Only Natural Pet

Only Natural Pet is a Boulder, CO-based online pet retailer and private-label brand specializing in natural, holistic pet food, treats, supplements, and supplies. Founded in 2004 by Marty Grosjean, it became the first North American pet food and treat company to earn B Corp certification in 2019. The company operates an e-commerce site, a flagship Boulder retail store, and an auto-delivery subscription program. It was acquired by Pet360 in 2014 and passed to PetSmart when PetSmart acquired Pet360 for $130 million plus up to $30 million in performance payments, though it continues to operate under the Only Natural Pet brand with an emphasis on sustainability and natural ingredients.

22/ 100
Early Warning
1No Decay→Stable

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-26. Score revised 2026-10-26: 19 → 22.

Score History

MilestoneCriticalMajor
Natural E-Commerce Startup (2004–2011) · 4/100Natural E-Commerce StartupGrowth Capital Phase (2011–2014) · 5/100GrowthPet360/PetSmart Acquisition (2014–2015) · 8/100BC Partners House Brand (2015–2019) · 13/100BC PartnersHouse BrandB Corp Certification Era (2019–2022) · 18/100B Corp EraCertificat…Auto-Delivery Friction (2022–present) · 22/100Auto-Delivery Friction100755025020052010201520202026-10Natural E-Commerce Startup (2004–2011) · 4/100Growth Capital Phase (2011–2014) · 5/100Pet360/PetSmart Acquisition (2014–2015) · 8/100BC Partners House Brand (2015–2019) · 13/100B Corp Certification Era (2019–2022) · 18/100Auto-Delivery Friction (2022–present) · 22/100458131822MilestonesFounded (2004)Revelry Brands Investment (2011)Acquired by Pet360 (2014)Acquired by PetSmart (via Pet360) (2014)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Natural E-Commerce Startup
4/100
2004-05-01 – 2011-09-15

Marty Grosjean founds Only Natural Pet in Boulder as an online curator of third-party natural pet products, earns BBB accreditation in 2005 and opens a Boulder flagship store in 2008. Founder-owned and small, it shows almost no enshittification pressure beyond the premium prices natural products carry.

Growth Capital Phase
5/100+1
2011-09-15 – 2014-01-10

Boulder-based Revelry Brands takes a stake with $3.5 million of growth capital for customer acquisition, a wholesale brand and wider distribution. Only Natural Pet expands its affiliate program in 2012 and co-founds the Pet Sustainability Coalition in 2013. Outside capital brings mild return expectations, but the company stays small and transparent.

Pet360/PetSmart Acquisition
8/100+3
2014-01-10 – 2015-03-11

Pet360 buys Only Natural Pet from Revelry in January 2014, and by May Pet360's discounted AutoShip program carries the brand's line. PetSmart agrees in August to buy Pet360 for up to $160 million and closes the deal on September 29. In December, BC Partners agrees to an $8.7 billion buyout of PetSmart. The brand keeps its own site and launches PowerFood and PowerPate with Dr. Jean Hofve.

BC Partners House Brand
13/100+5
2015-03-11 – 2019-02-28

The BC Partners consortium completes its buyout of PetSmart on March 11, 2015, putting Only Natural Pet under PE control. PetSmart pays an $800 million dividend in February 2016. In November 2015, PetSmart becomes the brand's exclusive national retailer, starting with 133 stores. Truth About Pet Food flags misleading Wholesome Homemade marketing in 2016, and Pet360's e-commerce operations are folded into Chewy in 2017.

B Corp Certification Era
18/100+5
2019-02-28 – 2022-04-01

In February 2019, Only Natural Pet becomes the first North American pet food and treat company certified as a B Corp, scoring 86.1, and builds sustainability goals into employee reviews. Its 2020 privacy policy discloses interest-based ad tracking. That year, two proposed class actions over its hemp products, filed against PetSmart, are dismissed without prejudice within weeks. It recertifies in 2022.

