Home Assistant
Home Assistant is a free, open-source home automation platform that puts local control and privacy first. It connects over 1,000 device brands and services, runs on local hardware without cloud dependency, and is governed by the Open Home Foundation, a Swiss non-profit. An optional paid cloud service (Nabu Casa) funds development.
Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-30.
Score History
Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.
Paulus Schoutsen publishes Home Assistant on GitHub in September 2013 as a personal Python project for controlling Philips Hue lights. It grows as a volunteer, fully open-source project with no commercial entity and no cloud dependency, formalizing an Apache 2.0 license and contributor agreement in January 2017 and launching the Hass.io operating system in July 2017. Decisions stay concentrated in its founder.
Home Assistant Cloud launches as a free beta in December 2017, with a planned $5/month package to fund development. In September 2018 Paulus Schoutsen starts Nabu Casa, a subscriber-funded company that pledges not to take investor money, and remote access is added in March 2019 while core automation stays free. In May 2020 the project puts a plan to deprecate Supervised installs on generic Linux on hold after community feedback.
At its first conference in December 2020 the project announces Home Assistant Blue, its first official hardware, and ships automation Blueprints. Nabu Casa acquires ESPHome in March 2021, Home Assistant Yellow is crowdfunded in September 2021, and the cloud subscription rises from $5 to $6.50 in February 2022. With over 1,900 integrations, it describes itself as the world's largest home automation platform, which adds mild switching costs.
Home Assistant ships an alpha Matter integration in December 2022 and spends 2023 on the Year of the Voice, delivering local voice control in more than 50 languages. The Works with Home Assistant certification program, launched in July 2022, signs manufacturers, Home Assistant Green launches at $99, and Nabu Casa joins the Z-Wave Alliance to certify Z-Wave JS. Control still sits with founder-owned Nabu Casa.
The Open Home Foundation is announced in April 2024 as a Swiss non-profit owning Home Assistant, ESPHome and more than 240 projects, protecting them against acquisition. Works with Home Assistant moves to the Foundation, Paulus Schoutsen joins the Z-Wave Alliance board, and the Voice Preview Edition launches at $59. Automatic backups arrive in January 2025, drawing questions about how clearly free local storage is distinguished from paid cloud storage, and Matter certification follows in March 2025.
In April 2025 the Foundation reports that it has become a tax-exempt Stiftung and taken on 39 full-time project staff from Nabu Casa, separating development from the commercial partner, as installations pass 2 million. Since then, support for Core, Supervised and 32-bit installs ended in December 2025, Green's price rose to $199 on component costs, and the roadmap went public. The subscription price is unchanged, and a built-in Marketplace is set to replace HACS.
Alternatives
Free, open-source home automation platform with a Java-based architecture, supporting more than 400 technologies and systems and thousands of devices. Runs on your own hardware without requiring a cloud service and keeps data at home. An actively maintained alternative with a similar focus on local control and privacy. Free to self-host.
Local-processing smart home hub with automations that continue working during internet disruptions, similar to Home Assistant. Requires dedicated hardware; the standard Hubitat Elevation C-8 Pro is listed at $199.95 in the US. A hardware-based option for users who want local control.
Dimensional Breakdown
Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.
Dimension History
Timeline (64 events)
Paulus Schoutsen Pushes First Home Assistant Code to GitHub
After experimenting with the Philips Hue local API in Python while a visiting scholar at UC San Diego in 2012, Paulus Schoutsen publishes the first version of Home Assistant on GitHub on September 17, 2013. The open-source project grows into a community that, by its tenth anniversary, is described as GitHub's second most active open-source project.
Governance Formalized with Apache 2.0 License and CLA
Home Assistant formalizes its governance model by switching to the Apache 2.0 license and adopting a Contributor License Agreement based on GitHub's CLA. Starting with release 0.37, all contributions require an electronically signed CLA. This establishes clear legal frameworks for the growing contributor base and protects the project's open-source status.
Hass.io Managed Operating System Launched
Home Assistant launches Hass.io, a managed operating system designed to simplify running Home Assistant on single-board computers like the Raspberry Pi. The add-on store lets users install, configure, and update complementary services in a couple of clicks. It is designed to reduce the time users spend maintaining their systems and applications. An April 2018 follow-up documents single-click installation of an adblocker, MQTT broker, or Tor add-on. LWN’s 2023 retrospective credits the managed installation and web interface with broadening Home Assistant’s appeal beyond technically inclined enthusiasts.
