MuseScore

MuseScore is a dual product: free, open-source desktop notation software (MuseScore Studio) and a commercial sheet music sharing website (musescore.com). The desktop app allows users to compose, arrange, and engrave sheet music at no cost. The website hosts millions of scores; eligible public-domain and original community scores can be downloaded with a free account when the uploader permits it, while copyrighted community arrangements require a paid Pro subscription. Owned by Muse Group, whose portfolio also includes Audacity, StaffPad, and Hal Leonard. Francisco Partners invested in Muse Group in 2023 and exited in June 2026; founder Eugeny Naidenov remains majority owner.

42/ 100
Actively Enshittifying
2Squeezing Users↓Worsening

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-24. Score revised 2026-10-24: 38 → 42.

Score History

MilestoneCriticalMajor
Open-Source Origins (2002–2011) · 2/100Open-Source OriginsCommunity Growth (2011–2018) · 4/100Community GrowthUltimate Guitar Takeover (2018–2019) · 10/100Score Download Paywall (2019–2021) · 22/100ScoreMuse Group Controversies (2021–2023) · 31/100MusePE-Backed Consolidation (2023–2024) · 38/100Regulator-Fined Upsell Funnel (2024–present) · 42/100Regulator…Upsell…100755025020052010201520202026-10Open-Source Origins (2002–2011) · 2/100Community Growth (2011–2018) · 4/100Ultimate Guitar Takeover (2018–2019) · 10/100Score Download Paywall (2019–2021) · 22/100Muse Group Controversies (2021–2023) · 31/100PE-Backed Consolidation (2023–2024) · 38/100Regulator-Fined Upsell Funnel (2024–present) · 42/100241022313842MilestonesFounded (2002)MuseScore.com Launched by End of 2011 (2011)Acquired by Ultimate Guitar (2017)Acquired StaffPad (2020)Muse Group Formed (2021)Acquired Audacity (2021)Acquired Hal Leonard (2023)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Open-Source Origins
2/100
2002-01-01 – 2011-02-07

Werner Schweer starts MuseScore as a volunteer, GPL-licensed notation program forked from the MusE audio workstation. There is no website platform and no monetization; MusicXML import and export arrive in 2004. The only governance is the informal structure of a small open-source project.

Community Growth
4/100+2
2011-02-07 – 2018-02-19

MuseScore 1.0 ships in February 2011 as a free cross-platform notation program, and the musescore.com sharing site, announced in alpha in 2010, launches by the end of 2011 with a freemium model. MuseScore 2.0 (2015) adds linked parts and a better layout engine. Downloads of shared scores stay largely free, while free accounts are capped at five uploaded scores.

Ultimate Guitar Takeover
10/100+6
2018-02-19 – 2019-07-01

Ultimate Guitar publicly announces its acquisition of MuseScore and musescore.com (ownership changed in 2017), promising more development resources. MuseScore 3.0 follows in December 2018, and the founding trio retire from active development in 2019, handing stewardship to a company-employed team. Score downloads have not yet been paywalled.

Score Download Paywall
22/100+12
2019-07-01 – 2021-04-26

In July 2019 musescore.com makes score downloads a Pro feature, citing copyright and licensing, and previously free community uploads become part of the paid offering; forum users ask whether MuseScore is still free. The five-score upload cap for free accounts is lifted in February 2020. The same month a MuseScore developer demands removal of the musescore-downloader tool and threatens referral to lawyers.

Muse Group Controversies
31/100+9
2021-04-26 – 2023-12-04

Muse Group forms in April 2021 as the Cyprus-headquartered umbrella for MuseScore and Ultimate Guitar and takes over Audacity, after acquiring StaffPad in December 2020. The Audacity telemetry and privacy-policy rows, and a strategy head's July 2021 warning that the musescore-downloader developer could be deported to China, define the company's reputation. Tim Gadanidis's November 2021 analysis documents musescore.com's one-hour cancellation wait and confirm-shaming, while MuseScore 4.0 (December 2022) substantially improves the free desktop app.

PE-Backed Consolidation
38/100+7
2023-12-04 – 2024-12-16

Muse Group acquires Hal Leonard with growth investment from Francisco Partners, combining notation tools, score-sharing platforms and the largest sheet music publisher. The desktop app is renamed MuseScore Studio in early 2024 to separate it from the paid website, Hal Leonard songbooks arrive behind a Songbook subscription and Muse Credits, and Finale's August 2024 discontinuation narrows the notation field. Cyprus's consumer regulator opens an inquiry into musescore.com's subscription pages in mid-2024.