Auto-Delivery Friction
22/100+4
2022-04-01 – present

In April 2022, Only Natural Pet's current auto-delivery terms take effect: discounts at the company's discretion, a reminder email before each order, a 24-hour cutoff, and mandatory individual arbitration. From late 2023, BBB and Trustpilot complaints build up about unwitting enrollment, charges after attempted cancellation and products arriving damaged or near expiry. The company usually refunds once contacted. Apollo takes a minority stake in PetSmart in 2023. The FTC's Click-to-Cancel rule, which targeted such friction, is vacated in July 2025.

Alternatives

Memphis-founded regional natural pet store chain dating to the 1950s, family-owned by the McGhee family, with a strong focus on customer education and natural/holistic brands. A store-based option for buying premium natural brands in person.

Open Farm20/100

Ethically sourced natural pet food with an ingredient-origin lookup by lot code and animal ingredients from farms audited by Certified Humane or Global Animal Partnership. Similar mission to Only Natural Pet. Available online and at select retailers; easy switch by purchasing direct from their site.

Fresh dog food made with human-grade ingredients in USDA kitchens and delivered on a subscription. Higher quality tier than kibble-based options but also a subscription model; the subscription can be paused, skipped or canceled from account settings. Best fit if you want fresher food than Only Natural Pet's shelf-stable line.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
The core natural food and supply range is intact, but complaints about individual products and service keep coming in: 23 of 80 cans arriving dented, a flea collar that snapped twice and was then refused a replacement, bully sticks a customer blamed for sick dogs, and in 2026 supplements delivered with less than 30 days of shelf life (refunded). FDA's adverse-event database also holds unverified consumer reports, including sharp objects in Just Fish Feast kibble (2019) and an unannounced Power Function to Raw Blends switch (2023). These are recurring annoyances, not a systematic decline of the product.
How It Got Here
Only Natural Pet launched in 2004 as a curator of third-party natural pet products. By 2014 it had developed more than 500 of its own branded items, adding PowerFood and PowerPate lines formulated with holistic veterinarian Dr. Jean Hofve, then the PowerStew line (2015), a carbon-neutral PowerFood line (2016) and Mindful Meals in bioplastic packaging (2018). Quality complaints grew as the company scaled. In 2016 Truth About Pet Food flagged Wholesome Homemade marketing that described 'chunks of meat' while the company said by phone that the product was 'similar to kibble.' FDA's adverse-event database holds unverified consumer reports of sharp objects in Just Fish Feast kibble (2019) and of Power Function food being rebranded as Raw Blends without notice of any formula change (2023). Reviews on Sitejabber (2.4/5) and Trustpilot document dented cans (23 of 80 in one order), flea collars that snapped and a refused replacement, a wood chip in Senior Mobility Chews, and a 2024 complaint that bully sticks made dogs ill. In 2026 a BBB complaint reported bulk supplements delivered with less than 30 days of shelf life; the order was refunded. The company's list of 40 unacceptable ingredients and its B Corp commitments act as quality guardrails, but its handling of defective products has been inconsistent.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2004Natural E-Commerce Startup2011Growth Capital Phase2014Pet360/PetSmart Acquisition2015BC Partners House Brand2019B Corp Certification Era2022Auto-Delivery FrictionUser Value111223Biz Exploit000111Shareholder012333Lock-in001123Algorithms000012Dark Patterns001234Advertising111122Competition111111Labor/Gov111222Regulatory000011
Timeline (43 events)
major2004-05-01

Marty Grosjean founds Only Natural Pet in Boulder

Inspired by his dog Crinkles's health problems (his family adopted her in 2002) and the lack of accessible natural pet products online, Marty Grosjean launches Only Natural Pet as an e-commerce retailer in Boulder, Colorado. The company initially curates third-party natural pet food, treats, and supplements for dogs and cats.

minor2005-11-14

Only Natural Pet earns BBB accreditation

Only Natural Pet Store receives Better Business Bureau accreditation, establishing early credibility for the young e-commerce company. The BBB profile lists accreditation since November 14, 2005, and the business currently holds an A+ rating.

major2008-07-11

Boulder flagship retail store opens

Only Natural Pet opens its first physical retail store, a 3,500-square-foot shop in the Crossroads Commons shopping center at 28th and Pearl streets in Boulder, Colorado, moving beyond pure e-commerce. The store sells natural, raw and organic foods, supplements, natural remedies and eco-friendly pet supplies.

