Proton Pass

Proton Pass is an open-source, end-to-end encrypted password manager from Swiss privacy company Proton AG. It encrypts all fields including usernames and URLs, not just passwords. Available as browser extensions, desktop apps, and mobile apps with a generous free tier offering unlimited passwords and devices. Paid plans add unlimited integrated 2FA logins, unlimited email aliases via SimpleLogin integration, and dark web monitoring. Secure vault sharing is available on free and paid plans with different limits.

14/ 100
Healthy
1No Decay→Stable

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-26.

Score History

Milestone← Crowdfunding Campaign Launched (2014) · $2M Seed (CRV & FONGIT) (2015) · Acquired SimpleLogin (2022)CriticalMajor
Launch and Buildout (2023–2024) · 13/100Launch and BuildoutFoundation Era (2024–2025) · 12/100Foundation EraTrust Under Scrutiny (2025–present) · 14/100Trust Under Scrutiny100755025020242026-10Launch and Buildout (2023–2024) · 13/100Foundation Era (2024–2025) · 12/100Trust Under Scrutiny (2025–present) · 14/100131214MilestonesProton Pass Launched (2023)Acquired Standard Notes (2024)Proton Foundation Established (2024)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Launch and Buildout
13/100
2023-04-20 – 2024-06-17

Proton Pass entered beta in April 2023 and launched publicly in June with a free tier of unlimited passwords on unlimited devices. Within weeks it was open-sourced under GPLv3 with a published Cure53 audit. By early 2024 Proton had halved the annual Pass Plus price to $1.99 a month, launched Pass for Business, shipped a Windows app and given passkeys to free users. Proton AG was then owned by its founders and employees, with no venture investors left; the main blemish was a 2023 memory bug that returned after the audit.

Foundation Era
12/100-1
2024-06-17 – 2025-01-28

The founders' share donation made the non-profit Proton Foundation Proton AG's primary shareholder, with outside trustees on its board. Pass completed its desktop lineup and added Secure Links, Identities and a six-user Family plan. In November 2024 Proton folded SimpleLogin Premium into Pass Plus and raised the new-subscriber price to $2.99 a month, while existing subscribers kept their rate. Governance was at its strongest, and no controversy touched the product.

Trust Under Scrutiny
14/100+2
2025-01-28 – present

Reporting on CEO Andy Yen's pro-Republican post and an official Proton comment backing it opened a period in which Proton's conduct drew more scrutiny than its product. Phrack journalists' accounts were suspended in August 2025 after an unnamed CERT alert. A June 2026 researcher report showed that Pass vault sharing never ran the Key Transparency checks its security model claimed. Meanwhile the product kept maturing: file attachments, Emergency Access, a CLI, a 2026 Recurity Labs audit, the July 2026 autofill overhaul and folders. Proton also responded to a proposed Swiss surveillance expansion by moving infrastructure abroad.

Alternatives

Fully open-source, offline-first password manager with zero subscription fees or cloud dependency. Hard switch — multi-device synchronization must be arranged separately and has a steeper learning curve. Best for users who want complete control over their vault with no reliance on any company's servers.

Bitwarden19/100

Open-source password manager with a generous free tier offering unlimited passwords on unlimited devices. Easy switch — supports importing Proton Pass JSON exports. Premium costs $19.80/year, with published security audits.

