Depop

Depop is a peer-to-peer fashion resale marketplace popular with Gen Z users, enabling individuals to buy and sell secondhand clothing, vintage items, and streetwear. The platform blends social media features like follower networks and curated feeds with e-commerce functionality across 150+ countries.

37/ 100
Actively Enshittifying
2Squeezing Users↓Worsening

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-24.

Score History

MilestoneCriticalMajor
Indie Social Marketplace (2011–2019) · 12/100Indie Social MarketplaceScale-Up & Safety Lapses (2019–2021) · 19/100Scale-Up &Safety…Etsy Consolidation (2021–2024) · 27/100EtsyConsolidationBuyer-Fee Shift (2024–2026) · 36/100Buyer-FeeShifteBay Ownership (2026–present) · 37/100eBay100755025020122016202020242026-10Indie Social Marketplace (2011–2019) · 12/100Scale-Up & Safety Lapses (2019–2021) · 19/100Etsy Consolidation (2021–2024) · 27/100Buyer-Fee Shift (2024–2026) · 36/100eBay Ownership (2026–present) · 37/1001219273637MilestonesFounded (2011)Series C ($62M) (2019)Acquired by Etsy (2021)Sale to eBay Agreed (2026)Acquired by eBay (2026)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Indie Social Marketplace
12/100
2011-01-01 – 2019-06-06

Simon Beckerman founded Depop in Italy in 2011 and moved it to London in 2012. It was a small VC-backed social shopping app funded by a $1 million seed round (2013) and an $8 million Series A led by Balderton (2015), with Maria Raga as CEO from 2016. Sellers paid a flat 10% commission plus PayPal fees, discovery was largely chronological, and there were no promoted listings. Lock-in was modest and came from follower networks and reviews.

Scale-Up & Safety Lapses
19/100+7
2019-06-06 – 2021-07-13

Depop's hypergrowth began with a $62 million Series C led by General Atlantic in June 2019, when it had 13 million users. The pandemic accelerated it: 2020 GMS more than doubled to about $650 million. Trust and safety lagged behind. A November 2019 BoF investigation documented sexual harassment of users including minors, Vice reported in May 2020 that scammers were taking over accounts with leaked credentials, and a 2021 Vice investigation found the curated Explore page favoured thin white models. The 10% commission model was unchanged, and the era ended with Etsy agreeing to buy the company.

Etsy Consolidation
27/100+8
2021-07-13 – 2024-03-20

Etsy closed its $1.625 billion acquisition on July 13, 2021, making Depop a subsidiary of a public company. Depop Payments became mandatory for UK and US sellers in 2021-22, and Boosted Listings added an 8% pay-to-play layer in October 2022. In January 2023 the US processing fee rose to 3.3% plus $0.45, on top of the 10% commission. Etsy wrote down about $898 million of Depop goodwill in Q3 2022 and replaced CEO Maria Raga with its own product chief. It also sold Elo7 and cut 11% of its staff in December 2023.

Buyer-Fee Shift
36/100+9
2024-03-20 – 2026-07-30

Depop scrapped the 10% seller commission in the UK (March 2024) and US (July 2024) and moved part of the cost to buyers through a marketplace fee shown only at checkout, which later drew drip-pricing class actions. Over the same period, activist Elliott Management joined Etsy's board and Etsy spent about $724 million on buybacks in 2024. An October 2024 ranking change hurt newer sellers, and Boosted Listings fees rose from 8% to 12% (UK in December 2025, US in March 2026). Depop kept growing fast but stayed loss-making, and in February 2026 Etsy agreed to sell it to eBay for $1.2 billion.

eBay Ownership
37/100+1
2026-07-30 – present

eBay completed its purchase of Depop for about $1.4 billion on July 30, 2026, after clearance in the US, Germany, Australia and the UK. Depop now belongs to the largest general resale marketplace, which also owns Tise, and eBay says it will keep its own brand and platform. Around the closing, the buyer-fee model reached Australia along with mandatory Depop Payments, and from October new Australian sellers had to use Depop Shipping. A new drip-pricing suit followed in September, and in October eBay announced its second layoff round of 2026, about 1,000 jobs.

Alternatives

Vinted39/100

Zero seller fees — you keep 100% of the sale price. Strong in Europe, growing in the US. Easy switch if you cross-list, but you'll rebuild your follower base and review history from scratch.

