Amica Mutual

Amica Mutual is a policyholder-owned mutual insurance company founded in 1907, offering auto, home, renters, and umbrella insurance across most U.S. states. As a mutual insurer, Amica has no external shareholders, and eligible policyholders can choose dividend-paying policies that return a portion of premiums.

30/ 100
Early Warning
1No Decay→Stable

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-25. Score revised 2026-10-25: 27 → 30.

Score History

MilestoneCriticalMajor
Mutual Auto Pioneer (1907–1956) · 5/100Mutual Auto PioneerMulti-Line Diversification (1956–1973) · 8/100Multi-LineDiversific…Amica Mutual Consolidation (1973–2005) · 12/100Amica MutualConsolidationDiMuccio Modernization (2005–2017) · 19/100DiMucc…Catastrophe Pressure (2017–2022) · 24/100Shallcross Rate Reset (2022–present) · 30/100Shallc…10075502501910192019301940195019601970198019902000201020202026-10Mutual Auto Pioneer (1907–1956) · 5/100Multi-Line Diversification (1956–1973) · 8/100Amica Mutual Consolidation (1973–2005) · 12/100DiMuccio Modernization (2005–2017) · 19/100Catastrophe Pressure (2017–2022) · 24/100Shallcross Rate Reset (2022–present) · 30/1005812192430MilestonesFounded (1907)Merged Automobile Mutual & Factory Mutual (1973)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Mutual Auto Pioneer
5/100
1907-01-01 – 1956-01-01

A.T. Vigneron founded the Automobile Mutual Insurance Company of America in Providence as a policyholder-owned insurer offering auto, fire and theft coverage, and a companion liability mutual was chartered in 1914. The mutual structure removed outside-shareholder extraction by design. The record holds little else for this period, and the 1941 Boston office began its geographic expansion.

Multi-Line Diversification
8/100+3
1956-01-01 – 1973-01-01

Amica began writing homeowners insurance in 1956, creating its first auto-plus-home bundling and mild switching costs, and later added marine and umbrella lines. Amica Life wrote its first policy in 1970, opening life insurance cross-selling. The company remained a policyholder-owned mutual with no documented conduct problems.

Amica Mutual Consolidation
12/100+4
1973-01-01 – 2005-02-10

The 1973 merger of Automobile Mutual and Factory Mutual Liability created Amica Mutual Insurance Company, combining auto, home and life lines under one name with deeper multi-policy bundling. Amica moved to a larger Lincoln, Rhode Island campus in 1994 and set up its foundation in 1996. Advertising grew late in the era with the 2003-2007 Macy's parade float.

DiMuccio Modernization
19/100+7
2005-02-10 – 2017-02-03

Robert DiMuccio became CEO in February 2005 (adding the chairman title in 2008) and moved claims, policy and billing onto Guidewire systems. Service rankings stayed strong and Amica ran TV brand campaigns. The first documented conduct findings appeared: a 2012 Massachusetts settlement over allegedly inflated motorcycle values used in premiums, and a 2015 Missouri order over unpaid sales tax on total-loss claims.

Catastrophe Pressure
24/100+5
2017-02-03 – 2022-06-17

AM Best cut Amica from A++ to A+ in February 2017, citing catastrophe losses and auto claims severity. Amica then shifted auto to six-month terms (2018-2021), launched the CARE CRM, adopted predictive claims triage and StreetSmart telematics, and raised advertising to $167 million in 2021. Claims settlements came under scrutiny in Florida and Washington class actions and in Illinois and North Carolina exams. Rhode Island let Amica classify its 2020 COVID-19 auto relief, expected to total about $84.2 million, as policyholder dividends.

Shallcross Rate Reset
30/100+6
2022-06-17 – present

Ted Shallcross was named CEO in June 2022, as auto and homeowners losses in 2022-2023 eroded surplus and led AM Best to a negative outlook in February 2024. Amica responded with large rate increases (California homeowners up 31.1% and about 21% in 2024), dividend cuts and a pullback toward its northeastern core, returning to operating profitability with a 102.7% combined ratio in 2025 and a stable outlook in March 2026. Since then rate actions have been modest, claims satisfaction has stayed at the top of the industry, and new credit-scoring models and older claims settlements, such as Arizona's UM/UIM case, have defined the record.

Alternatives

A regional auto and home insurer with strong customer-satisfaction recognition. Erie sells through independent agents in 12 states and Washington, D.C.; check availability before comparing renewal quotes.

