Hoopla Digital

Hoopla Digital is a library-based digital media service that provides free instant access to ebooks, audiobooks, movies, TV shows, music, and comics through public library partnerships. Users need only a library card and face no hold queues, with monthly borrow limits set by each library (as low as two per month at some systems by 2025).

27/ 100
Early Warning
2Squeezing Users→Stable

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-25. Score revised 2026-10-25: 28 → 27.

Score History

Milestone← Founded (Midwest Tape) (1989) · Launched Dreamscape Media (2010)CriticalMajor
Library Innovation (2013–2017) · 11/100Library InnovationRapid Adoption Strain (2017–2019) · 13/100Rapid StrainAdoptionFlex and Consolidation (2019–2022) · 16/100Flex andConsolidationContent Moderation Crisis (2022–2024) · 23/100Content ModerationCrisisMass Library Exodus (2024–present) · 27/100Mass LibraryExodus10075502502016202020242026-10Library Innovation (2013–2017) · 11/100Rapid Adoption Strain (2017–2019) · 13/100Flex and Consolidation (2019–2022) · 16/100Content Moderation Crisis (2022–2024) · 23/100Mass Library Exodus (2024–present) · 27/1001113162327MilestonesLaunched Hoopla Digital (2013)Sold Dreamscape Media to RBmedia (2024)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Library Innovation
11/100
2013-03-01 – 2017-07-01

Midwest Tape launched Hoopla as a beta at seven library systems in March 2013, offering instant, no-holds streaming media and audiobooks at $0.99-$2.99 per circulation, and added ebooks in May 2014. Patrons paid nothing, libraries paid only for what was borrowed, and the founder-owned company competed with OverDrive through a different lending model rather than acquisitions. Catalog and usage grew quickly, setting up the cost question that followed.

Rapid Adoption Strain
13/100+2
2017-07-01 – 2019-06-20

Circulation of publisher content more than doubled in 2016, HarperCollins brought about 15,000 backlist ebooks to the model in 2017, and Hoopla moved onto TV devices. By mid-2017 pay-per-use bills had grown enough that libraries began imposing monthly checkout caps and daily spending limits, the first visible cost to patrons of the model's popularity.

Flex and Consolidation
16/100+3
2019-06-20 – 2022-02-22

At ALA 2019 Hoopla announced lending models with holds, which launched as Flex in 2020 alongside free Bonus Borrows and gave libraries more budget control. KKR bought OverDrive in June 2020 and OverDrive then agreed to buy RBdigital's library business, leaving a two-player market. Midwest Tape filed a WARN notice covering 183 Holland workers in March 2020, co-founder John Eldred died in 2021, and Hoopla expanded to Australia and launched BingePass.

Content Moderation Crisis
23/100+7
2022-02-22 – 2024-12-27

Library groups' February 2022 demand for accountability over Holocaust-denial and fascist ebooks, followed by Vice reporting on conspiracy content, exposed how little control libraries had over Hoopla's all-catalog model. Library costs kept rising: Nassau County added a daily cap in 2024 and other systems cut limits. In 2024 the ALA criticized Hoopla's content-ratings system, Library Futures found the catalog still flooded with low-quality titles, Midwest Tape sold Dreamscape, and Hoopla users filed a privacy class action in December.

Mass Library Exodus
27/100+4
2024-12-27 – present

Greenfield's December 2024 exit, citing a 452% increase quote, and Milwaukee County's cut to two borrows a month opened a wave of cancellations that ran through 2025 and 2026, including Deschutes, Boston, Joplin, the Bridges system and Montgomery County, while many remaining libraries cut limits or added daily caps. 404 Media's February 2025 report on AI-generated books in the catalog deepened the trust problem. Hoopla says it has not raised prices and in 2026 added Instant Bundles and AI-content controls, but exits continued into autumn 2026.

Alternatives

Libby39/100

The dominant library lending app (by OverDrive), offering ebooks and audiobooks from your local library with a waitlist model. Covers a broader catalog of popular titles than Hoopla, though you'll wait for popular books. Easy switch — just download the app and sign in with your library card. Many libraries offer both services simultaneously.

