Carrot Weather
Carrot Weather is a weather forecasting app for Apple and Android platforms known for its snarky AI personality, highly customizable interface, and multiple weather data source options. The app offers free basic forecasts with premium subscription tiers unlocking advanced features like radar maps, Apple Watch complications, and alternative data sources.
Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-26. Score revised 2026-10-26: 22 → 19.
Score History
Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.
Carrot Weather launched on iOS on March 19, 2015 as a $2.99 paid app from solo developer Brian Mueller, delivering Forecast.io (Dark Sky) forecasts through a snarky AI personality. By late 2015 it cost $3.99, with an optional $1.99/year premium subscription for extras and a separate $3.99 Apple TV app. It was humor-first, ad-free and simple, with growing Apple Watch support.
Version 4.0 (July 2017) rebuilt the app around an illustrated one-screen layout with five personality modes and expanded the Premium Club subscription ($2.49/year) to cover Weather Underground data, deep customization and notifications. In November 2017 Mueller rebuilt the Apple Watch app from scratch, a redesign he later called the 'turning point' toward a serious weather app. The base app stayed a one-time purchase of about $4.99.
Version 4.7 (July 2018) put weather maps and future radar in a $9.99/year Ultrapremium tier, and a week later Carrot launched on Android as a free, ad-supported app with a Premium Club. Version 4.9 (December 2018) added selectable data sources, though The Weather Channel cut off its data in July 2019, and a May 2019 restructuring created three tiers ($5/$12/$25 a year) with critical alerts gated. A separate $15 Mac app (2019), Apple's March 2020 purchase of Dark Sky, Carrot's default data source, and subscription-gated iOS 14 widgets rounded out the era.
Version 5.0 made Carrot Weather free to download and restructured subscriptions at $19.99/year (Premium), $39.99/year (Premium Ultra) and $59.99/year (Premium Family), roughly three to four times the old tiers. New users now needed a subscription for widgets, Watch complications and notifications, while existing buyers kept their features and Premium Club pricing. The free version gained joke 'fake ads'. The app won the 2021 Apple Design Award and Apple Watch App of the Year, and new Lock Screen widgets and Live Activities shipped behind Premium.
Apple shut down the Dark Sky iOS app at the start of 2023 and ended its API that March, leaving Carrot as a leading premium iOS weather app that draws on several providers. Its iOS development has stayed strong since (a ChatGPT chatbot, Vision Pro, a CarPlay app, a 2025 glassy redesign, and 2026's multi-model forecasts and Trip Planner), but many headline features ship behind Premium Ultra. The Android app has not been updated since June 2023. Prices have stayed at the 2021 tiers, and the chatbot became free on Apple Intelligence devices in September 2025.
Alternatives
Visualizes multiple weather models (ECMWF, GFS) in an interactive map format — useful for understanding forecast uncertainty. Easy switch and free for basic use. Lacks the polish and widget ecosystem of Carrot, but excellent for weather enthusiasts.
Hyperlocal weather data powered by a network of personal weather stations, offering high accuracy for neighborhood-level forecasts. Easy switch: free with ads, with an annual subscription to remove ads. Less customizable than Carrot but no subscription required for basic use.
Dimensional Breakdown
Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.
Dimension History
Timeline (42 events)
Grailr LLC Founded with Carrot To-Do App
Brian Mueller, a Philadelphia-based screenwriter with no prior development experience, founded Grailr LLC and launched Carrot To-Do, an iOS productivity app featuring a snarky AI personality. The Carrot character's dark humor would become the defining identity across all future Carrot apps.
Carrot Weather Launches on iOS for $2.99
Carrot Weather debuted on the iOS App Store at $2.99, initially focused more on entertainment than weather utility, with the signature Carrot AI personality. Its forecasts used Forecast.io, the same backend that powers Dark Sky, covering current conditions, barometric pressure, wind, visibility, sunrise and sunset, and a 7-day forecast.
