Guilded

Guilded was a gaming-focused chat and community platform competing with Discord, offering voice/video calls, text messaging, integrated calendars, scheduling tools, and 10 channel types for free. Founded in 2017 by Eli Brown (YC S17), it was acquired by Roblox in a deal initially valued at about $90 million in August 2021. In May 2024, Roblox announced that users would need linked Roblox accounts by July 15, prompting departures reported by users and developers. The platform was shut down on December 19, 2025, after Roblox said it would focus on Roblox Communities.

36/ 100
Actively Enshittifying
2Squeezing Users↓WorseningDiscontinued

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-24. Score revised 2026-10-24: 38 → 36.

Score History

MilestoneCriticalMajor
YC Esports Roots (2017–2020) · 3/100YC Esports RootsChat Platform Growth (2020–2021) · 5/100Chat GrowthPlatformRoblox Acquisition (2021–2023) · 18/100Roblox AcquisitionRoblox Integration Begins (2023–2024) · 21/100Forced Integration (2024–2025) · 34/100ForcedIntegrationSunset and Shutdown (2025–present) · 36/100Sunset andShutdown100755025020182020202220242026-10YC Esports Roots (2017–2020) · 3/100Chat Platform Growth (2020–2021) · 5/100Roblox Acquisition (2021–2023) · 18/100Roblox Integration Begins (2023–2024) · 21/100Forced Integration (2024–2025) · 34/100Sunset and Shutdown (2025–present) · 36/1003518213436MilestonesLaunched (2017)Series A ($7M) (2020)Acquired by Roblox (2021)Shut Down (2025)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

YC Esports Roots
3/100
2017-03-17 – 2020-04-30

Guilded launched on March 17, 2017 as an esports team manager for games such as Overwatch and entered Y Combinator's Summer 2017 batch. Seed funding from YC, Susa Ventures and Liquid 2 backed recruiting, team-comp and matchmaking tools, and the April 2018 redesign added forums, calendars and rosters. The product was small, free and user-focused, with no documented extraction.

Chat Platform Growth
5/100+2
2020-04-30 – 2021-08-16

A $7 million Series A led by Matrix Partners on April 30, 2020 funded Guilded's growth into a full gaming chat platform that challenged Discord on free features. Tournament tools, Server Subscriptions with a 2.5% fee and the March 2021 bot API followed. Community network effects grew and an optional Guilded Gold membership existed, but the core product stayed free and user-friendly.

Roblox Acquisition
18/100+13
2021-08-16 – 2023-10-26

Roblox acquired Guilded on August 16, 2021, five months after its own NYSE listing, in a deal announced at about $90 million and later booked at $77.6 million. Guilded kept operating as an independent product, shipping the 2022 bot API beta and private servers, but it now sat inside a loss-making, founder-controlled public company whose CEO received a $232.8 million 2021 package. Developers later described slow API fixes during this period.

Roblox Integration Begins
21/100+3
2023-10-26 – 2024-05-31

Roblox announced an opt-in Guilded community integration for Roblox experiences on October 26, 2023, weeks after describing founder Eli Brown as leading its Community Team while still overseeing Guilded. Guilded began to serve as Roblox's community layer: the Spring 2024 update added Roblox Group announcements and Marketplace items. A researcher said in December 2023 that a malformed-content crash bug had stayed unfixed for over three years.

Forced Integration
34/100+13
2024-05-31 – 2025-09-29

On May 31, 2024 Guilded announced that every account must link a Roblox account by July 15 and that email login would end, reversing the acquisition-era promise of independence. Users and community owners reported leaving for Discord, and moderation bots including Yoki shut down, with its developer estimating 10,000+ servers left without a moderation bot. Users in Russia hit an unexplained country block that October.

Sunset and Shutdown
36/100+2
2025-09-29 – present

Roblox announced on September 29, 2025 that Guilded would sunset by the end of the year so it could focus on Roblox Communities instead of two products. In November it set December 19 as the closing date, released a content export tool and ended Server Subscription sign-ups and renewals; server owners reported that the export omitted media and usernames. Guilded closed on December 19, 2025, and its website now redirects to Roblox Communities.