Library streaming service for films and TV. Several libraries that dropped Hoopla, including Deschutes and Joplin, pointed patrons to Kanopy for movies and television, which Libby does not carry. Sign in with your library card if your library offers it.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
What patrons get from Hoopla depends on library budgets, and the pay-per-use model keeps shrinking access. Through 2025 and 2026 many systems cut monthly limits (Pleasant Hill from six to three in April 2026) or added shared daily caps that Sachse said were reached very early most days, and Montgomery County said more than 4,400 patrons a month were turned away before it dropped Hoopla in August 2026. Boston, Joplin, Lexington County and others ended the service outright, and low-quality and AI-generated titles (Library Futures 2024, 404 Media 2025) have degraded search. The decline is uneven rather than universal: the app still rates 4.8/5 on the App Store, Hoopla reported 11% borrow growth in 2025, and it keeps adding content such as TED BingePasses.
How It Got Here
When Hoopla launched in 2013 it offered a new library experience: instant streaming media and audiobooks, and from 2014 ebooks, with no hold queues and no cost to patrons. It reached Apple TV, Fire TV and Roku in late 2017. As usage grew, the patron experience began to erode, not through Hoopla's interface but through limits libraries imposed to control pay-per-use bills. Caps appeared from 2017; by 2024 many systems allowed 5-8 borrows a month, and Milwaukee County cut to two in January 2025. Shared daily caps made the service unavailable for much of the day at some libraries; Albuquerque's was often reached by 7:00 a.m. Low-quality and seemingly AI-generated titles skewed search (Library Futures, August 2024; 404 Media, February 2025). From late 2024 a wave of libraries dropped Hoopla entirely, including Boston and Joplin in 2025, and the cuts continued in 2026: Pleasant Hill halved its limit to three, Montgomery County said more than 4,400 patrons a month were turned away by its daily cap before it left in August, and Sachse ended service in October. Hoopla still reports growth (11% more borrows in 2025), keeps a 4.8/5 App Store rating and adds content such as TED BingePasses, so for patrons at well-funded libraries the service remains strong while many others have lost access.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2013Library Innovation2017Rapid Adoption Strain2019Flex and Consolidation2022Content Moderation Crisis2024Mass Library ExodusUser Value12234Biz Exploit12235Shareholder11122Lock-in11222Algorithms11133Dark Patterns11111Advertising11111Competition11222Labor/Gov22333Regulatory11134
Timeline (41 events)
critical2013-03-01

Hoopla Launches Beta at Seven Library Systems

Midwest Tape launched Hoopla Digital as a beta pilot at seven library systems including Columbus Metropolitan Library, Los Angeles Public Library, and Seattle Public Library. The service offered 2,500 movies, 9,000 audiobooks, and 200,000 music albums on a pay-per-circulation model ranging from $0.99 to $2.99 per checkout, with instant access and no hold queues.

major2014-05-27

Hoopla Adds Ebook Lending to Platform

Hoopla expanded beyond streaming media to include ebook lending, using a transactional pay-per-circulation model rather than the one-copy/one-user approach. Founder Jeff Jankowski said Hoopla was 'totally against the one copy/one user platform.' At the announcement, the platform offered 170,000 unique media titles, and 60,000 of them had circulated in the first four months of the year.

minor2015-10-01

Midwest Tape Breaks Ground on $12M Global Headquarters

Midwest Tape broke ground in late September 2015 on a $12-13 million, 135,360-square-foot global headquarters in Wolf Creek Business Park, Holland, Ohio. The campus was to include a 100,800-square-foot warehouse and a 34,560-square-foot office building housing both Midwest Tape and Hoopla Digital employees. The company already had more than 350 employees in Holland.

major2017-01-04

Hoopla Reports Publisher Circulation More Than Doubled in 2016

Hoopla said 2016 was a strong year, with significant user and circulation growth since the launch of its ebook vertical. Founder Jeff Jankowski said publishing verticals had become Hoopla's strongest growth area, with circulation of publishing content more than doubling over the past year and more than 70% of publisher titles on the platform being borrowed. The catalog had passed 600,000 titles.

major2017-06-22

HarperCollins Makes Ebooks Available via Hoopla Multi-User Model

HarperCollins agreed to make about 15,000 backlist e-book titles available on Hoopla's multi-user, pay-per-circulation model, starting in July 2017. HarperCollins became the first Big Five publisher to offer e-books to library patrons on an on-demand model, with titles including works by Neil Gaiman, Louise Erdrich, and Dennis Lehane. The move was seen as validating Hoopla's transactional approach as an alternative to the one-copy/one-user model.