major2011-09-15

Revelry Brands invests $3.5M for growth capital

Boulder-based Revelry Brands acquires a stake in Only Natural Pet Store, providing $3.5 million in growth capital. The investment is earmarked for expanding the online customer base, building out a wholesale brand and team, and extending product distribution to new retail outlets. This is Revelry's fourth investment since its 2009 founding.

minor2012-06-04

Only Natural Pet expands its affiliate program across three networks

Only Natural Pet hires Versa Marketing to manage its affiliate program across Commission Junction, LinkShare and ShareASale and to recruit more publishers, including pet bloggers. Pet affiliates earn a base commission of 8%, rising to as much as 14% through automatic tiers based on monthly sales.

major2013-03-01

Only Natural Pet co-founds Pet Sustainability Coalition

Only Natural Pet becomes one of eight founding members of the Pet Sustainability Coalition, formed at Global Pet Expo 2013. Other founding members include KONG Company, Cardinal Pet Care, Petco, West Paw, Planet Dog, Worldwise, and I and Love and You. The coalition works to accelerate social and environmental performance across the pet industry.

critical2014-01-10

Pet360 acquires Only Natural Pet from Revelry Brands

Pet360, Inc. acquires Only Natural Pet Store from Revelry Brands. Pet360 operates a network of pet websites including petMD.com, PetFoodDirect.com, and Pet360.com. Only Natural Pet is described as the leading online retailer in the natural pet supplies market at the time of acquisition.

minor2014-05-22

Pet360's AutoShip program carries Only Natural Pet's line

A May 2014 pet blog describes Pet360's AutoShip program, which ships pet products on a schedule the customer sets, with free shipping and a discount. It notes that Pet360 had recently added nearly the whole Only Natural Pet line. This is the earliest record of Only Natural Pet products being sold through an autoship subscription.

minor2014-07-14

Only Natural Pet celebrates 10th anniversary with 500+ branded products

Only Natural Pet marks its 10th anniversary, announcing it has grown from an online curator to developing over 500 products under the Only Natural Pet brand. The company offers more than 3,900 natural product options total and says new Only Natural Pet dog and cat food will launch that fall.

critical2014-08-29

PetSmart agrees to acquire Pet360 for up to $160M, including Only Natural Pet

PetSmart agrees to acquire Pet360 for $130 million plus up to $30 million in performance-based payments through 2016, as part of its push into e-commerce. Pet360 owned Only Natural Pet, which came under PetSmart's corporate umbrella when the deal closed.

minor2014-10-06

Canine PowerFood and Feline PowerPate food lines launch

Only Natural Pet releases its new Canine PowerFood and Feline PowerPate product lines, formulated with holistic veterinarian Dr. Jean Hofve. PowerFood is a grain-free, allergy-friendly dog kibble with meat as the first ingredient, while PowerPate is canned cat food made in small batches at a US micro-cannery with 100% human-grade ingredients.

critical2014-12-14

BC Partners agrees to acquire PetSmart in $8.7B leveraged buyout

A private equity consortium led by BC Partners agrees to buy PetSmart for $8.7 billion, the largest leveraged buyout of 2014. Citigroup, Nomura, Jefferies, Barclays, and Deutsche Bank committed debt financing. Once completed, the buyout places Only Natural Pet under indirect PE ownership, though the brand continues to operate with significant autonomy.

major2015-03-11

BC Partners consortium completes PetSmart buyout

PetSmart announces that the consortium led by BC Partners, which includes La Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec, StepStone and Longview Asset Management, has completed its acquisition. The deal was announced on December 14, 2014. Shareholders receive $83 a share in cash, and Only Natural Pet, a PetSmart subsidiary through Pet360, comes under private-equity control.

minor2015-07-09

PowerStew canned dog food line expands product range

Only Natural Pet launches the PowerStew line of grain-free canned dog food as a complement to Canine PowerFood. The stew comes in Turkey & Duck Feast, Beef & Lamb Feast, and Chicken & Liver Feast varieties, all made in the USA with real meat as the first ingredient.