USAA33/100

An auto and home insurance option focused on the military community. Eligibility includes active-duty military, Guard and Reserve members, eligible veterans, and qualifying spouses and children; check USAA's membership rules before seeking a quote.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Amica still delivers top-tier service: first in J.D. Power's 2025 home and renters study, first in New England auto satisfaction, and first in the 2026 property claims study. The pressure is on price and terms. California approved homeowners increases of 31.1% and about 21% in 2024, Texas homeowners rates rose 13% in 2023, and AM Best cited dividend cuts among the 2024 corrective measures. In the past year rate actions were modest or negative (Texas auto -1.5%, North Carolina auto -2%, Nevada homeowners +5% requested), though Virginia's Good Driver Rewards program is being replaced with an optional accident-forgiveness endorsement. The NAIC auto complaint index rose to 1.03 in 2024.
How It Got Here
For most of its history Amica delivered unusually strong policyholder value as a mutual competing on service, accumulating more than 65 J.D. Power awards. Early lapses were limited: in 2012 it agreed to refund more than $800,000 to Massachusetts motorcyclists over allegedly inflated vehicle values used in premiums. Pressure on value rose after catastrophe losses led AM Best to downgrade Amica in 2017. Amica P&C moved auto policies to six-month terms from 2018 to 2021, allowing more frequent repricing, while 2020 COVID relief returned premium to drivers. After the 2022-2023 losses, the price side worsened: Texas homeowners rates rose 13% in 2023, a 54.1% Florida dwelling-fire request reached a public hearing in February 2024, and California approved homeowners increases of 31.1% in June and about 21% in December 2024. AM Best listed dividend reductions among the corrective steps, and the NAIC auto complaint index rose from 0.72 in 2023 to 1.03 in 2024. The January 2025 California wildfires cost Amica about $240 million. Since late 2025 rate actions have been small or negative, including a 1.5% Texas auto cut and a 2% North Carolina auto decrease, though Virginia's Good Driver Rewards program is being replaced by an optional endorsement. Service remains top-ranked: first in J.D. Power's 2025 home and renters study and the 2026 property claims study, and a free Flume leak-monitor program began in October 2026.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

1907Mutual Auto Pioneer1956Multi-Line Diversification1973Amica Mutual Consolidation2005DiMuccio Modernization2017Catastrophe Pressure2022Shallcross Rate ResetUser Value111223Biz Exploit111233Shareholder000011Lock-in123333Algorithms011234Dark Patterns001234Advertising112233Competition001112Labor/Gov111223Regulatory011334
Timeline (66 events)
critical1907-01-01

Automobile Mutual Insurance Company Founded in Providence

A.T. Vigneron founded the Automobile Mutual Insurance Company of America in Providence, Rhode Island, offering auto, fire, and theft insurance. Organized as a mutual company owned by policyholders, it became the oldest mutual insurer of automobiles in the United States.

minor1914-01-01

Factory Mutual Liability Insurance Company Chartered

The Factory Mutual Liability Insurance Company of America was chartered to provide liability insurance to Automobile Mutual policyholders, expanding the product range beyond the original auto, fire, and theft offerings.

major1941-01-01

First Branch Office Opens in Boston

Amica opened its first branch office in Boston, Massachusetts, beginning a geographic expansion from its Rhode Island headquarters. By 2014, it had 44 offices across the country.

major1956-01-01

Homeowners Insurance Added

Amica began issuing homeowners insurance in 1956, expanding its automotive, fire, theft, and liability offerings. It later added marine and umbrella insurance.

major1970-01-01

Amica Life Insurance Company Begins Operations

Amica Life Insurance Company, chartered in 1969, wrote its first life insurance policy in 1970. This subsidiary expanded Amica's product suite to include life insurance alongside auto and home policies, enabling cross-selling and bundling across all major personal insurance lines.

critical1973-01-01

Automobile Mutual and Factory Mutual Merge

Automobile Mutual Insurance Company of America and Factory Mutual Liability Insurance Company of America merged into Amica Mutual Insurance Company, consolidating operations into a more efficient corporate identity.

minor1994-01-01

Corporate Headquarters Relocated to Lincoln Campus

Amica moved its corporate offices from Providence, Rhode Island, to a larger campus in nearby Lincoln.