major2017-07-01

Libraries Begin Imposing Borrowing Caps Due to Rising Costs

By mid-2017, libraries began experiencing budget strain from Hoopla's pay-per-circulation model as the service grew in popularity. Libraries started imposing checkout caps on patrons and setting daily spending limits to control unpredictable costs. The Digital Reader reported that the initial enthusiasm for the model had waned as 'monthly bills started arriving and the honeymoon ended.'

minor2017-11-14

Hoopla Launches Apps on Apple TV and Fire TV

Hoopla officially went live on Apple TV and Amazon Fire TV in mid-November 2017, offering library patrons free, ad-free movies and TV shows on their televisions, with an Android TV release following that week. Roku support was promised for the near future. The TV catalog was relatively small compared to commercial streaming services, consisting largely of catalog titles.

major2019-06-20

Hoopla Announces Plans for Additional Lending Models at ALA

At the start of the 2019 American Library Association Annual Conference, Hoopla confirmed plans to expand beyond its always-available transactional model to include metered and perpetual access models, with a holds list for some titles. Hoopla officials said the company was picking beta partners and expected to roll out the expanded capabilities in early 2020. The holds-based option later launched as Hoopla Flex in 2020.

major2020-01-01

Hoopla Launches Flex and Bonus Borrows Programs

Hoopla introduced its Flex model (one-copy/one-user titles with holds) and Bonus Borrows, titles that do not count against patrons' monthly borrowing limits, in 2020. At that time the platform had 6.5 million library card holders and 2,700+ library partners. Bonus Borrows are offered during the last seven days of each month and are free for libraries.

minor2020-03-23

Midwest Tape Files WARN Notice Covering 183 Holland Workers

Midwest Tape filed an Ohio WARN Act notice on April 6, 2020 for its Holland facility, listing about 183 affected workers with an effective date of March 23, 2020. It is the only WARN notice on record for the company in this data set.

critical2020-06-09

KKR Completes Acquisition of OverDrive from Rakuten

KKR completed its acquisition of OverDrive, the dominant library digital lending platform behind the Libby app, from Rakuten on June 9, 2020. Two weeks later, on June 23, OverDrive announced it was acquiring the library business of KKR-owned RBmedia, including the RBdigital platform. The deal reshaped the competitive landscape of library digital lending, concentrating the largest player under PE ownership while Midwest Tape's Hoopla remained independently owned.

minor2021-04-15

Hoopla Expands Internationally to Australia

Hoopla Digital announced its expansion to Australia, its first international market beyond North America, on April 15, 2021. The City of Wanneroo Libraries in Western Australia was the first library system to pilot a partnership, starting in February 2021.

major2021-05-27

Co-Founder John Eldred Passes Away at Age 73

John Eldred, co-founder of Midwest Tape and a pioneer of library media distribution, died on May 27, 2021 at age 73. Eldred had opened his first video store in 1983, began selling tapes to libraries in 1989, and helped launch Dreamscape Media in 2010 and Hoopla in 2013. Jeff Jankowski, his partner of more than 30 years at Midwest Tape, continued to lead the company.

minor2021-09-20

Midwest Tape Expands Executive Team for Dreamscape and Hoopla

Midwest Tape expanded its executive roster, appointing Sean McManus as president of Dreamscape Media and promoting Cat Zappa to vice president of digital acquisitions at Hoopla Digital. The moves reflected growing vertical integration between Midwest Tape's library distribution, Dreamscape's audiobook publishing, and Hoopla's digital lending platform.

minor2021-12-09

Hoopla Introduces BingePass Unlimited Streaming Feature

Hoopla launched BingePass, a new borrowing format giving patrons seven days of unlimited access to entire content collections with a single borrow. Initial partners included hoopla Magazines (via eMagazines) and The Great Courses Library Collection with over 300 courses. The feature expanded Hoopla's content depth but introduced another cost vector for libraries under the pay-per-use model.

critical2022-02-22

Library Groups Demand Accountability Over Fascist and Holocaust Denial Ebooks

The Library Freedom Project and Library Futures issued a joint statement on February 22, 2022 demanding full accountability for how fascist and Holocaust denial ebooks were selected for Hoopla, and more transparency in its material selection. Hoopla removed the titles within 48 hours. Jankowski's letter to customers said the titles came from five independent publishers in its network of more than 18,000 and had made it through its human and system-driven screening. The statement was updated on March 10, 2022 to add COVID-19 misinformation and gay conversion therapy texts.

major2022-04-20

Vice Exposes Ongoing Conspiracy and Hate Content on Hoopla

Vice/Motherboard reported that despite Hoopla's earlier removals of Holocaust denial titles, the platform continued to host a wide range of conspiracy theory books, COVID disinformation, anti-LGBTQ+ conversion therapy materials, and other extremist content. Keyword searches for 'homosexuality' and 'abortion' returned largely self-published religious texts categorized as nonfiction, rather than balanced information.