Mercari43/100

Broader category coverage than Depop (not just fashion), with a 10% seller fee. Good for reaching buyers outside the streetwear/vintage niche. Easy switch — straightforward listing process.

Poshmark45/100

Large US buyer base with a strong social community for fashion. The 20% commission is much higher than Depop's current fees, so compare your category before switching. Moderate switch — listings don't transfer automatically.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Depop has improved for sellers on fees but declined for buyers. Sellers in the UK (March 2024), US (July 2024) and Australia (July 2026) no longer pay a 10% commission, but buyers now pay a marketplace fee of up to 5% plus up to $1 (or A$1) that appears only at checkout. Scams are the biggest problem: in a January 2024 Which? survey, 57% of Depop buyers said they had been scammed in the prior two years, the highest of any platform surveyed, and IDCARE logged 30+ Depop-related scam reports in July-August 2025 with average losses of $2,947. Sellers also faced a March 2024 payout bug and an October 2024 ranking change that cut visibility for newer sellers. October 2025 security upgrades (magic-link login, AI fraud detection, in-app dispute resolution) were a real improvement, and ratings are split: 4.8 on iOS, a mixed 3.1 on Trustpilot.
How It Got Here
Depop launched in 2011 as a simple social shopping app where users could buy and sell secondhand fashion with little friction, and its early experience was largely positive. Problems came with scale. A November 2019 Business of Fashion investigation documented sexual harassment of users including minors, and in May 2020 Vice reported scammers taking over accounts with leaked credentials and selling them on darknet markets. Pandemic demand outpaced safety investment. Depop answered with two-factor authentication and a Safety Centre in 2021. After the Etsy acquisition, Depop Payments became mandatory for UK and US sellers in 2021-22, and Boosted Listings put paid placements into search from October 2022. In March 2024 a payout-system bug delayed seller payments for about a week. The 2024 fee reset removed seller commissions in the UK and US but added a buyer marketplace fee of up to 5% plus up to $1, shown only at checkout, and Australia followed in July 2026. An October 2024 ranking change cut visibility for newer sellers. In a January 2024 Which? survey, 57% of Depop buyers said they had been scammed in the prior two years. October 2025 upgrades (magic-link login, AI fraud detection and in-app dispute resolution) were a real improvement, and ratings stay split: 4.8 on iOS, 3.1 on Trustpilot.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2011Indie Social Marketplace2019Scale-Up & Safety Lapses2021Etsy Consolidation2024Buyer-Fee Shift2026eBay OwnershipUser Value13344Biz Exploit12333Shareholder11344Lock-in23344Algorithms12344Dark Patterns11244Advertising11233Competition11334Labor/Gov23344Regulatory12233
Timeline (42 events)
minor2013-10-16

Depop Raises $1M Seed Round as Founder Steps Back as CEO

London-based Depop raised $1 million in seed funding led by Italy's Red Circle Investments. Founder Simon Beckerman stepped down as CEO in 2013 and joined the board, and Runar Reistrup took over as chief executive. The company had moved its headquarters from Italy to London in 2012.

minor2015-01-29

Balderton Capital Leads $8M Series A

Depop raised an $8 million Series A led by Balderton Capital and Holtzbrinck Ventures (later HV Capital). The money funded US expansion, including a New York office led by former Reddit general manager Erik Martin.

major2016-01-01

Maria Raga Becomes CEO, Leads Strategic Pivot

Maria Raga, who joined Depop as VP of Operations in 2014, was promoted to CEO in early 2016. Under her leadership, Depop focused on professionalizing operations and accelerating US expansion, growing from a niche Italian fashion app to a global Gen Z marketplace.

major2019-06-06

Depop Raises $62M Series C, Passes 13M Users

Depop closed a $62 million Series C round led by General Atlantic, with participation from existing investors Balderton Capital, HV Capital, and Creandum. The platform had reached 13 million registered users with $500 million in cumulative GMS and 100% year-over-year revenue growth.

major2019-11-12

BoF Investigation Exposes Sexual Harassment on Depop

Business of Fashion published an investigation documenting widespread sexual harassment of Depop users, including minors being solicited for nude photos. The platform allowed users as young as 13 to join, and its open messaging system enabled predators to contact sellers directly. Depop's COO stated a 'zero-tolerance approach' but users reported inadequate enforcement.

