Organic Maps

Organic Maps is a free, open-source, privacy-focused offline maps and navigation app for Android and iOS, built on OpenStreetMap data. Started in December 2020 as a fork of MAPS.ME, it offers turn-by-turn navigation, hiking trails, cycling routes, and offline search with no ads, no tracking, and no data collection. The project reported around 6 million lifetime downloads across all platforms by the end of 2025.

12/ 100
Healthy
1No Decay→Stable

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-29.

Score History

MilestoneCriticalMajor
Ad-Free Fork Launch (2020–2023) · 4/100Ad-Free Fork LaunchKAYAK Referral Detour (2023–2024) · 9/100KAYAK ReferralDetourMetaserver Revolt (2024–2025) · 12/100Metaserv…Sole-Owner Consolidation (2025–present) · 12/100Sole-OwnerConsolidation1007550250202220242026-10Ad-Free Fork Launch (2020–2023) · 4/100KAYAK Referral Detour (2023–2024) · 9/100Metaserver Revolt (2024–2025) · 12/100Sole-Owner Consolidation (2025–present) · 12/100491212MilestonesFounded (2020)Organic Maps OÜ Registered (2021)iOS App Store Launch (2021)CoMaps Fork Announced (2025)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Ad-Free Fork Launch
4/100
2020-12-21 – 2023-11-08

Original MapsWithMe developers forked the last open-source MAPS.ME code after its new owner's December 2020 rewrite, launching on Google Play in January 2021 and iOS in June 2021 with no ads or trackers. Releases added CarPlay, Wikipedia articles, GPX import and an outdoor style, and the app passed one million users in 2023. Behind the community image, Organic Maps OÜ was registered as a for-profit company in May 2021 and a private metaserver ran outside the public repository.

KAYAK Referral Detour
9/100+5
2023-11-08 – 2024-12-06

A ready-made pull request added KAYAK hotel referral links, shipped in the November 2023 release, and in January 2024 F-Droid flagged the app for ads; the project suspended its F-Droid updates rather than remove the links. Product work continued with Android Auto, one-click backup and Track Recorder. A June 2024 GitHub discussion opened the governance debate.

Metaserver Revolt
12/100+3
2024-12-06 – 2025-08-21

Roman Tsisyk's December 2024 disclosure of the private metaserver, after its MIT license was removed and logging enabled, split the founders and set off an open letter with 199 verified signatures demanding nonprofit governance. The owners did not accept the demands, contributors launched the CoMaps fork in May 2025, and the KAYAK link was removed on May 20, 2025. In August the project put its compiled map files under a separate attribution license.

Sole-Owner Consolidation
12/100
2025-08-21 – present

Tsisyk's removal from the management board on August 21, 2025 and a single registered shareholder from August 28 left Havaka and Borsuk in control. The project then restricted fork reuse of its map files, locked a question about its map-generation code, and revised its data license only after the OpenStreetMap Foundation flagged attribution. Meanwhile releases kept improving the app, adding GeoJSON export, public-transport routing and a CarPlay dashboard by 2026.

Alternatives

Maps app with real-time traffic, transit directions, and Street View. Organic Maps offers some public transport information but lacks full transit navigation. Google Maps supports offline driving within downloaded areas; offline walking, cycling, and transit directions are unavailable. Google collects location information under its privacy policy and displays ads in Maps.

Community fork of Organic Maps created in 2025 after governance disputes, using OpenStreetMap data with similar core offline navigation and a commitment to nonprofit, community governance. It builds its own map files and dropped Organic Maps' KAYAK links and Google Firebase dependency. Available on F-Droid, Google Play and the App Store; bookmark lists exported from Organic Maps can be opened in CoMaps via the system share function.