minor1996-01-01

Amica Companies Foundation Established

The Amica Companies Foundation was formally created in 1996, focusing on harnessing enduring relationships to help individuals, families, and communities become economically independent. Amica separately reports that its employees direct more than $1 million in giving each year through its charitable programs.

minor2003-11-27

Amica Debuts Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade Float

Amica made its Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade debut with the 'American Classic Malt Shop' float, a 25-foot-tall, 35-foot-long vintage-themed creation. The float appeared for five consecutive years through 2007, marking a major advertising investment for the mutual insurer funded by policyholder premiums.

major2005-02-10

Robert DiMuccio Named CEO and President

Robert A. DiMuccio was named president and chief executive officer after joining Amica in 1991 and rising through VP, treasurer, and CFO roles. He led Amica for 17 years, overseeing the technology modernization documented in later Guidewire announcements and continued J.D. Power recognition.

minor2005-08-16

Amica Selects Guidewire ClaimCenter

Amica selected Guidewire ClaimCenter for on-premises deployment to modernize its legacy claims infrastructure and move to electronic claim files. This began a long-term technology partnership that would eventually encompass claims, policy administration, and billing systems.

major2008-09-16

Guidewire ClaimCenter Fully Deployed for All Lines

Amica fully deployed Guidewire ClaimCenter as its claims management system across auto, homeowners, marine, and personal excess liability lines. The system served 2,500 active users including 1,100 claims professionals, enabling a transition to a paperless claims environment integrated with over 20 internal and external systems.

minor2009-05-13

Amica Selects Guidewire PolicyCenter for Underwriting

Amica selected Guidewire PolicyCenter as its new policy administration and underwriting system, planning a phased implementation starting with auto and expanding to homeowners, marine, and personal excess liability. The planned system would replace legacy infrastructure and enable faster response to business changes.

minor2011-02-21

Amica Launches Eight-State TV Brand Campaign

Amica launched a brand campaign focused on what it feels like to be an Amica customer, developed by Cronin and Company. It included two 30-second and two 15-second TV spots and ran in eight states: Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Massachusetts, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Texas and Washington.

minor2012-09-11

Guidewire BillingCenter Selected for Billing Management

Amica selected Guidewire BillingCenter as its new billing management system for all lines of business across all states, completing its selection of Guidewire InsuranceSuite products (ClaimCenter, PolicyCenter, BillingCenter). ClaimCenter was in production since 2008 and PolicyCenter implementation was underway; a unified technology stack was the goal.

major2012-12-04

Amica Settles Massachusetts Motorcycle Overcharge Allegations

Under an assurance of discontinuance with the Massachusetts Attorney General, Amica agreed to pay policyholders more than $800,000 to resolve allegations that it overcharged motorcycle customers by using inflated, un-depreciated motorcycle values to calculate premiums. Amica and Encompass together also made civil payments of $93,600 to the Commonwealth.

minor2015-01-01

Missouri Market Conduct Order Over Total-Loss Sales Tax

A 2015 Missouri order approved a stipulation after an investigation found Amica failed to include sales tax in two first-party auto total-loss settlements although its policy provided for it. Amica agreed to a $2,000 voluntary forfeiture and to review total-loss claims back to May 1, 2010, paying restitution where sales tax had not been paid.

critical2017-02-03

AM Best Downgrades Amica From Perfect A++ Rating

AM Best downgraded Amica's Financial Strength Rating from A++ (Superior) to A+ (Superior), ending the company's perfect rating. The downgrade cited deteriorating underwriting results driven by increased catastrophe losses and elevated automobile claims severity, with 2015 producing negative operating cash flow from higher-than-normal catastrophe experience.

major2018-06-07

CARE CRM System Launched with Salesforce and Guidewire

Amica deployed its CARE (Customer Acquisition, Retention, and Engagement) system, combining Salesforce Financial Services Cloud with Guidewire applications to create a 360-degree view of policyholders. The system provided representatives with actionable insights from policy, claims, and billing data in a single interface.

major2018-11-01

Amica P&C Begins Conversion to Six-Month Auto Policies

Amica Property and Casualty Insurance Company, Amica Mutual's wholly owned subsidiary, began converting auto policies in select states to six-month periods at renewal in November 2018. New auto policies in affected states were written exclusively with six-month terms to respond more quickly to underwriting conditions. Its financial statements say the rollout was complete by December 31, 2021; this disclosure does not date a simultaneous transition across all Amica Mutual policies.

