Macy's

Macy's is the largest department store chain in the United States, operating about 430 Macy's stores alongside Bloomingdale's and Bluemercury (665 locations in total as of January 2026). The company offers apparel, accessories, home goods, and beauty products through physical stores and an online marketplace.

44/ 100
Actively Enshittifying
2Squeezing Users→Stable

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-11. Score revised 2026-10-11: 47 → 44.

Score History

Milestone← Founded (1858) · Federated exits bankruptcy (1992) · Acquired by Federated (1994)CriticalMajor
Post-May Consolidation (2005–2009) · 26/100Post-MayConsolidationMy Macy's Localization (2009–2015) · 24/100My Macy's LocalizationRevenue Decline Era (2015–2020) · 36/100Revenue Decline EraPolaris and Pandemic (2020–2022) · 38/100Polarisand Pande…Digital Monetization Push (2022–2024) · 43/100Bold New Chapter (2024–present) · 44/100Bold NewChapter10075502502010201520202026-10Post-May Consolidation (2005–2009) · 26/100My Macy's Localization (2009–2015) · 24/100Revenue Decline Era (2015–2020) · 36/100Polaris and Pandemic (2020–2022) · 38/100Digital Monetization Push (2022–2024) · 43/100Bold New Chapter (2024–present) · 44/100262436384344MilestonesAcquired May Dept Stores (2005)Rebranded to Macy's Inc. (2007)Acquired Bluemercury (2015)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Post-May Consolidation
26/100
2005-08-30 – 2009-02-02

Federated's $17 billion acquisition of May Department Stores, completed August 30, 2005, created a $30 billion retailer with about 950 department stores; the FTC closed its review without action while five state attorneys general secured store divestitures. In September 2006 about 400 former May stores across 12 regional nameplates, including Marshall Field's, were converted to Macy's, drawing customer backlash in Chicago. Competition is the era's defining dimension; prices, fees and labor practices were otherwise those of a conventional department store.

My Macy's Localization
24/100-2
2009-02-02 – 2015-01-08

On February 2, 2009, amid the recession, Macy's eliminated about 7,000 positions, cut its quarterly dividend from 13.25 to 5 cents and rolled out its 'My Macy's' localization initiative nationally to tailor assortments to local markets. The years that followed were relatively stable, with few documented harms beyond automated debt-collection calls on its store cards (settled in 2015), the decision to open on Thanksgiving evening from 2013, and a $650,000 settlement in 2014 of New York racial-profiling allegations against its loss-prevention staff.

Revenue Decline Era
36/100+12
2015-01-08 – 2020-02-04

In January 2015 Macy's announced 14 store closures and about 2,200 job cuts, the first of a series of retrenchments as comparable sales fell; in August 2016 it announced about 100 closures and in January 2017 more than 10,000 job cuts. It still returned heavily to shareholders, repurchasing $2.0 billion of stock in 2015 and raising its dividend 15%. Consumers' Checkbook (2015) and the Los Angeles city attorney (2016) accused it of fake 'sale' reference prices, the Labor Department sued over its health plan in 2017, and customer data was exposed in 2018 and 2019 security incidents.

Polaris and Pandemic
38/100+2
2020-02-04 – 2022-09-28

The February 2020 Polaris plan to close 125 stores and cut about 2,000 corporate jobs was overtaken weeks later by COVID-19, which shut all 775 stores, furloughed most of about 130,000 employees and led to 3,900 permanent corporate layoffs in June 2020. Macy's launched its Media Network in August 2020, was sued that month over alleged Clearview AI facial-recognition searches, and in December locked out union engineers in a move the NLRB later found unlawful. As sales recovered it raised its minimum wage to $15 but also resumed buybacks: $500 million in 2021 and a new $2 billion authorization in February 2022.

Digital Monetization Push
43/100+5
2022-09-28 – 2024-02-27

Macy's opened a Mirakl-powered third-party marketplace in September 2022, charging invited sellers a 15% commission plus listing and payment fees, while its Media Network grew to $155 million in 2023 revenue. In August 2023 it ended free mailed returns for shoppers outside Star Rewards, charging $9.99 and nudging customers into the loyalty program. Total revenue fell from $25.4 billion in fiscal 2022 to $23.9 billion in fiscal 2023, and in January 2024 Macy's cut about 2,350 jobs.

Bold New Chapter
44/100+1
2024-02-27 – present

CEO Tony Spring's Bold New Chapter, announced February 27, 2024, set out to close about 150 underperforming stores and invest in about 350 go-forward locations; 64 closed in fiscal 2024, 14 more were announced in January 2026, and Connecticut fulfillment closures cut about 1,050 jobs. A $151 million concealment of delivery expenses surfaced in November 2024. From fiscal 2025 comparable sales turned positive, and Macy's resumed buybacks ($251 million in fiscal 2025, $100 million in the first half of 2026), raised its dividend, and pursued its fight against NLRB lockout remedies to the Supreme Court, which declined the case in June 2026.