Regulator-Fined Upsell Funnel
42/100+4
2024-12-16 – present

Cyprus's Consumer Protection Service fines MuseScore Limited €30,000 over misleading subscription practices, a decision the minister upholds on appeal in April 2025. Monetization keeps widening: individual renewals rise, the NoteVision converter becomes upload-limited for free users, a MuseSounds Pro subscription launches, and a March 2026 review documents countdown-timer deals and ads in MuseScore Studio, prompting a cease-and-desist letter by its author's account. Francisco Partners exits in June 2026 through a debt-and-cash-financed transaction, while the free desktop app keeps shipping major releases.

Alternatives

Professional notation software by Steinberg (Yamaha), built by former Sibelius developers. Offers a free Dorico SE tier with limited features and paid Pro/Elements desktop licenses. Strong engraving quality and modern interface. Paid desktop licenses are purchased outright. Offers a migration path for Finale users.

Long-established professional notation software by Avid. Available via subscription or perpetual license. Offers professional engraving, score sharing, and educational tools. A paid alternative to MuseScore Studio with several editions for different needs.

Free, open-source music engraving program that produces publication-quality output. Text-based input instead of a WYSIWYG editor requires a different workflow. Best for users comfortable with markup languages.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
The free, open-source MuseScore Studio desktop app keeps improving: version 4.7 (May 2026) added engraving, guitar and audio-engine upgrades, and a free beta Audio-to-Score converter arrived in August 2026. The erosion sits on musescore.com, where score downloads became a Pro feature in July 2019 and most community arrangements still need a subscription to download. Users acknowledge the decline in forum threads about the paywall and in billing complaints, a forum subscriber reported a renewal rising from $39.99 to $54.99 in January 2025, and the NoteVision converter went from fully free to upload-limited in November 2025. A March 2026 review by a former Muse Group team member also reports ads inside MuseScore Studio.
How It Got Here
MuseScore began in 2002 as a volunteer open-source notation tool, and the desktop software has stayed free throughout. MuseScore 2.0 (2015), 3.0 (2018) and the 4.0 redesign with Muse Sounds (December 2022) each improved it substantially, and the renamed MuseScore Studio kept going with 4.7 in May 2026. The erosion story is on musescore.com. After Ultimate Guitar's acquisition, the site made score downloads a Pro feature in July 2019, and forum users soon asked whether MuseScore was still free. One improvement followed: in February 2020 the five-score upload cap on free accounts was lifted. Since then the paywall has hardened rather than eased. Users describe the site as almost a scam and file billing complaints, a subscriber reported a renewal rising from $39.99 to $54.99 in January 2025, and the NoteVision converter went from fully free to upload-limited in November 2025. The January 2024 rename to MuseScore Studio acknowledged that the shared name had confused the free app with the paid site. A March 2026 review by a former Muse Group team member reports ads inside the desktop app, even as Muse added free features such as August 2026's Audio-to-Score beta.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2002Open-Source Origins2011Community Growth2018Ultimate Guitar Takeover2019Score Download Paywall2021Muse Group Controversies2023PE-Backed Consolidation2024Regulator-Fined Upsell FunnelUser Value0014445Biz Exploit0002233Shareholder0011244Lock-in1112233Algorithms0001223Dark Patterns0012677Advertising0124456Competition0012344Labor/Gov1122333Regulatory0112334
Timeline (35 events)
major2002-01-01

Werner Schweer Creates MuseScore Notation Software

German developer Werner Schweer forks notation code from the MusE audio workstation to create a standalone open-source music notation program. The project begins as a personal hobby, developed entirely by volunteers under the GPL license with no commercial component.

major2010-04-01

MuseScore.com Sharing Platform Announced in Alpha

Co-founders Nicolas Froment, Thomas Bonte, and Werner Schweer announced musescore.com in April 2010 as an online sheet music sharing platform to support development of the free, open-source app. In November it was still in alpha. The planned freemium model offered subscriptions for more storage and features, with revenue intended to fund the three core developers.

major2011-02-07

MuseScore 1.0 Stable Release Published

MuseScore 1.0 is published as a stable milestone release after years of development, offering free cross-platform notation software for Windows, Mac, and Linux in 35 languages. The release establishes MuseScore as a viable free alternative to commercial notation software like Finale and Sibelius.