1Password27/100

Polished commercial password manager with family and team sharing features. Moderate switch — Proton Pass CSV exports can be imported through 1Password's CSV import tool. The regular Individual price is $3.99/month billed annually, with a first-year promotional price of $2.99/month. 1Password raised $920M in venture funding by 2022; executives have said they are preparing for a possible IPO without committing to a date.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Proton Pass is at or near its quality peak. Since its 2023 launch it has added desktop apps, free passkeys, sharing, file attachments, Emergency Access, a paid command-line interface (November 2025) and, in October 2026, folders, URL-matching rules and local compromised-password checks. A July 2026 update resolved 80% of user-reported autofill issues, which had been the main community complaint. The free tier still offers unlimited passwords and devices, and the record shows no free feature moved behind the paywall; residual friction comes from paid-only new features, earlier user bug reports and Proton-wide outages such as the August 2026 Frankfurt cooling failure.
How It Got Here
Proton Pass entered beta in April 2023 and launched publicly that June as a deliberately minimal product: browser extensions and mobile apps, without desktop clients, passkeys or sharing. Improvement was rapid. Open-source code and a Cure53 audit followed in July 2023, vault sharing in October 2023, a Windows app with offline mode in February 2024, passkeys for all users including free ones in March 2024, and macOS and Linux apps by June 2024. Pass Monitor, Identities, file attachments (April 2025) and Emergency Access (August 2025) came next, and in November 2025 Proton added a command-line interface for paid plans. Autofill reliability was the most persistent complaint, alongside user reports of browser compatibility problems and occasional data loss. In July 2026 Proton said an update resolved 80% of the autofill issues users had reported, including forms inside iframes on sites such as banks. October 2026 brought folders, configurable URL matching and local compromised-password detection, though only paid plans can create folders. The free tier has kept unlimited passwords and devices throughout, and the record shows no free feature moved behind the paywall. Reliability dips came from Proton-wide incidents such as the August 2026 Frankfurt datacenter cooling failure. The arc is one of steady additions rather than erosion.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2023Launch and Buildout2024Foundation Era2025Trust Under ScrutinyUser Value111Biz Exploit111Shareholder111Lock-in222Algorithms112Dark Patterns111Advertising222Competition111Labor/Gov212Regulatory111
Timeline (53 events)
major2014-06-17

ProtonMail Indiegogo crowdfunding campaign launches

ProtonMail launched its Indiegogo crowdfunding campaign seeking $100,000 to fund development of an end-to-end encrypted email service.

major2014-06-30

PayPal freezes ProtonMail crowdfunding funds

PayPal froze ProtonMail's crowdfunding account without prior notice on June 30. Proton's own announcement referred to $275,000 raised. A PayPal representative questioned whether ProtonMail was legal and whether it had government approval to encrypt emails. Proton reported that restrictions were lifted and funds extracted on July 1, illustrating payment processor risks for privacy-focused companies.

major2015-03-18

ProtonMail raises $2M seed from CRV and FONGIT

ProtonMail secured a $2M financing round from Charles River Ventures (CRV) and Fondation Genevoise pour l'Innovation Technologique (FONGIT), intended to grow the team and accelerate development. The company had previously raised over $550,000 from over 10,000 crowdfunding supporters.

major2015-08-13

ProtonMail open-sources web client code

ProtonMail released its web client source code publicly with version 2.0, making the entire frontend open source. This was an early commitment to transparency that would extend across all Proton products over the following years, enabling independent security verification.

major2015-11-03

ProtonMail suffers major DDoS attack, pays $6,000 Bitcoin ransom

ProtonMail was hit by sophisticated DDoS attacks that repeatedly disrupted the service over several days. Under pressure from collateral damage to other companies sharing its ISP, ProtonMail paid 15 BTC (~$5,850) to the Armada Collective. The attacks continued from a second, more sophisticated group. ProtonMail subsequently declared it would never pay another ransom.

major2016-03-17

ProtonMail exits beta, opens public registration

ProtonMail opened public registration after nearly two years of invitation-only beta access. Its iOS and Android apps became available worldwide, making the encrypted email service more widely accessible. The redesigned 3.x web client was already in use before this public launch.

major2017-06-20

Proton VPN launches with free tier and Secure Core

Proton launched ProtonVPN with both free and paid tiers, featuring a Secure Core architecture that routes traffic through multiple encrypted tunnels across different countries. The service expanded Proton's privacy ecosystem beyond email for the first time.

