Hacker News

Hacker News is a social news aggregation and discussion site owned and funded by Y Combinator, focusing on computer science, startups, and technology. Users submit links and text posts, upvote submissions, and discuss and vote on comments. Its deliberately minimalist design has no paywall; YC job ads and startup launches receive front-page placement.

17/ 100
Healthy
1No Decay→Stable

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-26. Score revised 2026-10-26: 14 → 17.

Score History

Milestone← Y Combinator Founded (2005)CriticalMajor
Graham's Hands-On Forum (2007–2014) · 11/100Graham's Hands-On ForumProfessionalized Moderation (2014–2015) · 13/100Prof…Autonomous HN Unit (2015–2023) · 15/100Autonomous HN UnitTan Takes Over (2023–present) · 17/100Tan Takes Over1007550250200820122016202020242026-10Graham's Hands-On Forum (2007–2014) · 11/100Professionalized Moderation (2014–2015) · 13/100Autonomous HN Unit (2015–2023) · 15/100Tan Takes Over (2023–present) · 17/10011131517MilestonesFounded (2007)Sam Altman Becomes YC President (2014)Garry Tan Becomes YC CEO (2023)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Graham's Hands-On Forum
11/100
2007-02-19 – 2014-03-29

Paul Graham launches Startup News in February 2007 as an Arc demo and a community tool for the YC network, renaming it Hacker News that August. Graham runs and moderates the site himself while it grows quickly, peaking at 1,474 submissions in one day in November 2011, and adds defenses such as hellbanning, publicly criticized in 2012, and hidden ranking penalties that a 2013 analysis found on about 20% of front-page stories. YC job posts and batch launches already reach the front page, which Graham acknowledged was clogged with launches before Demo Day in August 2012.

Professionalized Moderation
13/100+2
2014-03-29 – 2015-09-29

Daniel Gackle becomes HN's first full-time moderator as Graham steps back and Sam Altman takes over YC. The team experiments in the open: it retunes comment ranking so some downvotes count more (April 2014), labels items killed by user flags and reverses an unpopular experiment that auto-killed downvoted comments (November 2014). Algolia search, a formal Show HN section and a public Firebase API with no rate limits improve the product, and Altman reports traffic up about 30% alongside better discussion.

Autonomous HN Unit
15/100+2
2015-09-29 – 2023-01-01

YC takes HN out of its investment branch as an autonomous unit with editorial independence and launches vouching so users can rescue [dead] posts. The era's opacity concerns come from moderation: a two-day political detox week in December 2016, 2017 analyses of severe rank drops and flagging abuse, and community accounts of political topics being flagged, partly offset by the second-chance pool made public in 2021. HN also feeds YC's deal flow, as in the 2016 Apply HN fellowship experiment.

Tan Takes Over
17/100+2
2023-01-01 – present

Garry Tan becomes YC's CEO and president; in March 2023 YC cuts about 20% of staff and shuts its Continuity operation. Tan's politics (the January 2024 'die slow' post aimed at San Francisco supervisors, YC's opposition to SB 1047 and the February 2026 launch of Garry's List) raise concerns about the parent's governance, while HN itself stays free, minimalist and YC-funded. In 2026 HN responds to a surge of low-familiarity and AI-generated posting by temporarily restricting Show HN and banning AI-generated and AI-edited comments.

Alternatives

Reddit61/100

Subreddits like r/programming, r/technology, and r/netsec cover similar ground to Hacker News. Topic-specific communities offer a different way to find programming, technology, and security discussions.

Invitation-only, open-source tech link aggregator with mandatory tagging and transparent moderation logs. Smaller but more focused community than HN. Easy switch for reading; participating requires an invitation, which can also be sought through the community chat.

Non-profit, open-source discussion platform with thoughtful moderation and no advertising. Broader topic range than HN with a similar culture of substantive discussion. Easy to start reading; requires an invite to participate.