Alternatives

Nordstrom34/100

Department store with a stronger reputation for customer service, free shipping and free returns with no loyalty program required. Similar product range in apparel, shoes, and beauty. Easy switch — just shop there instead. Prices run slightly higher on average, but Nordstrom Rack offers comparable discount shopping.

Target34/100

Not a traditional department store, but Target has expanded significantly into fashion (designer collaborations), home goods, and beauty — covering most of what people buy at Macy's. Lower price point overall. Easy switch for everyday apparel and home shopping, though the selection is less premium.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Macy's has shrunk its store base under the Bold New Chapter: 64 stores closed in fiscal 2024 and 14 more were announced in January 2026, removing local access for many shoppers. Since August 2023 non-members of Star Rewards pay $9.99 for mailed returns, a fee on a previously free service, and tariffs brought 'selective' price increases in 2025. Satisfaction data are mixed rather than collapsing: ACSI ranked Macy's the top department store at 82 in 2024, while Trustpilot reviews (2.0/5) and Comparably's small-sample NPS of -11 record complaints about cancelled orders and customer service. Comparable sales grew for five straight quarters through Q2 2026.
How It Got Here
Macy's customer experience first took a hit in September 2006, when about 400 former May Company stores lost their regional nameplates, prompting a 60,000-signature petition in Chicago to keep Marshall Field's. The 2009 'My Macy's' rollout tried to restore locally tailored assortments, and the chain was relatively stable until 2015, when falling sales triggered rounds of closures: 14 stores announced in January 2015, about 100 in August 2016, and a 125-store plan in February 2020 that the pandemic overtook when all 775 stores shut. Security incidents in 2018 and 2019 exposed online customers' account and card data. In August 2023 Macy's ended free mailed returns for shoppers outside Star Rewards, charging $9.99 for a previously free service. The 2024 Bold New Chapter plan targeted about 150 closures; 64 stores closed in fiscal 2024 and 14 more were announced in January 2026, and tariffs brought 'selective' price increases in 2025. Satisfaction data are mixed rather than collapsing: ACSI ranked Macy's the top department store at 82 in 2024, while Trustpilot reviews and Comparably's small-sample NPS of -11 record complaints about cancelled orders and service. Comparable sales grew for five straight quarters through mid-2026, leaving Macy's a smaller but not broken place to shop.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2005Post-May Consolidation2009My Macy's Localization2015Revenue Decline Era2020Polaris and Pandemic2022Digital Monetization Push2024Bold New ChapterUser Value324455Biz Exploit223344Shareholder335555Lock-in222233Algorithms223344Dark Patterns224455Advertising223455Competition533333Labor/Gov335656Regulatory234444
Timeline (53 events)
major2005-08-30

FTC closes Federated/May probe without action; states win store divestitures

The FTC closed its six-month investigation of Federated's $17 billion acquisition of May Department Stores without enforcement action, concluding the deal was unlikely to reduce price or non-price competition and noting Federated's plan to divest 75 stores in 72 malls. Five state attorneys general (California, Maryland, Massachusetts, New York and Pennsylvania) separately signed an Assurance with Federated requiring store divestitures in their states, including at least 26 Macy's and Robinsons-May stores in Southern California.

critical2005-08-30

Federated acquires May Department Stores for $17 billion

Federated Department Stores completed its $17 billion acquisition of May Department Stores Company, creating a $30 billion national retailer with 950 department stores and about 700 bridal and formalwear stores. May ran its department stores under 12 regional trade names, including Marshall Field's, Filene's, Kaufmann's, and Robinsons-May. The FTC cleared the transaction without enforcement action, while five states secured store divestitures.

critical2006-09-09

Regional department store brands converted to Macy's in mass rebranding

Federated converted about 400 former May Company stores to the Macy's nameplate, ending regional brands including Marshall Field's, Filene's, Foley's, Hecht's, Kaufmann's, L.S. Ayres, Meier & Frank, Robinsons-May, and Strawbridge's. Marshall Field's State Street flagship officially became Macy's on September 9, 2006. The change sparked public backlash in Chicago, where about 60,000 people signed an online petition urging Federated to keep the Marshall Field's name. A November 2007 Associated Press report described falling sales in Macy's Chicago business, but said Macy's would not disclose the size of the decline.

major2009-02-02

Macy's cuts 7,000 jobs and dividend, rolls out My Macy's

Facing the recession, Macy's announced a net elimination of about 7,000 positions, roughly 4% of its 180,000-position workforce, as it merged its regional divisions into one national organization, with nearly 40% of central-office executive positions cut. It reduced its quarterly dividend from 13.25 cents to 5 cents and expanded its 'My Macy's' localization initiative, piloted in 20 markets since 2008, nationwide. The company expected the moves to cut expenses by about $400 million a year from 2010.