major2019-06-24

Amica Announces Migration to Guidewire Cloud on AWS

Amica announced that it would migrate from on-premises Guidewire InsurancePlatform to Guidewire Cloud, a SaaS solution powered by Amazon Web Services. It had been a Guidewire customer since 2005. A later conference account described its core-outward strategy of moving enterprise-class applications to the cloud first; that account is separately cited in evidence.

major2019-07-02

Florida Total Loss Class Action Filed Against Amica

A plaintiff filed a class action lawsuit (Cruz-Santiago v. Amica Mutual) claiming Amica breached its auto insurance policies by failing to pay title transfer fees and license plate registration fees to customers with Florida first-party total loss auto claims. The class covered claims from July 2, 2014 onward.

major2020-01-01

Washington Diminished Value Class Action Filed

Washington state drivers filed a class action (Brunswick v. Amica) claiming the insurer systematically undervalued vehicles in auto insurance diminished value claims. The suit covered accidents after March 23, 2014, for vehicles under six years old with repairs exceeding $1,000.

major2020-04-09

COVID-19 Auto Premium Relief Program Announced

Amica launched its COVID-19 Auto Premium Relief Program on April 9, 2020, providing eligible existing auto policyholders a 20% credit for two months. A second program launched June 25 refunded up to 10% of monthly auto premiums for four more months, totaling up to six months of relief. Amica also temporarily stopped policy cancellations for customers facing pandemic hardship. In its April 10 announcement, Amica said the hardship measures, including stopped cancellations and non-renewals, would remain in effect through June 2, 2020. ProgramBusiness independently reported that June 2 cutoff for cancellations due to unpaid premiums.

minor2020-06-01

Rhode Island Approves COVID Relief as Policyholder Dividends

Effective June 2020, the Rhode Island Department of Business Regulation Insurance Division permitted Amica Mutual to classify COVID-19 relief funds as dividends paid to policyholders. Reduced driving and auto accidents lowered losses during spring sheltering. The company expected to disburse approximately $84.2 million under its relief program.

major2020-10-02

Illinois Exam Finds Total-Loss Underpayments; Amica Reimburses

Illinois's market conduct examination found that in 55 of 82 reviewed first-party auto total-loss claim files (67.07%), Amica failed to pay required sales taxes and transfer and title fees at settlement and misstated relevant coverage facts; it had altered the vendor valuation's sales-tax amount, causing underpayments. Amica reimbursed all affected policyholders back to May 1, 2018, and the Department closed the exam on proof of compliance.

major2020-11-11

Florida Total Loss Class Action Settlement Approved

A court granted final approval to the Cruz-Santiago v. Amica class action settlement in Florida. The settlement addressed allegedly unpaid title and registration transfer fees on total loss auto claims, with $79.85 specified for qualifying class members. Amica did not admit wrongdoing. A court-filed settlement listing separately documents the $464,168 total, cited in evidence.

major2021-01-01

Washington Diminished Value Class Action Settled for $484K

Amica agreed to pay $484,800 to settle the Brunswick v. Amica diminished value class action in Washington state. Payments were expected to be in the range of $550 per claimant for qualifying drivers whose vehicles suffered structural or body damage in accidents after March 23, 2014. Amica did not admit wrongdoing.

major2021-01-01

Advertising Spending Reaches $167 Million

Amica's advertising spending reached $167 million in 2021, a 39% increase from the previous year, according to a Dowling & Partners study reported by Repairer Driven News. The study reported $2.07 billion for GEICO and $1.87 billion for Progressive. This was a significant marketing expense for the mutual insurer.

major2021-10-21

StreetSmart Telematics Program Documented in October 2021 Terms

Amica offered StreetSmart by October 2021, when its terms were last updated. The voluntary telematics program uses Cambridge Mobile Telematics and collects location, speed, braking and mobile-device data for driving scores, underwriting and rating. Amica may retain and share aggregated or anonymized data for business purposes; its StreetSmart privacy notice states that it does not sell participants' data to third parties.

major2021-11-03

Guidewire Innovation Award for Predictive Analytics Claims Triage

Amica won its fourth Guidewire Innovation Award for leveraging Predictive Analytics to enhance claims review. The system predicts which claims are suitable for desk review versus field inspection, replacing a manual process where every property claim was thoroughly reviewed before handler assignment. This reduced processing time significantly, especially during catastrophic events.