major2015-03-23

MuseScore 2.0 Brings Major Feature Improvements

MuseScore 2.0 releases with significant improvements including linked parts, Guitar Pro import, continuous view, an inspector panel, and improved layout engine. The update establishes MuseScore as competitive with commercial alternatives for basic notation needs.

critical2018-02-19

Ultimate Guitar Announces Its Acquisition of MuseScore

Ultimate Guitar publicly announces its acquisition of MuseScore and its sheet music sharing platform. Muse Group’s official history and co-founder Thomas Bonte date the ownership change to 2017; February 19, 2018 is the public announcement date. The announcement promises more development resources, including a dedicated mobile team and a soundfont specialist, while preserving the desktop editor’s free, open-source status.

minor2018-12-24

MuseScore 3.0 Released with Improved Engraving

MuseScore 3.0 releases on Christmas Eve 2018, bringing significant improvements to automatic spacing, layout, and engraving quality. The release demonstrates continued investment in the open-source desktop application despite growing commercial focus on the website.

major2019-01-01

Founding Developers Retire from Active Development

After 17 years of MuseScore development, Werner Schweer, Thomas Bonte, and Nicolas Froment — the founding trio — retire from active involvement in 2019. Schweer started the project in 2002; Bonte and Froment joined in 2008. The project continues with an in-house development team and open-source contributors.

critical2019-07-01

MuseScore.com Makes Score Downloads a Pro Feature

MuseScore.com changes its subscription model in July 2019, making score downloads a Pro feature while addressing copyright and licensing concerns. Previously free community uploads become part of the paid download offering. Original and public-domain works are subsequently available for free download, while copyrighted arrangements require Pro. A June 2020 account reports the annual Pro price as $49 and says free uploads are no longer limited to five scores.

major2020-02-08

Developer Posts MuseScore Takedown Request Against musescore-downloader

Wenzheng Tang posts a takedown request from a person identifying themself as a MuseScore developer. The request alleges unauthorized use of the private API and distribution of licensed music, asks for removal of the GitHub repository and Greasy Fork script, and threatens referral to lawyers. The later Register report identifies the sender as MuseScore developer Maksim Chistyakov.

minor2020-02-19

MuseScore.com Lifts Five-Score Upload Limit for Free Accounts

MuseScore lifted the five-score upload limit that had applied to basic, non-paid musescore.com accounts since the site's launch. The limit had forced many users to make older scores private to publish new ones. After the change, all accounts could save all their scores online and share them publicly.

major2021-04-26

Muse Group Formed as Umbrella for Music Software Brands

The company behind Ultimate Guitar and MuseScore announces the formation of Muse Group and the acquisition of Audacity. The umbrella supports its music creation, learning, and distribution products, including Ultimate Guitar, MuseScore, MuseClass, and Tonebridge. Muse Group’s headquarters are in Limassol, Cyprus. Muse Group’s Terms of Service identify Muse as MuseCY Holdings Ltd. and its affiliates and divisions.

major2021-05-14

Audacity Telemetry Plans Spark Community Outrage

Shortly after acquiring Audacity, Muse Group proposes adding telemetry to the open-source audio editor, sparking community backlash. Over 1,000 comments are left on the GitHub pull request, and the original plan to use Google Analytics and Yandex is dropped. This is an episode in the parent company’s governance of Audacity; it does not establish MuseScore’s data practices.

critical2021-07-06

Audacity Privacy Policy Proposes Law Enforcement Data Sharing

Muse Group updates Audacity’s privacy policy in early July 2021 with vague provisions concerning data for law enforcement, litigation, and authorities’ requests, and a provision discouraging use by children under 13. Commentators raise concerns that the age restriction conflicts with the GPL. The controversy damages confidence in Muse Group’s open-source stewardship; it concerns Audacity rather than establishing MuseScore’s own data practices.

critical2021-07-20

Muse Group Representative Warns Developer He Could Be Deported to China

Muse Group head of strategy Daniel Ray writes that Wenzheng Tang’s residency could be revoked and he could be deported to China if found in violation of laws, noting Tang’s criticism of the Chinese government and questioning how he might be received. Tang characterizes the message as a public death-threat. Ray tells The Register he did not intend it as a threat. The incident concerns the enforcement dispute over musescore-downloader and LibreScore.

major2021-07-22

Muse Group Backtracks on Audacity Privacy Policy

After community criticism, the Audacity team publishes a revised privacy policy and formal apology. It removes the under-13 provision, clarifies that no additional information is collected for law enforcement, and describes anonymization of update-check and error-report data. The team says the only change to data sent by Audacity is removal of the error-report comment field. The revision addresses the policy’s wording and data handling rather than eliminating all networking features.