In the News

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Hacker News's plain-HTML interface and its submit, vote and discuss loop are essentially unchanged since 2007, with nothing paywalled or removed and improvements such as Algolia search and the public API (2014) and the 2024 move to SBCL that removed pagination on long threads. The main pressure on quality is scale and, in 2026, an influx of AI-generated content, which HN answered by temporarily restricting Show HN posts and banning AI-generated and AI-edited comments. Graham long acknowledged a slow decline in the community as it grew, but the product remains near its quality peak.
How It Got Here
Hacker News launched in February 2007 with a deliberately spartan interface that has remained virtually unchanged for nearly two decades: plain HTML, no JavaScript frameworks, no infinite scroll. Paul Graham acknowledged as early as 2009 that growth was diluting community quality, and a historical analysis recorded a daily submission peak of 1,474 stories in November 2011. After Daniel Gackle took over moderation in 2014, HN improved steadily: Algolia-powered search in January 2014, retuned comment ranking in April, a formal Show HN section in July and a public API in October; by November 2014 Sam Altman reported traffic up about 30% alongside better discussion. A September 2024 migration from Racket to Common Lisp (SBCL) improved performance, removing pagination on long threads. In 2026 the pressure came from outside: amid a surge of posting from new and AI-assisted accounts, HN temporarily restricted Show HN posts in March and codified a ban on AI-generated and AI-edited comments to keep discussion human. No features have been removed, no paywalls erected and no paid third-party display ads introduced, though YC job ads and startup launches receive front-page placement. The score of 1 reflects a product near its quality peak, with the modest concern that scale has broadened the community beyond its original tight-knit hacker focus.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2007Graham's Hands-On Forum2014Professionalized Moderation2015Autonomous HN Unit2023Tan Takes OverUser Value1011Biz Exploit1111Shareholder0111Lock-in2333Algorithms2233Dark Patterns1111Advertising1111Competition1222Labor/Gov1112Regulatory1112
Timeline (46 events)
critical2007-02-19

Paul Graham Launches Hacker News as Arc Demo

Paul Graham launches Startup News (later Hacker News) as a real-world application of the Arc programming language he co-developed. The site is designed partly for Y Combinator's own use and to recreate the startup community that had gathered on early Reddit, providing a user-ranked list of startup-related links and a place for founders and would-be founders to meet.

major2007-08-14

Startup News Renamed to Hacker News

The site changes its name from Startup News to Hacker News, broadening its focus from startup news to news interesting to hackers generally. Paul Graham says the aim is to recreate early Reddit's hacker community and describes the scope as anything that gratifies intellectual curiosity.

major2008-03-10

TechCrunch Features Hacker News as Must-Read Tech Source

TechCrunch publishes 'Little Known Hacker News Is My First Read Every Morning,' bringing significant mainstream tech visibility to the site. The coverage helps accelerate HN's growth beyond the YC founder community into the broader tech ecosystem.

major2009-02-01

Paul Graham Publishes Lessons from Running HN

Graham publishes "What I've Learned from Hacker News," explaining that weekday traffic grew from about 1,600 daily unique visitors at launch to around 22,000. He identifies the tension between growth and quality, saying he would not want HN to become as large as Digg or Reddit because that would dilute its character.

major2009-03-16

Sequoia and Angel Investors Commit $2M to YC-Managed Startup Fund

Sequoia Capital and angel investors commit $2 million to a new entity managed by Y Combinator, rather than investing directly in YC. The capital lets YC increase the number of startups it funds from around 40 to 60 per year, expanding the ecosystem that Hacker News supports.

major2011-02-28

Monthly Hiring Threads Documented by Early 2011

The March 2011 edition of "Ask HN: Who's Hiring?" is posted on February 28, offering employers a community thread for job listings. Its introduction calls it "another Hiring thread," showing that such threads already existed. These monthly discussions develop into a longstanding free job-posting venue open beyond YC companies.

minor2011-11-29

HN Submission Volume Peaks at 1,474 Daily Stories

Debarghya Das's analysis of Hacker News data reports that daily submissions peaked at 1,474 stories on November 29, 2011. After that peak, average daily volume remained around 900 through the analysis's October 2015 cutoff, showing stabilization in that dataset.

major2012-06-13

Hacker News Hellbanning Draws Public Criticism

Joshua Stein publicly criticizes Hacker News hellbanning after finding that his comments appear to post but are hidden from ordinary readers, while remaining visible to him and users who enable showdead. He reports being banned after criticizing title moderation and says the practice leaves the moderation process opaque. The system already existed before this report; it is generally used against spam and abuse.

minor2012-07-03

Lobste.rs Launches as HN Alternative

Joshua Stein launches Lobste.rs, an invitation-only, open-source link aggregation site with transparent moderation logs and mandatory story tagging. Stein describes creating it after being banned from Hacker News, and its design offers moderation transparency as an alternative.

minor2012-08-16

Graham Apologizes for YC Launches Clogging the Front Page

Paul Graham thanked readers for their patience because the front page had been clogged with launches by YC's Summer 2012 batch ahead of Demo Day, saying most startups launch at the last minute. In the thread, users also complained about recurring job posts from YC companies.