minor2021-11-16

North Carolina Exam Cites Rating Errors and Claim Delays

A North Carolina target market conduct exam of 2018-2019 found incorrect premiums on 62 of 100 sampled homeowners policies and 10 of 100 auto policies, discounts shown on 12 homeowners declarations pages that did not apply, and undue settlement delays in 5 of 50 bodily-injury claims. Examiners directed refunds of $348.34 and $378.40 and a corrective action plan; sampled paid physical-damage claims showed no violations.

major2022-01-01

Underwriting Losses Mount from Auto and Homeowners Lines

Amica recorded substantial underwriting losses in 2022 driven by turbulent investment markets, rapid interest rate increases, and elevated loss costs in both auto and homeowners lines. The deterioration in risk-adjusted capitalization significantly impacted the company's surplus position and overall liquidity.

major2022-06-17

Edmund Shallcross III Named CEO to Succeed DiMuccio

Amica announced that Edmund (Ted) Shallcross III would become CEO and president effective October 1, 2022, succeeding Robert DiMuccio after 17 years. The appointment followed a year-long search with Heidrick & Struggles. Shallcross previously led Amica Life as senior VP and general manager, having joined in 2007 from KPMG's insurance practice.

major2022-10-01

Arizona UM/UIM Coverage-Stacking Class Action Filed

Chase Whitehead sought class certification in Maricopa County Superior Court in or around October 2022 on behalf of Amica policyholders with stacked uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage on multiple vehicles. The complaint alleged breach of contract and bad faith over Amica paying only one vehicle's coverage limit.

major2022-11-16

New York Fines Amica $200,000 Over Cancellation Notices

New York DFS approved a consent order fining Amica $200,000 after finding that from November 2016 to May 2020 it failed to send notices of cancellation for nonpayment of premium at least 15 days before the cancellation date, as its filed and approved policy condition required.

minor2022-12-30

First Circuit Rejects Home Coverage-Limit Premium Class Appeal

The First Circuit affirmed judgments for Amica in Peter Gottlieb's putative class action alleging Amica set an excessive home replacement-cost coverage limit, using a projected reconstruction-cost multiplier from E2Value, that made his premium $16 too high. The court found no reversible error.

minor2022-12-31

Dividend Policyholders Receive More Than $138 Million

Amica reported that customers with dividend policies received more than $138 million in dividends at year-end 2022, a loss year for the company. As a mutual, Amica describes its policyholders as its collective owners.

minor2023-02-01

Texas Homeowners Renewal Rates Rise 13%

The Texas Department of Insurance's 2023 market conditions report lists a 13% overall rate change for Amica Mutual's homeowners coverage, effective January 1, 2023 for new policies and February 1, 2023 for renewals, driven by revised base rates.

minor2023-09-20

First Circuit Rules Against Merullo in Diminished Value Appeal

The First Circuit affirmed dismissal of Michael Merullo's claims over Amica's denial of inherent diminished value coverage. It concluded that the 2016 Massachusetts standard auto policy excluded IDV coverage unless required by law, and that the refusal to pay was neither unfair nor deceptive under the arguments presented.

major2024-01-01

NAIC Auto Complaint Index Spikes Above Average

Amica's NAIC auto complaint index was 1.03 in 2024, up from 0.72 in 2023. An index of 1.0 is the industry baseline, making the 2024 figure slightly above average. Bankrate also reported zero complaints in 2022; that historical figure is not evidence of a company-wide first-ever above-average result.

critical2024-02-01

AM Best Revises Outlook to Negative Citing Surplus Deterioration

AM Best revised Amica's outlook to negative from stable while affirming the A+ (Superior) FSR. The negative outlook reflected declining risk-adjusted capitalization from substantial underwriting losses in 2022 and 2023, where increased auto and homeowners loss costs significantly impacted surplus and liquidity. AM Best noted Amica was implementing rate increases and reducing dividends as corrective measures.

major2024-02-12

Glassdoor Reviewer Reports Turnover and Retention Bonuses

A Glassdoor claims-adjuster review dated February 12, 2024 reported quarterly retention bonuses amid turnover and said only two people from a 26-person training cohort remained after three years. Other reviews criticized return-to-office policies and workloads. These are employee allegations rather than measured company-wide turnover; an earlier report of 50–60-hour weeks is separately cited in evidence.