Alternatives

Discord33/100

A gaming chat platform offering text, voice, video, community servers, and a broad bot ecosystem. Guilded users reported returning to Discord after the mandatory Roblox account linking. Rebuilding server structure and preserving old messages require separate planning.

Open-source chat built on Matrix, with self-hosting and end-to-end encrypted messaging and calls. Running your own server gives community admins more control over hosting and data, with ongoing setup and maintenance work.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Guilded went from a free, feature-rich Discord alternative to a closed service within four years of Roblox's 2021 acquisition. The July 15, 2024 Roblox account mandate made the core use case harder: one Trustpilot reviewer reported 300 members leaving a three-year-old community, and moderation bots such as Yoki shut down. Roblox then announced the sunset in September 2025 and closed the website and apps on December 19, 2025, after which all platform content became inaccessible.
How It Got Here
Guilded launched in March 2017 as an esports team management tool for Overwatch, and within two months its founder called it the most popular web recruiting platform for Overwatch teams. The April 2018 redesign added forums, calendars and roster tools, and by 2020-2021 it had become a full gaming chat platform with tournament tools and extra channel types, with core features free. After Roblox's August 2021 acquisition, developers reported slow bot API fixes and missing promised features. The Spring 2022 update brought the bot API beta, but later updates increasingly centred on Roblox integration. In December 2023 a researcher said a malformed-content crash he had investigated around 2020 was still unfixed, though his old XSS payloads no longer worked. The May 2024 Roblox account mandate drove departures: one Trustpilot reviewer reported 300 members leaving a three-year-old community, and users said they were returning to Discord rather than create Roblox accounts. Trustpilot reviewers also cited bugs and performance problems on Windows and Android. Roblox announced the sunset in September 2025; a server owner reported that the official export omitted media and usernames, and on December 19, 2025 the website and apps closed and all content became inaccessible.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2017YC Esports Roots2020Chat Platform Growth2021Roblox Acquisition2023Roblox Integration Begins2024Forced Integration2025Sunset and ShutdownUser Value001267Biz Exploit001133Shareholder113334Lock-in122244Algorithms001233Dark Patterns000033Advertising011111Competition002233Labor/Gov115555Regulatory002333
Timeline (43 events)
major2017-03-17

Guilded Launches as an Esports Team Manager

Guilded's initial release was March 17, 2017. Eli Brown, a former Xbox and Instagram engineer and Grandmaster StarCraft II player, founded the company, which entered Y Combinator's Summer 2017 batch. Its early team management tools served games such as League of Legends and Overwatch.

minor2017-07-24

Overwatch Team Comps Feature Launches on Product Hunt

Guilded launched its Overwatch Team Comps feature on Product Hunt, describing it as a real-time team analysis app for gaming teams. Earlier that month, founder Eli Brown said Guilded had become the most popular web recruiting platform for Overwatch teams within two months of beta.

minor2017-09-08

Guilded Receives Seed Funding from YC, Susa Ventures, and Liquid 2

Guilded closed its seed funding round with investments from Y Combinator, Susa Ventures, and Liquid 2 Ventures. The capital supported the company's early development of esports team management tools.

minor2017-11-21

Overwatch Team Matchmaking Feature Launches

Guilded launched its Overwatch Team Matchmaking feature to help teams find challenging opponents. The tool extended its esports team management and competition features.

major2018-04-04

The New Guilded: Major Platform Redesign Launches

Guilded unveiled a ground-up redesign of its esports team management platform. The update introduced forums (the most-requested feature), a Team Overview tab, a Streams tab with Twitch integration, game-specific rosters, and enhanced calendars and scheduling tools.

major2020-04-30

Guilded Raises $7 Million Series A Led by Matrix Partners

Guilded closed a $7 million Series A funding round led by Matrix Partners, with participation from Initialized Capital, Susa Ventures, and Sterling.VC. General partner Ilya Sukhar joined the board. The funding was earmarked for team expansion and building out the chat platform's feature set.