minor2013-05-18

TechCrunch Documents HN's Evolution and Growth Tensions

TechCrunch publishes 'The Evolution of Hacker News,' reporting 200,000 unique weekday visitors and 1.6 million daily pageviews. The article documents concerns about community quality dilution and the tension between HN's role as a YC community tool and a public tech forum. Graham says, "The community has been in a perpetual but slow decline because the site is growing."

major2013-11-18

Researcher Exposes Hidden Penalty System Affecting 20% of Stories

Ken Shirriff publishes an empirical analysis of Hacker News ranking, estimating that about 20% of front-page stories receive penalties beyond the basic formula. He documents a controversy penalty for stories with more comments than upvotes after reaching 40 comments, a title penalty for "NSA," and domain-based penalties. He says it is unclear whether other penalties come from administrators or flagged stories.

major2013-12-27

Paul Graham Faces Backlash Over Women in Tech Comments

Valleywag publishes Paul Graham's interview with The Information where he states women 'haven't been hacking for the past 10 years.' The comments spark a controversy about gender bias in YC's culture and the tech industry broadly. Graham claims the quote was taken out of context, saying he said 'make *these* women look...' but the incident highlights governance concerns at HN's parent organization.

major2014-01-24

Algolia Replaces ThriftDB as HN Search Provider

Algolia announces its Hacker News search engine at hn.algolia.com, succeeding Octopart's HNSearch. The service provides instant search with typo-aware ranking across 1.2 million articles and 5.2 million comments. Algolia is part of YC's Winter 2014 batch, and the freely accessible search service showcases its technology.

critical2014-02-21

Paul Graham Steps Down, Sam Altman Becomes YC President

After nine years running Y Combinator, Paul Graham steps away from day-to-day operations. Sam Altman, a YC alum from the first 2005 batch, takes over as president. Graham states 'YC needs to grow, and I'm not the best person to grow it.' The transition marks HN's shift from founder-led to institutional oversight.

critical2014-03-29

Daniel Gackle Hired as Full-Time HN Moderator

Y Combinator hires Daniel Gackle (username 'dang') as the first full-time Hacker News moderator, after he had been doing informal moderation for approximately 18 months. Gackle, a Stanford literature major and former YC-backed startup founder, brings a distinctive personal approach to moderation, engaging in extended email conversations with users to improve discussion quality.

minor2014-04-17

HN Retunes Comment Scoring and Ranking Algorithms

Sam Altman said moderators dang and kogir had studied the data and tuned the comment scoring and ranking algorithms to make some downvotes more powerful, and that the change appeared to be reducing toxic comments. He also described moderators posting neutral feedback in threads as a second experiment.

minor2014-07-03

Show HN Becomes Official Feature with Dedicated Section

Hacker News creates a dedicated section for Show HN posts, formalizing what had been an informal convention since 2009. Average daily Show HN submissions nearly triple from 19 to 53 per day after the change, providing a structured way for makers to share their projects with the community.

major2014-10-07

HN Launches Public Firebase API with No Rate Limits

Y Combinator launches an official Hacker News API built on Firebase, providing real-time read access to all stories, comments, and user data with no rate limits or authentication required. The API replaces ad-hoc scraping that developers had been doing, enabling a rich ecosystem of third-party HN clients and tools.

major2014-11-10

HN Labels Flag-Killed Posts and Reverses Auto-Kill Experiment

Sam Altman reported that HN had lowered the threshold for user flags to kill inappropriate comments and begun indicating in the interface which items were killed by flags. A separate experiment that automatically killed sufficiently downvoted comments was reversed after users objected that it punished unpopular opinions too harshly. Altman said traffic was up about 30% over the previous six months and attributed it mainly to better quality.

minor2015-07-20

YC Launches Equity-Free Fellowship Program

Y Combinator launches the Fellowship program, offering $12,000 equity-free grants to very early startups. The initial program chooses about 20 teams for an eight-week period with dedicated partner support and continued access to the YC community.

major2015-09-29

YC Makes HN an Autonomous Unit and Launches Vouching

Y Combinator moved Hacker News out of its investment branch into its own autonomous unit, saying HN must have full editorial independence and that Daniel Gackle could report directly to the YC Board of Overseers if he chose. The same announcement launched 'vouch' links that let users with at least 30 karma rescue [dead] posts, with moderators reviewing vouched posts.