major2019-03-08

Proton receives ~€2M EU Horizon 2020 grant for ProtonSuite

The European Commission awarded Proton approximately €2M through the Horizon 2020 research program to develop the Proton ecosystem. CORDIS lists the ProtonSuite contribution as €1,911,875. Proton said the funding was mostly earmarked for Proton Drive technologies and gave the EU no shares or voting control.

major2021-03-26

CRV sells venture capital stake in Proton to non-profit FONGIT

Charles River Ventures (CRV) transferred its minority stake to FONGIT, a Swiss non-profit foundation. CRV sold all its Proton shares; Proton said the transactions aligned its shareholders with putting users ahead of profits. The company said its employees continued to hold the vast majority of shares. Proton later confirmed that it had no venture capital investors remaining.

critical2021-09-06

ProtonMail discloses French climate activist's IP address to police

ProtonMail complied with a legally binding Swiss order concerning a French climate activist's account; TechCrunch reported that French police routed their request through Europol and Swiss authorities to obtain the IP address. The activist was arrested. Proton said it had not known the targeted users were climate activists and announced website and privacy policy clarifications about its legal obligations. Its encryption prevented disclosure of message contents.

critical2021-10-22

Proton wins Swiss court ruling: email is not telecommunications

Switzerland's Federal Administrative Court ruled that email providers are not telecommunications providers under Swiss law, exempting them from telecom-specific data retention requirements. Proton had challenged the Swiss government's attempt to reclassify email services under stricter surveillance rules.

major2021-10-25

Proton co-founds Coalition for Competitive Digital Markets

Proton helped found the Coalition for Competitive Digital Markets (CDM) in October 2021 to advocate stronger interoperability rules in the EU's Digital Markets Act. The coalition, which included Open-Xchange and Element, called for rules addressing pre-installed defaults, bundling, and gatekeeper self-preferencing.

major2022-04-08

Proton acquires SimpleLogin email alias service

Proton acquired SimpleLogin, a French open-source email aliasing service with over 100,000 users and two million aliases created. SimpleLogin continued operating as an independent service while its technology was later deeply integrated into Proton Pass as the email alias feature.

major2022-05-25

ProtonMail rebrands to Proton with unified ecosystem

ProtonMail rebranded to simply 'Proton,' unifying Proton Mail, Proton VPN, Proton Calendar, and Proton Drive under a single brand, account, and subscription. The rebrand included new logos, a visual redesign, and the proton.me domain, signaling the shift from a single email product to a full privacy ecosystem.

minor2022-09-22

Proton Drive exits beta with end-to-end encrypted cloud storage

Proton Drive launched publicly as an end-to-end encrypted cloud storage service on September 22, 2022. Its encryption was designed so that only users and those they authorized could access their files.

major2023-04-20

Proton Pass beta rolls out to Lifetime and Visionary users

Proton announced the Proton Pass beta for Lifetime and Visionary subscribers, with invitations rolling out over the following week. The beta offered iOS and Android apps and browser extensions for Brave and Chrome; Firefox followed on April 28. Proton Pass used end-to-end encryption on all fields including usernames and URLs, not just passwords.

minor2023-06-14

Proton Unlimited adds Proton Pass premium and raises monthly price for new subscribers

Proton announced that Proton Unlimited would include the paid features of Proton Pass, making it a bundle of five services. Effective July 1, 2023, the monthly price for new Unlimited subscribers rose from $11.99 to $12.99; existing monthly subscribers and annual or two-year subscribers were not affected.

critical2023-06-28

Proton Pass launches globally with freemium model

Proton Pass launched to the general public with a free tier offering unlimited passwords on unlimited devices, and a paid Pass Plus tier costing $2.99–$4.99 per month depending on subscription length. TechCrunch called it a solid password manager that lacked some competitors' features, noting the absence of a native desktop app and credit card autofill; shared vaults were planned. Desktop offline access and passkey support followed in 2024.