major2020-05-18

Vice Exposes Widespread Account Hacking and Scams

A Vice UK investigation revealed that scammers were systematically flooding Depop, using leaked credentials to take over legitimate seller accounts. Hacked accounts were sold on darknet marketplace Empire Market. Depop denied a data breach but acknowledged the problem, and hackers published some users' home addresses, raising GDPR concerns.

major2020-06-08

Pandemic Drives 163% Surge in Depop Signups

COVID-19 lockdowns accelerated Depop's growth as users turned to resale during store closures. FashionUnited reported on June 8, 2020 that, since April 1, Depop had seen a 163% year-over-year increase in new app signups, 200% year-over-year traffic growth in the US, and a 300% year-over-year increase in items sold. Figures Etsy later disclosed when it agreed to buy Depop put 2020 GMS at about $650 million and revenue at about $70 million, each up more than 100% year over year.

major2021-04-09

Vice Investigation Reveals Explore Page Favors Thin White Models

A Vice investigation found that Depop's editorially curated Explore page overwhelmingly featured thin, straight-size, and predominantly white models. A seller experiment showed the same item received dramatically more engagement when modeled by a thinner person. A Change.org petition with over 800 signatures demanded greater body diversity in curation. Depop claimed the issue was 'already addressed' but the evidence contradicted this.

critical2021-06-02

Etsy Acquires Depop for $1.625 Billion

Etsy agreed to acquire Depop for $1.625 billion, mostly in cash, as part of its 'house of brands' strategy alongside Reverb (musical instruments). It was Etsy's biggest acquisition to date. Etsy said Depop would operate as a separate brand under its existing leadership team, and about 90% of Depop's active users were under 26. The acquisition closed on July 12, 2021.

minor2021-07-20

Depop Launches Safety Centre and Two-Factor Authentication

Depop launched an online Safety Centre with guides for buyers, sellers, parents and younger users. The launch followed the rollout of two-factor authentication across Depop earlier in 2021, after press investigations in 2019 and 2020 into harassment of users and the takeover of accounts with leaked passwords. Depop Help Centre guidance checked in October 2026 specifies six-digit SMS login codes, with a recovery code for users who cannot access the SMS code.

major2021-12-08

Depop Payments Becomes Mandatory for UK and US Sellers

Depop introduced Depop Payments, a Stripe Connect-based system letting buyers pay by card, Apple Pay, Google Pay or PayPal, and made it a requirement for selling: UK sellers had to sign up by 8 December 2021 and US sellers by 10 January 2022 to keep listing. Seller payouts in those markets moved from PayPal to Depop's own system, consolidating payment processing under Depop's control. Depop US help guidance checked in October 2026 states that payments reach Depop Balance two business days after delivery or ten business days after the sale, whichever comes first; bank withdrawals can then take up to five days.

major2022-07-20

Maria Raga Steps Down as CEO; Etsy Names Kruti Patel Goyal

Maria Raga announced her resignation as Depop CEO after leading the company since 2016 (eight years at Depop in all), a period in which she raised close to $100 million and oversaw the $1.625 billion Etsy acquisition. Etsy named its Chief Product Officer, Kruti Patel Goyal, as Depop's CEO effective September 12, 2022, the first of several leadership changes at the subsidiary.

major2022-10-19

Etsy Monetizes Depop with Boosted Listings at 8% Fee

Etsy introduced promoted listings on Depop, branded as 'Boosted Listings,' charging sellers an 8% fee on the total transaction amount when an item sells via a boosted tile in search, on top of existing selling and transaction fees. Boosted items are highlighted in search results, establishing a pay-to-play dynamic that did not exist during Depop's independent era. Depop Selling API documentation checked in October 2026 also lists additional boosted placements on "Suggested for you" pages, alongside search results.

critical2022-11-02

Etsy Takes $1 Billion Impairment Charge on Depop and Elo7

Etsy recorded about $1.0 billion of goodwill impairment charges in Q3 2022 against Depop ($897.9 million) and Elo7 ($147.1 million), citing adverse macroeconomic conditions, executive management changes at both subsidiaries, downward revisions to business forecasts and higher discount rates driven by rising interest rates.