major2015-10-15

YC Raises $700M Continuity Fund

Y Combinator raises a $700 million Continuity Fund for growth-stage investments in YC alumni companies, led by Ali Rowghani. The fund represents YC's expansion beyond seed-stage acceleration, potentially increasing the strategic importance of Hacker News as a funnel for YC's expanding investment apparatus.

minor2016-05-05

Apply HN Winners Announced; Top-Voted Applicant Left Out

YC announced the startups funded through Apply HN, an experiment that let the HN community vote on applications for YC Fellowship spots. YC said it received 343 applications and over 1,700 comments, and that the application with the most votes was not on the final list.

major2016-12-05

HN Imposes Political Detox Week After 2016 Election

Moderator Daniel Gackle announces a "Political Detox Week" banning political stories and political threads on non-political stories, following flamewars around the 2016 US election. Critics accuse the experiment of suppressing political perspectives. The experiment ends after two days rather than the planned week. Gackle says it is impossible to define politics by consensus because that question is itself highly political, and that HN works best when it can follow intellectually interesting subjects, some with political dimensions.

major2017-03-13

Analysis Finds Severe Rank Drops in 2.1% of Sampled Front-Page Stories

Researcher Evan Sangaline analyzes Hacker News ranking data and finds 26 of 1,213 front-page stories over roughly two weeks that dropped more than 100 places in less than 30 seconds without being marked dead, duplicate, or flagged. He interprets these abrupt drops as possible moderator intervention and notes that they occurred daily.

minor2017-09-13

Drew DeVault Publishes Detailed HN Censorship Analysis

Developer Drew DeVault publishes "Analyzing HN moderation & censorship," documenting story-rank interventions and arguing that users abuse flagging to suppress posts. He describes the removal threshold as low, lists examples he considers questionable, and notes that HN provides no flagging guidelines. Separately, in August 2019, Anna Wiener reported in The New Yorker that, as an occasional reader, she had observed users often flagging stories about diversity in tech or structural barriers facing women so quickly that hardly any comments accrued.

minor2018-05-02

Tildes Launches Invite-Only Alpha as a Non-Profit Community Site

Chad Birch, known as Deimos and formerly a Reddit developer, announces Tildes' invite-only alpha. He describes a non-profit link-aggregator-style community site with no investors or advertising, supported by donations, and open-source code. Its design prioritizes users and substantive discussion, adding to the ecosystem of alternatives for discussion-site readers.

major2019-03-08

Sam Altman Departs YC to Focus on OpenAI

Sam Altman leaves the Y Combinator presidency to focus on OpenAI, where he becomes CEO. Later reporting and Paul Graham's account disagree about whether he was forced out: Graham says Jessica Livingston asked Altman to choose between leading OpenAI and YC, and he agreed, while other reporting describes partners pushing him out over conflicts with personal projects. Geoff Ralston subsequently succeeds him as YC president.

major2019-08-08

New Yorker Profiles HN's Moderation Approach

Anna Wiener publishes "The Lonely Work of Moderating Hacker News" in The New Yorker, profiling Daniel Gackle and Scott Bell's distinctive personal and slow moderation approach. The article describes email exchanges with individual users that can last four or five years, offering a rare public look at HN's governance philosophy.

minor2021-04-30

Second Chance Pool Mechanism Made Public

Hacker News publicly documents its 'second chance pool' at news.ycombinator.com/pool, a mechanism where moderators can give quality stories that didn't gain traction a second chance at the front page. Users can also email hn@ycombinator.com to suggest stories for the pool, providing a counterweight to algorithmic and flagging-based suppression.

minor2022-06-07

Garry Tan Backs the Successful 2022 Boudin Recall

Garry Tan, a former YC partner and Initialized Capital co-founder, backs the campaign to recall San Francisco District Attorney Chesa Boudin, contributing at least $100,500 before the June 2022 election. The recall succeeds, establishing Tan as a major local political donor before he becomes YC CEO in 2023.

critical2023-01-01

Garry Tan Becomes Y Combinator CEO and President

Garry Tan officially assumes the roles of CEO and president of Y Combinator, succeeding Geoff Ralston. Tan, a former YC partner and founder of Initialized Capital, brings a more politically outspoken leadership style to the organization that runs Hacker News.

major2023-03-13

Y Combinator Cuts 20% of Staff, Shuts Down Continuity Fund

Under Garry Tan's leadership, Y Combinator shuts down its Continuity growth-investing operation and related programs in March 2023, laying off 17 employees, about 20% of its full-time staff. The operation's leaders, Anu Hariharan and Ali Rowghani, also depart.