Feature-rich open-source offline maps app with more advanced options than Organic Maps, including public transit, topographic overlays, and extensive customization. Free version has a map download limit; paid version removes it. Steeper learning curve but more powerful for power users.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Organic Maps is near its quality peak and still improving. Since late 2025 it has added public-transport routing and alternate routes (June 2026), a CarPlay dashboard (August 2026), faster cross-border routing, two million U.S. addresses and a setting to turn off search history. Minor annoyances remain: no real-time traffic, iOS 12 to 14 dropped in April 2026, and occasional bugs. The governance split did not slow releases.
How It Got Here
Organic Maps began in December 2020, with its first Android release in January 2021, as a clean fork of MAPS.ME's open-source codebase, stripping ads and proprietary backends while keeping core offline navigation. CarPlay support followed the June 2021 iOS launch, Wikipedia articles for places arrived in March 2022, and 2023 brought GPX import, an outdoor map style and one million users. Android Auto reached Google Play in January 2024, followed by Track Recorder that September. The KAYAK hotel button added from November 2023 to May 2025 and a brief, unexplained Google Play removal in August 2024 were minor irritations. Through 2025, 13 releases added global hiking and cycling routes and EU iOS default-navigation support, and the project estimated about 6 million lifetime downloads by year end. Development did not slow after the CoMaps fork: 2026 releases added faster cross-border routing, two million U.S. addresses, public-transport routing and alternate routes, a search-history off switch and a CarPlay dashboard. The April 2026 release dropped iOS 12 to 14. Remaining limitations are feature gaps such as real-time traffic, not value erosion.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2020Ad-Free Fork Launch2023KAYAK Referral Detour2024Metaserver Revolt2025Sole-Owner ConsolidationUser Value0111Biz Exploit0000Shareholder0111Lock-in1111Algorithms1222Dark Patterns0110Advertising0110Competition0012Labor/Gov2244Regulatory0001
Timeline (45 events)
critical2020-12-20

MAPS.ME December Update Triggers Community Backlash

After MAPS.ME was sold in November 2020, its December 20 iOS update replaced the old app with a rewrite using the MapBox SDK. Organic Maps later recalled user disappointment with the change and described it as the catalyst for its own creation. LWN later reported that the rewrite returned MAPS.ME to a proprietary license by the end of 2020 and met widespread user disapproval.

critical2020-12-21

Borsuk and Havaka Fork MAPS.ME as Organic Maps

Original MapsWithMe co-founders Alexander Borsuk and Viktar Havaka (also known as Viktor Govako) registered the organicmaps.app domain and Organic Maps GitHub organization on December 21, 2020, and began work on the last open-source version of MAPS.ME under a new name. A community hackathon bootstrapped the new project in roughly 20 hours on December 27–28.

major2021-01-03

First Android Release on Google Play

The first Android release under the 'app.omaps' application identifier was approved by Google Play on January 3, 2021. The initial release focused on removing ads, eliminating copyrighted graphics, and removing functionality dependent on proprietary backends from the MAPS.ME codebase.

major2021-05-06

Exodus Privacy Report Finds No Trackers

Organic Maps reported on May 6, 2021 that the latest Exodus Privacy Report found no trackers in the app.

major2021-05-07

Organic Maps OÜ Registered in Estonia

Organic Maps OÜ was entered into the Estonian Business Register on May 7, 2021 as a private limited company registered in Tallinn, Estonia.

major2021-06-17

Organic Maps Launches on iOS App Store

Organic Maps became publicly available on the Apple App Store on June 17, 2021, expanding the app from Android-only to a cross-platform offering. The iOS version offered privacy-focused, ad-free offline navigation.

minor2022-02-22

February Update Arrives on Huawei AppGallery and F-Droid

The February 2022 update of Organic Maps became available on Huawei AppGallery and F-Droid, with the same changelog as the Google Play version.

minor2022-03-11

Organic Maps Announces Google Summer of Code 2022 Participation

Organic Maps announced its participation in Google Summer of Code 2022 and invited student contributors to propose or choose project ideas. Android Auto was among the 2022 ideas; Wikipedia parser improvements were included in the 2023 program. The GSoC 2023 project plan confirms that initial Android Auto research was carried out during the 2022 program.

minor2022-03-25

Wikipedia Articles Added for Map Points of Interest

The March 2022 update introduced offline Wikipedia articles for well-known places, improved search suggestions, and brighter roads in night mode. This feature allowed users to read Wikipedia summaries for landmarks and locations directly within the map without an internet connection.

minor2023-02-01

FUTO Awards $1,000 Micro-Grant to Organic Maps

FUTO, a technology organization focused on fighting 'tech tyranny,' awarded a $1,000 micro-grant to Organic Maps in February 2023. While modest, this was one of the first institutional grants the project received, supplementing donation-based funding that fell significantly short of covering development costs.

minor2023-05-12

Organic Maps Receives 4 GSoC 2023 Slots Including Android Auto

Organic Maps received four slots in Google Summer of Code 2023 for Android Auto, better mobile and desktop user interfaces, Wikipedia parser improvements, and a better map styling system. The announcement expressed hope that the students would finish their tasks.