Home Assistant Cloud Beta Launches with Alexa Integration
Home Assistant introduces Home Assistant Cloud in a free public beta, initially providing Amazon Alexa Smart Home integration without exposing the local instance to the internet. The announcement plans to end the beta on March 1, 2018, after which a $5/month Community Support package would fund development and operating costs. The beta ultimately continued into September 2018; secure remote access was added in March 2019.
Nabu Casa Founded as Subscriber-Only Company
On Home Assistant's fifth anniversary, Paulus Schoutsen announces that he has started Nabu Casa, Inc. to manage Home Assistant Cloud subscriptions at $5/month. The company explicitly commits to subscriber-only funding and not raising money from investors. Revenue will fund cloud functionality, infrastructure, and full-time Home Assistant contributors.
Lovelace UI Released as Default Dashboard
After 8 months in beta, the Lovelace UI becomes Home Assistant's default interface in version 0.86. The new dashboard separates UI configuration from the backend state machine, introduces a visual card editor with live preview, and supports custom community cards. It represents a major usability improvement over the previous states UI.
Major Brand Consolidation Simplifies Naming
Home Assistant restructures its branding to reduce confusion. Hass.io is renamed to Home Assistant, while the core Python application becomes Home Assistant Core. The operating system is renamed Home Assistant OS. The supervisor component manages system administration. This simplification helps newcomers navigate the ecosystem.
Generic Installer Deprecation Put on Hold; Supported Installation Methods Defined
After announcing plans to deprecate the generic Home Assistant Supervised installer, the project says the method proved more popular than expected and puts the plan on hold. It introduces a distinction between officially supported and community-supported installation methods and apologizes for outdated installation guides.
First Home Assistant Conference and Blue Hardware Launch
Home Assistant hosts its first online conference with 16 talks across three tracks, between opening and closing keynotes. Tickets cost $1, and a free YouTube livestream covers the keynotes and the everyone track. At the conference the project also announces its first official hardware, the limited-edition Home Assistant Blue, an ODROID-N2+ hub sold for $140.
Automation Blueprints Feature Launched
Home Assistant 2020.12 introduces Blueprints, pre-created automations with configurable inputs that can be shared and imported via URL. This enables complex automations to be packaged and distributed by the community, making sophisticated home automation accessible to users who prefer the UI editor over YAML configuration.
Nabu Casa Acquires ESPHome to Protect Open-Source Project
Nabu Casa acquires the ESPHome project from founder Otto Winter to help sustain its development as free, open-source software. ESPHome enables users to compile and flash custom firmware onto ESP32/ESP8266 microcontrollers and integrate them with Home Assistant. Winter steps back from project management as personal obligations increase; the existing development team continues the project.
Energy Dashboard Launches for Home Energy Monitoring
Home Assistant 2021.8 introduces a dedicated Energy Dashboard enabling users to monitor electricity consumption, solar production, and grid usage. The feature is vendor-agnostic, supporting smart meters, inverters, CT clamps, and smart plugs. It includes integration with Forecast.Solar for solar production predictions and leverages new long-term statistics for historical tracking.
Home Assistant Yellow Crowdfunded on Crowd Supply
For Home Assistant's eighth birthday, Nabu Casa launches a Crowd Supply campaign for Home Assistant Yellow, originally named Amber. The Raspberry Pi CM4-based hub includes a Silicon Labs Zigbee radio with OpenThread support and planned Matter compatibility. The campaign has a $140,000 goal and goes on to exceed 180% of target. Kits start at $99 without a CM4 or $149 complete; the goal is reached in less than five days.
100,000 Opt-in Analytics Installations Milestone
Seven months after launching the opt-in analytics system, Home Assistant reaches 100,000 installations reporting to analytics. Since analytics require active opt-in, the actual installation base is estimated at 4-5x higher (400,000-500,000). Raspberry Pi is the most popular platform, followed by virtual machines.
First Cloud Subscription Price Increase to $6.50/Month
Nabu Casa raises the Home Assistant Cloud subscription from $5 to $6.50/month for new subscriptions and payment-method changes after February 1, 2022, its first increase in over three years. Annual subscriptions launch first in the United States at $65/year. Existing subscribers keep their previous price for three months if unchanged. The increase covers inflation and further development of the open home.