minor2023-09-27

SF Standard Profiles Tan's War on Progressive Politics

The San Francisco Standard publishes an extensive profile documenting Garry Tan's aggressive engagement in San Francisco politics, describing him as one of the "fiercest critics of progressives." Tan urges tech people to get involved through voting, saying, "I'm not asking for more than a vote. I just want our vote."

critical2024-01-28

YC CEO Tan Posts 'Die Slow' Tweet Targeting SF Supervisors

Garry Tan posts a since-deleted tweet naming seven San Francisco supervisors followed by "Die slow motherfuckers," referencing Tupac Shakur lyrics. Tan deletes the post and apologizes, but the incident raises serious governance concerns about the CEO of Hacker News's parent organization.

major2024-01-31

SF Supervisors File Police Reports Over Tan Tweet Threats

Three San Francisco supervisors, Aaron Peskin, Myrna Melgar and Dean Preston, receive threatening letters following Garry Tan's "die slow" tweet. Peskin quotes a letter saying, "I wish a slow, painful death for you and your loved ones." The three and two other supervisors have made police reports. Peskin says he does not believe the letter came from Tan.

minor2024-02-02

Front-Page Removal Tracker Prompts Moderator Explanations

A GitHub project logging stories that drop off the HN front page in real time reached 712 points and 489 comments on HN. In the thread, moderator dang said stories users cited had been downranked by the flamewar detector or by user flags rather than by admins, and that moderators review stories hit by that software penalty and restore those that are not flamewars.

minor2024-05-26

Tan Takes Position on AI Regulation Debate

Garry Tan publicly discusses AI regulation, supporting NIST's proposed GenAI risk framework and parts of the Biden administration's executive order while describing California and San Francisco legislative efforts as concerning. In the underlying May 22 interview, he also warns that attempts to address speculative AI risks could concentrate power in just a few models, creating a monopolistic situation and enabling rent extraction. The positioning reflects YC's increasing role in tech policy debates beyond its traditional startup accelerator function.

major2024-06-24

YC Signs Letter Opposing California AI Safety Bill SB 1047

Garry Tan and Y Combinator sign a letter opposing California's SB 1047 AI safety bill, claiming 'AI software developers could go to jail' under the law. State Senator Scott Wiener specifically criticizes YC and Andreessen Horowitz for spreading this narrative. Governor Newsom ultimately vetoes the bill in September 2024.

minor2024-09-01

HN Migrates from Racket to Common Lisp (SBCL)

Hacker News completes a migration from its original Racket-based Arc implementation to SBCL (Steel Bank Common Lisp) via a reimplementation called Clarc. The migration, motivated by performance, enables multi-core processing and removes pagination on long discussion threads. The code remains proprietary to protect anti-abuse measures.

minor2025-04-02

Tom Howard Announced as Second Public HN Moderator

Hacker News announces Tom Howard (username "tomhow") as a public moderator alongside Daniel Gackle. Howard had been moderating privately for years; the announcement makes his role visible. Gackle says users will now see moderator comments from two people.

minor2026-01-15

Tan Warns Khanna's Policies Could 'Destroy California Startups'

Garry Tan publicly warns that Rep. Ro Khanna's support for a billionaire tax and unrealized gains taxes could 'destroy California startups and set back American innovation by a decade.' The statement reflects YC's escalating political engagement under Tan's leadership, with the organization actively opposing tax policies that could affect its portfolio companies.

major2026-02-11

Tan Launches 'Garry's List' Dark-Money Political Nonprofit

Garry Tan launches 'Garry's List,' a 501(c)(4) dark-money nonprofit described as a 'voter education group.' As a 501(c)(4), the organization can spend on elections without revealing all its donors. The nonprofit begins with a blog attacking public-sector unions, opposing a teachers' strike, and denouncing proposed billionaire taxes, expanding YC's political footprint from San Francisco to statewide California politics.

minor2026-03-08

HN Temporarily Restricts Show HN Posts

Replying to a 721-point Ask HN thread asking HN to stop new accounts posting what the author saw as AI-generated submissions, moderator dang said HN would at least restrict Show HNs for a while. HN's notice says Show HN was temporarily restricted because of a massive influx, mostly from users not yet familiar with the site or its culture.

major2026-03-12

HN Bans AI-Generated and AI-Edited Comments

Hacker News formally updates its guidelines to ban AI-generated and AI-edited comments, with the rule: "Don't post generated comments or AI-edited comments. HN is for conversation between humans." Moderator Daniel Gackle notes the rule already existed as "case law" but is being codified. He also says the site plans to add a way to flag suspected AI content, joking that he can change his mind about flag reasons "every decade or so."