major2023-07-19

Proton Pass open-sourced under GPLv3, publishes Cure53 audit

Three weeks after public launch, Proton published the source code for its Proton Pass clients under the GPLv3 license and published the results of an independent security audit by Cure53. The audit, conducted May-June 2023, found a moderate number of issues, most limited in severity. All were resolved except one medium-severity Android platform limitation.

minor2023-09-19

Proton Pass memory cleartext bug disclosed by researchers

Security researchers reported that Proton Pass retained passwords in cleartext form in memory for up to 30 minutes after PIN lock activation. The issue had been identified in the Cure53 audit but was reintroduced in a subsequent release. Proton confirmed the bug and pushed patches, describing exploitation as a highly unlikely end-game scenario involving browser or memory access; the report also noted the risk from malware on the device.

minor2023-10-25

Proton Pass adds secure vault sharing feature

Proton Pass introduced end-to-end encrypted vault sharing, allowing users to share passwords and sensitive information with other Proton Pass users. Free users could share with up to two people; paid subscribers with up to nine per vault.

major2024-01-25

Proton halves the annual Pass Plus price to $1.99 per month

Proton cut the annual-plan price of Pass Plus from $3.99 to $1.99 per month for both new and existing customers. It attributed the cut to economies of scale from faster-than-expected growth in paid Proton Pass users.

major2024-02-07

Proton launches Proton Pass for Business

Proton introduced Proton Pass for Business, an encrypted vault for organizations' login details, bank cards and secure notes. Administrators could add and manage multiple users and set permissions, and the plan included built-in two-factor authentication and hide-my-email aliases.

major2024-02-29

Proton Pass launches Windows desktop app with offline mode

Proton Pass released a native Windows desktop application, one of the most requested community features. The app included offline mode (for paid subscribers) protected by Argon2 encryption, allowing access to passwords without an internet connection. This addressed a major gap compared to competitors like 1Password and Bitwarden.

major2024-03-21

Proton Pass adds passkey support for all users including free tier

Proton Pass rolled out passkey support across all platforms, making it available to both free and paid users. Unlike competitors that restricted passkeys to paid tiers, Proton offered FIDO2-based passwordless authentication at no cost. The implementation was open-source and based on the open FIDO standard.

major2024-04-10

Proton acquires Standard Notes encrypted note-taking app

Proton acquired Standard Notes, an end-to-end encrypted note-taking app with over 300,000 users. The acquisition was Proton's second after SimpleLogin. Standard Notes remained open source, independently operated, and honored existing subscriptions. Both companies shared values of E2E encryption, open source, and independence from venture capital.

major2024-05-06

Proton Pass launches Pass Monitor with dark web monitoring

Proton Pass introduced Pass Monitor, a security suite with four features: dark web monitoring for credential leaks, weak/reused password alerts, inactive 2FA identification, and Proton Sentinel account protection. Password Health and Inactive 2FA were available to free users; Dark Web Monitoring and Sentinel required a paid plan.

major2024-05-08

Proton provides recovery email through Swiss authorities in Spanish investigation

Proton complied with legal requests routed through Swiss police and provided the recovery email address associated with a Proton Mail account linked to Tsunami Democratic, a Catalan pro-independence movement. Spanish police, investigating events from the 2019 Catalonia protests as an organized crime and terrorism case, used the iCloud recovery address to obtain identifying information from Apple.

minor2024-06-06

Proton Pass launches macOS and Linux desktop apps

Proton Pass released native desktop applications for macOS and Linux, completing platform coverage across all major operating systems. The Linux version supported Debian and RedHat-based distributions including Ubuntu, Fedora, and CentOS, reflecting Proton's commitment to open-source platforms.

minor2024-06-06

Proton renames business plans and raises Business Suite prices for new subscribers

