Craigslist

Craigslist is an online classified advertisements platform where users can post and browse listings for jobs, housing, goods, services, and community events. Founded in 1995, it serves as a free, minimalist marketplace connecting local buyers and sellers across hundreds of cities worldwide.

20/ 100
Healthy
2Squeezing Users→Stable

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-26. Score revised 2026-10-26: 19 → 20.

Score History

MilestoneCriticalMajor
Community Email List (1995–2000) · 4/100Community ListEmailBuckmaster's Expansion (2000–2004) · 7/100Buckmaster'sExpansioneBay Minority Stake (2004–2008) · 14/100eBaySafety & eBay Crisis (2008–2012) · 17/100Safety &eBay CrisisAnti-Scraping Offensive (2012–2016) · 18/100Anti-Scrap…OffensiveMarketplace Competition (2016–2020) · 21/100Marketp…Neglect-Driven Plateau (2020–present) · 20/100Neglect-Driven Plateau10075502502000201020202026-10Community Email List (1995–2000) · 4/100Buckmaster's Expansion (2000–2004) · 7/100eBay Minority Stake (2004–2008) · 14/100Safety & eBay Crisis (2008–2012) · 17/100Anti-Scraping Offensive (2012–2016) · 18/100Marketplace Competition (2016–2020) · 21/100Neglect-Driven Plateau (2020–present) · 20/100471417182120MilestonesFounded (1995)Incorporated (1999)eBay acquires 28.4% stake (2004)eBay divests stake (2015)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Community Email List
4/100
1995-03-01 – 2000-01-01

Craig Newmark starts Craigslist as a free email list for San Francisco Bay Area events and jobs, moving to the web in 1996. It is a one-person community project with no monetization, no outside owners and no regulatory exposure. Users get a simple, free service that improves as it grows.

Buckmaster's Expansion
7/100+3
2000-01-01 – 2004-08-10

Craigslist, incorporated as a private for-profit company in 1999, brings in Jim Buckmaster in 2000, who soon becomes CEO and leads its expansion beyond San Francisco to nine U.S. cities. The anti-maximization philosophy takes shape: no banner ads, no marketing and fees only for San Francisco job posts. Governance is a small, closely held company.

eBay Minority Stake
14/100+7
2004-08-10 – 2008-01-02

eBay buys a 28.4% stake, the founders take $8 million each through a special dividend tied to the deal, and Craigslist extends $25 job fees to New York and Los Angeles, followed by a $10 fee for NYC broker apartment listings in 2006. The site's first Section 230 test, a 2006 fair-housing suit, arrives as it scales. The relationship with eBay sours after eBay launches the rival Kijiji in 220 U.S. cities in 2007.

Safety & eBay Crisis
17/100+3
2008-01-02 – 2012-07-20

Newmark and Buckmaster adopt a staggered board, rights plan and dilutive share issuance aimed at eBay, which sues in April 2008; in 2010 a Delaware court rescinds the rights plan and issuance as breaches of fiduciary duty. Safety pressure peaks at the same time: a multistate attorney-general agreement on erotic-services ads, the 2009 'Craigslist Killer' case, a lawsuit against South Carolina's attorney general and the 2010 Adult Services shutdown. Competitors turn the flagging system into a weapon against rivals' listings.

Anti-Scraping Offensive
18/100+1
2012-07-20 – 2016-10-03

Craigslist sues 3Taps and PadMapper for aggregating its housing listings and briefly claims an exclusive license to users' posts, dropping it within weeks after EFF criticism; 3Taps countersues alleging anticompetitive conduct. Dealer car listings become paid at $5 in December 2013. eBay sells its stake back in June 2015, and the scraping suits settle days later for $3.1 million and permanent injunctions.

Marketplace Competition
21/100+3
2016-10-03 – 2020-01-30

Facebook Marketplace launches in October 2016 and begins drawing Craigslist's users away. Craigslist extends job fees to more than 60 additional local sites, adds fees for motorcycle dealers and, in April 2019, for private car sellers, and wins large judgments against RadPad and Instamotor. FOSTA-SESTA prompts the March 2018 removal of U.S. Personals, and Craigslist pays Sidley Austin $380,000 to lobby on the bill; its first official app arrives in December 2019.