major2015-11-03

PetSmart becomes Only Natural Pet's exclusive national retailer

PetSmart announces a dedicated Only Natural Pet shop section and calls itself the brand's exclusive national retailer. A 25-product collection is to reach 133 PetSmart stores that month, with a 120-item assortment on petsmart.com. Prices range from $8 for a four-ounce bag of Jerky Bites to $80 for a seven-pound bag of dehydrated dog food.

major2016-02-01

PetSmart pays $800 million dividend after buyout

A Delaware Court of Chancery opinion in the PetSmart appraisal case states that PetSmart was able to issue an $800 million dividend in February 2016, a 38% return on invested capital, less than a year after the BC Partners buyout. The dividend was paid at the parent level. No effect on Only Natural Pet's operations is documented.

major2016-04-20

PowerFood line achieves 100% carbon neutrality

Only Natural Pet announces its PowerFood dog and cat food line manufactured and distributed in 2016 is 100% carbon neutral, achieved through a partnership with Carbon Credit Capital. The company expects to donate more than $10,000 in 2016 to the ADPML Portel-Para REDD Amazon forest preservation project in Brazil, offsetting more than 800 metric tons of carbon emissions.

major2016-10-25

Truth About Pet Food flags misleading Wholesome Homemade claims

Pet food safety advocate Truth About Pet Food reports that Only Natural Pet's Wholesome Homemade product uses misleading marketing. A phone conversation reveals the 'cooked meat blend' is 'similar to kibble,' while email advertising describes 'chunks of meat.'

minor2016-12-17

Second flagship store opens in Aspen

Only Natural Pet opens a 2,000-square-foot store at 416 East Cooper Avenue in Aspen's pedestrian mall, its second physical retail location. Grand opening events span December 17-18 with extended events on New Year's Eve and into January. The store later closes, though the exact closing date is undocumented.

minor2017-01-26

First pet brand to sponsor X Games Aspen

Only Natural Pet becomes the first-ever pet brand to sponsor the X Games, activating a Dog Demonstration Park at X Games Aspen 2017 at Buttermilk Mountain. The activation features world-class canine avalanche rescue demonstrations and a booth showcasing the Wholesome Homemade dehydrated dog food product.

minor2017-07-31

Pet360 e-commerce operations merge into Chewy.com

Pet360's e-commerce operations are folded into Chewy.com, the online retailer PetSmart acquired in 2017 for a reported $3.35 billion. Pet360's network had included Only Natural Pet, which keeps its own website and brand.

major2018-08-30

Mindful Meals launches with bioplastic sustainable packaging

Only Natural Pet introduces the Mindful Meals dry dog food line with at least 30% bioplastic packaging from Braskem's sugarcane-based I'm green Polyethylene. Every ton of the bioplastic used captures 3.09 tons of CO2 from the atmosphere. The line is sold in select retail stores and online.

minor2018-10-26

Third store opens in Greenwood Village with grooming partnership

Only Natural Pet opens its third Colorado retail location, a store of more than 6,000 square feet in Cherry Hills Marketplace, Greenwood Village. The store includes 'The Groomery,' a grooming service operated in partnership with PetSmart, plus a self-service dog wash; its grand-opening weekend included pet adoptions. The store has since closed.

critical2019-02-28

First North American pet food company earns B Corp certification

Only Natural Pet becomes the first pet food and treat company in North America to earn B Corp certification from B Lab, scoring 86.1 on the B Impact Assessment (B Lab's profile lists its current score as 84.8). The certification legally requires the company to consider the impact of its decisions on workers, customers, suppliers, community, and the environment.