Proton renamed Proton Pass Business to Pass Professional and Proton Business to Proton Business Suite. For new Business Suite subscribers, monthly pricing rose from $12.99 to $14.99 per user, and annual-billing pricing rose from $10.99 to $12.99 per user per month. Existing Business Suite customers retained their pricing unless they changed their billing cycle before renewal or changed plan type.

critical2024-06-17

Proton Foundation established as controlling shareholder

Proton co-founders Andy Yen, Jason Stockman, and first employee Dingchao Lu donated shares to the newly established Proton Foundation, a Swiss non-profit, making it the primary shareholder. The Foundation's board of trustees included Tim Berners-Lee and privacy scholar Carissa Veliz. Swiss foundations cannot have shareholders and are legally bound to their stated purpose, blocking hostile takeovers.

minor2024-07-03

Proton Docs launches as encrypted Google Docs alternative

Proton launched Docs in Proton Drive, an end-to-end encrypted real-time collaborative document editor. Every keystroke, cursor movement, and document was encrypted in real time, and Proton said not even it could access document contents or metadata. The feature was available free through Proton Drive.

minor2024-07-12

Proton Pass introduces Secure Links for sharing with non-users

Proton Pass introduced Secure Links, allowing paid users to share credentials with people who do not have Proton Pass accounts via encrypted, expiring links. Links could be set to expire from one hour to 30 days, limited to a chosen number of accesses, and revoked at any time. Rollout began with Visionary and Lifetime users, followed by other paid Pass users in the coming days. The feature expanded sharing beyond the Proton ecosystem.

minor2024-07-24

Proton Wallet launches for Bitcoin self-custody

Proton released Proton Wallet in early access, a self-custody Bitcoin wallet integrated into the Proton ecosystem. Motivated by PayPal's 2014 freezing of ProtonMail's crowdfunding donations, the wallet allowed users to send Bitcoin via email addresses.

minor2024-08-08

Proton Pass adds Identities feature and desktop biometric auth

Proton Pass launched Identities, allowing users to store and auto-fill personal data like name, address, and phone number in web forms. The feature was available to all users including free tier. Paid users also received biometric authentication on desktop via Windows Hello and Touch ID on macOS.

minor2024-10-09

Proton Pass launches Family plan for six users

Proton launched the Pass Family plan for up to six users, including the account holder. The 12-month subscription launched with a limited-time $3.99/month offer, reduced from the regular $4.99/month. Each member received Pass Plus features, private vaults, shared family vaults, and admin controls. At the regular $4.99 price, the cost was under $1 per person per month with six members.

major2024-11-07

Pass Plus adds SimpleLogin Premium and raises the new-subscriber price

Proton integrated SimpleLogin's premium alias features into Pass Plus so users would not need two subscriptions. The price for new Pass Plus subscribers rose to $2.99 per month on a 12-month plan (billed at $35.88); existing subscribers kept their $1.99 or early-adopter $1 monthly rate while gaining the new features.

minor2025-01-27

Venak Security publishes disputed memory vulnerability claims

Security firm Venak Security published claims about memory protection vulnerabilities in Proton Pass and Proton VPN. Its report described Proton as having 500 million users and alleged that Windows users were exposed to memory-based attacks; this was Venak's claim, not a verified account-exposure count. Proton later published a detailed rebuttal: Pass must hold actively viewed data unencrypted in memory, while VPN traffic uses separate session keys rotated every two minutes rather than the static keys Venak described.

minor2025-01-28

CEO Andy Yen sparks political controversy with pro-Republican post

In December 2024, Proton CEO Andy Yen praised the Republican Party on his personal X account. Proton's official Reddit account separately posted a now-deleted comment arguing Republicans were more likely to tackle Big Tech abuses. After backlash, Proton removed its response and said official accounts could not express personal political opinions; Yen described Proton as politically neutral. In its response to The Intercept, Proton also praised the appointment of Gail Slater to lead DOJ antitrust.