Carrot Weather Launches on Apple TV as Separate $3.99 Purchase
Carrot Weather debuted on tvOS for the Apple TV 4th generation as a separate $3.99 purchase: iOS owners had to pay again for the TV version, which marked the first cross-platform purchase fragmentation in the Carrot ecosystem. At the time the iOS app also cost $3.99, with an optional $1.99/year premium subscription for more frequent updates, rain predictions and additional Apple Watch complications. The Verge recommended Carrot Weather in its October 30, 2015 roundup of apps for new Apple TV owners.
Version 4.0 Redesign Expands Premium Club Subscription
Carrot Weather 4.0 brought a complete UI redesign built around a one-screen illustrated landscape, and five personality modes (Professional to Overkill). The optional Premium Club subscription was expanded: for $0.49/month or $2.49/year it unlocked Weather Underground data, near-total customization of the iOS and watchOS apps, and notifications, while Weather Underground data on Apple Watch cost $9.99/year or $1.49/month. The base app remained a one-time $3.99 purchase.
Apple Watch App Rebuilt with New UI, Speech and Radar
CARROT Weather's Apple Watch app was redesigned from the ground up, with a new interface, spoken forecasts via watchOS 4, animated radar on a firm press (U.S. only), full weather alert text, and complications that could show cloud cover, weather alerts and side-by-side Fahrenheit and Celsius temperatures. The app cost $4.99.
Version 4.7 Adds Weather Maps and Future Radar in Ultrapremium Tier
Carrot Weather 4.7 introduced nine new weather map layers and future radar forecasting. The new features went into the Ultrapremium Club subscription at $9.99/year, which added future radar, lightning strikes and 12 additional map layers on top of the $3.99/year Premium Club. The app itself cost $4.99 on the App Store.
Carrot Weather Launches on Android After Beta
After a pre-release beta that began in May 2018, Carrot Weather officially launched on the Google Play Store on July 12, 2018. The Android app was free, with a Premium Club subscription at $0.99/month or $3.99/year that removed ads and added a homescreen widget. Droid Life's launch-day review reported that the Android app lacked weather alerts, including push notifications for upcoming rain or other local weather events.
Siri Shortcuts Integration Adds Voice Automation
Carrot Weather added support for Siri Shortcuts, allowing users to build automated weather queries by voice with 17+ configurable shortcuts including current weather, extended forecast, wind speed, and moon phase data. This deepened Apple ecosystem integration while maintaining transparency in how data was accessed.
Version 4.9 Adds Multiple Weather Data Sources and Netatmo
Carrot Weather 4.9 expanded from Dark Sky as the only data source, letting users choose The Weather Channel, AccuWeather or Aeris Weather as their primary source, plus integration with Netatmo personal weather stations. Netatmo integration, personal weather station lookup, and air quality and pollen data were marked Premium Club only; Premium Club cost $4/year or $0.49/month.
Critical Alerts and Third Subscription Tier Introduced
A major update added critical alerts for US users covering life-threatening weather such as tornado warnings, using iOS 12's Critical Alerts so they sound even when the iPhone is muted or on Do Not Disturb (Tier 1 membership required). The update also introduced a third subscription tier, Tier 3 at $25/year, and renamed the existing tiers: Premium became Tier 1 ($5/year) and Ultrapremium became Tier 2 ($12/year).
The Weather Channel Cuts Off Carrot's Data Feed
Developer Brian Mueller announced that The Weather Channel had unexpectedly terminated its data contract with CARROT Weather, effective July 1, 2019, because it would no longer sell weather data to competing weather apps. Users of that source had to move to the remaining providers, including Dark Sky, AccuWeather and Aeris Weather.
iOS 13 Support Adds Dark Mode and Independent Watch App
Carrot Weather updated for iOS 13 with system-wide Dark Mode, full Siri Shortcuts parameters, iPad multiwindow support, and a fully independent Apple Watch app that no longer required the iPhone nearby. The independent Watch app deepened ecosystem investment for Apple Watch users.