D10D5D1
Vice ↗
minor2023-06-01

Midwest Tape Named Toledo Area Top Workplace Despite Mixed Reviews

Midwest Tape | hoopla Digital was named a 2023 Top Workplace in the Toledo metro area (No. 5 among companies with 300+ employees) in the Energage employee-survey program published with The Toledo Blade.

major2024-05-01

Nassau County Public Library Imposes Daily Hoopla Budget Cap

Nassau County Public Library (Florida) imposed a daily budget cap on Hoopla borrows starting May 2024, on top of its six-items-per-month limit. The library said checkouts averaged about $3.00 each and that Hoopla borrowing had risen 30.9% year over year since October 2023, driving up its costs. Other libraries tightened limits in the same period, such as Alameda County Library, which cut its monthly limit from 10 to 8 on April 1, 2024.

major2024-06-24

ALA Criticizes Hoopla's Universal Content Ratings System

The American Library Association's Office for Intellectual Freedom issued a statement criticizing Midwest Tape/Hoopla's new Universal Content Ratings System (UCRS), which assigned audience categories and age-based filters to library materials. The ALA argued the system resembled 'morality-based labels,' challenged intellectual freedom principles, and could violate First Amendment rights. Midwest Tape clarified the ratings would not be publicly visible and called the system an 'audience filter' developed to help libraries comply with state content legislation.

major2024-07-09

Midwest Tape Agrees to Sell Dreamscape Media to RBmedia

RBmedia signed a definitive agreement to acquire Dreamscape Media, Midwest Tape's audiobook publishing arm founded in 2010, with closing expected in the third quarter of 2024. Dreamscape had a catalog of over 7,000 audiobooks and released nearly 1,000 new titles annually. The sale removed a vertical integration element from the Midwest Tape/Hoopla ecosystem, separating the company's publishing and distribution arms.

major2024-08-12

Library Futures Reports Ongoing Catalog Quality Problems

Library Futures published 'Hoopla's Content Problem: Strange, Skewed Results Still Dominate Catalog,' reporting that Hoopla's catalog was flooded with low-quality, unvetted digital materials numbering in the tens of thousands, which skew search results. Top line searches returned 'a plethora of irrelevant, seemingly AI-generated, and even pirated materials.'

major2024-12-06

Hoopla Users File Privacy Class Action Over Data Sharing with Meta and Google

Kevin Smith, later joined by Lyly Tran, filed a consumer privacy class action against Midwest Tape, doing business as Hoopla, in the Northern District of California. The plaintiffs allege the company illegally shared information about their reading and video-viewing preferences with Meta Platforms and Google, in violation of the California Invasion of Privacy Act, California Civil Code section 1799.3 and the California Constitution. The allegations have not been decided.

major2024-12-27

Greenfield Library Cites 452% Price Increase, Drops Hoopla

Greenfield Public Library announced it would end its Hoopla contract effective January 1, 2025, after being quoted a 452% price increase for 2025. The library was part of the Milwaukee County Federated Library System, which transferred Hoopla costs to individual member libraries. The library put Hoopla's average cost at $2.40 per checkout under a pay-per-use model its operating budget could not absorb.

critical2025-01-01

Milwaukee County System Slashes Hoopla Borrows to Two Per Month

The Milwaukee County Federated Library System reduced Hoopla borrows from four to two per month across member libraries beginning January 1, 2025. Shorewood Public Library's notice put each Hoopla checkout at $2.38 and anticipated about 166,800 checkouts across the system in 2024; keeping the four-borrow limit would have projected a 2025 cost of around $470,000.