minor2025-04-16

Proton Pass adds file attachments for paid subscribers

Proton Pass introduced file attachments, allowing paid users to attach files up to 100MB each to any vault item. Storage limits varied by plan: 10GB for Pass Plus/Pro, 50GB for Family, and 500GB for Unlimited. Files were end-to-end encrypted and could be shared via Secure Links or vault sharing.

major2025-06-30

Proton joins antitrust class action against Apple's App Store practices

Proton filed papers to join an existing class-action antitrust lawsuit against Apple, alleging the App Store's 30% commission, restrictions on alternative payment methods, and censorship of privacy-oriented apps constitute anti-competitive practices. Proton pledged to donate any damages received to democracy and human rights organizations through the Proton Foundation.

major2025-08-14

Proton moves infrastructure out of Switzerland over proposed surveillance rules

Proton confirmed it had begun moving physical infrastructure out of Switzerland because of legal uncertainty over a proposed revision of the Swiss surveillance ordinance. The revision would require VPNs, messaging apps and other services with at least 5,000 users to identify users and retain data for up to six months. Proton's Lumo assistant was the first product to move, to servers in Germany; a spokesperson said investing in Europe did not mean leaving Switzerland.

major2025-08-15

Proton suspends journalist accounts after CERT alert

Proton disabled email accounts used by Phrack security journalists for responsible disclosures on August 15 and 16, 2025, after a CERT alert about alleged misuse. The journalists had researched intrusions into South Korean government computer systems. After public outcry, Proton reinstated the accounts in September but did not disclose which CERT had sent the alert, raising transparency concerns.

minor2025-08-28

Proton launches Emergency Access for account recovery

Proton introduced Emergency Access, allowing paid users to designate up to five trusted contacts who can gain access to their Proton data (emails, passwords, files) either immediately or after a custom waiting period. Unlike Google's inactive account manager, Proton's system didn't rely on inactivity detection, giving users explicit control.

minor2025-11-12

Proton details its fix for a DOM-based clickjacking attack on Proton Pass

Researcher Marek Tóth demonstrated at DEF CON 33 a DOM-based clickjacking technique against browser password-manager extensions; all 11 he tested, including Proton Pass, were vulnerable. Proton said version 1.31.6 of Proton Pass addressed the affected extension elements and overlay, urged users to update, and added Tóth to its Security Contributors list.

minor2025-11-25

Proton Pass launches a command-line interface for paid plans

Proton introduced a Proton Pass command-line interface for retrieving and managing vault items in terminals, scripts, deployments and CI/CD pipelines. It was available on Pass Plus, Pass Family, Pass Professional and Proton bundles; free-plan users had to upgrade for access.

minor2026-01-09

Proton Lifetime Fundraiser raises $1.27M for digital rights organizations

Proton's 2025 Lifetime Account Charity Fundraiser generated $1,273,800, comprising $1,073,800 from ticket sales and a $200,000 Foundation contribution, bringing charitable contributions over eight years to more than $5 million. Over 100,000 tickets were sold to more than 50,000 participants. The 2025 beneficiaries included EDRi, WITNESS, and Hack Club, alongside select past beneficiaries.

minor2026-03-31

Proton launches Workspace and upgrades Business Suite customers at no extra cost

Proton launched Proton Workspace, a business suite including Proton Pass alongside Mail, Calendar, Drive, Docs, Sheets, Meet and VPN, with Workspace Standard priced at $12.99 per user per month annually or $14.99 monthly. Existing Proton Business Suite customers received a free upgrade to Workspace Standard, including Proton Meet.

major2026-05-12

Recurity Labs audit of Proton Pass finds no remote exploits or encryption bypasses

Proton published an audit by Recurity Labs, which tested the Proton Pass browser extensions, mobile and desktop apps and CLI between January and April 2026. Proton reported that the auditors found no remote exploits or encryption bypasses and rated its security posture well above par; recommendations on handling secrets in memory led to desktop memory-handling fixes confirmed on retest.

major2026-06-23

Researcher finds Proton Pass vault sharing lacked the key verification its security model claimed