minor2020-06-30

Guilded Launches Early Access to All-in-One Tournament Product for Esports

Guilded introduced early access to its tournament product for Guilded Gold members and partners, with general availability planned for the fall. Announced tools included custom bracket types, event calendars, and advanced stat tracking integrated with its chat platform. Partners including the Corporate Esports Association had already run dozens of tournaments before the early access launch.

major2021-03-10

Roblox Goes Public via Direct Listing on NYSE

Roblox Corporation commenced trading on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol RBLX at $64.50 per share, implying a market cap of $35.5 billion. Its shares closed at $69.50, giving the company a market cap of $38.26 billion. Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, and BofA Securities served as financial advisors.

major2021-03-16

Server Subscriptions Enable Paid Community Tiers with a 2.5% Platform Fee

By March 2021, Guilded offered Server Subscriptions (Server Subs), allowing server owners and content creators to earn money from their communities with customizable tiers priced between $2 and $100. Guilded charged a 2.5% platform fee plus Stripe processing.

major2021-03-22

Guilded Bot API Announced with Early Access Program

Guilded announced a public bot API, closing a major feature gap with Discord. Initial partners included Statbot, PatchBot, Pixel Chat, and PLAYR.gg. The API supported all eight additional channel types that Discord lacked, enabling bots to integrate with calendars, forums, and scheduling tools.

major2021-05-25

Class Action Filed Against Roblox Over Content Moderation and Refunds

Plaintiff Jane Doe filed a class action lawsuit alleging Roblox should have refunded users who spent Robux on virtual items that were later removed through content moderation. The $10 million settlement received final approval on October 5, 2023.

critical2021-08-16

Roblox Acquires Guilded in Approximately $90 Million Transaction

Roblox Corporation acquired Guilded in a transaction initially announced at approximately $90 million in cash and stock, five months after going public. Guilded was to continue operating as an independent product. CEO Eli Brown said Roblox believed in its team and mission, while Roblox CEO David Baszucki praised the team and technology. The acquisition was framed as a social infrastructure play.

major2022-04-05

Roblox CEO Baszucki's $232.8M Compensation Disclosed While Company Unprofitable

Fortune reported that SEC filings showed Roblox CEO David Baszucki's 2021 compensation package totaled $232.8 million, up from $6.8 million in 2020. Fortune estimated it at roughly 1,680 times average annual Roblox employee pay, based on Payscale data. Roblox remained unprofitable in 2021 and had acquired Guilded the previous August in an announced approximately $90 million transaction.

minor2022-04-12

Spring Update 2022: Bot API Beta and Private Servers Launch

Guilded's Spring 2022 update announced Bots & API beta, private servers, picture-in-picture streaming, a YouTube bot, and performance improvements.

major2022-04-19

Truth in Advertising Files FTC Complaint Against Roblox Over Advergames

Consumer advocacy group Truth in Advertising filed a complaint with the FTC alleging Roblox used deceptive advergames that blurred the line between gameplay and advertising for children. Its complaint noted that the FTC had received 1,291 consumer complaints about Roblox and provided TINA.org a sample of 200 in response to a FOIA request; it did not characterize all 1,291 as advertising complaints.

minor2022-07-01

Yoki Moderation Bot Launches on Guilded

Developer Nico launched Yoki, a moderation bot for Guilded, after obtaining early access to the bot API in July 2021. Yoki would grow to serve 4,500+ servers, manage 200,000+ members, scan 50 million+ messages, and process 100,000+ images before its shutdown in 2024.

critical2022-10-05

Child Safety Lawsuit Filed Against Roblox Over Predator Grooming

A parent filed suit alleging Roblox and Discord enabled adult men to exploit her underage daughter. The complaint describes a Roblox user grooming the girl and persuading her to send sexually explicit images via Snapchat. The lawsuit alleged the companies failed to provide basic safeguards for children.

major2023-05-12

CARU Finds Roblox in Violation of Children's Advertising Guidelines

The Children's Advertising Review Unit found Roblox violated its Advertising Guidelines for children under 13 by failing to adequately disclose advertising within experiences and video content and failing to ensure influencers disclosed material connections. CARU separately raised privacy concerns for direct follow-up with Roblox's COPPA Safe Harbor. Roblox said its new Advertising Standards banning ads to under-13 users would take effect June 15, 2023.

