10→7 (D3 2→1, D4 3→2, D6 1→0 recalibrated); 'Open-Source Rebirth' (2022-05-01) and 'Community Momentum' (2024-01-01, no inflection event) merged into 'Volunteer Open Source' re-dated to 2022-04-29 (MIT open-sourcing); final era re-dated 2026-02-19→2025-06-08 (stipend proposal) and relabeled 'Maturing Community'→'Paid Contributor Model'. Added 2024 hosted-service shutdown (FAQ gives year only), GoCardless July 2025 sign-up closure and 25.8.0 running-balance removal as historical gap-fills; timeline event 25 now notes the 25.12.0 restoration.

restore-check2026-10-30RESTORED

Checked 7 removed/trimmed candidates: 0 restored, 2 partly restored, 5 confirmed removed, 0 already present. PARTLY RESTORED: timeline:update:18 — Actual Budget release 25.2.0 (https://actualbudget.org/blog/release-25.2.0/) establishes the multilingual-interface launch on February 5, 2025 with nl, pt-BR, uk and en-GB, rather than a March launch into 42 languages. Added a supporting release evidence item; kept all existing March expansion and voting/threshold corrections. PARTLY RESTORED: timeline:update:3 — Fission’s archived March 11, 2021 host report (https://web.archive.org/web/20210615140619/https://blog.fission.codes/building-actual-budget-with-james-long/) confirms the SQLite/CRDT synchronization context; hybrid logical clocks and offline/background-sync exposition remain unestablished. CONFIRMED REMOVED: timeline:update:7 — exact October 1, 2022 takeover date; timeline:update:26 — December 2025 star-count and Docker-figure attribution; evidence:remove:28 — SoftwareSuggest feature; evidence:update:16 — annual pay-what-you-want plan; evidence:update:32 — exact 42-language historical count. Underlying takeover, architecture, donations, Weblate and January 2025 Docker facts remain in the current record. Read original live pages, attempted archives, checked named origins and date drift, and used at most 3 search calls per candidate. GitHub archive of December 18, 2025 shows 23.7k stars. Archive/403/429 failures were not treated as negative evidence. Full candidate findings: work/restore-check-findings.json. No removals or score changes.

fact-audit2026-10-29FABRICATION FOUND

Checked all 67 timeline/evidence/milestone items plus 2 alternatives and all prose/metadata. 26 verified, 25 corrected (10 date-only), 16 re-sourced, 2 removed. Strict invented detail: D3 narrative’s $4,000/month revenue is contradicted by James Long’s explicit $3,200/month in https://changelog.com/podcast/495. Wrong-entity iOS listing removed; SoftwareSuggest coverage unsupported, not fabricated. True 35-paid-subscriber figure retained at June 2019, not called invented. Unsupported distinct details: SoftwareSuggest coverage, annual pay-what-you-want plan, exact 42-language count, October 2022 takeover date, historical 25,000-stars/2,200-forks attribution, and detailed subjects of unreadable Fission talk (underlying architecture preserved separately). All FIX/REVIEW decisions logged in work/lead-decisions.json. No scores or era dates changed.

Alternatives Review2026-09-26MINOR FIXES

Removed typed-in site scores from alternatives text (they go stale on re-score; the page shows live scores). No other changes.

Deep Enrichment2026-03-15
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-19