Security researcher Pascal Schärli reported that Proton Pass did not perform Key Transparency verification when users shared vaults, although its security model said public keys were protected by that system. He said Proton removed the claim from the Pass security model at his request without notice to users or a changelog entry, and that vault sharing still relied on trusting Proton's backend at the time of writing. He also reported a Key Transparency implementation flaw in Proton Mail and an unsigned-update issue in Proton's desktop updater.

major2026-07-30

Proton Pass update resolves 80% of user-reported autofill issues

Proton said a new Proton Pass version resolved 80% of the autofill issues users had reported, one of the main community requests. Autofill now detected login forms inside iframes and worked on previously unsupported sites, including banking websites; the update also improved 2FA autofill and eased organization-wide deployment.

minor2026-08-27

Frankfurt datacenter cooling failure causes widespread Proton outage

A total cooling-system failure in Proton's Frankfurt datacenter caused a widespread outage across Proton services in the early hours of August 27, 2026. Proton's incident report said recovery took longer because primary database failovers require human supervision and overheated network cards had to be reset; some servers were lost.

minor2026-10-15

Proton Pass adds folders, URL matching rules and compromised-password alerts

Proton released folders and subfolders, configurable autofill URL matching (including wildcard and regular-expression modes) and compromised-password detection that runs locally on the device. Folder creation is limited to paid consumer and business plans; free and Pass Essentials users can only use folders in vaults shared with them.

Evidence (58 citations)
Scoring Log (6 entries)
fact-audit2026-10-26FABRICATION FOUND

Checked 87 timeline/evidence/milestone items and 3 alternatives plus all prose/fields. Every original item has one verdict in work/final-item-decisions.json. Two distinct false details: (1) Proton participation in the 2024 FIDO effort, contradicted by the actual Bitwarden article and FIDO contributor list (https://bitwarden.com/blog/security-vendors-join-forces-to-make-passkeys-more-portable-for-everyone/); (2) an established exposure of 500 million accounts, a CyberPress headline overstating an allegation contradicted by Proton's technical rebuttal (https://proton.me/support/venak-false-claims). Venak's real 500-million-user allegation is preserved and not counted invented. Unsupported details: ratio, three Glassdoor specifics, fixed annual Pass audit cadence, unqualified no-layoffs inference, only historical VC round, universal no-hidden-fees claim. Revenue/headcount estimates, $70,000 lobbying, $251,721 PayPal report, and true GPLv3/Brave/SimpleLogin details were preserved after rejecting over-trims. No scores, era scores, or era dates changed.

regrade2026-10-26RESCORED

14→14. D1 2→1 (event: the July 2026 autofill overhaul resolved 80% of user-reported autofill issues, the main complaint, and October 2026 added folders and URL matching; no free feature paywalled). D5 1→2 (event: a June 2026 researcher report found Pass vault sharing never ran the Key Transparency verification its security model claimed, and Proton removed the claim without notice or a changelog entry). Others confirmed against criteria. Eras: merged 'Barebones Launch' and 'Feature Buildout' (scores indistinguishable under criteria; D1 4→1 because a minimal new product is not an eroded one) into 'Launch and Buildout', re-dated from 2023-06-01 to 2023-04-20 (beta) and relabeled. Kept 'Foundation Era', re-dated from 2024-10-01 to 2024-06-17 (Foundation established; D9 1). Re-dated 'Stable Maturity' from 2026-02-19 (assessment date) to 2025-01-28 (Yen controversy reporting) and relabeled it 'Trust Under Scrutiny'. Since Oct 2025: clickjacking fix detailed (Nov 2025), paid CLI (Nov 2025), Workspace launch with free Business Suite upgrade (Mar 2026), Recurity Labs audit (May 2026), Key Transparency claim removal reported (Jun 2026), autofill overhaul (Jul 2026), Frankfurt outage (Aug 2026), folders and URL matching plus planned credential exchange support (Oct 2026); no price changes, enforcement, litigation outcomes on the merits, or labor actions. Historical gap-fills: 2023 Unlimited bundling, the Jan 2024 price cut, the Feb 2024 business launch, Nov 2024 SimpleLogin bundling with a new-subscriber price rise, and the 2025 Swiss infrastructure relocation. Alternatives unchanged.