major2023-01-05

Depop Raises US Payment Processing Fee for Sellers

Depop raised the transaction fee for US sellers using Depop Payments from 2.9% plus $0.30 per sale to 3.3% plus $0.45, effective January 5, 2023, and kept its 10% selling fee. Sellers therefore paid 13.3% of the total sale plus $0.45 per transaction. Depop blamed higher card-processing costs.

major2023-07-18

Etsy Agrees to Sell Brazilian Marketplace Elo7

Etsy agreed to sell its Brazilian marketplace Elo7 to local firm Enjoei S.A. on undisclosed terms, two years after paying $217 million for it. The Motley Fool read the undisclosed price as a likely loss. The sale cut Etsy's 'house of brands' to Etsy, Reverb and Depop and raised questions about whether Depop could face a similar disposal if its performance disappointed.

major2023-12-13

Etsy Lays Off 11% of Workforce Including 225 Employees

Etsy CEO Josh Silverman announced the layoff of approximately 225 employees, 11% of the workforce, citing a "very challenging" macro and competitive environment. The cuts were expected to cost $25-30 million, mostly severance payments, employee benefits and other related costs. CMO Ryan Scott departed. The cuts were made at the Etsy marketplace, Depop's parent.

critical2024-02-01

Elliott Management Takes 13% Stake in Etsy, Gains Board Seat

Activist hedge fund Elliott Management disclosed a roughly 13% economic interest in Etsy and secured a board seat for partner Marc Steinberg. Elliott is known for pressuring companies to cut costs, boost shareholder returns through buybacks, and divest underperforming units. The move introduced extraction-oriented governance pressure over Depop's parent company.

minor2024-03-13

Depop Admits Payout System Bug Delayed Seller Payments

Sellers reported payment dates being pushed back repeatedly and limited responses from Depop support. Depop said an issue in its automated payouts system had caused delays over the previous week, that the issue had been fixed, and that all pending payments had been sent to affected sellers.

major2024-03-20

Depop Eliminates Seller Commission in UK, Shifts Cost to Buyers

Depop removed the 10% seller commission for UK sellers on new listings created from 20 March 2024. It was paired with a buyer-side Marketplace Fee of up to 5% of the item price plus a fixed amount of up to £1 (excluding taxes and postage), which applied from 15 April 2024. While framed as a pro-seller move, the change shifted part of the fee burden to buyers. Sellers outside the UK continued to pay the original 10% commission.

major2024-07-15

Depop Eliminates US Seller Commission Amid Resale Fee Wars

Depop removed the 10% seller commission for US sellers on all new listings from 15 July 2024, matching the UK change from March 2024. Buyers now pay a marketplace fee of up to 5% of the item purchase price plus a fixed amount of up to $1 (excluding taxes and postage), applying from 18 July 2024. The move was part of a broader 2024 'resale fee wars' in which eBay, Mercari, Poshmark and Depop all changed their fee structures, while Vinted, which charges sellers no fees, was the European benchmark.

major2024-10-01

Search Ranking Update Frustrates Depop Sellers

Sellers reported that Depop changed its search ranking so that newly listed or reposted items no longer automatically appeared at the top of results; search now prioritized sellers with good reviews, high-quality photos and detailed descriptions. New and smaller sellers reported drops in visibility, likes, messages and sales.

major2024-10-30

Etsy Announces $1 Billion Share Repurchase Program

Etsy's board authorized a new $1 billion share repurchase program on October 30, 2024. Etsy had already repurchased about $464 million of stock in the first nine months of 2024 and bought back about $260 million more in the fourth quarter, roughly $724 million for the year. The program came less than a year after Elliott Management gained a board seat.

minor2024-12-05

Depop CEO Kruti Patel Goyal Moves to Etsy Leadership

Etsy named Depop CEO Kruti Patel Goyal its President and Chief Growth Officer. She stayed on as acting Depop CEO through April 2025 while Depop's executive team looked for her successor. Etsy credited her with making Depop the fastest-growing brand in its portfolio.

minor2025-01-31

Depop Moves Home Feed to Machine-Learning Recommendations

Depop introduced a personalised recommendation feed tailored to each user's size, style and preferences. It said its ML model processes a user's last 300 views, narrows all listings to 600 options ranked by in-session actions, and updates the feed several times a day. The same release added AI-generated listing descriptions from photos.