D9D2D3D10
PR Web ↗
minor2019-06-19

SOCAP profile highlights B Corp transparency mission for pets

SOCAP Global publishes a feature on Only Natural Pet founder Marty Grosjean, who argues pets deserve the same product transparency as humans. The article highlights the pet industry's historical opacity around supply chain origination and ingredient sourcing, positioning Only Natural Pet's B Corp certification as an industry-leading accountability step.

minor2019-07-03

Colorado Biz profiles sustainability-linked employee compensation

Colorado Biz Magazine publishes a feature on Only Natural Pet's supply chain sustainability practices, revealing that every employee has a sustainability goal built into their annual review and that wages are tied to the company's sustainability performance. The article details the company's unacceptable ingredients list of 40 items and partnerships with Global Animal Partnership and MSC.

minor2019-07-09

FDA consumer report alleges sharp objects in Just Fish Feast kibble

An entry in FDA's adverse-event database records a customer's report that a 22.5-pound bag of Only Natural Pet Just Fish Feast held sharp white objects lodged in the kibble, and that an exchanged bag did too. The customer says the company apologized for an irregularity but did not answer a follow-up email. FDA notes that a report does not by itself show a product was defective.

minor2020-01-01

Privacy policy discloses interest-based ad tracking by partners

Only Natural Pet's privacy policy, last updated January 1, 2020, says its advertising partners may use cookies to track visitors' activity on its site and other sites to serve interest-based ads, with an opt-out. It says email activity is shared with its email provider to target campaigns, and that abandoned carts trigger SMS reminders.

major2020-04-22

Class actions allege PetSmart sold Only Natural Pet hemp products as unapproved drugs

Astorria Sassano (April 22, 2020) and Robyne Newell (April 28) file proposed class actions against PetSmart in Broward County, Florida, over Only Natural Pet Hemp Seed Oil with Krill and Cod Liver and Hemp Calming Support chews. They allege the health and calming claims made the products unapproved new animal drugs without FDA approval. These were allegations against the retailer, not findings. Both cases are removed to federal court in May 2020.

minor2020-06-05

Both Only Natural Pet hemp-product suits voluntarily dismissed

Both plaintiffs file notices of voluntary dismissal without prejudice on June 5, 2020, and the court dismisses the Newell case and denies pending motions as moot. The Sassano notice says no class had been certified and the dismissal was not part of any compromise or resolution. There was no ruling on the merits and no settlement.

major2022-01-01

B Corp recertification achieved

Only Natural Pet successfully completes B Corp recertification, three years after its initial 2019 certification. The recertification confirms continued compliance with B Lab's standards for social and environmental performance, accountability, and transparency across all areas of the business.

major2022-04-01

Auto Delivery terms reserve discount discretion and require individual arbitration

Only Natural Pet's Auto Delivery Program terms, last updated April 2022, let the company change discounts, promotions and eligibility at its sole discretion. Item prices and shipping charges may change between deliveries, though not after an order's confirmation email. The terms promise a reminder email before each order and allow changes up to 24 hours before placement. Loyalty rebates do not apply to auto-delivery orders, and disputes go to mandatory individual arbitration with a class-action waiver.

major2023-05-01

PetSmart and Only Natural Pet reach ICON-level PSC membership

PetSmart and Only Natural Pet elevate their Pet Sustainability Coalition membership to the ICON tier, the highest level in the organization. PetSmart becomes the first retailer to achieve ICON status. The investment supports PSC's work on systemic issues including sustainable packaging and responsible ingredient sourcing across the pet industry.

minor2023-07-24

Apollo funds agree to take minority stake in PetSmart

PetSmart announces that funds managed by Apollo affiliates have agreed to make a strategic equity investment. BC Partners, with co-investors including GIC and PetSmart management, remains majority shareholder and keeps board control. The value and size of the stake are not disclosed.

minor2023-09-14

FDA consumer report alleges unannounced Raw Blends food change

An entry in FDA's adverse-event database records a customer's report that Only Natural Pet's Power Function dog food was rebranded as Raw Blends Digestive Care without notice of any formula change. The customer reports itching, loose stools and an emergency vet visit after feeding it. The report is unverified, and FDA notes it does not show that the product caused the symptoms.

minor2024-08-23

BBB complaint: bully sticks caused dogs to fall ill

A BBB complaint filed in August 2024 alleges that several dogs became very sick after eating Only Natural Pet bully sticks given on April 6, 2024; the company said it found no product defect and sent a $200 check. An earlier BBB complaint (November 2023) reports a wood chip found in a Senior Mobility Chews product.