critical2023-08-15

Class-Action Gambling Lawsuit Filed Against Roblox Over Minor Gambling

Mothers Rachelle Colvin and Danielle Sass filed a class action in the Northern District of California alleging Roblox and three co-defendants (RBXFlip, Bloxflip, RBLXWild) operated a gambling ring targeting minors. Children purchased Robux and gambled on third-party casino sites, with Roblox earning a 30% fee on conversions.

major2023-09-21

Roblox Lays Off 30 Talent Acquisition Staff Amid $282.8M Q2 Loss

Roblox cut about 30 talent acquisition team members, citing a need to align the organization with adjusted hiring targets. The company posted a $282.8 million net loss in Q2 2023, up from $176.4 million the prior year.

major2023-10-03

Eli Brown's Role Evolves to Lead Roblox Communities Org

Roblox profiled Eli Brown as one of eight startup founders continuing to innovate at Roblox. His role had evolved from Guilded CEO to leading the Community Team, responsible for building community tools across the Roblox platform. The profile said the Guilded team was part of Roblox's User Group.

major2023-10-05

Roblox $10 Million Avatar Shop Settlement Approved

Judge William H. Orrick approved the $10 million settlement in the Roblox content moderation class action. Users who had paid-for virtual items removed received Robux credits or cash payments. Roblox agreed to maintain automatic refund policies for at least four more years.

major2023-10-17

Roblox CEO Issues Return-to-Office Ultimatum: Relocate or Leave

CEO David Baszucki announced that a number of remote Roblox employees would need to work at the San Mateo headquarters three days per week or take severance. Employees asked to relocate had until January 16, 2024 to decide and July 15, 2024 to begin working in the office; employees unable to relocate had until April 15, 2024 to transition out.

major2023-10-26

Guilded-Roblox Community Integration Announced on Developer Forum

Roblox announced an opt-in Guilded Community Integration on its Developer Forum, enabling creators to link a Guilded community from a Roblox experience details page. The Creator Dashboard gained a community section to create or link a Guilded community. This deepened integration between the platforms.

major2023-12-20

Researcher Publishes Guilded Vulnerabilities, Says Tournament Bug Was Unfixed After 3+ Years

A security researcher described Guilded vulnerabilities investigated about three years earlier: stored XSS enabling password changes, malformed content producing errors in forum threads and capable of crashing tournament sections, credential changes without additional authentication or notifications, reusable magic links lasting 48 hours, and overprivileged email tokens granting full account access. He said the malformed-content bug remained unfixed after more than three years, while the original XSS payloads no longer worked after client-side validation was added. He published a November 9, 2020 reply from Guilded’s security team saying the XSS should be fixed and some other issues might still be in progress or not an immediate priority for repair, establishing that the report had reached Guilded by that date.

minor2024-04-09

Guilded Terms Require Binding Arbitration and Class-Action Waiver for U.S. Users

Guilded's Terms of Use, effective April 9, 2024, required U.S. users to resolve disputes through binding individual arbitration instead of court and to waive class actions. The terms also said users who rejected future changes would no longer be able to use the service.

minor2024-04-15

Spring Update 2024: Roblox Group Announcements and Marketplace Integration

Guilded's Spring 2024 update introduced cross-posting announcements directly to Roblox Groups and showcasing Roblox Marketplace items within Guilded servers. The update deepened Roblox platform coupling while offering little value to non-Roblox gaming communities.

critical2024-05-31

Guilded Announces Mandatory Roblox Account Linking by July 15

Guilded announced that all accounts must link a Roblox account by July 15, 2024 to maintain access. Email login would no longer be supported. The decision prompted a Change.org petition and criticism that it conflicted with the acquisition assurance that Guilded would operate as an independent product group.

minor2024-05-31

Change.org Petition Launched to Reverse Roblox Account Requirement

A Change.org petition titled 'Guilded Linking Account Update' was launched demanding Guilded reverse its mandatory Roblox account linking decision. Its author said not all Guilded users used Roblox and reported backlash from community members, server owners, official Guilded partners, bot developers and Gil Gang members.