minor2025-01-07

Hoopla Launches SeasonPass TV Streaming Feature

Hoopla introduced SeasonPass, a new feature bundling full TV seasons into a single borrow for seven days of unlimited access. The launch included 14 TV series from BBC Studios, PBS, and other partners. SeasonPass was accessible with no additional fees for participating libraries, offering ad-free streaming via the Hoopla app and Roku devices.

critical2025-02-04

404 Media Reports Low-Quality AI-Generated Books in Hoopla's Catalog

404 Media published an investigation titled 'AI-Generated Slop Is Already In Your Public Library,' reporting that low-quality books that appear to be AI-generated are entering Hoopla's catalog and reaching public libraries. One example was a diet cookbook by an author with no online footprint and an apparently AI-generated headshot. Because libraries must opt into Hoopla's entire catalog and pay for whatever patrons borrow, librarians paid for AI content they could not curate. The article contrasted this with OverDrive, where librarians can pick individual titles. Separately, Nashville Public Library's March 18, 2025 board packet reported that staff had removed thousands of newly discovered AI audiobooks from its Hoopla collection.

D10D5D1D2
404 Media ↗
major2025-02-20

Hoopla Pledges AI Content Removal After Librarian Backlash

Following the 404 Media investigation, Hoopla emailed librarians on February 10 and 14 acknowledging concerns and outlining actions: revising its collection development policy, removing all 'summary titles' from vendors (with exceptions such as HMH Books, publisher of CliffNotes), removing some publishers and authors it identified as producing poor-quality AI-generated content, and offering libraries the option to opt out of publisher-tagged AI-generated content by contacting their sales representatives. Library Futures executive director Jennie Rose Halperin said Hoopla had broken librarians' trust 'in favor of a profit-motivated, exploitative model that flies in the face of professional values.' In an April 22, 2025 follow-up, C & G Newspapers reported that Hoopla had emailed librarians saying it had removed thousands of AI books; Baldwin Public Library librarian Mick Howey said he was seeing fewer AI titles.

major2025-06-30

Deschutes Public Library Drops Hoopla Over Budget Strain

Deschutes Public Library discontinued Hoopla effective June 30, 2025, after determining the service consumed over 19% of the library's total collections budget while fewer than 8% of cardholders used it in an average month. The library redirected funds to Libby/OverDrive for ebooks and audiobooks, and Kanopy for streaming video. Placer County also ended Hoopla access June 30, 2025, according to its June 19 notice. Lincoln Public Library's November 5, 2025 staff report records that both Sacramento Public Library and Placer County Library had discontinued Hoopla that year.

major2025-08-29

Lexington County Library Ends Hoopla, Citing Costs and AI Content

Lexington County Library in South Carolina announced it would discontinue Hoopla after September 30, 2025. It said Hoopla checkouts were only 5% of its checkouts but would consume 30% of the next year's total print and digital materials budget even at three monthly checkouts per user, and that Hoopla lacked controls to filter out low-quality AI-generated content.

major2025-09-30

Boston Public Library Ends Hoopla Access

Boston Public Library made September 30, 2025 the last day to borrow new Hoopla items with a BPL card. It said Hoopla's pay-per-use model was no longer sustainable as demand grew, that the average Hoopla checkout cost more than three times that of its other library resources, and that Hoopla accounted for less than 5% of its digital checkouts.

major2025-10-01

Bridges Library System Begins Staggered Hoopla Discontinuation

All member libraries of the Bridges Library System serving Waukesha and Jefferson Counties began discontinuing Hoopla, with staggered end dates from October 2025 through January 2026; for example, Menomonee Falls ended service October 16 and Waukesha Public Library November 13. The system determined the pay-per-checkout model had become unsustainable, consuming a disproportionate share of resources while serving a limited percentage of patrons, and focused funding on the Libby app. Brookfield Public Library ended Hoopla on October 12, 2025, as recorded in its January 21, 2026 library board packet.

major2025-10-31

Joplin Public Library Ends Hoopla After It Took 78% of Digital Budget

Joplin Public Library in Missouri discontinued Hoopla effective October 31, 2025. It said Hoopla consumed about 78% of its budget for digitally circulated materials while accounting for 15% of digital circulation, and that only 4% of active cardholders could use it each month because the library had to restrict monthly and daily usage to stay within budget.