Neglect-Driven Plateau
20/100-1
2020-01-30 – present

AIM Group reports Craigslist's first-ever revenue drop, nearly 27% from 2018 to 2019, beginning a slide to about $302 million in 2024 and a further 2% dip in 2025. The litigation campaign goes quiet and the product barely changes: no ads or new fees of note, but persistent scams and thin moderation, highlighted by Consumer Reports' 2026 finding of banned infant sleepers and unremoved reported listings. Regulatory pressure on marketplaces grows through the INFORM Consumers Act and Georgia's blocked Act 564, while Newmark moves his equity to his foundation.

Alternatives

OfferUp41/100

Mobile-first local marketplace with in-app messaging, user ratings, and a cleaner interface than Craigslist. Covers most of Craigslist's buy/sell use cases. Smaller user base than Facebook Marketplace but less privacy baggage. Easy switch — download the app and create an account.

Much larger active user base than Craigslist with in-app messaging, user profiles with ratings, and local buy/sell groups. Much easier to find buyers and sellers for most categories. Significant privacy trade-off — Facebook harvests extensive data. Easy switch — use your existing Facebook account.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Craigslist's decline for users comes from neglect rather than active degradation. Scams and fraud remain the main user problem, the community flagging system is abused to remove legitimate listings, and a September 2026 Consumer Reports evaluation found banned infant in-bed sleepers for sale, no way to flag a product as banned or recalled, no removal of the items CR reported, and no response from Craigslist. Private sellers have paid $5 to list cars since April 2019, and the audience has thinned: revenue fell from $1.035 billion in 2018 to about $302 million in 2024 and slipped another 2% in 2025 as users moved to Facebook Marketplace and other rivals. The core post-and-browse workflow still works simply and without ads or monetization friction.
How It Got Here
Craigslist launched in 1995 as a free email list for San Francisco events and delivered immediate value through simplicity and zero cost. As it expanded to hundreds of cities, scams became its defining user problem: rental fraud, fake escrow services and overpayment schemes grew with its reach. The 2009 'Craigslist Killer' case brought safety fears to national attention, and competitors turned the community flagging system into a tool for removing rivals' legitimate listings. The interface stayed essentially static, and Craigslist did not release an official mobile app until December 2019. Facebook Marketplace's October 2016 launch accelerated user migration, the U.S. Personals section disappeared in March 2018 after FOSTA-SESTA, and in April 2019 private sellers began paying $5 to list a car. Revenue fell from $1.035 billion in 2018 to about $302 million in 2024 and slipped another 2% in 2025. In September 2026, Consumer Reports found banned infant in-bed sleepers for sale on Craigslist, no way to flag items as banned or recalled, and no removal of the listings it reported. Despite a 4.8-star App Store rating and a workflow free of ads, the platform's erosion comes from neglect of trust and safety rather than deliberate degradation.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

1995Community Email List2000Buckmaster's Expansion2004eBay Minority Stake2008Safety & eBay Crisis2012Anti-Scraping Offensive2016Marketplace Competition2020Neglect-Driven PlateauUser Value1123344Biz Exploit0122222Shareholder0122111Lock-in1111111Algorithms0011111Dark Patterns0000011Advertising0011122Competition0011443Labor/Gov1223222Regulatory1123333
Timeline (42 events)
major1995-03-01

Craig Newmark starts email list for SF events

Craig Newmark, a software engineer at Charles Schwab, begins a free email distribution list sharing local San Francisco events with friends. Job postings and other categories were added over time as the list outgrew his personal circle, establishing the community-first ethos that would define the platform for decades.

major1996-01-01

Craigslist transitions to web-based service

Newmark registers craigslist.org and launches the website, transitioning from an email list to a browsable web service. The site retains its minimalist, text-heavy design and remains entirely free. Categories expand beyond events to include jobs, housing, and for-sale items.