major2024-06-01

User Reports 300 Members Abandoning 3-Year-Old Community Over Roblox Mandate

A Trustpilot reviewer reported 300 users abandoning their 3-year-old Guilded communities rather than create Roblox accounts, saying they were going back to Discord. This was an individual user report rather than a platform-wide migration count.

major2024-06-08

Guilded Partner Reports Receiving No Advance Notice of Account Linking Mandate

A self-described Guilded Partner wrote on Forum Promotion that partners had not been told about the Roblox account requirement before it was publicly announced, even the day before. The report reflected partner criticism of how the change was communicated.

major2024-07-01

Yoki Moderation Bot Shuts Down After Two Years

Developer Nico shut down Yoki on July 1, 2024 after two years, citing the mandatory Roblox account requirement as the final straw after months-long API bugs and feature delays. Yoki had peaked at 4,500+ servers and 200,000+ members. His post said Yoki followed other moderation bots including Parrot, Server Guard and EcoNuker, and estimated that 10,000+ servers would be without a moderation bot.

critical2024-07-15

Roblox Account Linking Mandate Takes Effect, Blocking Login Without a Connection

The mandatory Roblox account requirement went into effect. Users who did not connect a Roblox account could no longer log in or access Guilded, but could restore access later by connecting an account.

critical2024-10-08

Hindenburg Research Publishes Damning Report on Roblox

Short seller Hindenburg Research published a report alleging Roblox overstated the number of people on its platform by 25-42%+, engagement hours by 100%+, and maintained two sets of user statistics. The report also criticized child safety practices and cited a 2% year-over-year decline in trust and safety expenses in Q2 2024.

major2024-10-11

Guilded Becomes Unavailable to Users in Russia

Guilded users in Russia encountered an Amazon CloudFront message saying the distribution was configured to block access from their country. The cause was not established in the contemporaneous reporting. The restriction followed Russia blocking Discord on October 8.

minor2025-05-13

SEC Case Involving Roblox Closed Without a Disclosed Determination

Bloomberg Law reported that an SEC case involving Roblox, opened in October 2024, was closed according to a May 13, 2025 case-closing report obtained through a FOIA request. The document did not describe the investigation or say whether the SEC made any determination.

critical2025-09-29

Roblox Announces Guilded Sunset by the End of 2025

Roblox announced Guilded would sunset by the end of 2025, saying it would focus on Roblox Communities for users of all ages rather than investing in two separate products. Guilded was limited to users ages 13 and up. The company encouraged creators to build their communities within Roblox.

major2025-09-30

Guilded Server Owner Requests Safer Export Tools Before Shutdown

A Guilded server owner reported that it was too hard to safely download all chat conversations before the announced end-of-2025 shutdown. The owner said an existing third-party tool had security issues and did not export uploaded images and videos, and requested safer official export functionality to preserve community history.

critical2025-11-07

Texas Attorney General Sues Roblox Over Child Safety Allegations

Texas AG Ken Paxton sued Roblox alleging the company exposed children to predators, explicit content and exploitation. Texas became the third state to sue over child safety after Kentucky and Louisiana.

major2025-11-07

Guilded Sets December 19 Shutdown, Offers Export Tool and Ends Server Subs

AlternativeTo reported that Guilded would close on December 19, 2025, after which the website and apps would stop working and all content would become inaccessible. Guilded offered a content export tool for server owners and Bot API access until the cutoff, closed new server-subscription sign-ups the following week, and stopped renewals after mid-November.

minor2025-12-10

Server Owner Reports Guilded Export Omits Media and Usernames

A Guilded server owner wrote on Roblox's Developer Forum that the official content export had to be run channel by channel and that the exported JSON left out uploaded media and posters' usernames, giving only user IDs. The post came nine days before the shutdown.

major2025-12-12

JPML Centralizes Roblox Child Exploitation Litigation

The Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation transferred federal child sexual exploitation suits against Roblox to the Northern District of California for coordinated pretrial proceedings. The panel found common questions about Roblox's knowledge, safety representations, controls and warnings; the allegations are unadjudicated.

critical2025-12-19

Guilded Platform Officially Shuts Down

Guilded was discontinued and shut down by Roblox on December 19, 2025. Its website redirected visitors to Roblox Communities, and its desktop and mobile apps displayed a Sunset notification. Before the shutdown, server owners could use export tools to archive message history and media.