Works with Home Assistant Certification Program Launched
Nabu Casa introduces the Works with Home Assistant program for manufacturers. Members must maintain their Home Assistant integration, provide product samples and an engineering contact, and in return may use the program badge. The terms are set in an agreement between Nabu Casa and each manufacturer.
SkyConnect USB Dongle Opens for Preorder for Zigbee and Thread
Home Assistant's SkyConnect USB stick, later renamed Connect ZBT-1, is available for preorder at $29.99. Based on the Silicon Labs EFR32MG21 chip, it supports Zigbee 3.0 and Thread protocols. The report says the first batch is expected to ship in November or December, with over-the-wire firmware updates planned for additional protocol support.
Home Assistant Releases First Matter Integration as Alpha Preview
Home Assistant releases the first iteration of its Matter integration, describing itself as one of the first platforms to roll out Matter support publicly. The integration is an alpha or developer preview, allowing users to commission a Matter-certified product. Companion-app commissioning support is still being developed for release in the coming weeks.
Year of the Voice Initiative Announced for 2023
Home Assistant announces that 2023 will be the 'Year of the Voice,' with the goal of enabling users to control Home Assistant in their own languages. The initiative aims to provide a privacy-preserving, locally focused alternative to cloud-dependent voice assistants. Mike Hansen joins Nabu Casa to lead the effort; the team starts by collecting intent-matching sentences in different languages.
Voice Chapter 1: Assist Launches with 22 Languages
The first chapter of Year of the Voice delivers Assist, Home Assistant's built-in voice assistant supporting text-based interaction in 22 languages. Users can control devices and query states through natural language processed entirely locally. The feature introduces intent recognition and sentence parsing for smart home commands.
Remote Supervisor API Authentication Bypass Disclosed and Patched
Home Assistant publishes an advisory for a remotely exploitable vulnerability that bypassed authentication to the Supervisor API, affecting all installation types using Supervisor 2023.03.2 or older. The fix in Supervisor 2023.03.3 had already been rolled out to affected installations through auto-update before publication.
Voice Chapter 2: Local Speech-to-Text and Text-to-Speech
The second voice chapter adds audio processing capabilities, enabling full voice input and output with local options. Piper, Home Assistant's locally running neural text-to-speech system, is introduced with over 40 voices across 18 languages. On a Raspberry Pi 4 it can generate two seconds of audio in one second of processing. Whisper integration provides local speech-to-text processing.
10th Anniversary Celebrated with Green Hardware Launch
On its tenth anniversary, Home Assistant announces Home Assistant Green, a turnkey hardware hub with a 1.8 GHz quad-core CPU, 4GB RAM, and 32GB eMMC. The anniversary batch of 1,000 units has sold out. The device features the project's refreshed logo. The parallel anniversary announcement sets its launch MSRP at $99 and describes Home Assistant as GitHub's second most active open-source project.
Voice Chapter 4: Wake Word Detection Added
Wake word processing is added inside Home Assistant, allowing hands-free voice activation. The feature uses openWakeWord, an open-source wake word detection engine that runs locally. Users can trigger Assist by saying a customizable wake phrase, eliminating the need for a button press or screen interaction.
Nabu Casa Attends Matter Member Meeting at CSA
Nabu Casa participates in the Connectivity Standards Alliance member meeting to advocate for Home Assistant users and the Open Home vision. As a CSA participant member, Nabu Casa has access to official Matter technical documentation and a voice in the standard's development. This ensures open-source interests are represented in the smart home industry's primary standards body.
Voice Chapter 5: Year of the Voice Completed with 50+ Languages
The final chapter of Year of the Voice completes the initiative with voice control available in over 50 languages across multiple device types. A Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W can handle local audio cleanup and wake word detection without straining the Home Assistant server. Home Assistant offers a privacy-preserving alternative to cloud-dependent commercial voice assistants.
Nabu Casa Joins Z-Wave Alliance to Certify Z-Wave JS
Nabu Casa joins the Z-Wave Alliance and begins the certification process for Z-Wave JS, the fully open-source Z-Wave protocol implementation that powers Home Assistant's Z-Wave support. Dominic Griesel, Z-Wave JS creator, works full-time at Nabu Casa funded by Home Assistant Cloud subscribers. This deepens Home Assistant's commitment to open protocol implementations.