major1999-01-01

Craigslist incorporates as for-profit company

Craig Newmark incorporates Craigslist as a private for-profit company and decides to monetize it as little as possible, turning away bankers and venture capitalists who urged him to monetize aggressively. He later told Nieman Lab that by monetizing Craigslist the way he did in 1999, 'I probably gave away already 90 percent or more of my potential net worth.' The incorporation preserved the community-service mission within a sustainable business structure.

major2000-01-01

Jim Buckmaster joins as lead programmer and CTO

Jim Buckmaster, who posted his resume on Craigslist in late 1999, is hired as lead programmer and CTO. He is promoted to CEO in November 2000. Buckmaster establishes an anti-maximization management philosophy with no meetings, no sales team, no marketing budget, and no business development staff — principles that persist to this day.

major2000-06-01

Craigslist expands beyond San Francisco to nine cities

Craigslist launches in Boston, Chicago, Los Angeles, New York, Portland, San Diego, Seattle, Washington D.C., and Sacramento. The expansion establishes the geographic city-by-city model that would define the platform's growth, reaching close to 30 cities by the start of 2004. Michael Rappa's Managing the Digital Enterprise case study records 175 local Craigslist sites in an August 2005 snapshot.

major2004-08-01

Craigslist begins charging for job postings in NYC and LA

Craigslist begins charging $25 per job posting in New York and Los Angeles, extending the paid job ads it already charged in San Francisco. A new free 'Gigs' section is simultaneously added for low-cost and unpaid work. This establishes the selective-fee model that funds the platform without advertising, keeping the vast majority of categories completely free.

critical2004-08-10

eBay acquires 28.4% stake in Craigslist

eBay purchases a 28.4% stake from former Craigslist employee Philip Knowlton for approximately $32 million. The deal gives eBay insight into the fast-growing classifieds business. The partnership sours when eBay launches Kijiji, a competing classifieds service, which Craigslist views as a direct betrayal.

major2004-08-10

Founders take $8 million each in special dividend tied to eBay deal

In conjunction with eBay's purchase of its stake, Craigslist paid Craig Newmark and Jim Buckmaster $8 million each through a special dividend, according to the Delaware Court of Chancery. eBay separately paid former employee Philip Knowlton $16 million for his shares.

major2006-02-03

Fair Housing Act lawsuit tests Section 230 immunity

Chicago Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights sues Craigslist over discriminatory housing ads containing phrases like 'NO MINORITIES.' The Seventh Circuit rules in 2008 that Section 230 shields Craigslist from liability for user-posted discriminatory content, an early landmark decision establishing platform immunity for classified ad sites.

minor2006-03-01

Craigslist adds $10 fee for New York broker apartment listings

Craigslist began charging $10 for each listing in the New York site's broker apartment categories, both 'fee' and 'no fee', after months of evaluating feedback. It was the first paid housing category, aimed at brokers rather than individual renters.

minor2007-06-29

eBay launches rival Kijiji classifieds in 220 U.S. cities

eBay, then a 28.4% Craigslist shareholder, launched its competing Kijiji classifieds site in 220 cities across all 50 states, according to the Delaware Court of Chancery. The launch set up the board and shareholder conflict that followed.

major2008-01-02

Newmark and Buckmaster adopt staggered board and dilutive measures against eBay

Craigslist's two controlling shareholders restated the charter and bylaws to add a staggered board, and adopted a stockholder rights plan and a right-of-first-refusal share issuance that diluted eBay's stake. eBay sued over these measures in April 2008.

major2008-03-14

Seventh Circuit upholds Craigslist's Section 230 defense in fair-housing case

The Seventh Circuit affirmed summary judgment for Craigslist in the Chicago Lawyers' Committee suit over discriminatory housing ads posted by users, holding that Craigslist was not the publisher or speaker of third-party ads under Section 230.