minor2013-10-14

Macy's breaks tradition to open on Thanksgiving evening

Macy's announced that most of its roughly 800 stores would open at 8 p.m. on Thanksgiving Day, ending a tradition of keeping stores closed on the holiday and following Walmart, Target and Sears into Thanksgiving-evening hours. Retail employees at other chains had petitioned against such openings because they cut into workers' family holidays.

major2014-08-20

Macy's settles racial profiling allegations for $650,000

Macy's agreed to pay $650,000 to settle a New York Attorney General investigation into racial profiling that began in February 2013. Eighteen minority customers said they had been detained at Macy's stores between 2007 and 2013 and accused of stealing. In one high-profile case, actor Robert Brown said he was held for about an hour at the Herald Square flagship after buying a Movado watch (about $1,300) for his mother. The settlement required Macy's to adopt new anti-profiling policies and designate an independent expert.

D10D9D6
NPR ↗
major2015-01-08

Macy's announces 14 store closures and 2,200 layoffs

Macy's announced a reorganization that would close 14 under-performing stores and cut about 2,200 jobs across Macy's and Bloomingdale's store and field operations, merging the two chains' merchandising and marketing organizations to respond to omnichannel shopping. The company said the moves would save $140 million a year. The announcement came alongside holiday results showing existing-store sales up 2.7% in November and December.

major2015-03-09

Macy's acquires Bluemercury beauty chain for $210 million

Macy's completed the acquisition of Bluemercury, a specialty beauty retailer operating approximately 60 stores in 18 states. The acquisition expanded Macy's portfolio into the premium beauty retail segment, complementing the department store and off-price (Backstage) formats. Macy's planned to significantly expand Bluemercury's standalone store count and integrate selected boutiques into Macy's locations.

major2015-05-29

Consumers' Checkbook study finds Macy's 'sales' are often permanent

A 44-week price-tracking study by the nonprofit Consumers' Checkbook of items at seven national chains found that Macy's, Sears and Kohl's offered what it called fake sale prices: items were on 'sale' so much of the time that the discounted price was effectively the regular price. Macy's disputed the study and said it complies with pricing laws.

minor2015-10-01

Macy's card banks settle debt-collection robocall suit for $12.5 million

Department Stores National Bank and FDS Bank agreed to pay $12.5 million to settle a class action alleging they violated the Telephone Consumer Protection Act by placing autodialed or prerecorded debt-collection calls to cell phones about Macy's and Bloomingdale's credit card accounts without consent between 2009 and 2015. The defendants denied the allegations; checks went out in late 2016 after an appeal was dismissed.

major2015-12-16

NCLC report on deferred interest credit cards names Macy's among retailers

The National Consumer Law Center published 'Deceptive Bargain: The Hidden Time Bomb of Deferred Interest Credit Cards,' arguing that deferred interest promotions are a trap: consumers who fail to pay off the full balance before the promotional period ends are charged interest retroactively on the entire original amount, even on portions already paid. The report names Macy's among retailers offering such plans through Citibank (whose Department Stores National Bank issues Macy's cards) and Synchrony, and says financially vulnerable consumers are most likely to fall prey. Separately, a December 2016 Money Talks News comparison listed the Macy's credit card purchase APR at 25.49%.

major2016-03-30

Macy's spent $2 billion on buybacks in 2015 as sales fell

Macy's fiscal 2015 annual report showed it repurchased 34.8 million shares for $2.0 billion during 2015 and raised its annualized dividend 15% to $1.44 per share, the fifth increase in four years, in the same year it announced 14 store closures and about 2,200 job cuts as comparable sales declined.

critical2016-08-11

Macy's announces 100 store closures, then more than 10,000 job cuts

After six consecutive quarters of declining comparable sales, Macy's said on August 11, 2016 that it would close about 100 stores, roughly 14-15% of its fleet, mostly in early 2017; its shares rose on the news. On January 4, 2017 it said it would eliminate more than 10,000 jobs, including about 3,900 positions affected by store closings and 6,200 cut through restructuring, with an expected $550 million in annual savings.

D1D9D3
NPR ↗
major2016-12-08

Macy's and three retailers sued for fake sale pricing

The Los Angeles city attorney's office filed lawsuits against Macy's, JCPenney, Sears, and Kohl's alleging 'false reference pricing': advertising sale prices against 'original' prices that were never actually charged. The complaint against Macy's cited a sterling silver cross pendant advertised at a $30 sale price, marked down from a $120 'original' price, that it said had never sold for more than $30. Macy's was already facing consumer class actions over the same practice, including a 2015 federal suit (Haley v. Macy's) that also named Bloomingdale's.

minor2017-08-16

Labor Department sues Macy's over health plan and wellness surcharge

The US Department of Labor sued Macy's and two third-party administrators, alleging ERISA fiduciary violations in how out-of-network health claims were paid (reimbursed as a percentage of Medicare rates rather than as the plan document described) and alleging that Macy's administered a tobacco-user premium surcharge in violation of HIPAA's wellness rules (Acosta v. Macy's, S.D. Ohio).