Mac Catalyst App Launches at $15 Separate Purchase
Carrot Weather launched on macOS via Apple's Catalyst framework alongside macOS Catalina. The Mac version was priced at $15 as a separate purchase from the iOS app, though existing Mac app owners received a free upgrade. This continued the pattern of per-platform pricing within the Carrot ecosystem.
Apple Acquires Dark Sky, Threatening Carrot's Data Source
Apple bought Dark Sky, the hyperlocal weather service that was Carrot Weather's default forecast source. Dark Sky announced the deal in a blog post: its API stopped accepting new signups but would keep working through the end of 2021, the Android app was to be shut down, and the iOS app stayed on sale with no immediate changes. The API change put third-party apps like Carrot Weather under pressure to find other data providers.
iOS 14 Widgets: 12 Options Unlocked by In-App Purchases
Carrot Weather 4.16 added five iOS 14 widget types in three sizes (12 options in total) and 25 Apple Watch complications. In-app purchases were needed to unlock the widgets: Tier 1 for the Hourly and Daily widgets and frequent background widget updates, and Tier 3 for the Weather Maps widget. The app was a $4.99 download with in-app purchases from $0.99/month.
Version 5.0: Free-to-Download Model with Higher Subscription Prices
Carrot Weather 5.0 dropped the $4.99 upfront price and became free to download with an optional premium subscription. The new tiers cost $19.99 per year (Premium), $39.99 per year (Premium Ultra) and $59.99 per year (Premium Family), several times the previous $5-$25 yearly tiers. Features such as widgets and Apple Watch complications are unlocked by Premium. Existing customers kept the original app's features and had their Premium Club pricing locked in, and the free version shows ads only for other indie apps or fake products. The redesign added card-based sections and the Interface Maker customization tool. The redesign also switched to a vertical layout, as documented in 9to5Mac's launch review.
Version 5.2 Deepens Layout Customization with Premium Gates
Carrot Weather 5.2 overhauled layout customization with live previews for layout presets and individual sections, and added new Maps and Alerts sections. The Weather Maps section was exclusive to Premium Ultra subscribers ($39.99/year). The update also added tide data to certain existing sections and multiple font choices in a new Display settings section.
Wins Apple Design Award for Interaction
Apple awarded Carrot Weather the 2021 Apple Design Award in the Interaction category at WWDC, recognizing the app's unique combination of weather data delivery, customization, and personality-driven design. The award validated the product quality of a solo developer competing against major companies.
Apple Postpones Dark Sky Shutdown, Extending Carrot's API Reprieve
Macworld reported that Apple had postponed the Dark Sky iOS app's shutdown to the end of 2022. It noted that third-party apps using the Dark Sky API, including Carrot Weather, gained a reprieve.
Smart Layouts and Weather Report Videos Added
Version 5.3 introduced Smart Layouts, which automatically switch the app's display based on conditions (e.g., showing precipitation-focused UI when rain is expected). Users could also record 30-second weather report videos with AI-generated scripts. Smart Layouts required a Premium Club subscription, adding another premium-gated convenience feature.
Named Apple Watch App of the Year 2021
Apple named Carrot Weather its 2021 Apple Watch App of the Year, citing its best-in-class forecasts and 20 complications optimized for the wrist. The recognition came the same year as the Design Award, making 2021 a landmark year for the solo developer's product quality.
Version 5.5 Redesigns Maps with 3D Globe View
Carrot Weather 5.5 rebuilt its weather maps with six map styles, a 3D globe view, and faster-loading layers. Premium users gained individual U.S. radar stations and up to 48 hours of forecast map layers, and Premium Ultra users gained an Inspector Tool that shows exact map values.
iOS 16 Update Adds 20+ Lock Screen Widgets Behind Paywall
Carrot Weather 5.8 launched with 20+ Lock Screen widgets for iOS 16, including snark, forecast, hourly, and daily types. A major iPad multicolumn redesign was also introduced. Lock Screen widgets required a Premium subscription, creating another touchpoint where free-tier users encountered premium-gated functionality that Apple's Weather app offered for free.