Evidence (55 citations)
Scoring Log (7 entries)
regrade2026-10-24RESCORED

38→36. Product discontinued Dec 19, 2025; final era's scores are the current scores and the discontinued badge was added. D3 5→4 (correction: fact audit removed the minimal-investment/talent-extraction/writeoff support; parent made no buybacks), D5 4→3 (correction: partner-consultation and Russia-motive claims narrowed; chat product with no ranking feed, changes mostly announced with reasons), D7 2→1 (correction: $5 platform premium removed as false; core product free with no documented in-app ads), D9 4→5 (recalibration: Roblox dual-class control and >200:1 CEO pay ratio meet 6-7 criteria items, labor actions moderate). Eras: 'YC Esports Roots' re-dated 2017-03-01→2017-03-17 (launch); 'Chat Platform Growth' re-dated 2020-05-01→2020-04-30 (Series A); 'Roblox Acquisition' re-dated 2021-09-01→2021-08-16; 'Silent Neglect' re-dated 2023-06-01→2023-10-26 (Guilded community integration) and relabeled 'Roblox Integration Begins'; 'Forced Integration' re-dated 2024-07-01→2024-05-31 (mandate announcement); final era re-dated 2026-02-20→2025-09-29 (sunset announcement) and relabeled 'Platform Killed'→'Sunset and Shutdown'. Since Feb 2026: no Guilded developments (service closed Dec 19, 2025); Roblox-level child-safety rulings, settlements and new state suits in 2026 concern the Roblox platform after Guilded's closure and were not added. Window additions: Nov 2025 shutdown date, export tool and Server Subs wind-down; Dec 2025 export-omits-media report; Dec 2025 JPML MDL order. Historical: Apr 2024 arbitration terms; May 2025 SEC case closure. Category Messaging fits.

restore-check2026-10-24RESTORED

Checked 19 removed/trimmed candidates: 0 restored, 1 partly restored, 14 confirmed removed, 4 already present. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:26: Antony Garand, DEV Community, December 20, 2023 (https://dev.to/antogarand/vulnerabilities-in-guildedgg-58m6; publication API https://dev.to/api/articles/antogarand/vulnerabilities-in-guildedgg-58m6). Inspected embedded screenshots: forum-message loading error and security-team response dated November 9, 2020; caption says October but the image says November. Do not restore October first reporting, whole-forum crashes, or many still-unfixed bugs. ALREADY PRESENT: timeline:update:13 and evidence:update:9 ($90m/independence); timeline:update:18 (30 arrests, evidence[46]); timeline:update:21 (annual losses, evidence[41]). Remaining 14 candidates lack qualifying support for their dropped specifics. All verdicts and dropped subclaims recorded in work/restore-ledger.json. Original sources read or attempted, Wayback retried for unavailable pages, no more than three web-search calls per candidate; failures not treated as evidence of falsity. No removals or score changes.

fact-audit2026-10-23FABRICATION FOUND

Checked90 original items including2 alternatives, plus all prose/fields. 22 verified, 30 corrected (6 date-only), 33 re-sourced, 5 removed. Invented specific1: $5/month Guilded platform premium is contradicted by TechWiser pricing (https://techwiser.com/guilded-vs-discord-comparison/amp/) and Guilded creator-tier help (https://support.guilded.gg/hc/en-us/articles/1500002339481-Server-Subs-Get-started); $5 was Discord Nitro Classic. Corrected34 distinct prose claims; retained true $90m/24%/70%/13,316/132/30-arrest facts with proper context. Added7 sources solely to preserve existing claims separated from miscited items. Unsupported details23 listed in work/final-ledger.json. No scores changed.

deep-enrichment-reset2026-03-19

Stripped for Phase 2 re-enrichment

Deep Enrichment2026-03-19
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-20