minor2017-11-01

Class action accuses Macy's of inflating bed-sheet thread counts

A class action filed in November 2017 accused Macy's and two textile suppliers of deceptively marketing bed linens with inflated thread counts (Hawes v. Macy's, S.D. Ohio). A settlement won preliminary approval in May 2023, but the court denied final approval in December 2023.

major2018-02-21

Coresight: Macy's loses apparel share as Prime shoppers switch to Amazon

A Coresight Research report found Macy's lost 410 basis points of apparel market share as its annual revenue fell by $3 billion between 2012 and 2017. Among shoppers spending less on apparel at Macy's, 53% of Amazon Prime members said they had switched to Amazon, versus 22% of non-Prime members; off-price and discount chains such as T.J. Maxx, Kohl's and Walmart also gained.

minor2018-04-30

Macy's doubles Backstage off-price footprint to compete with TJX and Ross

Macy's expanded its Backstage off-price store-within-a-store concept, doubling the number of Backstage locations within existing department stores to compete with TJX Companies (TJ Maxx, Marshalls) and Ross Stores, which had been steadily capturing market share from traditional department stores. The strategy acknowledged that Macy's full-price model was losing ground and attempted to defend market position by embedding a discount format inside its remaining fleet rather than competing directly on the department store value proposition.

minor2018-05-30

Macy's moves $400 million media account to Publicis Groupe

Macy's moved its U.S. media buying account, valued at about $400 million, to Publicis Groupe's Spark Foundry and Digitas after a closed review, seeking data-driven solutions to help drive growth. Dentsu Aegis Network's Carat had handled the account since 2012. Macy's spent $415.4 million on U.S. measured media in 2017, according to Kantar Media. In a later shift, MediaPost reported that Macy's newspaper advertising spending fell 37% year over year in the first half of 2019, while television spending rose 27%, citing MediaRadar.

major2018-07-12

Customer data exposed in credential-stuffing breach

Macy's disclosed that between April 26 and June 12, 2018, unauthorized third parties used valid usernames and passwords obtained from an outside source to access customer online profiles on Macys.com and Bloomingdales.com. The breach exposed names, addresses, phone numbers, email addresses, birthdays, and payment card information. Macy's eventually settled the resulting class-action lawsuit for $192,500.

major2019-10-15

Magecart hackers inject malicious code into Macy's checkout page

Macy's disclosed that an unauthorized third party added skimming code to the checkout and wallet pages of macys.com on October 7, 2019; Macy's was alerted and removed it on October 15. Customer names, addresses, phone numbers, email addresses, card numbers, security codes and expiration dates entered during that week were at risk. Only website users were affected, not mobile app customers. The breach led to a class-action lawsuit filed in Massachusetts.

critical2020-02-04

Macy's announces 125-store closure plan and 2,000 corporate layoffs

Macy's announced plans to close 125 of its least productive stores, many in lower-tier malls, over three years and cut approximately 2,000 corporate jobs, including closing its Cincinnati headquarters and San Francisco tech offices. The 125 stores accounted for roughly $1.4 billion in annual sales. The company expected restructuring costs of $450-$490 million. Macy's planned to shift focus toward smaller-format stores in strip centers and expand its Backstage off-price concept.

D1D9D3
CNBC ↗
minor2020-02-05

Macy's targets billion-dollar private label brands

At its February 2020 investor day, Macy's set out to turn four in-house fashion labels, I.N.C. International Concepts, Alfani, Style & Co and Charter Club, into billion-dollar brands, and to raise private label merchandise from about 20% to 25% of revenue by 2025 (40% including exclusives from outside brands). It dropped six minor labels. Private labels carry higher margins and compete with national brands for Macy's floor space and promotion. Separately, Macy's 2023 Vendor Standards document compliance expense offsets and a MacysNet system for viewing chargebacks and account deductions. Vendors must submit deduction disputes and supporting documentation through MacysNet AP Forms within 60 days of the deduction.

critical2020-03-30

Macy's furloughs 130,000 employees during COVID-19 pandemic

After closing all 775 stores in mid-March 2020, Macy's furloughed the majority of its approximately 130,000 employees. The company suspended its dividend and fully drew its $1.5 billion credit facility to preserve cash. First-quarter net sales fell 45.2% to $3.0 billion from $5.5 billion, and the company reported a net loss of $3.6 billion for the quarter, including $3.15 billion in non-cash impairment charges (mostly goodwill). In June 2020 it completed financing activities of nearly $4.5 billion.

major2020-06-25

Macy's permanently lays off 3,900 corporate workers post-COVID

Macy's announced the permanent elimination of 3,900 corporate staffers, roughly 3% of its overall workforce, as part of post-pandemic restructuring. The layoffs were projected to save $630 million annually. These cuts came on top of the furloughs and the pre-pandemic 125-store closure plan, accelerating the company's shift away from its traditional department store footprint.