minor2023-06-07

GPX Import Support Added

Organic Maps added native GPX track import support, eliminating the need for users to convert GPX files to KML format. This improved data portability with other mapping applications like OsmAnd and GPS devices, alongside new OpenStreetMap data and routing improvements.

major2023-11-08

KAYAK Affiliate Links Pull Request Sparks Community Backlash

A pull request appeared on the Organic Maps GitHub repository to add 'Details on KAYAK' affiliate links to hotel listings, developed by co-founder Roman Tsisyk. Users who selected hotels would see a button linking to KAYAK, with Organic Maps receiving a referral bonus for bookings. Community members debated the commercial integration, with some calling it a violation of the 'no ads' promise. The PR stated that Organic Maps would not collect or share user or device information with KAYAK. LWN later reported that some contributors felt the links compromised the app’s privacy promises; this was a reported concern, rather than evidence of Organic Maps sharing personal data.

minor2023-11-22

Outdoor Map Style Preview Released

The November 2023 release introduced a preview of the outdoor map style, tailored for hiking, backcountry cycling, and other outdoor activities. The style emphasized paths, cliffs, rivers, peaks, mountain passes, campsites, and other features relevant to off-road navigation.

major2023-12-23

Organic Maps Reaches One Million Users

Organic Maps announced reaching its first million users in December 2023. The milestone came alongside the year's major feature additions: GPX import, a ruler tool, the outdoors map style, background voice directions, and Android Auto, which was still in Google’s review. The 2023 release cycle also introduced search for skiing and ski runs.

minor2024-01-10

Android Auto Support Officially Released on Google Play

Android Auto support for Organic Maps, developed during Google Summer of Code 2023, was finally made available on Google Play in January 2024. The feature allowed drivers to use Organic Maps navigation directly on their car's Android Auto display for safer driving.

major2024-01-25

F-Droid Flags Organic Maps with 'Ads' Anti-Feature

F-Droid flagged Organic Maps with the 'Ads' anti-feature label due to the KAYAK affiliate links, creating a paradox: the app's upstream description said 'No Ads' while F-Droid listed 'Ads' as an anti-feature. Organic Maps responded by requesting suspension of its F-Droid updates, disputing that affiliate links constitute advertising.

minor2024-03-11

One-Click KMZ Backup of All Bookmarks and Tracks

Organic Maps added a one-click option to back up or share all bookmarks and imported tracks as a single KMZ file, and to import everything back from the same file. The feature made moving a user's saved places to another device or app simpler.

minor2024-06-24

Community Opens Governance Discussion on GitHub

Contributor pastk opened GitHub Discussion #8559 titled 'Project's direction, values and governance,' raising concerns about Organic Maps' privacy positioning, the KAYAK decision-making process, and the lack of formal community governance structures. The discussion became a focal point for growing contributor discontent.

minor2024-07-15

NGI0 Entrust Fund Features Released

The July 2024 release introduced two major features funded through the EU's NGI0 Entrust Fund via NLnet Foundation: improved USA address search using TIGER data from the Nominatim project, and fixed text rendering for non-Latin scripts. This represented a significant institutional grant supporting Organic Maps development.

minor2024-08-17

Google Play Briefly Removes Organic Maps; OSM Login Disabled

Organic Maps said Google Play removed the app on August 17, 2024 without warning, citing Family Program requirements, and that the app was later restored without explanation. While investigating, the project temporarily disabled OpenStreetMap login in the app.

minor2024-09-19

Track Recorder Feature Released

Organic Maps released Track Recorder, allowing users to record and save routes while hiking, biking, running, or navigating.

critical2024-11-23

Borsuk Removes MIT License from Secret Metaserver

Co-founder Roman Tsisyk reported that Alexander Borsuk removed the MIT license from the private metaserver CDN repository on November 23, 2024, with the comment “No MIT yet, sorry.” A November 24 commit enabled Cloudflare logging. The Cloudflare Worker had existed since 2021 to direct users to geographically suitable map download mirrors. Tsisyk described the license change as effectively privatizing the previously MIT-licensed code.