Voice Chapter 6: On-Device Wake Word Detection via ESP32-S3
Home Assistant introduces microWakeWord, enabling wake word detection directly on ESP32-S3 microcontrollers without requiring server-side wake word processing. Supported ESPHome voice satellite hardware can detect wake words locally, reducing the CPU usage and network traffic required when detection runs inside Home Assistant. This advances distributed, privacy-preserving voice control.
Dashboard Sections View with Drag-and-Drop Editing
Home Assistant introduces an experimental Sections view as part of Project Grace, the dashboard redesign initiative. The layout introduces drag-and-drop card rearrangement and responsive grid sections, making dashboard customization easier. Redesigned badges follow in the August 2024 release.
Open Home Foundation Launched with 240+ Projects
The Open Home Foundation is announced to govern Home Assistant, ESPHome, and over 240 open-source projects, standards, drivers, and libraries. Its original Swiss non-profit Verein structure is intended to protect projects against acquisition or mission drift. Nabu Casa becomes the inaugural commercial partner, contributing a majority of its revenue. Ownership and stewardship of the projects and trademarks move to the Foundation; contributors retain copyright in their own contributions.
State of the Open Home 2024: 1 Million Installations Announced
At State of the Open Home 2024, where the Foundation is launched, Home Assistant reports an estimated 1 million installations worldwide. The event includes voice and hardware updates, teasing upcoming Z-Wave and voice-assistant hardware, and a roadmap of upcoming features. Panel discussions include founders of collaborating projects WLED, Zigbee2MQTT, Rhasspy, and Z-Wave JS.
Music Assistant 2.0 Launches as a Home Assistant Add-on
Music Assistant 2.0 launches as a standalone music server that can run as a Home Assistant add-on, with a HACS integration. The open-source music library manager unifies streaming services and local music with audio players using AirPlay, Cast, and DLNA. Its players can be controlled through Home Assistant automations, scripts, and connected voice assistants.
AI Agent Integration for Smart Home Control
Home Assistant 2024.6 introduces AI agent support, allowing Google Gemini and OpenAI ChatGPT to control smart-home devices through Assist, scripts, and automations. Local models via Ollama are available for experimentation but cannot yet control Home Assistant at this launch. The feature builds on the conversation integration developed during Year of the Voice.
Voice Chapter 7: Supercharged Wake Words and Timers
Voice Chapter 7 delivers improved wake word detection and multiple timers for Assist, available on ESPHome and Wyoming voice satellites. The update also brings area-aware media player commands. Shared conversation context for LLM follow-up questions is documented in the later February 2025 voice update.
Works with Home Assistant Certification Moves to Foundation
The Works with Home Assistant certification program transfers from Nabu Casa to the Open Home Foundation, reinforcing its non-commercial nature. The program charges manufacturers 500 CHF per partner per year and tests actual local-first functionality. This structural change ensures the certification serves users rather than commercial interests.
HACS 2.0 Redesigned for Better Community Integration
The Home Assistant Community Store (HACS) receives a major 2.0 update, improving how community-created integrations, themes, and dashboard components are discovered and installed. HACS enables community developers to share custom code freely. The update improves the user experience for browsing and managing third-party extensions.
Home Assistant Founder Joins Z-Wave Alliance Board
Paulus Schoutsen takes a seat on the Z-Wave Alliance Board of Directors, representing Nabu Casa. Home Assistant estimates one-tenth of its households use Z-Wave, accounting for 1.7 million Z-Wave devices. The board position gives the open-source community a voice in the standard's governance and Home Assistant says it will continually push Z-Wave to align with Open Home values.
Home Assistant Ranked #1 on GitHub Octoverse 2024
GitHub's annual Octoverse 2024 report names Home Assistant the #1 public open-source project by active contributors, with over 21,000 contributors. Home Assistant also wins the Wonderfully Welcoming Award for being the 2nd most active project for first-time contributors. This recognition highlights the community-driven development model.
Voice Preview Edition Hardware Launches at $59 Recommended MSRP
Home Assistant releases the Voice Preview Edition, a dedicated voice assistant hardware device at a recommended MSRP of $59 (retailer prices may vary). It features an ESP32-S3 SoC, XMOS XU316 audio processor with echo cancellation, dual microphones, a hardware mute switch that physically cuts power to microphones, and a customizable LED ring. The device works out-of-the-box without firmware flashing.