major2021-11-09

Blog Analysis Documents MuseScore’s Deceptive Cancellation Design

Tim Gadanidis, identified in GIGAZINE’s later coverage as studying at the University of Toronto, publishes a blog analysis of MuseScore.com’s dark patterns. It documents the one-hour wait before cancellation and confirm-shaming language suggesting that declining renewal immediately removes paid benefits, even though access continues through the paid period. The analysis is later discussed on Hacker News and covered by GIGAZINE.

major2022-12-14

MuseScore 4.0 Launches with Muse Sounds Library

MuseScore 4.0 releases with a completely redesigned UI, major engraving improvements, and the Muse Sounds orchestral sample library. Described as the most significant update since 1.0, the release demonstrates continued investment in the free open-source desktop app amid controversy over the commercial website. MuseScore 4 is distributed via MuseHub, a new desktop app platform.

minor2023-01-07

iPhone User Reports Tiny Close Button on Mobile Subscription Offer

A MuseScore forum commenter reports that the iPhone app’s welcome flow presents trial and paid-membership choices without an obvious free-use option. They explain that a tiny “x” in the upper-left corner dismisses the subscription offer and enters the free app. They speculate that the button may initially be off-screen, but say they do not remember; that behavior is not established as a universal feature.

major2023-08-15

GIGAZINE Investigation Exposes MuseScore Dark Patterns

GIGAZINE reports on MuseScore.com’s dark patterns, revisiting Tim Gadanidis’s 2021 analysis. It describes seven-day trials that convert to annual billing, a one-hour wait before cancellation is available, confirm-shaming cancellation screens, and friction in obtaining refunds. It reports that the one-hour restriction remains in place in August 2023.

critical2023-12-04

Francisco Partners Backs Hal Leonard Acquisition

Muse Group acquires Hal Leonard, the world’s largest sheet music publisher, with growth investment from Francisco Partners. The deal combines creation tools, distribution platforms, and publishing. The announcement reports 300 million annual visitors across Ultimate Guitar and MuseScore and a combined content library of over 5.5 million scores, tabs, books, video courses, backing tracks, and presets.

minor2024-01-30

MuseScore Rebranded to MuseScore Studio

The open-source desktop application is rebranded from 'MuseScore' to 'MuseScore Studio' starting with version 4.3, attempting to reduce confusion between the free software and the paid musescore.com service. The rename acknowledges that the naming overlap has been a vector for users accidentally subscribing while seeking the free app.

major2024-06-14

Hal Leonard Songbooks and ArrangeMe Commissions Added to MuseScore

Muse Group announces that 2,000 best-selling Hal Leonard books are available on MuseScore and Ultimate Guitar, for one-off Muse Credits purchases on MuseScore.com or unlimited browsing with a Songbook subscription. The post also says ArrangeMe creators share music with MuseScore Pro+ subscribers and earn commission for views.

minor2024-07-12

Muse Group Hires C-Suite Executives from Spotify and Dell

Muse Group announces Debbie Diekelman as CFO (previously COO/CFO at Hal Leonard), Sven Ahrens as Chief Growth Officer (previously at Spotify), and Mohammed “Mo” Chahdi as COO (previously at Appen and Dell). The company says the appointments support growth, operational excellence, and financial strength as it continues integrating Hal Leonard.

major2024-08-26

Finale Discontinued, Reducing Notation Competition

MakeMusic announces that Finale, the 35-year-old professional music notation software, is being discontinued with no further development. The closure reduces the range of actively developed notation alternatives. MakeMusic directs Finale users toward a discounted Dorico purchase; MuseScore Studio remains a free alternative.

critical2024-12-16

Cyprus Consumer Protection Service Fines MuseScore €30,000

Cyprus's Consumer Protection Service fined MuseScore Limited €30,000 for breaches of the 2021 Consumer Protection Law on musescore.com. It found that a 42% discount from a struck-through €69.99 to €39.99 was not shown to be a genuine special price, that a window opened by 'Start Free Trial' also offered a 'Summer Deal' that charged immediately, and that the site lacked withdrawal-right information, a phone number, a clear payment-obligation button and a Greek-language version. The company had changed some practices during the inquiry.

major2025-01-24

Subscriber Reports Pro Price Rising from $39.99 to $54.99

A MuseScore forum user reports paying $39.99 for the previous year’s subscription and now facing $54.99, an increase of approximately 37.5%. The user asks whether the old plan can be retained and says they do not want the included official-score and class features. This documents an individual subscription-price complaint rather than establishing a universal tariff change on one date.