critical2024-12-06

Tsisyk Reveals Secret Server Component, Gets GitHub Access Revoked

On December 6, co-founder Roman Tsisyk publicly disclosed the metaserver code, previously available only to a few team members, and republished the pre-November 23 code under MIT after Alexander Borsuk removed its MIT license and enabled logging. Borsuk revoked Tsisyk’s GitHub permissions that day, which Tsisyk called an attempt to cover up the disclosure. On December 14, Viktor Havaka said Roman’s organization ownership had been restored. LWN later characterized Borsuk’s revocation of Tsisyk’s privileged access as retaliation for the disclosure.

critical2025-03-21

Open Letter Sent to Organic Maps Shareholders

A group of community contributors sent an open letter to the shareholders of Organic Maps OÜ demanding nonprofit conversion, financial transparency, and democratic governance. The letter documented concerns about closed-door decision-making, the secret KAYAK deal, allegations that Borsuk used donation funds for a personal holiday trip, and denial of financial information to contributors. It requested publication of all past income and expenses since the project’s inception in December 2020.

major2025-03-27

GitHub Blocks Organic Maps, Forced Migration to Forgejo

According to the community open letter, Roman Tsisyk revoked GitHub owner permissions from Alexander Borsuk and Viktor Havaka and granted them to contributor pastk, triggering GitHub’s automatic sanctions check. The organization was archived and administrative access blocked pending an appeal. With the review’s timing unknown, the project migrated two weeks later to self-hosted Forgejo at git.omaps.dev.

critical2025-04-16

Open Letter Published with 199 Signatures

The open letter to Organic Maps shareholders was made public on April 16, 2025, after being sent internally on March 21. CoMaps’ copy records 199 verified signatures as of May 10. The letter demanded a nonprofit structure, inclusive decision-making, and full financial transparency.

critical2025-05-12

CoMaps Fork Officially Announced

After shareholders ignored community demands, contributors announced a community-led fork of Organic Maps, provisionally named CoMaps. The project committed to transparency, community decision-making, not-for-profit operation, and fully open-source development. Development moved to Codeberg with finances on Open Collective.

major2025-05-20

Organic Maps Removes KAYAK Hotel Referral Link

The May 20, 2025 release notes stated that the referral link to view details or book some hotels on KAYAK had been removed, and invited users to say if they wanted it back. The removal ended the in-app affiliate feature added in November 2023 that had led F-Droid to flag the app for ads.

major2025-07-03

CoMaps Launches on App Store and Play Store

CoMaps announced availability on the Apple App Store, Google Play Store, and F-Droid on July 3, 2025. As a fork of Organic Maps, it gave users an alternative with the same core offline mapping and navigation functions.

major2025-08-01

Organic Maps Binary Data License Introduced

Organic Maps introduced a separate license for compiled binary map files on August 1, 2025. It required visible credit to the Organic Maps Project and a clickable link in user-visible areas such as About and Main Menu, prohibited redistribution without attribution, and required written permission for white-labeling or rebranding. The README separately asked projects using Organic Maps source code or its user interface to display visible attribution; that paragraph predated this commit. These requirements could create friction for forks using the processed map binaries.

minor2025-08-09

Global Hiking and Cycling Routes Added

The August 2025 release introduced global hiking and cycling routes from OpenStreetMap, allowing users to discover and follow popular trails worldwide with special map layers. The release also added bookmark names on the map, track selection, and elevation graph improvements.

critical2025-08-21

Tsisyk Removed from OÜ Management Board

Roman Tsisyk, who publicly disclosed the metaserver issue and supported the community’s governance demands, was removed from the Organic Maps OÜ management board on August 21, 2025. Alexander Borsuk joined the board alongside Viktar Havaka on September 18, 2025.

major2025-08-28

Register Lists a Single Shareholder of Organic Maps OÜ

The Estonian e-Business Register lists a single shareholder holding 100% of Organic Maps OÜ's EUR 10,000 share capital from August 28, 2025; the personal code matches the management board member registered since May 2021 (Viktar Havaka). In April 2025 Havaka had said he had sent Roman Tsisyk an offer to buy out his share; no price or terms have been published.

major2025-09-27

Map-Generator Question Locked as Spam, Ban Warning Issued

Asked publicly whether the code that builds Organic Maps' distributed .mwm map files is free software, co-founder Alexander Borsuk replied that the project reserves the right not to publish experimental or draft changes to its internal tools, suggested forks' code could create legal problems for users, and warned that accounts advertising on project resources would be permanently banned. The issue was redacted, closed and locked as spam.