major2024-10-16

FTC finalizes Click-to-Cancel rule affecting auto-renewal subscriptions

The FTC announces its final Click-to-Cancel rule requiring subscription sellers to make cancellation as easy as sign-up. The rule set civil penalties of up to $51,744 per violation. The Eighth Circuit vacated the rule on July 8, 2025, before it took effect.

minor2024-10-25

Customer reports flea collar snapped and company refused replacement

A customer review describes an Only Natural Pet natural flea and tick collar that snapped in two; the company sent a free replacement, which snapped the next day. When the customer asked for another replacement, Only Natural Pet refused, saying its 'system' would not allow replacement of an item bought in October 2023, although the sealed collar was dated to expire in June 2025.

minor2025-07-08

Eighth Circuit vacates FTC Click-to-Cancel rule

On July 8, 2025, the Eighth Circuit vacates the FTC's Click-to-Cancel Rule, holding that the agency did not follow the procedural requirements for rulemaking. The rule would have taken effect on July 14. It required express consent and a cancellation method at least as easy as sign-up, the kind of subscription friction customers report with Only Natural Pet's auto-delivery. State automatic-renewal laws remain in force.

minor2026-02-01

New Loyalty Rewards program replaces legacy 5% Back rebate

Only Natural Pet launches a revamped Loyalty Rewards program powered by Rivo, replacing the previous 5% Back rebate program. Members earn 5% cash back on purchases, with a $5 sign-up reward, $5 credits on first purchases, and a $10 anniversary reward each year. Rebate credits earned October to December were issued in January and expire in January 2027.

major2026-02-09

Accumulated auto-delivery complaints document subscription trap patterns

By early 2026, BBB and Trustpilot complaints about Only Natural Pet's auto-delivery program form a pattern: customers report being enrolled without realizing it, charges continuing after cancellation attempts, a confusing distinction between canceling a 'delivery' versus a 'subscription,' missing pre-shipment reminder emails, and orders that cannot be changed once processed (the company asks for 24-48 hours' notice before the ship date). The company says checkout requires a positive opt-in and that it emails a reminder four days before each auto-delivery.

minor2026-04-01

BBB complaint: bulk supplement order arrives weeks from expiry

A customer tells the BBB that four bottles of VetriScience Omega supplements, ordered on March 9, 2026, arrived with an April 2026 expiration date, leaving less than 30 days to use a bulk purchase. The company says it issued a refund on April 2, and the customer marks the complaint resolved on April 9.

minor2026-04-11

BBB auto-delivery complaints end in refunds; company cites four-day reminders

Two BBB complaints describe auto-delivery shipments customers did not want. One customer could not cancel on her phone and was charged $142.04 for two 50-pound bags. Another received a shipment early. The company says it emailed reminders four days before each order and had no earlier cancellation on record. It rerouted and refunded the first order and refunded the second, and both complaints were marked resolved.

Evidence (45 citations)
Scoring Log (8 entries)
regrade2026-10-26RESCORED

19→22. Since Feb 2026: no material corporate, pricing or legal change. BBB complaints in Mar-May 2026 (supplements near expiry, unwanted auto-delivery shipments) were refunded, and the company repeated that it emails a reminder four days before each order. Dimensions: D3 2→3 (event: historical gap-fill, the BC Partners buyout closing Mar 2015 and PetSmart's $800M dividend Feb 2016 at the parent level, though no operating-level effect is documented); D5 1→2 (event: Apr 2022 auto-delivery terms let discounts and item prices change between deliveries at the company's discretion, and the privacy policy discloses interest-based ad tracking); D10 0→1 (event: 2020 class actions over ONP hemp products, dismissed without prejudice, and the mandatory individual arbitration/class-action waiver). D6 stays at 4: the 'no reminder' basis is weakened, but cancellation still takes more steps than signup, done per product, and there is a 35% first-order nudge. Eras: Natural E-Commerce Startup kept; Growth Capital re-dated 2011-09-01→2011-09-15 (Revelry); Pet360/PetSmart Acquisition re-dated 2014-09-01→2014-01-10 (Pet360 purchase) and split at 2015-03-11 (BC Partners closing) into a new 'BC Partners House Brand' era; B Corp era re-dated 2019-03-01→2019-02-28; current era re-dated 2026-02-18→2022-04-01 (current auto-delivery terms) and relabeled 'Stable Sustainability'→'Auto-Delivery Friction'. Added the PetSmart exclusive-national-retailer launch (Nov 2015) and the hemp suits. Category is fine.