major2025-04-09

Cyprus Minister Upholds MuseScore Fine on Appeal

MuseScore Limited filed a hierarchical appeal against the discount finding in the Consumer Protection Service's December 2024 decision, arguing that its €69.99 reference price was not fictitious. The Minister of Energy, Commerce and Industry found the company had produced no evidence that €39.99 was a genuine special price and upheld the €30,000 decision in full.

minor2025-11-06

NoteVision Score Converter Moves From Free to Upload-Limited

Muse Group said its NoteVision optical music recognition converter, introduced in July 2025 and completely free since launch, was moving to free and premium access. Free use would continue with limits on the number of uploads, while MuseScore Pro Plus subscribers would get unlimited access. The company said uploads had grown about 130% year on year from July to September.

minor2026-01-20

Muse Group Launches $199-a-Year MuseSounds Pro Subscription

Muse Group launched MuseSounds Pro, a subscription bundling instrument libraries made with Spitfire Audio, Vienna Symphonic Library and Audio Imperia, plus Cantai vocal playback, for use inside the free MuseScore Studio. It costs $199 a year or $19.99 a month through MuseHub. The libraries had previously been sold only as individual purchases or bundles.

major2026-03-17

Former Team Member Documents MuseScore Pricing Tricks and Studio Ads

Leo Wattenberg, who says he was formerly on one of Muse Group's open-source teams, published screenshots taken in June 2025 of musescore.com countdown-timer deals, discount rates that changed between 75% and 90%, reference prices that rose when a deal was selected, a billing period that switched from 12 months to 12 weeks, and an introductory price that increased after the first period. He also reported ads inside MuseScore Studio and a download button that installs MuseHub; the official download page offers a MuseHub-free option.

major2026-03-19

Muse Group Sends Cease-and-Desist Over Critical Blog Post

Leo Wattenberg wrote that Muse Group sent him a cease-and-desist letter on March 19, 2026 over his post criticizing its pricing pages and app designs. After some back and forth with the company, he decided not to take the post down. The letter itself has not been published.

minor2026-05-13

MuseScore Studio 4.7 Adds Engraving, Guitar and Audio-Engine Upgrades

MuseScore Studio 4.7 added chord brackets, chord parentheses, arrow lines, guitar dive lines and capo transposition options, workflow improvements and audio-engine upgrades, with over 100 community contributions. The release notes say the main download option installs the MuseHub utility, with a separate download that skips MuseHub.

major2026-06-03

Francisco Partners Exits Muse Group in Credit-Financed Transaction

Muse Group announced the conclusion of Francisco Partners' 2023 investment. The transaction was supported by senior credit facilities arranged by J.P. Morgan and cash on hand rather than a new equity investor, and financial terms were not disclosed. Founder and CEO Eugeny Naidenov remains majority owner and controller, with Mo Chahdi as executive chairman and COO.

minor2026-07-14

Scoring Notes Reports MuseScore Studio Leadership Departures

Scoring Notes reported that across 2025 and 2026 MuseScore Studio lost its head of software Martin Keary (who left in March 2026), product owner Bradley Kunda and head of engraving Simon Smith, and that musescore.com's product owner left in September 2025. Muse Group said development continues more actively than ever, that it is recruiting a new product owner, and that the Francisco Partners exit was not a factor.

minor2026-08-17

MuseScore Adds Free Audio-to-Score and Mobile Score Recognition

MuseScore introduced Audio-to-Score, a free beta tool on the web desktop version that turns an MP3 upload of up to 30 MB, or a YouTube or Audio.com link, into an editable MSCZ file. It also launched a free Shazam-like recognition feature in its iOS and Android apps that finds matching scores.