Automatic Encrypted Cloud Backups Introduced
Home Assistant 2025.1 introduces automatic encrypted backups with configurable schedules. Cloud subscribers receive 5GB of encrypted off-site backup storage at no extra cost. A setup wizard guides new users through backup configuration in a few clicks. The feature addresses a long-standing gap in data protection for self-hosted installations.
Backup Downloads Become Unencrypted, Standard Archives
Home Assistant 2025.2 makes backups downloaded from the interface always unencrypted and extractable with standard archive tools, and lets users turn off encryption per storage location, except Home Assistant Cloud. The release also adds Google Drive and Microsoft OneDrive as backup locations.
Speech-to-Phrase Brings Fast Offline Voice to Low-Power Hardware
Home Assistant introduces Speech-to-Phrase, a local, offline speech engine that handles a subset of Assist commands. The project says it transcribes speech in under a second on Home Assistant Green or a Raspberry Pi 4, and in 150 milliseconds on a Raspberry Pi 5.
Apollo Automation Joins Works with Home Assistant Program
Apollo Automation certifies three ESPHome-based devices for the Works with Home Assistant program, becoming the first ESPHome-based products to receive certification. This marks the expansion of the certification program beyond traditional smart home manufacturers to the DIY sensor community.
First Open-Source Project to Achieve Matter Certification
The Connectivity Standards Alliance officially certifies Home Assistant and the Open Home Foundation Matter Server, making it the first open-source project to receive Matter certification. Home Assistant is certified as a UI Component and the Matter Server as a Software Component, covering all device types in the Matter 1.3 specification.
Foundation Transitions to Stiftung with Tax-Exempt Status
By its April 2025 State of the Open Home recap, the Open Home Foundation reports that it has transitioned from a Swiss Verein to a more protective Stiftung and achieved tax-exempt status under Swiss law. The Foundation has taken on 39 full-time project staff from Nabu Casa, while 56 people in total work to support Open Home projects and the surrounding community.
2 Million Active Installations Announced at State of the Open Home
At State of the Open Home 2025, Home Assistant reports that active installations grew from 1 million to over 2 million during 2024. The recap previews a 2025 roadmap focused on collective intelligence and a new device database, alongside a separate discussion of local AI experimentation.
Core and Supervised Installs and 32-Bit Systems Deprecated
Home Assistant deprecates the Core and Supervised installation methods and the i386, armhf and armv7 architectures, saying a small percentage of users are affected. From release 2025.6, affected systems show a notice that support ends with 2025.12, and users are advised to migrate to Home Assistant OS or Container.
First Global Community Day with 1,600+ Registered Guests
Home Assistant hosts its first global Community Day with 82 community-organized events and over 1,600 registered guests across nearly every major region. The meetups span over 26 hours worldwide. Events are free, with organizers encouraged to use cafes, community spaces, or bars. The event demonstrates the grassroots strength of the Home Assistant community.
Home Assistant Yellow Production Ends as Sales Slow
Nabu Casa announces the end of production for Home Assistant Yellow because declining sales no longer justify another production run, while noting users increasingly choose mini PCs. Earlier Raspberry Pi supply shortages had complicated its launch but eventually stabilized. Yellow will receive software builds as long as Home Assistant can run on it, with support expected far into the future. Existing inventory will not be replenished, and Home Assistant Green is recommended as an alternative.
Voice Chapter 11 Adds Multilingual Assistants
Home Assistant's voice assistant can now control more devices and handle multiple languages at the same time, and its supported language list grows again, including languages that major technology companies' voice assistants do not support.
Connect ZBT-2 Dongle Released with Upgraded Silicon Labs MG24
Home Assistant releases the Connect ZBT-2, a $49 USB adapter featuring the Silicon Labs MG24 chip with 4x faster internal communications compared to the ZBT-1. The new dongle supports Zigbee 3.0 and Thread with improved range and sensitivity. It works with ZHA, Zigbee2MQTT, matter.js, and OpenThread Border Router.
GitHub Blog Profiles Home Assistant as Local-First Rebellion
The GitHub Blog publishes a detailed profile of Home Assistant titled 'The local-first rebellion: How Home Assistant became the most important project in your house.' The article documents local control, privacy, and community-driven development. It describes Home Assistant as one of the fastest-growing open-source projects by contributors in the 2025 Octoverse report, alongside vLLM and Ollama, and reports 21,000 contributors in a single year.