major2025-07-01

California State Class Action Targets Depop Marketplace Fee

Nicole Yuen filed a proposed class action, Yuen v. Depop Inc. (Case No. 25CV469747), in Santa Clara County Superior Court, alleging that Depop hides its mandatory buyer Marketplace Fee until checkout. Depop later told a federal court that the parties had completed mediation and that it expected the case to be resolved within months.

minor2025-08-01

Peter Semple Becomes Depop's Permanent CEO

Depop appointed Peter Semple, its former Chief Marketing Officer, as Chief Executive Officer effective August 1, 2025, after he had served as interim CEO. He was Depop's third chief executive since 2022.

minor2025-09-24

Depop Launches Outfits Feature to Deepen Engagement

Depop introduced Outfits, a styling and collaging tool that lets users combine multiple listings into shoppable outfit collages and share them to Pinterest and Instagram. Features like this encourage browsing and time in the app beyond pure buying and selling. Depop positioned Outfits as a step in its long-term strategy for a "more socially driven experience" and an effort to make the app a daily destination for fashion inspiration.

major2025-10-30

Depop Adds Passwordless Login, AI Fraud Detection and In-App Dispute Resolution

Depop introduced magic-link logins to reduce account takeovers and AI-based detection of phishing and fraud, with human experts reviewing suspicious activity. It also added an in-app process for buyers and sellers to settle item-not-as-described disputes, with escalation to human support when needed. In the US, orders a seller cannot ship on time are now cancelled and refunded automatically.

major2025-12-03

Depop Raises UK Boosted Listings Fee from 8% to 12%

Depop increased the Boosted Listings advertising fee in the UK from 8% to 12% of the item sale price (excluding taxes and shipping), effective December 3, 2025. The 8% rate remained in the US and Australia at the time.

major2026-02-06

Class Action Filed Over Hidden Marketplace Fee Drip Pricing

A California consumer filed a class action lawsuit alleging Depop engages in illegal drip pricing by concealing the mandatory marketplace fee until checkout. The plaintiff was charged a $1.55 fee not disclosed in the item's advertised $17 price. The suit alleges violations of California's Honest Pricing Law, Unfair Competition Law, and False Advertising Law.

critical2026-02-18

Etsy Agrees to Sell Depop to eBay for $1.2 Billion

Etsy announced it had agreed to sell Depop to eBay for about $1.2 billion in cash, roughly $400 million less than the $1.62 billion it paid in 2021. Etsy's stock rose more than 14% in extended trading, and Etsy said the sale lets it focus on its core marketplace. The deal was expected to close in Q2 2026. Etsy's full-year results, published the next day, reported Depop's 2025 GMS at $1.0749 billion.

D3D8D9
CNBC ↗
minor2026-02-19

Depop Ends 2025 With 7 Million Active Buyers as Growth Continues

Etsy reported Depop Q4 2025 GMS of $299.7 million, up 37.2% year over year on a currency-neutral basis, with US buyer GMS up 60.2%. Depop had 3.2 million active sellers (up 41.1%) and 7.0 million active buyers (up 37.7%).

major2026-02-26

eBay Cuts 800 Jobs After Depop Acquisition Announcement

eBay announced the elimination of approximately 800 positions, about 6% of its workforce, days after its $1.2 billion agreement to acquire Depop. TechCrunch counted it as the third time in three years that eBay had cut jobs. eBay said the cuts would align its structure with strategic priorities as it reinvested across the business. CNBC reported that eBay was increasing spending on AI and using the planned Depop acquisition to expand in fashion.

major2026-03-23

Depop Raises US Boosted Listings Fee From 8% to 12%

Depop raised the Boosted Listings fee from 8% to 12% for new boosts from March 23, 2026, matching the UK increase of December 2025. The notice nudged sellers to take advantage of the lower rate before it rose. Sellers blamed incoming owner eBay, but Value Added Resource noted that Etsy still owned Depop and that Etsy had made seller-services revenue a priority. Depop's fee table lists the 12% rate for UK and US sellers on new listings from March 23, 2026.