major2020-08-01

Macy's Media Network launches retail advertising platform

Macy's launched its Media Network in August 2020, combining first-party shopper data from its Star Rewards loyalty program with digital advertising formats such as sponsored products and website display ads. By February 2021 it was already generating more than $35 million a year. Net revenue reached about $105 million in 2021, $144 million in 2022 and $155 million in 2023, establishing advertising as a significant new revenue stream.

major2020-08-05

Macy's sued over alleged Clearview AI facial-recognition searches

A putative class action filed in the Northern District of Illinois alleged that Macy's violated Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act by sending store surveillance images to Clearview AI's facial-recognition database, running more than 6,000 searches to identify customers without consent. In January 2022 the federal judge overseeing the consolidated Clearview litigation let most of the claims against Macy's proceed.

major2020-12-07

Macy's illegally locks out union engineers in Northern California

Macy's locked out members of the International Union of Operating Engineers at stores in Northern California and Reno, Nevada, after failing to reach a new collective bargaining agreement. Union engineers who reported for work were turned away. The NLRB ruled the lockout violated the National Labor Relations Act, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit upheld the order in October 2025, requiring Macy's to compensate affected workers.

minor2021-09-29

Macy's sues to keep Amazon off its Herald Square billboard

Macy's sued its landlord, the Kaufman Organization, in Manhattan Supreme Court to enforce a 1963 restrictive covenant barring retail competitors from the billboard above its Herald Square flagship, after learning a 'prominent online retailer' it believed to be Amazon wanted the space. Macy's argued that a competitor's ad there would harm its brand; the landlord denied it was negotiating with Amazon.

major2021-11-09

Macy's raises minimum wage to $15 and adds debt-free education

Macy's announced it would raise its company-wide minimum wage to $15 an hour nationally by May 2022, after phasing it in across several markets and for all distribution-center workers, and would offer a debt-free education benefit covering tuition, books and fees, plus an extra flexible paid holiday. It said average base pay would exceed $17 an hour once the increases were complete.

major2022-02-22

Macy's authorizes $2 billion buyback after pandemic layoffs

Macy's board authorized a new $2.0 billion share repurchase program with no expiration date, after completing a $500 million program in 2021 that bought back 20.5 million shares. Macy's repurchased about 24 million shares for $600 million during 2022, less than two years after its 3,900 permanent corporate layoffs.

major2022-09-28

Macy's launches third-party marketplace with Mirakl

Macy's launched its curated digital marketplace on macys.com, powered by Mirakl's marketplace technology platform. The marketplace introduced 400 new brands across 20 product categories, eight of them new to Macy's, with sellers charged a 15% commission plus $0.30 per listing and $2.50 per order payment processing fee. The invite-only platform gave Macy's significant control over seller access and terms, creating a new revenue stream from third-party transactions while deepening customer engagement through expanded assortment.

major2023-08-02

Macy's introduces $9.99 return shipping fee for non-members

Macy's ended free return shipping for customers who are not Star Rewards loyalty members and began charging them a $9.99 return shipping fee, effective August 2, 2023. Joining Star Rewards is free and waives the fee, so the change pushes shoppers toward the loyalty program. Macy's program disclosure reserves Silver, Gold and Platinum status for Macy's credit-card holders, while customers without the card can join at Bronze. The card requirement applies to those higher tiers; joining the free loyalty program suffices for the return-shipping waiver.

major2024-01-18

Macy's cuts 2,350 jobs and closes five stores; critics point to buybacks

Macy's announced the elimination of about 2,350 positions, approximately 3.5% of its workforce, plus the closure of five namesake stores. Les Leopold of the Labor Institute criticized the company, saying it had put $1 billion into stock buybacks since October 2019 and had 'siphoned off the corporation's wealth to Wall Street stock sellers and top officers,' which he said virtually guaranteed store closures and layoffs.

D3D9D1
CNBC ↗
major2024-01-18

Wrongfully jailed man sues Macy's over facial-recognition match

Harvey Murphy Jr., 61, sued Macy's and Sunglass Hut parent EssilorLuxottica, alleging that EssilorLuxottica's loss-prevention head worked with Macy's to run robbery footage through facial-recognition software, which identified him as the robber of a Houston Sunglass Hut. Murphy was arrested and jailed even though he was in a California jail when the robbery happened; his lawyers said he was sexually assaulted while detained. Macy's declined to comment on pending litigation.

critical2024-02-27

Macy's unveils Bold New Chapter: 150 store closures through 2026

New CEO Tony Spring announced Macy's 'Bold New Chapter' three-year restructuring strategy, calling for the closure of approximately 150 underproductive stores, about 50 by the end of fiscal 2024 and the rest through 2026, while prioritizing investment in approximately 350 go-forward locations, expanding Bloomingdale's and Bluemercury, and opening smaller-format stores. The 2025 proxy subsequently reported plans to resume share buybacks in 2025 under the remaining $1.4 billion authorization, market conditions permitting.