minor2025-11-18

Hoopla Says It Has Not Raised Prices

Responding to talk of unsustainable pricing, Hoopla published a statement saying it had not increased prices, that no Instant title costs more than $3.99 (less than 1% of the Instant catalog is at that price) and that its average cost per circulation hovers around $2 in the U.S. It said pricing is published on its website and pointed to cost controls libraries set themselves.

minor2025-12-10

Hoopla Reports 11% Borrow Growth and 80 New Library Partners in 2025

Hoopla said 2025 brought an 11% increase in total content borrows and 80 new library partners, based on circulation data from more than 10,000 U.S. public libraries. The company-reported growth came in the same year as a wave of library cancellations.

major2026-01-20

Hoopla Introduces Instant Bundles License Option

Hoopla introduced Instant Bundles, which let libraries pre-purchase a set of concurrent Instant circulations on individual titles. Hoopla said the option lowers the average cost per circulation once savings points are met and gives libraries more predictable budgets. In September 2026 it reported that San Francisco Public Library cut its cost per circulation by 55% on bundle titles that reached full use.

major2026-02-20

Court Transfers Hoopla Privacy Suit to Ohio Under Terms of Use

After Midwest Tape moved to compel individual arbitration under its 2021 Terms of Use, which require binding arbitration in Lucas County, Ohio and bar class, consolidated and representative actions, Judge James Donato transferred the privacy class action to the Northern District of Ohio under the terms' exclusive-venue clause. The order did not decide whether the arbitration clause is enforceable or rule on the privacy allegations.

major2026-02-20

Hoopla Details AI-Content Screening and Library Controls

Hoopla said its review teams declined nearly 20,000 titles in January 2026 alone for being AI-generated or low quality, out of more than 75,000 titles onboarded that month. It described detection workflows with human review and library-facing controls to identify and block AI-generated content, following the 2025 controversy over AI books in its catalog.

minor2026-06-10

Sweetwater County Library System Discontinues Hoopla

Sweetwater County Library System in Wyoming discontinued Hoopla on June 10, 2026, saying the pay-per-use model had become financially unsustainable. Its analysis found one Hoopla checkout cost the library five times more than one through Libby, even with a four-checkout monthly limit.

major2026-08-01

Montgomery County Library System Drops Hoopla After Daily Caps Turned Away Thousands

The Montgomery County Memorial Library System in Texas discontinued Hoopla on August 1, 2026 and moved the budget to OverDrive/Libby. Over the previous eight months Hoopla had consumed more than 36% of its digital materials budget while accounting for about 7% of digital circulation; about 1,600 patrons used it each month, while more than 4,400 a month were turned away because the daily spending cap had been reached.

minor2026-08-26

Hoopla Adds Five TED BingePasses

Hoopla announced a partnership with TED adding five BingePasses with 200 stage presentations and more than 400 educational lessons, which patrons can stream with a library card at no cost. Hoopla said the content is currently only available on Hoopla without fees or subscriptions.

Evidence (57 citations)

D4: Lock-in & Switching Costs

D6: Dark Patterns

D7: Advertising & Monetization Pressure

Hoopla Bonus Borrows FeatureLivingston Public Library · 2020-03-28
Bonus Borrows are the Best!Hoopla Digital · 2024-10-23
Scoring Log (6 entries)
fact-audit2026-10-25FABRICATION FOUND

Checked 67 items + prose. 19 verified, 39 corrected (17 date-only), 7 re-sourced, 2 removed (1 duplicate HQ-opening item, 1 dead Placer notice). Invented (junk-only): 75% 2015-16 circulation growth (only on Grokipedia, AI-generated); Sacramento Public Library discontinuation (only on citizenportal.ai, AI-generated). Unsupported and trimmed: Jankowski 'sole owner', 'thousands' of AI books (404 Media), 'thousands removed' and 'visible reduction', Placer County and Georgetown cancellations, Mukwonago/Brookfield end dates, AWS Personalize 80% accuracy, $95M revenue estimate, 401(k) vesting and health-insurance specifics. Fixed Library Futures report date (Aug 2024), Milwaukee $470K framing, KKR/RBdigital timing, OverDrive ownership, Glassdoor figures (now 3.2/58%), partner counts, Dreamscape sale as agreement. Added 7 evidence items for true details moved off wrong URLs.