Support Ends for Core, Supervised and 32-Bit Installations
After the six-month deprecation period, Home Assistant 2025.12 fully removes support for the Core and Supervised installation methods and the i386, armhf and armv7 architectures. These systems no longer receive updates, including security updates.
Works with Home Assistant Celebrates Massive Certification Year
The Works with Home Assistant program reports significant growth in 2025, with many major device manufacturers joining the 500 CHF/year certification program. The program tests actual local-first functionality rather than serving as revenue extraction. The certification has become a meaningful quality signal for consumers shopping for smart home devices.
Apollo Automation Becomes Second Foundation Commercial Partner
Apollo Automation becomes the Open Home Foundation's second commercial partner alongside Nabu Casa, committing to contribute a majority of profits from ESPHome-branded hardware sales to the foundation. This diversifies the foundation's funding beyond a single commercial partner and marks the beginning of official ESPHome-branded hardware.
Home Assistant Green Price Increased to $159 Due to Component Costs
Nabu Casa announces a Home Assistant Green price increase from its original $99 price, with later coverage reporting a price around $159 after the January increase. The company attributes the increase mainly to RAM costs and says total component costs have nearly doubled since production began. Nabu Casa says efficiency improvements avoided doubling the retail price and explains the component cost pressure.
HELTUN Removed from Works with Home Assistant
The Open Home Foundation removes HELTUN from the Works with Home Assistant program after its contract lapsed and the company did not respond to renewal requests during 2025. The Foundation says HELTUN devices should keep working over the open Z-Wave standard, but HELTUN no longer has a formal obligation to provide ongoing support.
Opt-In Device Database Announced
The Open Home Foundation announces its device database, built from anonymized device data that Home Assistant users choose to share. The aim is a public resource showing how devices perform in real homes, including whether they work without the cloud.
Backup Encryption Modernized After Trail of Bits Audit
Home Assistant announces SecureTar v3 backup encryption, applied automatically from release 2026.4 while older backups stay readable. The Open Home Foundation paid Trail of Bits to audit it; the firm identified three areas for improvement and confirmed in a follow-up review that all three were resolved.
Community Department Created and Roadmap Made Public
At State of the Open Home 2026, the Open Home Foundation introduces a new Community department led by Melissa Thermidor and makes the Home Assistant roadmap public on GitHub, inviting users to comment and submit feature requests.
Home Assistant Green Price Raised Again to $199 / EUR 179
Nabu Casa updates its January pricing notice to say component prices have kept rising and it has raised Home Assistant Green's price again. The suggested retail price becomes $199 / EUR 179, up from the $99 launch price, which Nabu Casa says keeps Green funding Home Assistant development.
New matter.js-Based Matter Server Released
After four months of beta testing, Home Assistant releases Matter Server app 9.0 based on matter.js as a drop-in replacement for the previous Python server. It adds network visualization, faster device reconnections, more reliable over-the-air updates and support for Matter 1.5.1 device types.
Home Assistant Cloud to Be Renamed Home Assistant Link
Nabu Casa announces that Home Assistant Cloud will be renamed Home Assistant Link with the 2026.12 release on December 2, 2026. It says the subscription stays the same, no action is needed, and subscriptions continue to fund full-time Home Assistant development.
Built-In Marketplace Documented to Replace HACS
Home Assistant documents the Marketplace, a Core integration shipping with release 2026.11 and set up by default, which brings the community HACS catalog into Home Assistant. It takes over existing HACS installations, keeping installed and custom repositories, while AppDaemon apps and Python scripts lose updates.