Evidence (36 citations)

D2: Business Customer Exploitation

D4: Lock-in & Switching Costs

D5: Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity

D10: Regulatory & Legal Posture

Scoring Log (7 entries)
regrade2026-10-24RESCORED

38→42. Since Mar 2026 (and over the last 12 months): NoteVision moved from free to upload-limited (Nov 2025), $199/yr MuseSounds Pro launched (Jan 2026), a former team member documented countdown deals, shifting discounts, 12-month→12-week switches and ads in MuseScore Studio (Mar 2026) and reported a Muse cease-and-desist, Francisco Partners exited via J.P. Morgan credit facilities and cash (Jun 2026), Studio leadership departed, and Studio 4.7 and free Audio-to-Score shipped. Historical gap: Cyprus Consumer Protection Service fined MuseScore Limited €30,000 (2024-12-16), upheld on appeal 2025-04-09. D5 2→3 (event: regulator found unsubstantiated discount reference price; 2026 documentation of shifting deal prices), D7 5→6 (event: NoteVision paywall, MuseSounds Pro, ads in Studio), D10 2→4 (event: Cyprus fine upheld on appeal; cease-and-desist to critic). D3 held at 4: PE exit replaced by debt financing. Eras: 'Community Growth' re-dated 2011-02-01→2011-02-07 (1.0 release); 'Post-Acquisition Monetization' re-dated 2018-01-01→2018-02-19 (acquisition announcement) and split at 2019-07-01 (download paywall) into 'Ultimate Guitar Takeover' + 'Score Download Paywall'; 'Muse Group Controversies' re-dated 2021-06-01→2021-04-26 (Muse Group formation); current era re-dated 2026-03-11→2023-12-04 (Hal Leonard/Francisco Partners) and split at 2024-12-16 (Cyprus fine) into 'PE-Backed Consolidation' + 'Regulator-Fined Upsell Funnel'; 'Open-Source Origins' kept. All eras re-scored from criteria. Rejected candidates: NMPA lawsuit/settlement (the cited SEC filing is Roblox's 10-Q, not Muse Group's); minor 4.6.4/4.7.x patch notes, 4.7 beta, Cantai and privacy-policy date items as low-signal. Description updated for the Francisco Partners exit. Category 'Music Tools' looks right.

restore-check2026-10-24RESTORED

Checked all 8 removed/trimmed candidates: 0 restored, 1 partly restored, 7 confirmed removed, 0 already present. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:10: Muse Group legal terms (https://www.mu.se/content/terms-of-service, effective February 26, 2021) identify Muse as MuseCY Holdings Ltd. and affiliates/divisions; added the legal terms as governance evidence. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:remove:17 and evidence:remove:13: no readable source or search corroborates the claimed August 2023 Deceptive.design listing; the original URL currently redirects to a Hall of Shame index with no MuseScore match. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:15: GIGAZINE supports a personal blog analysis and retained design details, not academic publication or an unmeasured frequently-cited status. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:22: Music Instrument News supports the retained hires and integration rationale, not specific PE direction. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:24: no qualifying source establishes a universal September 1, 2024 $39.99-to-$54.99 increase, renewal-only discovery, or a Francisco Partners return-funding motive; retained individual complaint is unchanged. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:update:1 and evidence:update:24: no dated source establishes a 2.0 Trustpilot rating on December 1, 2025 or a January 1, 2025 DMCA-policy publication. Archive/fetch failures were treated as access limitations, not proof of falsity. Detailed subclaims, searches and source checks: work/restore-findings.json. No content removed; all scores preserved.

fact-audit2026-10-23FABRICATION FOUND

Lead checked all 58 timeline/evidence/milestone items plus 3 alternatives and all prose/fields. One contradicted numeric detail: timeline[19] and the D3 narrative wrongly call 5.5 million items Hal Leonard scores; Francisco Partners’ primary release explicitly makes this the combined multi-format library (scores, tabs, books, video courses, backing tracks, presets). The founders’ 17-year project history is preserved with individual joining dates clarified; it is not counted as fabricated. Wrong chronology, including MusicXML since 2002 and GitHub since 2002, is counted as corrected prose rather than extra fabricated quantities. Unsupported details are listed once per distinct claim in work/unsupported-claims.json. Recovered the real 2017 acquisition, >1,000 telemetry comments, formal Audacity apology, Toronto affiliation, exact price-rise anecdote, and tiny mobile close button instead of deleting them. Full decisions/searches: work/item-decisions.json, work/prose-claims.json, work/prose-findings.md, work/metadata-findings.md.

Initial Scoring2026-03-11
Scoring Review2026-03-11MINOR FIXES

Corrected Trustpilot rating from 1.6 to 2.0 stars in D1/D6 summaries and evidence title; fixed VI-CONTROL evidence date from 2024-03-15 to 2023-11-10; corrected Pro subscription price from $49/year to $49.99/year; fixed Gadanidis evidence title from 'Academic Analysis' to 'Blog Analysis'

Deep Enrichment2026-03-11
narrative-gap-fill2026-03-11

Gap-fill: added 5 missing dimension narratives (d2, d4, d5, d9, d10)