major2024-07-15

Macy's rejects $6.9 billion Arkhouse/Brigade takeover bid

Macy's board unanimously voted to end talks, which began in December 2023, with Arkhouse Management and Brigade Capital Management over a potential $6.9 billion acquisition at $24.80 per share. The board said the revised proposal lacked certainty of financing and 'does not deliver compelling value,' and cited the distraction to management during the turnaround.

critical2024-11-25

Macy's reveals $154 million accounting fraud spanning three years

Macy's delayed its third-quarter earnings report after discovering that a single employee had intentionally hidden between $132 million and $154 million of small parcel delivery expenses through erroneous accounting accrual entries from Q4 2021 through Q3 2024. The company said it had no indication any other employee was involved. The independent investigation, concluded in December 2024, put the total at about $151 million. In its December 12, 2024 Form 10-Q, Macy's identified a material weakness in controls over manual journal entries for delivery and certain other non-merchandise expenses and reconciliation of related liabilities. It said the controls had not accounted for employee circumvention or adequately validated supporting information.

major2025-01-09

Macy's names 66 stores to close under its 150-store plan

Macy's confirmed the closure of 66 underproductive stores, most in the first quarter of 2025, as part of its plan to close about 150 stores over three years while investing in its go-forward fleet. Sixty-four Macy's stores ultimately closed in fiscal 2024.

minor2025-01-14

Macy's CEO rejects Bloomingdale's and Bluemercury spinoff demands

CEO Tony Spring publicly rejected activist investor demands to spin off Bloomingdale's and Bluemercury as independent companies, defending the three-brand portfolio strategy for back-end synergies and shared infrastructure. The refusal to break up the portfolio maintained Macy's control over multiple market segments (department store, luxury, specialty beauty) and prevented potential competitors from emerging as independent entities with established brand recognition and customer bases.

minor2025-05-28

Macy's makes 'selective' tariff price increases, cuts supplier orders

Reporting first-quarter results, CEO Tony Spring said 'limited' tariff-linked price increases were starting to appear on selected brands and categories, while stressing Macy's was not raising prices broadly. He said Macy's had renegotiated orders with suppliers and cancelled or delayed those where the value proposition was not right, and it trimmed its 2025 profit outlook.

major2025-08-21

Macy's Media Network partners with Amazon Retail Ad Service

Macy's Media Network announced a partnership with Amazon Retail Ad Service, Amazon's adtech product for other retailers, letting advertisers buy sponsored product ads on Macy's website through Amazon Ads and ad-buying firms such as Pacvue, with a pilot starting that fall. Macy's later said the offering had drawn over 175 new brands to its sponsored products. Media Network net revenue was $64 million in Q4 2024, up 6.7% year over year.

major2025-10-20

Ninth Circuit enforces NLRB order over Macy's union lockout

The Ninth Circuit upheld a National Labor Relations Board order finding that Macy's violated federal labor law when it locked out striking members of IUOE Stationary Engineers Local 39 in Northern California and Reno in December 2020 without clearly stating the conditions for their return. The court enforced reinstatement and make-whole relief, including compensation for direct or foreseeable financial harms.

minor2025-10-29

Macy's ends Backstage operations at South Windsor, cutting 106 jobs

Macy's notified Connecticut regulators that it would close the Backstage off-price operation at its South Windsor distribution center, eliminating 106 jobs between late December 2025 and January 2026, and centralize the work in Columbus, Ohio, as part of simplifying its supply chain.

major2025-11-21

Cl0p ransomware group lists Macy's on its leak portal

Cybersecurity researchers reported that Macy's had been added to the Cl0p ransomware group's leak portal as part of a campaign targeting organizations running Oracle E-Business Suite. Macy's had not publicly confirmed what data was accessed; the listing suggested internal systems may have been compromised, potentially including customer records, transaction histories, point-of-sale documentation, supply chain data, employee information and payroll records.

major2026-01-08

Macy's announces 14 more store closures

Macy's said it would close 14 stores in 12 states, mostly in the first quarter of 2026, with clearance sales of about 10 weeks, as part of its Bold New Chapter plan to close underperforming stores and invest in its go-forward locations, even as sales were showing momentum.

major2026-01-13

Macy's closes Connecticut fulfillment centers, lays off 1,050 workers

Macy's filed WARN notices in January 2026 for the closure of its fulfillment center in Cheshire and distribution center in South Windsor, Connecticut, eliminating about 1,050 jobs (993 in Cheshire and 57 in South Windsor), including fulfillment associates, loaders and unloaders, maintenance staff and operations managers. The company also planned to close its Oklahoma (Tulsa) fulfillment center that spring. The supply chain cuts came as part of the Bold New Chapter strategy's cost-savings push, following the closure of 66 stores in 2025.