Evidence (45 citations)

D1: User Value Erosion

Scoring Log (5 entries)
fact-audit2026-10-26FABRICATION FOUND

Checked 78 original timeline/evidence/milestone items and 3 alternatives, plus metadata, 10 dimension summaries, 10 narratives and 6 eras. 24 verified, 32 corrected (14 date-only), 24 re-sourced, 1 duplicate removed. Five supporting evidence additions preserve existing mixed-source facts. 27 distinct prose claims corrected. Strict contradicted specifics: Lobsters founder Josh Simmons — https://lobste.rs/about; Algolia YC S14 batch — https://community.algolia.com/jekyll-algolia-example/2014/01/24/hacker-news-search-algolia.html; 2.1% of front-page stories severely penalized daily — https://sangaline.com/post/the-stories-that-hacker-news-removes-from-the-front-page/; Registration form has three fields — https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45361945. Unsupported details are listed with search records in work/early-decisions.json, work/late-decisions.json and work/lead-decisions.json.

regrade2026-10-26RESCORED

14→17. Since Feb 2026: HN temporarily restricted Show HN (Mar 8) and banned AI-generated/edited comments (Mar 12) amid an influx of AI-assisted posting; parent-level Garry's List launch (Feb 11) already recorded; no HN pricing, ad, legal or labor changes found. D4 2→3 (recalibration: staff-mediated deletion rated 'hard' by JustDeleteMe, no takeout, non-portable reputation, against open API), D6 0→1 (recalibration: shadowbanning hides posts from banned users without notice, a minor deceptive mechanic within the 0-1 band's upper end), D7 0→1 (correction: fact audit established YC job ads and launches get front-page placement, so 'no ads' premise was false). Eras: 'Arc Experiment' re-dated 2007-02-01→2007-02-19 (launch) and merged with 'Rapid Growth' (2010-01-01 had no inflection event) as 'Graham's Hands-On Forum'; 'Professionalized Moderation' re-dated 2014-04-01→2014-03-29 (Gackle hired); 'Institutional Maturity' re-dated 2019-01-01→2015-09-29 (HN made an autonomous YC unit; Altman's 2019 exit did not change HN) and relabeled 'Autonomous HN Unit'; 'Tan Takes Over' kept; 'Community Asset' (dated to the 2026-02-28 assessment) merged into 'Tan Takes Over' since nothing since 2023 changed the forces driving scores. Early eras re-scored higher (old 4/6 → 11) mainly from D2/D7/D8 YC front-page placement (documented by 2011-2012), D6 shadowbanning and D4 staff-mediated deletion applied consistently. Category: HN is a link aggregator/discussion forum, not a publisher; the Digital News & Media guide's editorial criteria fit poorly (moderation was scored as D5 opacity) — consider a social/community category.

restore-check2026-10-26RESTORED

Checked all 10 trimmed candidates: 0 restored, 2 partly restored, 7 confirmed removed, 1 already present. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:21: The New Yorker (Anna Wiener, 2019-08-08) supplies an attributed observation of rapid diversity-story flagging, separately from DeVault; no quantified disparity or regardless-of-quality assertion. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:32: Economic Club transcript (2024-05-22) supplies the speculative-risk response/concentration/rent-extraction causal warning underlying TechCrunch's May 26 report. ALREADY PRESENT timeline:update:3: the perpetual-but-slow-decline quote is in current timeline[10], correctly attributed to TechCrunch 2013-05-18, read this session. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:0 (launch-day no-ad/minimal-infrastructure specifics); :5 (April 2011 first thread and 58,000 listings by 2024); :6 (500/day 2010 baseline and permanent organic ceiling); :19 (Gackle concluding detox could not solve civility); :22 (Tildes explicitly targeting HN moderation opacity); :24 (Gackle reads every comment); :35 (first moderation-team expansion in over a decade). Original cited pages and archives checked; unavailable/empty archives were not treated as evidence. Primary launch announcement, early hiring thread, Das analysis, moved DeVault article, Tildes launch post, New Yorker profile and moderator announcement read. At most three searches per candidate, with two for the recovered Tan warning and none needed for the already-present quote. Candidate decisions are recorded in work/restore-decisions.json. No removals or score changes.

Deep Enrichment2026-03-15
Initial Scoring2026-02-28