restore-check2026-10-26RESTORED

Checked 10 removed/trimmed candidates: 0 restored, 1 partly restored, 8 confirmed removed, 1 already present. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:0: SOCAP Global's 2019-06-19 founder interview says the family adopted Crinkles in 2002; restore that narrower adoption fact, not the unsupported rescue classification (https://socapglobal.com/2019/06/only-natural-pet-b-corp/). CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:1: BBB's profile establishes accreditation since 2005, not continuous A+ ratings or absence of historical complaints/regulatory actions. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:2: Tripawds and BizWest's 2008 opening report do not establish 2100 28th Street, nutritionist staffing or community-hub status at opening. A 2010 BizWest article was readable only as a paywalled excerpt; its linked newspaper PDF repeatedly returned no extracted text. Nutrition-consultant wording appeared in search results, which were not used as evidence; the underlying detail remains unverified, not disproved. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:10: the 2015 Tripawds launch review does not establish legume-free status; the current undated product page markets it as legume-free but cannot establish the 2015 formula. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:14: Truth About Pet Food contains no calcium figures; the 2.7%-4.8% and 2.5% claims were found in a May 2017 DogFoodAdvisor forum reply, an excluded source. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:15: Pet Insight's July 2017 report does not establish an April acquisition close, June merger or office closure; Pet360's own LinkedIn profile states its Philadelphia-area office closed in 2017, but no qualifying independent reporting was found. ALREADY PRESENT timeline:update:16: the regrade added PetSmart's exclusive-national-retailer status at timeline[14], evidence and summaries; PetfoodIndustry's 2015-11-03 article confirms it. The exact Mindful Meals wording was also read in Braskem's marketing release republished by Sustainable Brands and PetfoodIndustry; no additional restoration from marketing copy. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:27: quarterly credits appear in Rise AI's vendor case study about the legacy rebate program, not evidence of quarterly distribution under the February 2026 Rivo replacement. The FAQ distinguishes old rebate credits from new rewards; terms refer to four annual rebate redemption periods, not new-program credit distribution. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:remove:24: original FTC URL returns 404; Greenberg Traurig's 2025-07-11 analysis confirms the July 8 vacatur. The historical announcement and vacatur already have timeline entries, so no duplicate or current-rule evidence added. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:remove:28: PitchBook's revenue field is empty; three exact-figure/origin/date searches found no qualifying source for $4.8M in 2025. Original URLs were fetched first, with Wayback attempts before searches; archive failures and empty PDF output were treated as access limitations, never proof of falsity. Used 27 search queries across 7 WebSearch calls, at most three queries per candidate, and 39 fetch-page.py invocations. No removals or score changes.

fact-audit2026-10-25MAJOR FIXES

Checked 71 items + 3 alternatives + prose (team mode; 9 items missed by verifier packets checked by lead). 19 verified, 37 corrected (13 date-only), 14 re-sourced, 4 removed (2 duplicates, 1 dead/vacated-rule item, 1 unsupported $4.8M revenue). Fixed: 2019 B Impact score 86.1 not 84.8; ColoradoBiz profile 2019 not 2023; TAPF article 2016 and calcium figures not in it; Pet360 price up to $160M; BC Partners LBO agreed not completed in 2014; Click-to-Cancel vacated; ~51 employees/$4.8M revenue unsupported; company says it sends auto-delivery reminders; auto-delivery launch timing undocumented; typed-in score removed from alternatives.

Alternatives Review2026-09-26MINOR FIXES

Removed typed-in site scores from alternatives text (they go stale on re-score; the page shows live scores). No other changes.

deep-enrichment-reset2026-03-22

Stripped for Phase 2 re-enrichment

Deep Enrichment2026-03-22
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-18