major2025-10-06

OpenStreetMap Licensing Group Flags Map-Data Attribution

The OpenStreetMap Foundation's Licensing Working Group publicly told Organic Maps that its new data license could not replace the ODbL terms on OpenStreetMap data and that ODbL attribution requirements were not being met, noting an emailed notice from September 9, 2025 had gone unanswered. Organic Maps revised its data license after OSMF review, adding '© OpenStreetMap' and a link to the OSM copyright page, merged on October 16, 2025.

major2025-10-23

EU iOS Default Navigation App Option Added

The October 2025 release enabled EU users to set Organic Maps as the default navigation app in iOS Settings, made possible by Apple's compliance with the EU Digital Markets Act. This was a competitive milestone, placing Organic Maps alongside Apple Maps and Google Maps as a system-level default option.

minor2025-12-26

Request to Drop F-Droid Non-Free Assets Label Closed

Organic Maps asked F-Droid to remove the anti-feature label for compiled binary data files, including .mwm map files, under a non-FOSS license, arguing the data license only requires attribution and had been approved by the OSM Foundation. The merge request was closed without being merged, and F-Droid's listing still carried the label in October 2026.

major2025-12-31

Organic Maps Reaches 6 Million Installs with 13 Releases in 2025

Organic Maps ended 2025 with approximately 6 million total downloads across all platforms: nearly 2M on the App Store, nearly 3M on Google Play, and an estimated 1M from other sources. The year saw 1,500 commits from 100 contributors, and App Store ratings more than doubled from 4,100 to 11,100.

minor2026-01-26

GeoJSON Export Added and Cross-Border Routing Sped Up

The January 26, 2026 update added GeoJSON export for bookmarks and tracks and made routes between countries faster, ending out-of-memory crashes in some cases. GeoJSON joined KML, KMZ and GPX as supported open formats.

minor2026-04-07

April Update Adds U.S. Addresses, Drops iOS 12 to 14

The April 7, 2026 release added two million U.S. addresses parsed from TIGER Census data and selectable hiking and cycling routes with elevation charts. Citing TestFlight and App Store changes, it supports only iOS 15 and later; older devices keep working installs but get no new maps, features or fixes.

minor2026-06-11

Organic Maps OÜ Files 2025 Annual Report

The Estonian e-Business Register records the submission of Organic Maps OÜ's annual report for January 1 to December 31, 2025 on June 11, 2026. The 2024 report had been submitted on June 30, 2025, after the community's open letter asked for financial transparency.

major2026-06-29

Public-Transport Routing and Alternate Routes Arrive

The June 29, 2026 release added public transport routing by subway, light rail, bus and tram, and alternate routes that show the shortest route alongside the fastest. It also kept elevation and timestamps when importing and exporting GeoJSON tracks.

minor2026-07-23

Setting Added to Turn Off Search History

The July 23, 2026 update added a 'Save search history' setting that lets users turn search history off and hide it. Notes reported to OpenStreetMap were also placed on the exact spot the user selected.

minor2026-08-31

CarPlay Dashboard and Bulk Bookmark Editing Added

The August 31, 2026 update added a CarPlay dashboard and a multi-selection mode to delete, move or recolor many bookmarks and tracks at once. Exported bookmarks now keep their original names and descriptions.

Evidence (52 citations)

D10: Regulatory & Legal Posture

OSMF Licensing Working Group Says ODbL Attribution Was Not Being MetGitHub (organicmaps/organicmaps issue #11484) · 2025-10-06
Data License Revised After OSMF ReviewGitHub (organicmaps/organicmaps pull request #11536) · 2025-10-16
Scoring Log (6 entries)
regrade2026-10-29RESCORED