Apple WeatherKit Adopted as Data Source Option
The iOS 16 update added Apple Weather as a selectable data source in Carrot Weather, as Apple moved to end Dark Sky. Dark Sky's iOS app was set to stop providing weather data on 1 January 2023, and Apple's WeatherKit API lets developers integrate Apple Weather forecast data.
Live Activities Support Launches for Dynamic Island
Carrot Weather added Live Activities for iOS 16.1, displaying real-time precipitation tracking on the iPhone 14 Pro's Dynamic Island and Lock Screen. Users could see when rain would start or stop without opening the app. Live Activities required a Premium subscription, continuing the pattern of premium-gating iOS features.
Mini-Games and Bonding Activities with Robot AI
Version 5.9 added interactive mini-games where users 'bond' with the Carrot AI by charging power cells, praising her greatness using speech recognition, and debugging code. An inventory and crafting system let users combine gifts from Carrot. Users could even start a 'romance' with the AI. These features added engagement depth and sticky retention mechanics.
Dark Sky User Migration with 25% Discount Offer
As Dark Sky's iOS shutdown loomed (January 1, 2023), Carrot Weather offered displaced users 25% off Premium Ultra ($30/year instead of $40), marking the first discount ever on the Ultra tier. The app also added a vertical layout mirroring Dark Sky's familiar design to ease the transition. This strategic positioning captured migrating Dark Sky users.
Dark Sky iOS App Shuts Down Permanently
Apple shut down the Dark Sky iOS app at the start of 2023, forcing users to migrate to alternatives. Cult of Mac's guide recommended Carrot Weather as a way to re-create Dark Sky's main features with its Dark Sky-inspired Inline layouts, though setting it up that way required a $9.99/month or $39.99/year subscription. The shutdown removed a key competitor from the premium weather app market.
ChatGPT-Powered Chatbot Added with Pay-Per-Message Model
Version 5.10 integrated a ChatGPT-powered chatbot that kept Carrot's snarky personality across selectable personality modes including sarcastic, pirate, and mobster. Users got 5 free messages, with more available via the Tip Jar, reported at €0.99 for 50 messages up to €10.99 for 500 in Europe. The chatbot was presented as entertainment, not core weather functionality.
Dark Sky API Officially Discontinued
Apple's Dark Sky API reached end of support on March 31, 2023, so any remaining third-party apps using it had to switch to a different weather data provider. By then Carrot Weather already offered several other forecast providers, including Apple Weather, added with iOS 16 in September 2022. SlashGear had already described Foreca as Carrot Weather's default data source in October 2022.
Android App Receives Its Last Update (Version 2.5.2)
AppBrain's record of the Google Play listing shows version 2.5.2, released June 7, 2023, as the Android app's latest update. As of October 2026 the app rated about 2.3 stars from 2,952 ratings, and reviewers called it abandoned compared with the regularly updated iOS version.
Apple Watch Overhaul and StandBy Widgets for iOS 17
A major update redesigned the Apple Watch experience with new complications and added StandBy mode widgets for iPhone. The Apple Watch overhaul continued Carrot Weather's pattern of investing heavily in Apple ecosystem integration while requiring Premium subscriptions for Watch complications.
Vision Pro Launch with 3D Interactive Globe
Carrot Weather launched as a native visionOS app on Apple Vision Pro's release day, February 2, 2024, featuring an interactive 3D globe showing global temperatures, wind speeds, and precipitation intensity. It was one of more than 250 native visionOS apps available on day one. The app was a free download, with full features requiring a subscription priced at $4.99-$14.99/month or $19.99-$59.99/year depending on tier.
Version 6.0: Garden Layout Redesign with AccuWeather News
Carrot Weather 6.0 introduced a garden layout where robots prune trees and deliver supplies, resetting monthly. Line charts became a new layout option for hourly/daily forecasts (Premium required). Integrated weather news from AccuWeather appeared in the app. The update continued expanding features across all Apple platforms including Vision Pro.
iOS 18 Update Adds Control Center Widgets and Weather History
Version 6.1 added iOS 18 Control Center shortcuts, dark/tinted variants of 50+ alternate app icons, a new 30-day weather history section (Premium Ultra required), Apple Watch Live Activities (Premium required), and expanded radar coverage to Europe, Australia, and Japan (Premium Ultra required).