minor2026-07-10

Federal Depop Drip-Pricing Suit Voluntarily Dismissed

Linsey Dinh voluntarily dismissed her February 2026 federal class action (Dinh v. Depop, N.D. Cal.) without prejudice, with no ruling on whether Depop's fee disclosures broke California law. Depop had told the court that the earlier Yuen case in Santa Clara Superior Court covered the same claims and included Dinh in its proposed class. The Yuen case remained pending.

major2026-07-15

UK CMA Clears eBay's Acquisition of Depop

The Competition and Markets Authority cleared eBay's anticipated acquisition of Depop at Phase 1. Australia's ACCC had already cleared the deal without conditions in May 2026, though it noted that the merger removed competition between eBay and Depop, the largest suppliers of integrated listing, messaging and payment services for C2C pre-owned fashion in Australia.

major2026-07-22

Depop Removes Australian Seller Fees, Adds Buyer Fee and Mandatory Payments

Depop dropped its 10% commission for Australian sellers on AUD sales. Buyers now pay a marketplace fee of up to 5% of the item price plus up to A$1, and sellers still pay 2.6% plus A$0.30 in payment processing plus any boosting fees. Australian sellers must now use Depop Payments, and PayPal can no longer be connected. Depop said removing seller fees in the UK and US had increased listings by 30% to 45% within 28 days.

critical2026-07-30

eBay Completes $1.4 Billion Acquisition of Depop

Etsy completed the sale of Depop to eBay for about $1.4 billion in cash: the $1.2 billion purchase price plus $200 million of net purchase price adjustments and interest. Etsy said it would use the proceeds in line with a capital allocation plan that included accelerating its share repurchases. eBay said Depop would keep its distinct brand, platform and culture while eBay looked for synergies in shipping, personalisation and compliance.

major2026-09-15

Illinois Class Action Alleges Depop Drip Pricing

Javier Rivera filed a proposed nationwide class action (Rivera v. Depop, N.D. Ill., No. 1:26-cv-11297), alleging that a $400 item cost him $472.63 after a $20.70 Marketplace Fee appeared only on the final checkout screen. Value Added Resource found the same pattern on a Depop listing it checked on September 20, 2026, with no fee-inclusive price shown. The allegations have not been adjudicated.

minor2026-10-06

Depop Requires Australian Sellers to Use Depop Shipping

Depop's Australia shipping policy requires sellers who list from the effective date to send items with Depop Shipping, a service powered by Australia Post. It applies to users who signed up from October 6, 2026, and to existing Australian users from October 26, 2026.

major2026-10-21

Depop Parent eBay Announces Second 2026 Layoff Round

eBay CEO Jamie Iannone told staff that eBay would lay off about 9% of its workforce, about 1,000 jobs, to simplify operations and shift resources to its fastest-growing areas. This followed the roughly 800 jobs eBay cut in February. Reuters noted that the $1.4 billion Depop deal had helped eBay beat revenue forecasts.

Evidence (58 citations)

D7: Advertising & Monetization Pressure

D10: Regulatory & Legal Posture

Scoring Log (6 entries)
regrade2026-10-24RESCORED

37→37. Since Oct 2025: Boosted Listings fee raised 8%→12% for new US boosts (Mar 2026), Etsy agreed (Feb) and completed (Jul 30, ~$1.4B) the sale of Depop to eBay after US/German/ACCC/CMA clearance, Australian seller fees dropped with buyer fee + mandatory Depop Payments (Jul 2026) and mandatory Depop Shipping (Oct 2026), Dinh drip-pricing suit dismissed (Jul) while Yuen state case continues and Rivera filed (Sep 2026), Oct 2025 security upgrades, eBay layoffs of ~800 (Feb) and ~1,000 (Oct 2026) alongside $310M Q2 buybacks. D5 5→4 (correction: fact audit removed the Smart Feed and other unsupported ranking claims and showed the help centre lists ranking factors; remaining evidence fits 'limited transparency' at 4). D6 3→4 (recalibration: drip-priced buyer fee plus deletion obstruction plus boost-urgency/nagging are multiple pattern types, criteria 4-5; reinforced by three drip-pricing suits). Eras: 'Indie Social Marketplace' re-dated 2015-01-01→2011-01-01 (founding); 'Pandemic Growth Surge' re-dated 2020-01-01→2019-06-06 (Series C) and relabeled 'Scale-Up & Safety Lapses'; 'Etsy Consolidation' re-dated 2021-07-01→2021-07-13 (closing); 'Fee Wars & eBay Sale' (dated to 2026-02-17 assessment) re-dated to 2024-03-20 (UK commission removal), relabeled 'Buyer-Fee Shift' and split at 2026-07-30 into 'eBay Ownership'. Era re-scores: D8 Etsy eras 4→3 (Etsy not a fashion-resale rival; market stayed competitive), eBay era 4 (acquired by dominant rival that also owns Tise); D2 Etsy era 2→3 (Jan 2023 processing hike to 13.3% + $0.45); D10 Etsy era 3→2; D8 scale-up era 2→1. Category looks right.