regrade2026-10-25RESCORED

28→27. D8 3→2 (recalibration: the record shows no acquisitions of rivals, exclusivity terms, API lockouts or legal action by Hoopla; concentration stems from KKR/OverDrive and publisher licensing, fitting the 2-3 band's lower end). Other nine confirmed: D1 4 (2025-26 limit cuts, daily caps, exits vs. 4.8 rating and 11% borrow growth), D2 5 (libraries report 3-5x Libby per-circ cost and 36-78% of digital budgets; Hoopla says no price increase, avg ~$2, Instant Bundles), D10 4 (privacy class action filed Dec 2024, push for individual arbitration, Labaton inquiry, plus content-curation failures). Eras: all 5 re-dated — 2013-06-01→2013-03-01 (beta launch); 2016-01-01→2017-07-01 (libraries begin caps; old date keyed to the removed 75% growth claim); 2019-06-01→2019-06-20 (ALA lending-model announcement) and relabeled Cost Pressure Mounts→Flex and Consolidation; 2022-03-01→2022-02-22 (LFP/Library Futures statement); 2026-02-17→2024-12-27 (Greenfield exit opening the exodus). No new era: 2026 Instant Bundles and AI controls are mitigations within the exodus, not a change of forces. Since Oct 2025: more library exits (Boston, Joplin, Lexington County, Butler County, Sweetwater, Montgomery County, Garland, Portsmouth, Sachse; Salina announced), further limit cuts and daily caps, Hoopla pricing statement (no increase, max $3.99), 11% 2025 borrow growth, Instant Bundles (Jan 2026), AI screening and library controls (Feb 2026), privacy suit transferred to N.D. Ohio (Feb 2026; Ohio docket shows activity to Apr 2026, outcome unreadable), Labaton VPPA inquiry (May 2026), TED/BBC/Moonbug content additions. Trajectory worsening→stable: exits continued but no new extraction move by Hoopla, and its 2026 changes cut library costs. Milestone Dreamscape updated to the Aug 1, 2024 closing. Added Kanopy alternative. Not added: Zeisler v. Midwest Tape (N.D. Ohio 3:25-cv-02748; subject unreadable); Lincoln (CA) library minutes mention Sacramento cancelling Hoopla, but no primary source found, so the fact audit's removal stands.

restore-check2026-10-25RESTORED

Checked all 8 candidates: 2 RESTORED, 3 PARTLY RESTORED, 2 CONFIRMED REMOVED, 1 ALREADY PRESENT. timeline:update:12 CONFIRMED REMOVED: Publishers Weekly's June 11, 2021 obituary describes Eldred as owner and Jankowski as his partner; three searches, including sole-owner and post-2021 ownership queries, yielded no reliable confirmation of sole ownership or increased control. timeline:update:24 PARTLY RESTORED: Nashville Public Library March 18, 2025 board packet confirms thousands of AI audiobooks removed locally, not thousands of ebooks documented by 404 Media on February 4. The numerical scale is recovered with local scope, format and date corrected; fabricated content/factual-inaccuracy details remain unverified. timeline:update:25 PARTLY RESTORED: C & G Newspapers April 22, 2025 reports Hoopla's claim of thousands removed and Baldwin librarian Mick Howey's observed reduction, restoring the claim with later attribution and local scope. timeline:update:26 CONFIRMED REMOVED: Library Futures page is dated August 12, 2024, before the February 2025 removal pledge, and does not contain the alleged profit quote; the regrade already preserves Halperin's differently worded criticism in the February 20 item. timeline:update:27 RESTORED: Placer County June 19, 2025 archived notice and Lincoln Public Library November 5, 2025 staff report confirm Placer and Sacramento cancellations; no Sacramento end date is inferred from unreadable pages. timeline:update:28 PARTLY RESTORED: Brookfield January 21, 2026 board packet confirms October 12, 2025; Mukwonago October 11 remains unverified. evidence:remove:6 RESTORED: Placer County Government archived notice, dated June 19, 2025, replaces the dead URL and unsupported May 1 publication date. Added evidence sources/verdicts: Nashville and C & G Newspapers PARTLY RESTORED; Placer County and Lincoln Public Library RESTORED; Brookfield PARTLY RESTORED. milestones:update:3 ALREADY PRESENT: current milestone records August 1, 2024 closing, independently confirmed by Reed Smith's August 16, 2024 transaction report read this session. Wayback attempts failed with connection refusal and were not treated as evidence. No removals or score changes.

Deep Enrichment2026-03-13
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-17