CarPlay Navigation App Requires $39.99/Year Ultra Tier
Version 6.2 added a CarPlay app that doubles as a snarky navigation app, with live radar, severe weather alerts and weather along the driving route. The App Store release notes mark the CarPlay app as requiring Premium Ultra ($39.99/year), so the $19.99/year Premium tier does not include it.
10th Anniversary Musical Released Inside the App
Developer Brian Mueller created 'CARROT: The Musical,' a 15-song, 40-minute musical in two acts celebrating the app's 10th birthday, with one new song unlocking inside the app each day over two weeks. The musical tells the story of the Carrot AI trying to overthrow her maker, reinforcing the app's unique character-driven identity.
Version 6.3: Glassy Redesign and Free AI Chatbot via Apple Intelligence
Version 6.3 (September 15, 2025, the iOS 26 launch day) introduced a 'glassy redesign' for iOS and upgraded the chatbot to Apple Intelligence: unlimited conversations with no tipping required, on devices that support Apple Intelligence. It also added new secret locations and power-ups, daily horoscopes, and iPad multitasking support, and the same notes were repeated for 6.3.1 and 6.3.2. The Apple Intelligence integration removed a previous monetization friction point.
The Weather Channel Data Source and Dynamic Sky Layout Added
Carrot Weather added The Weather Channel as a data source option, National Weather Service discussions, Weather Underground station observations, and a new 'Sky' dynamic layout showing real-time weather visuals. The continued expansion of data source options reinforced transparency and user choice, though alternate sources remained Premium-gated.
Multi-Model Forecasts and Storm Prediction Center Outlooks Added
A Carrot Weather update added multi-model (ensemble) forecasts that compare multiple weather simulations to show the range of possible outcomes, plus Storm Prediction Center analysis of severe-storm and wildfire risk in the United States. It arrived a month after the February update that re-added The Weather Channel data.
Version 6.7 Adds Trip Planner and Threshold Alerts for Premium Ultra
Version 6.7 added a Trip Planner for single- and multi-stop trips, which shows monthly estimates for trips far ahead and switches to daily forecasts as departure approaches. It also added custom notifications that fire the moment a data point crosses a threshold. TapSmart reported on July 17 that both features require the Premium Ultra upgrade.
Version 6.9 Adds AI Layout Assistant, Highlights and Activities
Version 6.9 added an AI-powered Layout Assistant that builds a personalized layout from a few questions (Premium required), a Highlights section flagging upcoming weather changes and extremes, and an Activities section that finds good times for running, cycling or stargazing (Premium required). The same notes appear again for 6.9.1 in the App Store version history.