major2026-03-18

Macy's returns $448 million to shareholders, raises dividend

Macy's reported fiscal 2025 net sales down 2.4% to $21.8 billion with comparable sales up 1.5%. It returned $448 million to shareholders, $251 million in buybacks and $197 million in dividends, and raised its quarterly dividend 5%. Net credit card revenues rose 24.6% to $669 million and Macy's Media Network net revenue rose 6.8% to $188 million. It expanded its store-investment program to 'Reimagine 200' locations.

minor2026-03-31

Macy's proxy discloses 368-to-1 CEO pay ratio

Macy's 2026 proxy statement reported CEO Tony Spring's fiscal 2025 total compensation at $14,104,067 against median employee pay of $38,296, a ratio of 368 to 1.

major2026-06-15

Supreme Court rejects Macy's challenge to NLRB remedies

The Supreme Court denied Macy's petition for certiorari in Macy's Inc. v. NLRB, leaving in place the Ninth Circuit decision requiring Macy's to compensate locked-out union engineers for all direct or foreseeable financial harms. Macy's had argued the NLRB's expanded 'make-whole' remedies exceeded its statutory authority, an issue on which the federal circuits are split.

minor2026-07-02

Class action calls Macy's WorryNoMore furniture warranty a 'sham'

A proposed class action filed in California alleged that Macy's and Tarmo, the administrator of its WorryNoMore furniture protection plan, misled buyers about coverage and wrongfully denied valid claims, using vague fine-print exclusions and a claims portal whose drop-down menus allegedly steer customers into describing damage as excluded. The allegations are unproven.

minor2026-09-10

Macy's keeps part of $116 million tariff refund, reinvests the rest

After courts struck down the IEEPA tariffs, Macy's said it had received $116 million in refunds, of which about $20 million would flow to full-year earnings and $96 million would be reinvested in 2026. It bought back $100 million of stock in the first half of 2026, with about $1.0 billion left under its authorization, and reported comparable sales up 2.7%.

minor2026-10-03

ERISA suit alleges broker took 37% of Macy's workers' premiums

A proposed class action in the Southern District of New York alleged that Aon entities collected about $13.2 million in commissions and fees, averaging 36.7% of premiums, from supplemental insurance that Macy's employees paid for from 2019 to 2024, and that Macy's failed to monitor the arrangement. A similar suit filed in July had been voluntarily dismissed. The allegations are unproven.

Evidence (59 citations)
Scoring Log (7 entries)
restore-check2026-10-14RESTORED

Checked 16 candidates: 0 restored, 8 partly restored, 6 confirmed removed, 2 already present. timeline:remove:19 CONFIRMED REMOVED: 2021 complaint surge and declining NPS: archived Trustpilot contains later complaints, not a 2021 surge; searches found no eligible trend source. ACSI 2021 survey instead reports improved online satisfaction; this is a different metric, not proof about NPS. timeline:update:0 CONFIRMED REMOVED: FTC archive explicitly finds no likely reduction in non-price competition and describes divestitures/state inquiries; no eligible academic finding or consumer-group protest was read to establish the removed claims. timeline:update:2 PARTLY RESTORED: AP/NBC supports falling Chicago sales by November 2007, while withholding the amount. Wikipedia repeats 30% but its AP citation does not support it. timeline:update:6 PARTLY RESTORED: 25.49% purchase APR restored with December 2016 date, separately from NCLC 2015 report. timeline:update:7 PARTLY RESTORED: Primary 2023 Vendor Standards confirm MacysNet compliance charges; 45% jewelry share, 2016 timing and causal link to private labels remain unproved. timeline:update:11 PARTLY RESTORED: MediaPost confirms 37% newspaper-spending decline for first-half 2019, not the May 2018 account move. timeline:update:22 PARTLY RESTORED: Original higher-tier credit-card requirement is true; free Bronze membership suffices for loyalty participation and the fee waiver. Hidden checkout disclosure not established. timeline:update:24 PARTLY RESTORED: 2025 proxy confirms planned 2025 buyback resumption with $1.4B remaining. Later closure announcements and FY2024 compensation already exist. Peer average found only on an ineligible content-farm page. timeline:update:25 CONFIRMED REMOVED: Retail Dive does not report critics linking July rejection to executive pay. Arkhouse April proxy criticized compensation incentives earlier, and May 2025 Yahoo covered continuing disagreement; neither establishes the claimed July allegation. timeline:update:28 PARTLY RESTORED: SEC Q3 2024 filing confirms material control weakness; no specific separation-of-duties finding restored. timeline:update:30 CONFIRMED REMOVED: Morgan & Morgan says exposure was unconfirmed; three targeted searches did not establish a 24-hour, 100-company spree or a confirmed Macy's breach. evidence:update:1 ALREADY PRESENT: 66-store closure claim remains in evidence[1] and timeline[38], sourced to Reuters and Macy's; Reuters read this session. Original Retail Merchandiser page and archive unreadable; no reason to replace the verified source. evidence:update:12 CONFIRMED REMOVED: FY2024 $16,452,108 pay remains in evidence[12] and is verified in SEC proxy; dropped peer comparison is not established by an eligible source. Salary.com live/archive unreadable; failure is not proof of falsity. evidence:update:17 PARTLY RESTORED: Retail Dive confirms search queries and browsing behavior as contextual information in 2025 Amazon offering; restore this narrower detail without asserting manual keyword targeting or universal behavioral profiling. evidence:update:21 ALREADY PRESENT: Holiday return-fee claim remains under Wharton replacement; Wharton page read. Original Parade and archive unreadable and exact headline search found no restorable distinct claim. evidence:update:33 CONFIRMED REMOVED: Original Morgan & Morgan page explicitly describes unconfirmed possible exposure, not established customer-data loss. Shared Cl0p research found no qualifying confirmation. Added evidence sources: Associated Press/NBC (2007 Chicago decline), Money Talks News/Yahoo (2016 APR), Macy's 2023 Vendor Standards (MacysNet), MediaPost/MediaRadar (2019 spending), Macy's 2018 program disclosure (card tiers), SEC Q3 2024 Form 10-Q (controls). Vendor Standards is year-dated 2023; the evidence date records access on 2026-10-14, not a claimed exact publication day. Source checks used at most three search queries per candidate; failed fetches were not treated as contrary evidence.