Evidence (59 citations)
D1: User Value Erosion
D2: Business Customer Exploitation
D3: Shareholder Extraction
D4: Lock-in & Switching Costs
D5: Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
D6: Dark Patterns
D7: Advertising & Monetization Pressure
D8: Competitive Conduct
D9: Labor & Governance
D10: Regulatory & Legal Posture
Scoring Log (7 entries)
7->7. No dimension moved: all 10 re-derived from criteria and confirmed at D1 1, D2 1, D3 0, D4 1, D5 0, D6 1, D7 1, D8 1, D9 1, D10 0. Trajectory improving->stable (scores at floor and flat over the last 12 months; gains in features and openness offset by the end of Core/Supervised/32-bit support and two Green price rises). Since Feb 2026: Green price to $159 (Jan) and $199/EUR 179 (Apr), HELTUN removed from WWHA, opt-in device database, Trail of Bits-audited backup encryption, Community department and public roadmap, matter.js Matter server, Cloud-to-Link rename announced with unchanged terms, built-in Marketplace documented to replace HACS; cloud price unchanged at $6.50; no lawsuits, enforcement, layoffs or labor actions found. Eras: all six re-dated to their inflection events (2013-09-01->2013-09-17 first commit; 2017-12-01->2017-12-17 Cloud beta; 2020-12-01->2020-12-13 first conference/Blue; 2022-12-01->2022-12-07 Matter alpha; 2024-04-01->2024-04-20 Foundation launch; final era 2026-02-15 assessment date->2025-04-16 Stiftung and 39-staff transfer). Relabeled 'Professionalization Begins'->'Cloud Subscription Begins', 'Platform Maturation'->'Official Hardware Arrives', 'Open Home Maturity'->'Stiftung Independence'; 'Hobby Project Origins', 'Open Standards Push' and 'Foundation Era' kept. Era re-scores (recalibration): 'Official Hardware Arrives' 5->6 (D4 0->1 integration breadth, D8 0->1 ESPHome acquisition, D6 1->0 no documented dark patterns); 'Open Standards Push' 6->7 (D9 1->2 control still with founder-owned Nabu Casa until the Foundation, D8 0->1, D6 1->0). D10 evidence restored to 4 items as the fact-audit handoff asked.
Checked all 7 restore-candidates from work/before.json against the current regraded record: 0 restored, 2 partly restored, 5 confirmed removed, 0 already present. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:2: single-click installation of specific add-ons is documented by the April 22, 2018 Hass.io developer follow-up (date drift from the July 2017 launch); broader nontechnical appeal is established by LWN, October 24, 2023 (https://lwn.net/Articles/947843/), already in evidence. Launch-date correction is retained; accelerated adoption remains unproven. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:9 (current index 10): custom firmware compilation/flashing is documented in Otto Winter’s June 5, 2018 esphomelib introduction. The original March 18, 2021 acquisition announcement and archived copy retain open-source continuity, but do not establish prevention of abandonment or third-party commercialization. Native API documentation supports direct communication, not an exclusive local-only restriction. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:7 (current index 8): the 2020 conference page does not establish an annual tradition. State of the Open Home 2021 and the November 3, 2022 newsletter The Perfect Smart Home establish later recurring conferences, but do not establish that the December 2020 conference started that annual tradition. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:16 (current index 18): the 2022 announcement and December 13, 2023 Chapter 5 page establish five chapters delivered, not five chapters planned in advance. The completed Chapter 5 event and local voice functionality remain in the current record. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:24 (current index 27): Chapter 6 establishes low-powered hardware and reduced server/network work, not minimal electrical consumption. No supporting measurement was located. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:32 (current index 35): the August 2024 HACS post gives hundreds of thousands of downloads, not thousands of developers. October 2026 Marketplace contributor documentation describes thousands sharing a broader range of projects including blueprints; it does not establish the original 2024 HACS developer count. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:36 (current index 39): the 2025.1 release states a few clicks; a January 12, 2025 MostlyChris walkthrough also supplies no exact three-click specification. Research: each original cited URL was read live this session and explicitly retried via Wayback before targeted searches; only the ESPHome archive succeeded. Six archive connection failures were treated as unavailable, never as negative evidence. Three targeted search queries per candidate covered exact wording, company/project and origin/date drift (21 queries in 7 WebSearch calls); no search snippet was used as factual evidence. Technical release notes and documentation are used as original implementation records, not vendor marketing. No removals or score changes.
Checked 93 original timeline, evidence, milestone and alternative items plus all prose and identity fields. 37 verified, 42 corrected (8 date-only), 12 re-sourced, 2 duplicate removals. Contradicted specifics: Voice Preview Edition $69 launch price (official December 19, 2024 launch and CNX report state $59); all 56 Foundation staff/transfers (April 16 recap and April 30 newsletter state 39 project staff, 56 ecosystem staff). Preserved true miscited/date-drift details via supporting evidence; replaced SEO sources with original reporting. Fixed 20 distinct prose claims. Unsupported trims: five early-timeline qualifiers, HACS developer count, exact three-click backup measurement, asserted backup-resolution characterization, and four alternative comparisons. No score changes.
Stripped for Phase 2 re-enrichment