critical2008-04-22

eBay sues Craigslist over stake dilution

eBay files suit after Craigslist founders Craig Newmark and Jim Buckmaster adopt measures that diluted eBay's stake from 28.4% to 24.9%. Craigslist countersues in May 2008, accusing eBay of misappropriating confidential information and trademark infringement. In September 2010 the Delaware Court of Chancery rules that the founders breached their fiduciary duties, rescinding the poison pill.

major2008-11-06

Craigslist agrees with 43 attorneys general to verify erotic-services posters

Georgia's attorney general and counterparts from 42 other states announced an agreement under which Craigslist would require erotic-services posters to give a working phone number and pay a fee by valid credit card, provide that information in response to law-enforcement subpoenas, donate the proceeds to charity, and sue 14 companies that helped posters evade its defenses.

critical2009-04-14

'Craigslist Killer' murders woman met through site

Boston University medical student Philip Markoff murders masseuse Julissa Brisman at a Boston hotel after connecting through Craigslist's erotic services ads. The case generates nationwide safety concerns about the platform. Craigslist renames 'Erotic Services' to 'Adult Services' with manual review and $10 per listing fees in response.

D1D10
A&E ↗
major2009-05-13

Craigslist renames Erotic Services to Adult Services

Under pressure from law enforcement and attorneys general following the Philip Markoff murder case and a 2009 Illinois sheriff's federal lawsuit accusing the site of promoting prostitution, Craigslist replaces its 'Erotic Services' section with a manually reviewed 'Adult Services' section charging $10 per new listing.

major2009-05-20

Craigslist sues South Carolina attorney general over threatened prosecution

Craigslist sued South Carolina Attorney General Henry McMaster in federal court, seeking declaratory relief and a restraining order after he threatened criminal prosecution of the company's management unless it removed adult categories from its South Carolina sites. Buckmaster called the threat an unconstitutional prior restraint barred by Section 230.

critical2010-09-04

Craigslist shuts down Adult Services under AG pressure

After 17 state attorneys general send a scathing letter demanding removal, Craigslist shutters its Adult Services section nationwide, replacing it with a 'Censored' label. The section had generated approximately $36 million annually from $10 per listing. Critics note the closure pushes vulnerable sex workers to less-safe platforms rather than addressing trafficking.

major2010-09-09

Delaware court rescinds Craigslist rights plan as breach of fiduciary duty

After trial, the Delaware Court of Chancery found that Newmark and Buckmaster breached their fiduciary duties to eBay in adopting the rights plan and right-of-first-refusal dilutive issuance, and rescinded both, while leaving the staggered board in place.

major2012-07-20

Craigslist sues 3Taps and PadMapper over data scraping

Craigslist files suit against 3Taps and PadMapper, startups that scraped Craigslist housing listings to offer improved map-based search interfaces. The court rules in 2013 that a cease-and-desist letter plus IP blocking constitutes sufficient notice under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. The case establishes aggressive anti-scraping precedent that chills third-party innovation.

major2012-08-09

Craigslist drops short-lived exclusive license to users' posts

Shortly after suing 3Taps and PadMapper, Craigslist added a posting provision making it the exclusive licensee of each post, with the exclusive right to enforce copyright against anyone republishing it. EFF said this would have stopped users from republishing their own ads elsewhere; after meeting with EFF, Craigslist removed the provision about a week after it was noticed.

minor2012-09-24

3Taps countersues Craigslist alleging anticompetitive conduct

3Taps filed a countersuit in the Northern District of California, disputing Craigslist's copyright claims and accusing Craigslist of anticompetitive and antitrust behavior over its efforts to block use of listing data. The allegations were never tested; the dispute settled in 2015.

major2013-12-03

Craigslist starts charging dealers $5 per car listing

Craigslist began charging $5 per posting in the cars and trucks by-dealer category, with bulk posting blocks available through paid accounts. It extended paid posting to vehicle dealers for the first time.

critical2015-06-19

eBay divests 28.4% stake back to Craigslist

eBay sells its 28.4% stake back to Craigslist for an undisclosed sum, ending all litigation between the companies after an 11-year partnership. Craigslist returns to full private ownership under founder Craig Newmark, the largest holder (42.6% before the buyback), and CEO Jim Buckmaster, eliminating the external shareholder pressure that had generated years of legal conflict.