12→12. Since Feb 2026: steady product gains (public-transport routing, alternate routes, CarPlay dashboard, GeoJSON export), 2025 annual report filed June 2026, no legal/regulatory or pricing events; late-2025 events missing from record added (map-generator issue lock and fork ban warning, OSMF LWG ODbL attribution notice and Oct 16 fix, F-Droid non-FOSS assets label kept). D3 2→1 (recalibration: no documented extraction; private founder-funded company fits 0-1, KAYAK income ended May 2025). D6 1→0 (event: KAYAK referral link removed 2025-05-20). D7 1→0 (event: same removal). D8 1→2 (event: Sept 2025 map-tool non-publication/ban warning, F-Droid non-FOSS assets label on top of Aug 2025 binary license). D9 3→4 (recalibration: sole shareholder since 2025-08-28, two-person board, rejected community demands and contributor exodus fit 4-5 'tension/concentrated decision-making'). D10 0→1 (event: OSMF LWG found ODbL attribution unmet, Sept notice unanswered, fixed Oct 16 2025). Eras: merged 'Community Fork Launch' (2021-01-01) + 'Open-Source Growth' (2022-01-01, no inflection) → 'Ad-Free Fork Launch' re-dated to 2020-12-21 (fork start); 'KAYAK Monetization Shift' re-dated 2024-01-01→2023-11-08 (KAYAK PR) and relabeled 'KAYAK Referral Detour'; 'Governance Crisis' re-dated 2025-01-01→2024-12-06 (metaserver disclosure) and relabeled 'Metaserver Revolt'; 'Post-Fork Consolidation' re-dated 2026-02-19→2025-08-21 (Tsisyk board removal) and relabeled 'Sole-Owner Consolidation'. Trajectory worsening→stable (last 12 months: product improving, governance unchanged). Unresolved: e-Business Register page shows a deletion-notice banner (Ametlikud Teadaanded) whose content could not be read; company status otherwise active with 2025 report filed; no dissolution claim made. Category (Search & Navigation) fine.

restore-check2026-10-29RESTORED

Checked all 9 removed/trimmed candidates: 1 restored, 2 partly restored, 5 confirmed removed, 1 already present. timeline:update:0 PARTLY RESTORED — LWN confirms the proprietary rewrite and widespread disapproval; December update map-detail losses are already preserved in evidence. Three searches did not substantiate the betrayal rhetoric. timeline:update:1 CONFIRMED REMOVED — the original December 20 start-of-work date is not restored: the primary anniversary account explicitly dates registrations and beginning work to December 21; the founders and December 27–28 approximately 20-hour hackathon remain intact. timeline:update:3 CONFIRMED REMOVED — three exact/origin/date-drift searches and the readable May 6 announcement did not establish version 2021.05.05 or an independent audit proving no ads or data collection. The live Exodus report served unrelated text; Wayback failed, neither treated as contrary evidence. timeline:update:8 PARTLY RESTORED — GSoC 2023 project plan and the named student's 2022 work-product report establish actual Android Auto research in 2022. Three searches and 2022–2025 program records did not establish first participation in any structured mentoring program; preserve March 11 and Wikipedia work in 2023. timeline:update:21 RESTORED — LWN explicitly characterizes revocation as retaliation; retain attribution and primary GitHub corrected dates. timeline:update:28 ALREADY PRESENT — binary-data credit/link requirements and the distinct pre-existing source/UI attribution request all remain in the current record; the commit timestamp is August 1, not August 9. timeline:update:29 CONFIRMED REMOVED — the two-current-registered-shareholders conclusion is contradicted by the official register's 100% sole ownership from August 28, 2025. Board changes and governance concentration remain in current timeline/prose. evidence:remove:30 CONFIRMED REMOVED — readable Wikipedia does not say no legal issues; three exact/origin/date-drift searches did not substantiate legal clearance, and the current record documents an OSMF licensing compliance issue. evidence:update:4 CONFIRMED REMOVED — three exact/API-fee/program/date-drift searches, the repository, and the readable API/deep-links test page do not explicitly substantiate no API fees or no developer program. No inference from silence. Original URLs read first; Wayback attempts failed for Wikipedia, repository and historical announcements and were not treated as evidence of absence. No removals or score changes.

fact-audit2026-10-26MAJOR FIXES

Checked 71 original timeline/evidence/milestone items, 3 alternatives, and 8 sourced evidence splits preserving existing claims; all prose and identity fields reviewed. All 51 FIX and 3 REVIEW leads decided. Several proposed verifier trims rejected as over-trimming. 24 verified, 37 corrected (19 date-only), 20 re-sourced, 1 removed. Removed unsupported legal-clearance evidence and trimmed unsupported API-fee/program, version-specific Exodus/no-collection audit, first-mentoring, and betrayal rhetoric claims after source/origin/date-drift checks. No strict invented specific established; chronology, attribution and legal-ownership errors are corrections, not fabrication findings. Duplicate sweep found no duplicate event. No scores changed.

Deep Enrichment2026-03-15
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-19