major2024-02-20

Florida Hearing on Amica's 54.1% Dwelling Fire Rate Request

Florida held a public hearing on Amica's requested 54.1% average increase for its dwelling fire policies on February 20, 2024. Amica said it affected about 500 of its roughly 17,000 Florida homeowners customers, generally secondary residences or rental properties. Average annual premiums would rise from $295 to $451. The request was distinct from standard homeowners coverage.

major2024-06-01

California Homeowners Rate Increase of 31.1% Approved

California regulators approved Amica's request to increase homeowners insurance rates by 31.1%, renters rates by 15.4%, and condo rates by 14.3% in June 2024. Insurify also reports a nearly 95% California loss ratio in 2023, based on California Department of Insurance data; that ratio alone does not establish the specific causes or actuarial adequacy of the increase.

minor2024-08-20

Amica Joins Insurance Information Institute as Member

Amica joined the Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I) as a member, gaining access to industry economic and underwriting forecast reports and resources from its economists, actuaries, researchers and communications experts. This followed earlier NAMIC membership documented by Insurance Journal in July 2016; that report does not establish uninterrupted membership through August 2024.

major2024-10-21

Amica Announces Merkle Partnership to Modernize Marketing Ecosystem

Amica announced a multiyear partnership with Merkle to modernize marketing through first-party and third-party data integration. The planned ecosystem uses Merkle's Merkury identity solution to improve audience targeting and messaging consistency across channels including direct mail and email in a clean room environment.

critical2024-12-02

Additional 21% California Homeowners Rate Increase Approved

California approved another Amica homeowners rate increase of around 21%, with 14,393 policyholders facing 15–20% hikes and 9,255 facing 20–35% increases at renewal. Condo rates were approved to rise 4.5% and renters 1%. Together with June's 31.1% homeowners approval, this represented two large approved changes in 2024; the article does not document an over-50% increase actually paid by each household within that calendar year.

major2025-05-08

Rhode Island Investment Cap Relief Legislation Introduced

Rep. Alex Finkelman introduced an insurer investment-cap repeal bill on May 8, 2025 at FM's request, with Gov. Dan McKee's support. Amica separately requested similar relief and publicly supported changing Rhode Island's 10% cap on alternative investments. Massachusetts and Connecticut were among ten states without such a limit.

minor2025-06-18

Rhode Island Repeals Insurer Investment Cap Amica Sought

Rhode Island enacted legislation (HB6315/SB1047) repealing the 10% limit on domestic insurers' Schedule BA assets, effective June 18, 2025. Amica had publicly sought this relief earlier in 2025.

minor2025-12-11

Amica Announces COO Ted Murphy's Retirement After 45 Years

On December 11, Amica announced that Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Operations Officer Ted Murphy would retire at the end of 2025 after 45 years. Sam Palmisano, then SVP and CHRO, would assume the COO role January 1, 2026, with Scott Boyd becoming CHRO on the same date.

minor2025-12-31

Amica Puts January 2025 Wildfire Losses Near $240 Million

Amica's 2025 statutory annual statement estimated ultimate losses of about $240 million from the January 2025 Southern California wildfires, with $161,202,039 paid and $78,798,283 in case and IBNR reserves through December 31, 2025.

major2026-02-18

Court Preliminarily Approves $2.875M Arizona UM/UIM Settlement

The District of Arizona preliminarily approved a $2,875,000 common-fund settlement of Whitehead v. Amica over Amica paying only one vehicle's uninsured/underinsured motorist limit on multi-vehicle Arizona policies. The order put the projected value of insurance benefits owed to the class at $1,773,697.67; the settlement releases breach-of-contract and good-faith claims.

minor2026-02-23

Amica Launches 'Back to Zero' Campaign With Jayson Tatum

Amica announced an ad campaign built around basketball player Jayson Tatum's recovery from a 2025 injury, with out-of-home placements in Greater Boston and social media promotions.

minor2026-03-07

Amica Ends Good Driver Rewards in Virginia Auto

A Virginia rate and rule filing submitted March 7, 2026 eliminates Amica's Good Driver Rewards points program, which could waive accident surcharges, replacing it with an optional Auto Accident Forgiveness endorsement; existing points remain usable only for deductible buy-down. The filing also adds optional coverages and moves new business to a new credit-based insurance score model from July 1, 2026.