Evidence (39 citations)
D1: User Value Erosion
D2: Business Customer Exploitation
D3: Shareholder Extraction
D4: Lock-in & Switching Costs
D5: Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
D6: Dark Patterns
D7: Advertising & Monetization Pressure
D8: Competitive Conduct
D9: Labor & Governance
D10: Regulatory & Legal Posture
Scoring Log (7 entries)
22→19. D4 3→2 (recalibration: no data, social graph or DRM, many comparable free apps; only unexportable layouts and game progress, so the low end of 2-3), D6 3→2 (recalibration: trial auto-renewal, humorous upsells and joke fake ads are minor patterns; cancellation via Apple is 1:1; no documented nagging or obstruction beyond that), D10 2→1 (correction: the Common Sense Privacy 'Warning' was removed by the fact audit; what remains shows a proactive privacy stance: SDKs removed, no data sales, no ad use, disclosed chatbot routing). Other dimensions confirmed. Since Feb 2026: steady iOS feature releases (The Weather Channel re-added Feb 25; multi-model forecasts and SPC outlooks Mar 26; NOAA source, improved radar and new fake ads May-Jun; Trip Planner and threshold alerts, both Premium Ultra, Jul 15; air quality and smoke maps Aug; AI Layout Assistant Sep 14; iPhone Duo support Oct 9), with no price changes, legal matters, privacy incidents or corporate changes. Android remains frozen at 2.5.2 (June 2023). Eras: 'Paid App Launch' re-dated 2015-03-01→2015-03-19 (launch); 'Apple Watch Pivot' re-dated 2017-11-01→2017-07-20 (v4.0 Premium Club expansion) and relabeled 'Version 4 Redesign'; 'Multi-Source Expansion' re-dated 2019-01-01→2018-07-05 (v4.7 Ultrapremium tier, Android launch a week later) and relabeled 'Tiered Expansion'; 'Freemium Pivot' re-dated 2021-01-01→2021-01-28 (v5.0); final era 'Mature Freemium' re-dated from the 2026-02-16 assessment date to 2023-01-01 (Dark Sky iOS shutdown) and relabeled 'Post-Dark Sky Maturity'. All eras re-scored from criteria (D6/D10 lowered consistently across eras). Candidate rejected: 6.3.3 'chatbot' (Oct 31, 2025) is a bug-fix release; the researchers misread the App Store version history, whose notes precede each version heading. Alternatives unchanged (no stale claims, no typed scores). Category 'Weather' fits.
Checked all 7 candidates: 0 restored, 4 partly restored, 3 confirmed removed, 0 already present. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:2: The Verge October 30, 2015 app recommendation (original link recovered from a MacRumors forum post; the forum is discovery only, not evidence). PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:6: Droid Life July 12, 2018 missing weather alerts, narrowed from a general immediate and lasting quality gap. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:14 (current index 15): 9to5Mac January 28, 2021 vertical layout only; retain corrected pricing and grandfathering. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:27 (current index 29): SlashGear October 25, 2022 Foreca-default report, explicitly attributed; not the unsupported developer precipitation-precision acknowledgment. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:26 (current index 28): TechCrunch lists selectable personalities but no 13-mode total or $0.99/50-to-$9.99/500 price schedule; gHacks likewise lacks those figures, and three searches did not establish them. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:remove:19: Common Sense evaluation returns real HTTP 404, repeated Wayback attempts returned no readable copy, and search-index text is insufficient under the page-read rule; the historical Warning is unverified, not disproved. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:update:1: AppBrain live record is 2.32/2,952; August 10, 2025 archive shows 2.44/2,871, not the original 2.48/2,910. Exact-figure searches found no qualifying corroboration; June archive retrieval failed, so no claim of comprehensive archive coverage. All current facts retained; no scores or eras changed.
Team audit: checked 74 items (36 timeline, 34 evidence, 2 milestones, 2 alternatives) + prose. 22 verified, 38 corrected (17 date-only), 13 re-sourced, 1 removed (Common Sense Privacy evaluation, now 404 with no archive). Fixed launch price ($2.99, not $4.99), 2015 premium subscription, v3.0/v4.0 dating and Premium Club pricing, '5x' price claim, 5.0 grandfathering (existing buyers kept features), Dark Sky acquisition terms, iOS 14 widget gating, 6.3.1 attribution, Android rating, and trimmed unsupported details (Verge Apple TV list, Lansdale, '13 moods', Foreca-default timing). Kept the 'turning point' quote, re-sourced to Apple's Behind the Design as a new evidence item. [Amended by regrade 2026-10-26: timeline[34] was attributed to version 6.3.1 (2025-09-17). The App Store history lists notes before each version heading, as confirmed by 9to5Mac's Feb 25 and Mar 26, 2026 articles and TapSmart's 6.7 article, so the glassy redesign and Apple Intelligence chatbot shipped in 6.3 on 2025-09-15 (TapSmart covered it 2025-09-19). Re-dated and retitled the event, and updated the D5/D7 narratives. Also re-pointed evidence[4] and [13] from the 2020-era subscription FAQ to the current support index (handoff item 6).]
Stripped for Phase 2 re-enrichment