major2015-06-26

3Taps, PadMapper and Lovely settle scraping suits for $3.1M

Craigslist settles with 3Taps ($1 million, pledged to EFF), PadMapper ($0), and Lovely ($2.1 million). All parties accept permanent injunctions against using Craigslist data. The settlements effectively end the possibility of third-party services improving the Craigslist user experience through data aggregation.

critical2016-10-03

Facebook Marketplace launches as Craigslist competitor

Facebook launches Marketplace, a dedicated local buy-and-sell feature at a time when Facebook had 1.7 billion monthly active users, with in-app messaging to sellers and seller names and profile photos shown on listings. The social context it offers, which Craigslist's anonymous listings lack, makes it a major competitive threat to Craigslist.

minor2016-11-01

Craigslist extends paid job postings to dozens more local sites

Craigslist posts notices on more than 60 local U.S. and Canadian sites where job ads had been free, announcing fees from November 1, 2016, typically $7 or $10 per posting. Paid job postings had until then been limited to the larger markets, and the change pushes job fees well beyond the major metros.

minor2016-11-15

Craigslist adds $5 fee for motorcycle dealer ads

Craigslist began charging $5 per ad in the motorcycle dealers category, extending the dealer fee model from cars and trucks. Dealer ATV, UTV and snowmobile categories were not affected at the time.

major2017-04-13

Craigslist wins $60.5M judgment against RadPad

Craigslist obtains a $60.5 million default judgment against RadPad, a rental listing startup, for scraping Craigslist content and sending 400,000 unsolicited emails to Craigslist users. The award includes $40 million in CAN-SPAM damages — the largest CAN-SPAM judgment ever. RadPad's insolvency means Craigslist will likely never collect.

major2017-08-03

Craigslist reaches $31M settlement with Instamotor

Craigslist settles with Instamotor, a used car listing app, for $31 million over data scraping and CAN-SPAM violations. Instamotor had hired a team in the Philippines to extract listings and sent 85,581 unsolicited emails to Craigslist users. The settlement includes $25.7 million for CAN-SPAM violations ($300 per email) and $5.3 million for terms-of-service breaches.

critical2018-03-23

Craigslist removes Personals section over FOSTA-SESTA

Craigslist proactively shuts down its U.S. Personals section in response to the passage of FOSTA-SESTA, which amends Section 230 to make platforms potentially liable for facilitating sex trafficking. The removal eliminates a section used by millions for dating and casual encounters; missed connections stays up, and personals remain outside the U.S.

D1D10
NPR ↗
major2019-04-15

Craigslist begins charging private sellers $5 to list a car

Craigslist introduced a $5 fee to post a car ad in the by-owner section, the first time private parties were charged to list vehicles on the site. Dealers had paid since 2013.

major2019-12-03

Craigslist launches first official mobile app after 24 years

Craigslist releases its first official iOS app, 11 years after the App Store launched, with an Android version in beta. The day after launch the app ranks No. 10 in the App Store's Shopping category. For over a decade, third-party apps had filled the gap, some of which Craigslist sued for data scraping, making the official app overdue.

major2020-01-30

Craigslist revenue drops for first time ever

AIM Group reports that Craigslist's revenue declined nearly 27% from 2018 to 2019, the first drop since it began estimating the company's revenue in 2003, according to AIM Group's 2020 report overview. Revenue had peaked at about $1.03 billion in 2018. The decline is attributed mainly to a roughly 37% drop in paid job ads, along with the March 2018 removal of the personals section, fewer job openings, and competition from Facebook Marketplace, OfferUp and LetGo. A July 2020 report by 24/7 Wall St. put estimated 2019 revenue at about $760 million.

minor2023-01-19

Craigslist files Section 230 amicus brief at Supreme Court

Craigslist files an amicus brief in Gonzalez v. Google LLC, the first Supreme Court case considering the scope of Section 230. The brief argues that Section 230 is crucial to Craigslist's survival and the viability of its service model, joining other platforms and free speech organizations. The Court ultimately remands the case without narrowing Section 230.