restore-check2026-10-26RESTORED

Checked 8 trimmed candidates: 0 restored, 1 partly restored, 7 confirmed removed, 0 already present. PARTLY RESTORED evidence:update:4: Tekpon (April 3, 2026; read October 26) explicitly lists Pass Essentials at $4.99/user/month and Pass Professional at $6.99/user/month on monthly billing; corroborated by PasswordManager.com and SMB Guide. Restore these figures with billing context and a correct business-pricing source; keep the corrected observation date and annual-offer context. Source: https://tekpon.com/software/proton-pass/pricing/. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:1: the $251,721 estimate is already preserved in the bit-tech evidence item. The June 30 Proton announcement and its July 1 1700h release update do not support June 27 or release within 24 hours. TechCrunch live and Wayback, bit-tech and two exact/date searches checked. Sources: https://proton.me/blog/paypal-freezes-protonmail-campaign-funds and https://bit-tech.net/news/tech/software/protonmail-paypal/1/. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:2: TechCrunch in March 2015 documents the first outside funding round, not historical exclusivity. Its June 2024 retrospective confirms the 2021 CRV exit, which remains in the record. The small minority stake also remains in timeline index 8. Three searches, the original live/Wayback, the retrospective, Tracxn funding profile and the 2021 primary announcement did not establish only one venture round. Sources: https://techcrunch.com/2015/03/20/protonmail-seed/ and https://techcrunch.com/2024/06/17/privacy-app-maker-proton-transitions-to-non-profit-foundation-structure/. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:update:9 and evidence:update:28: the reviewed GetLatka and Tracxn pages do not establish an absence of layoffs. Their attributed estimates and the qualified absence of layoff evidence are already preserved in the current prose. Three shared searches including exact no-reported-layoffs, company employees/layoffs and no-known-layoffs found no readable qualifying source establishing the broader claim. A TrueUp lead could not be read after live, alternate-host and Wayback attempts; those failures are not evidence against the claim. Sources read: https://getlatka.com/companies/protonmail and https://tracxn.com/d/companies/proton/__9WjlLzTUCCIB4iGatDa3ZgK8gzgOKZD-4GpSQ_GGYo4. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:update:21: the consumer pricing page supports published tiers but not universal absence of hidden fees. Three searches checked exact language, the named pricing origin and 2024-2026 trial/pricing drift. The July 24, 2025 business announcement promises no hidden trial fees only; vendor marketing does not meet the restoring-source standard or prove the broader consumer claim. Sources read: https://proton.me/pass/pricing and https://proton.me/business/blog/proton-for-business-free-trial. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:update:34: CyberPress repeats Venak claims but does not document 500 million exposed accounts. Read the original article, Venak report and Proton technical rebuttal. The allegation and response are already preserved in evidence and the January 2025 timeline. Sources: https://cyberpress.org/500-million-proton-vpn-pass-accounts-exposed/ and https://proton.me/support/venak-false-claims. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:update:36: three searches, the original Glassdoor June 2025 archive and a near-January-2025 Wayback request checked historical and current metrics and turnover claims. The June snapshot supports 71% recommend (already preserved), while the returned April 2025 snapshot supports 78%, neither 73%. No readable qualifying source corroborated the removed turnover/culture/retention specifics. Current UK page fetches failed; no restoration relies on its search snippet. Source: https://web.archive.org/web/20250611035901/https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Proton-privacy-by-default-Reviews-E1405328.htm.

Deep Enrichment2026-03-15
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-19

Initial scoring with alternatives