fact-audit2026-10-11FABRICATION FOUND

Team audit: checked 75 items (31 timeline, 36 evidence, 6 milestones, 2 alternatives) + prose. 23 verified, 34 corrected (13 date-only), 17 re-sourced, 1 removed (2021 complaint-surge event, unsupported); 2 evidence items added. Invented (contradicted): timeline[8] '14% stock price drop' (14% was the share of stores closing; shares rose ~15%, Fortune/Retail TouchPoints 2016-08-11); timeline[10] 'Amazon surpasses Macy's as largest US apparel seller' (Retail Dive 2018-04-20: still 'edging closer'); timeline[15] '$1.1 billion quarterly loss' (Q1 2020 10-Q: $3,581M net loss); d7/era 'four consecutive years of revenue decline from $25.3B in 2023' (10-K: revenue rose FY2021-22, $25.4B was FY2022). Also fixed many misdated items (Amazon RAS 2025, Backstage 2018, private-label push 2020, CT layoffs 2026), the $151M final fraud figure, NPS source (Comparably, not QuestionPro), and removed unsupported specifics (Marshall Field's 30% sales drop, 45% jewelry share, 37% newspaper cut, $8.22M peer pay average, State & Broadway lobbying, behavioral/keyword targeting, 'ultra confusing' checkout, academic non-price study).

regrade2026-10-11RESCORED

47→44. Since Feb 2026: 14 more store closures and ~1,050 Connecticut fulfillment layoffs (Jan 2026), fiscal 2025 shareholder returns of $448M incl. $251M buybacks and a 5% dividend raise, positive comps for five quarters, 368:1 CEO pay ratio, Supreme Court denied Macy's NLRB-remedies petition (Jun 2026), $116M tariff refund mostly reinvested, WorryNoMore warranty and Aon ERISA class actions (unproven). D1 6→5 (recalibration: closures and the return fee fit 4-5; ACSI 82 department-store leader 2024, comps positive; Comparably NPS is a small sample), D2 5→4 (recalibration: 15% marketplace take rate and a Media Network under 1% of sales are emerging pay-to-play, not 'vocally unhappy' sellers), D3 6→5 (recalibration: buybacks moderate relative to earnings and alongside real store investment; no record profits), D8 4→3 (recalibration: no acquisitions of rivals since 2005 May merger; weakening position), D9 5→6 (recalibration: 368:1 pay ratio, layoffs concurrent with buybacks and an NLRB-found unlawful lockout litigated to the Supreme Court meet the 6-7 row). Eras: split 'Post-May Consolidation' at 2009-02-02 (recession restructuring, 7,000 jobs, My Macy's) → new 'My Macy's Localization'; first era re-dated 2006-01-01→2005-08-30 (merger close); 'Revenue Decline Era' re-dated 2016-01-01→2015-01-08 (first closure/layoff wave); 'Pandemic Retrenchment' re-dated 2020-06-01→2020-02-04 (Polaris plan) and relabeled 'Polaris and Pandemic'; 'Digital Monetization Push' re-dated 2023-01-01→2022-09-28 (marketplace launch); 'Bold New Chapter' re-dated 2026-02-17→2024-02-27 (plan announced). Trajectory worsening→stable. Coverage gaps (2020-23 D1/D6/D8) filled or the cells lowered (D8 4→3).

narrative-gap-fill2026-03-11

Added 1 missing dimension narrative

Deep Enrichment2026-03-10
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-17