major2023-06-27

Federal INFORM Consumers Act takes effect for online marketplaces

The INFORM Consumers Act, signed into law in 2022, takes effect requiring online marketplaces to collect and verify identifying information for high-volume sellers (200+ transactions and $5,000+ in 12 months). Classified sites such as Craigslist, where buyers typically pay sellers offline, sit largely outside its verification duties, a gap retailers later pressed states such as Georgia to close.

major2024-06-06

NetChoice sues Georgia over marketplace seller verification law

NetChoice, representing Craigslist and Meta among others, sues to block Georgia's Act 564, which would require online marketplaces to verify high-volume seller identities even for off-platform transactions. A federal judge grants a preliminary injunction on July 1, 2024, ruling the state law conflicts with the federal INFORM Act. Georgia appeals to the 11th Circuit.

major2025-04-01

Craigslist revenue estimated at $302M, down 70% since 2018

AIM Group estimates Craigslist's 2024 revenue at $302 million, down 20% from the year before and 70% below the 2018 peak of $1.035 billion. Traffic has also kept declining. Despite the losses, Craigslist remains the No. 1 U.S. horizontal classified site by traffic and revenue. In later reporting on February 19, 2026, The Philadelphia Inquirer cited Similarweb for more than 105 million monthly users.

minor2025-12-08

Newmark says he has given all his Craigslist equity to his foundation

Announcing that he had signed the Giving Pledge, Craig Newmark wrote that he had given away all his Craigslist equity to his charitable foundation. The date of the transfer itself was not disclosed.

minor2026-02-25

AIM Group reports Craigslist revenue fell 2% in 2025

AIM Group reported that Craigslist's 2025 revenue was down 2% year over year, with jobs and real estate helping stem the decline, and that a dramatic fall in traffic suggested users were choosing rivals.

major2026-09-23

Consumer Reports finds banned infant sleepers on Craigslist; company does not respond

In a May-June 2026 evaluation of four secondhand marketplaces, Consumer Reports found banned infant in-bed sleepers for sale on Craigslist. Its prohibited-products guidance did not cover several banned children's products, a used car-seat listing triggered no safety prompts, users could not flag an item as banned or recalled, and Craigslist did not remove the products CR reported or respond to the findings.

Evidence (43 citations)

D2: Business Customer Exploitation

D4: Lock-in & Switching Costs

D5: Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity

Craigslist FAQs: FlaggingCraigslist · 2024-01-01

D6: Dark Patterns

Redesigning Craigslist With Focus On UsabilitySmashing Magazine · 2009-03-11
Craigslist Privacy PolicyCraigslist · 2024-05-29
How to Delete Your Craigslist AccountJoinDeleteMe · 2024-07-10

D7: Advertising & Monetization Pressure

D8: Competitive Conduct

Scoring Log (6 entries)
regrade2026-10-26RESCORED

19→20. Since Feb 2026: AIM Group reported 2025 revenue down 2% (Feb 2026); Consumer Reports found banned infant sleepers on Craigslist and no removal or response (Sep 2026); Newmark disclosed his Craigslist equity went to his foundation (Dec 2025); NetChoice v. Carr (Georgia Act 564) appeal still pending; fee page unchanged; no new litigation, enforcement or product changes found. D7 1→2 (correction: fact audit found the fee list broader than recorded, and the 2019 by-owner car fee turned a free listing type into a paid one; free tier has minor limits). Other 9 dimensions confirmed. Eras: 'Buckmaster's Expansion' split at 2004-08-10 (eBay stake, special dividend, NYC/LA job fees) → new 'eBay Minority Stake'; 'Safety & eBay Crisis' re-dated 2008-01-01→2008-01-02 (board entrenchment measures against eBay) and split at 2012-07-20 (3Taps/PadMapper suit) → new 'Anti-Scraping Offensive'; 'Marketplace Competition' re-dated 2016-10-01→2016-10-03 (Facebook Marketplace launch); current era 'Neglect-Driven Plateau' re-dated 2026-02-17→2020-01-30 (first-ever revenue drop reported); 'Community Email List' kept. All eras re-scored: early eras slightly lower (1995: 5→4, 2000: 8→7); D8 4 in 2012-2020 for the aggregator litigation campaign (was 1/3), falling to 3 now as no action since 2017; D9 3 in 2008-2012 for the Delaware fiduciary-breach ruling. Added 16 timeline events (13 historical: special dividend, NYC broker fee, Kijiji launch, 2008 board measures, Seventh Circuit ruling, 2008 AG agreement, SC AG suit, 2010 Delaware ruling, exclusive-license episode, 3Taps counterclaim, dealer/motorcycle/by-owner car fees) and 7 evidence items. Narratives rewritten for D1, D2, D3, D4, D7, D8, D9, D10. Alternatives unchanged (no typed scores, both still active).