major2026-03-17

AM Best Revises Outlook Back to Stable

AM Best revised Amica's outlook to stable from negative, affirming the A+ (Superior) FSR. The revision reflected improved balance sheet strength from a return to operating profitability, driven by rate increases, underwriting discipline, and geographic rebalancing toward core northeastern states. Risk-adjusted capitalization returned to the strongest level through 2025.

major2026-03-17

Amica Ranks Highest in J.D. Power 2026 Property Claims Study

Amica ranked first in J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study with 773 points, 71 above the study average and 28 above its own 2025 score, its 12th property-claims award. It led six study categories, including time to settle the claim and level of trust.

minor2026-03-19

Maine Regulator Overturns Amica Homeowners Nonrenewal

In DuBois v. Amica, Maine's Bureau of Insurance ruled for the insureds and barred Amica's nonrenewal of their homeowners policy, which Amica based on three loss events in two years, because its notice did not state the reason specifically enough. A 2024 Maine decision likewise overturned an Amica homeowners nonrenewal.

major2026-04-22

Amica Rolls Out 'Attract One' Credit Scoring Model in Georgia

A Georgia filing moves Amica's auto new business and reorders to the Attract One credit-based scoring model with more granular credit tiers, plus new pricing levers such as Policy Rate Level factors and vehicle-specific scores, effective September 1, 2026, with no overall rate change for 19,212 policyholders. A similar Attract Credit Model filing was made in Kansas.

minor2026-04-29

CEO Ted Shallcross Named Chair of the Board

Amica's board appointed president and CEO Edmund (Ted) Shallcross III as chair, combining the CEO and chair roles.

minor2026-05-12

Amica Loses Duty-to-Defend Appeal on Diminished-Value Claim

In Amica Mutual Ins. Co. v. Gilleran, the Connecticut Appellate Court affirmed that Amica must defend its insured in a negligence suit in which a third party sought diminished value for a repaired vehicle, because the claim could fall within the policy's property-damage coverage. Amica had sought a declaration that it owed no defense.

minor2026-06-04

Amica Cuts Texas Auto Rates 1.5%

Amica filed a 1.5% overall rate decrease for its Texas private passenger auto program, affecting about 45,856 policyholders and reducing written premium by about $2.3 million; actuarial indications supported a 2.8% decrease.

minor2026-08-26

Amica Launches National 'Every Policy Tells a Story' Campaign

Amica announced its integrated brand campaign Every Policy Tells a Story, developed with Mother New York, with spots airing nationally across television, streaming and digital channels. No spending figure was published.

minor2026-09-17

Amica Signs Drake and Ann Michael Maye Ad Partnership

Amica announced a partnership with NFL quarterback Drake Maye and content creator Ann Michael Maye, beginning with a new advertising campaign that debuted the same day.

major2026-09-21

Court Grants Final Approval of Arizona UM/UIM Settlement

The District of Arizona granted final approval of the Whitehead v. Amica class settlement, covering Arizona policyholders who received only one vehicle's UM/UIM limit from October 18, 2016 through July 14, 2024, and entered judgment. Final approval is not a finding of liability.

minor2026-10-07

Amica Offers Eligible Homeowners Free Flume Leak Monitors

Amica announced that eligible home policyholders in participating markets can enroll to receive a no-cost Flume Smart Home Water Monitor, which attaches to the existing water meter and alerts customers to unusual water use.

Evidence (65 citations)

D10: Regulatory & Legal Posture

Amica Mutual Insurance PAC and Political ContributionsProPublica FEC Itemizer · 2020-12-31
Amica Mutual 2020 Rhode Island Regulatory FilingRhode Island Department of Business Regulation · 2020-09-30
NY DFS Consent Order: $200,000 Fine Against AmicaNew York Department of Financial Services · 2022-11-16
Missouri Stipulation and $2,000 Forfeiture Over Total-Loss Sales TaxMissouri Department of Insurance · 2015-01-01
Rhode Island Repeals 10% Schedule BA Investment CapRhode Island Department of Business Regulation · 2025-06-18
Scoring Log (7 entries)
fact-audit2026-10-25FABRICATION FOUND