restore-check2026-10-24RESTORED

Checked all 14 removed/trimmed candidate items: 2 restored, 6 partly restored, 5 confirmed removed, 1 already present. RESTORED: pandemic 163% signups/200% US traffic/300% items sold since April 1 (FashionUnited 2020-06-08); Outfits social-experience strategy and daily-destination aim, retaining 2025 date (Retail Dive 2025-09-25). PARTLY RESTORED: existing leadership and active-user qualifier (Etsy June 2021 SEC exhibit), not June 2 completion; SMS codes (Depop Help Centre checked October 2026), not an asserted 2021 mechanism or credential-stuffing purpose; Suggested for you boosted placements (Depop Selling API checked October 2026), not an asserted 2022 launch placement; US two/ten-business-day payout timing and up-to-five-day bank withdrawals (Depop Help Centre checked October 2026), not new-versus-established seller tiers or October 2023 mandate; $1.0749B annual 2025 GMS (Etsy full-year results 2026-02-19), with 7M active buyers already present and no accounting-loss claim; eBay reinvestment, AI spending and fashion context (CNBC 2026-02-26), not an earmark or integration-concern claim. Each of the six evidence additions supports the corresponding verdict above; dates on live operational documentation explicitly record the session check, not original publication. CONFIRMED REMOVED: 2015 Series A use for social-commerce feature expansion (TechCrunch/Balderton describe US office; platform/new-feature funding is a separate September 2016 $8.25M round per Startups.co.uk); Etsy layoff misquote, all-severance characterization and asserted Depop resource constraint (CNBC and Etsy 2023 10-K do not establish them); UK fee change without reduced total take (Value Added Resource does not establish this); specific Vinted-zero-fee motive for all 2024 fee changes (Depop, Modern Retail and Value Added Resource do not establish it); Smart Feed/30-50% refresh boost/undisclosed rollout (only vendor CLOSO repeats specifics; official ranking documentation supplies no figure). ALREADY PRESENT: account-deletion process in evidence[13] and D4/D6 prose, verified against Depop Help Centre; no duplicate Sage Datum evidence added. Original cited URLs were read or attempted first; Wayback attempts for inaccessible pages failed and were not treated as evidence. Three or fewer search calls per candidate. Detailed research notes are in work/restore-research.json. No removals or score changes.

fact-audit2026-10-23FABRICATION FOUND

Checked 71 items (26 timeline, 38 evidence, 4 milestones, 3 alternatives) + prose. 30 verified, 25 corrected (12 date-only), 15 re-sourced, 1 removed (dead domain). Invented (contradicted): Depop 2024 operating loss given as GBP 4M (FashionUnited 2025-10-08: GBP 42M); Etsy layoff quote 'increasingly competitive' (CNBC 2023-12-13: 'very challenging macro and competitive environment'). Major corrections: Depop Payments mandate 2021-22 not 2023/2024; UK boost fee rise Dec 2025 not Mar 2025 (eBay-blame belonged to 2026 US rise); 57% scam figure is a Jan 2024 Which? survey; Outfits launched 2025; Etsy deal and eBay sale were agreements at the cited dates; parentCompany now eBay Inc. (sale closed 2026-07-30). Removed unsupported specifics: 163%/200%/300% pandemic figures, Smart Feed 30-50% boost, 10-day new-seller holds, SMS 2FA, eBay layoff savings earmarks, dispute-fee claim, Etsy 'dual-class' claim, Glassdoor specifics.

Deep Enrichment2026-03-13
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-17