restore-check2026-10-26RESTORED

Checked all 6 candidates from restore-candidates.py against the current regraded record: 0 restored, 5 partly restored, 1 confirmed removed, 0 already present. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:4: 175 local sites in an August 2005 snapshot (Michael Rappa, Managing the Digital Enterprise); evidence added with the page's actual March 3, 2023 publication date, while the claim explicitly identifies the historical snapshot. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:15 (current index 26): 1.7 billion monthly active Facebook users (Los Angeles Times, October 3, 2016); no identity-verification or strongest-ever-threat assertion. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:21 (current index 34): tracking since 2003 (AIM Group 2020 report overview, https://aimgroup.com/2020-craigslist-report/, and AIM release via Job Board Hive) and about $760M 2019 revenue (24/7 Wall St., July 20, 2020), not unsupported $756M. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:25 (current index 38): more than 105M monthly users in reporting dated February 19, 2026 (Philadelphia Inquirer/Similarweb), not April 2025 visits attributed to AIM. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:remove:15: original Common Sense evaluation URL, trailing-slash variant, HTTP variant and full privacy-report URL returned 404; two Wayback attempts yielded no readable copy. Three searches surfaced indexed evaluation/report text, suggesting the evaluation existed, but no readable dated source was obtained. This is an evidence-availability decision, not a finding that the evaluation was invented; original January 1, 2024 date remains unverified. PARTLY RESTORED evidence:remove:33: added narrower independently reported support for the resale-channel claim: The Gazette, September 24, 2023, quotes Sheriff Darren Weekly saying organized retail theft suspects resell stolen goods on sites like eBay or Craigslist. This remains an attributed law-enforcement account, not an adjudicated finding or proof of Craigslist misconduct. ArcadianAI's marketing article itself is not restored; its live publication metadata is September 1, 2025, not 2024, and its alleged DHS 70%-within-10-days statistic remains unsupported after three searches of the figure, alleged origin and adjacent years. Every original URL was fetched, with explicit Wayback checks. Search calls per candidate in order: 3, 2, 3, 1, 3, 3 (15 total). All restorations rely on pages read with fetch-page.py this session. No removals, score changes, or unrelated prose changes.

fact-audit2026-10-25FABRICATION FOUND

Checked 67 items + prose. 19 verified, 20 corrected (12 date-only), 23 re-sourced, 5 removed (1 duplicate, 2 junk-only, 2 dead). Invented (contradicted or junk-only): D2 '$450 in New York' job fee (craigslist fee page: $10-75); D10 'does not engage in federal lobbying' (Senate LDA filings: $380K via Sidley Austin 2017-18); D10 DHS '70% of ORC goods within 10 days' (only on an AI-style vendor blog); Newmark '~28% stake' (Delaware Chancery opinion: 42.6%). Unsupported trims: 175 cities by 2005, $756M 2019 revenue, 105M monthly visits, 'Craigslist Auto Flagger', Buckmaster 'keep it simple' quote, Marketplace 'identity verification'. Fixed eBay-suit ruling year (2010), U.S.-only personals removal, 3Taps/RadPad settlement wording.

Deep Enrichment2026-03-14
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-17