Checked all 81 original timeline/evidence/milestone items plus two alternatives and all prose/identity fields. Contradicted specifics: (1) first-place property-claims streak through 2025; primary 2025 J.D. Power release ranks Amica second (https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2025-us-property-claims-satisfaction-study; readable republication cited in evidence). (2) poor-credit drivers pay up to 88% more than good-credit drivers; Amica source states higher-credit rates may be up to 88% LOWER than poor-credit rates (https://www.amica.com/resources/auto/what-is-an-insurance-score). Unsupported details are separately counted; CEO pay and 12 resignations are unsupported, not labeled invented. Preserved miscited true details with separate evidence instead of deleting them. Prose claim ledger records each distinct correction once. Unsupported inventory enumerates 23 distinct claims; the 2018 transition date was resolved positively, not counted unsupported. Stats: {"corrected": 23, "dateFixes": 6, "inventedDetails": 2, "itemsChecked": 83, "proseFixes": 47, "removed": 2, "resourced": 27, "unsupportedDetails": 23, "verified": 31}

regrade2026-10-25RESCORED

27→30. D2 2→3 (event: Arizona Whitehead UM/UIM $2.875M settlement preliminarily approved Feb 2026 and finally approved Sep 2026, plus newly added regulator findings of repeated total-loss underpayments in Missouri 2015 and Illinois 2020, North Carolina 2021 claim delays and 2024/2026 Maine nonrenewal reversals, weighed against J.D. Power #1 2026 and Weiss 29.4% no-payment rate). D5 3→4 (recalibration plus event: credit-based scoring with up to 88% spread, voluntary telematics and third-party marketing data match the guide's medium band; 2026 rollout of granular 'Attract' credit models in GA/KS/VA). D6 3→4 (recalibration: phone-only cancellation and PII-first quoting match the guide's medium band; newly added NY DFS $200K fine for late cancellation notices 2016-2020 and NC inapplicable-discount display). Others confirmed: D1 3, D3 1, D4 3, D7 3, D8 2, D9 3, D10 4. Eras: 'National Expansion' re-dated 1994-01-01→1973-01-01 (merger forming Amica Mutual) and relabeled 'Amica Mutual Consolidation'; 'DiMuccio Modernization' re-dated 2005-02-01→2005-02-10 (CEO named); 'Catastrophe Pressure' re-dated 2017-02-01→2017-02-03 (AM Best downgrade); current era re-dated 2026-02-18 (assessment date)→2022-06-17 (Shallcross named CEO as loss years began) and relabeled 'Telematics & Rate Pressure'→'Shallcross Rate Reset'; 'Mutual Auto Pioneer' and 'Multi-Line Diversification' kept. All eras re-scored. Since Oct 2025: rate actions mostly small or negative (TX auto -1.5%, NC auto -2%, AR auto +1%, NV home +5% requested), new Attract credit-scoring models, Virginia Good Driver Rewards ended, J.D. Power 2026 property claims #1, AM Best outlook back to stable, Arizona UM/UIM settlement approved, CT duty-to-defend loss, Maine nonrenewal reversal, CEO named board chair, national ad campaigns and celebrity partnerships, free Flume leak monitors. Rhode Island investment-cap repeal (June 2025) resolves the fact audit's open lead. New Jersey 2018 order remains unread (no readable text).

restore-check2026-10-25RESTORED

Checked all 9 restore candidates: 1 RESTORED, 1 PARTLY RESTORED, 7 CONFIRMED REMOVED, 0 ALREADY PRESENT. RESTORED timeline:update:18: announced June 2, 2020 cancellation/non-renewal cutoff, supported by ProgramBusiness 2020-04-06 and formal Amica program announcement published by PRWeb 2020-04-10. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:35: historical NAMIC membership documented by Insurance Journal 2016-07-11; no uninterrupted August 2024 membership claim. Evidence additions carry the same verdicts and sources. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:3 (1956 rename, housing-boom motive and auto-only origins); :5 (measured redundancy reductions and growing-demand rationale); :6 (1994 move motive and contemporary most-states footprint); :9 ($985,000 CEO compensation and resulting peer comparison); :22 (October 1, 2021 launch precision); :31 (12 branch resignations in six months and company-wide RTO causal acceleration); :34 (wildfire/repair-cost causation for the particular June 2024 rate increase). Original cited pages and Wayback attempted before targeted searches, no more than 3 search queries per candidate. Unreadable archives and blocked Glassdoor pages were not treated as contrary evidence; failed searches yielded no qualifying support. Source-by-source record: work/restore-check-ledger.json. Existing content preserved; scores unchanged.

deep-enrichment-reset2026-03-20

Stripped for Phase 2 re-enrichment

Deep Enrichment2026-03-20
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-18