Proton Mail

Proton Mail is an encrypted email service operated by Proton AG in Switzerland. It provides end-to-end encryption between Proton Mail users and compatible OpenPGP correspondents, and zero-access encryption for stored messages. Proton AG operates under the supervision of the non-profit Proton Foundation, its primary shareholder.

17/ 100
Healthy
1No Decay→Stable

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-26. Score revised 2026-10-26: 15 → 17.

Score History

MilestoneCriticalMajor
CERN Privacy Mission (2014–2016) · 5/100CERN PrivacyMissionFreemium Growth Years (2016–2021) · 9/100Freemium Growth YearsPrivacy Reckoning (2021–2022) · 9/100Unified Proton Ecosystem (2022–2024) · 13/100Unified ProtonEcosystemFoundation Era (2024–2025) · 14/100Found…Lumo AI and Relocation (2025–present) · 17/100Lumo AI andRelocation10075502502016202020242026-10CERN Privacy Mission (2014–2016) · 5/100Freemium Growth Years (2016–2021) · 9/100Privacy Reckoning (2021–2022) · 9/100Unified Proton Ecosystem (2022–2024) · 13/100Foundation Era (2024–2025) · 14/100Lumo AI and Relocation (2025–present) · 17/100599131417MilestonesProton Mail public beta launched (2014)Seed funding ($2M) (2015)Public launch (v3.0 exits beta) (2016)CRV stake transferred to non-profit FONGIT (2021)Acquired SimpleLogin (2022)Acquired Standard Notes (2024)Proton Foundation established (2024)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

CERN Privacy Mission
5/100
2014-05-16 – 2016-03-17

ProtonMail launched as a public beta from CERN-linked founders in May 2014, funded first by a crowdfunding campaign that PayPal briefly froze and then by a $2 million seed round from CRV and FONGIT in March 2015. The service was free and donation-funded, with no paid plans and no ads, and version 2.0 open-sourced the web client in August 2015. The November 2015 DDoS attacks, during which Proton paid a ransom that did not stop them, were the era's main disruption.

Freemium Growth Years
9/100+4
2016-03-17 – 2021-09-06

ProtonMail exited beta with version 3.0 in March 2016, weeks after introducing its first paid accounts and custom domains, and settled into a freemium model with paid-only IMAP access through Bridge and, from 2017, plans for organizations. Proton launched ProtonVPN and a Tor onion site in 2017, Calendar and Drive betas in 2019-2020, open-sourced its iOS, Android and Bridge apps by 2020, and co-founded the Coalition for App Fairness. External pressures, such as Google's year-long search suppression and Apple's App Store demands, shaped the period more than any extraction by Proton, and CRV's minority stake passed to the non-profit FONGIT in early 2021.

Privacy Reckoning
9/100
2021-09-06 – 2022-05-25

Proton's acknowledgment that it had logged a French climate activist's IP address under a Swiss order it could not appeal exposed the gap between its 'no IP logs' marketing and its legal obligations. Proton removed the claim and updated its privacy policy, then won a Swiss Federal Administrative Court ruling in October 2021 that email providers are not telecom providers subject to data retention, and co-founded the Coalition for Competitive Digital Markets. The crisis was answered with more transparency rather than resistance.

Unified Proton Ecosystem
13/100+4
2022-05-25 – 2024-06-17

ProtonMail rebranded as Proton, unifying Mail, VPN, Calendar and Drive under one account with Free, Mail Plus and Unlimited tiers, shortly after acquiring SimpleLogin. Drive and Pass launched, Standard Notes was acquired, the June 2024 business update added Mail Professional, and Proton's US terms added individual arbitration and a class-action waiver in June 2023. Restrictions crept in at the edges: the desktop app launched paid-only in March 2024 after beta-era statements that free users would get access, and an April 2024 policy let Proton delete long-inactive free accounts, including ones that had previously paid. The May 2024 Catalan case showed recovery-email data could still help identify users.

Foundation Era
14/100+1
2024-06-17 – 2025-07-23

Proton's founders and first employee donated shares to the new non-profit Proton Foundation, which became Proton AG's primary shareholder with consent rights over any change of control. Product expansion continued with the Scribe AI writing assistant, Proton Wallet and a record Lifetime fundraiser. CEO Andy Yen's January 2025 political posts prompted a neutrality controversy, an Indian court directed blocking proceedings against Proton Mail in April 2025, and Proton joined antitrust litigation against Apple in June 2025.

Lumo AI and Relocation
17/100+3
2025-07-23 – present

Proton launched the Lumo AI chatbot and announced it would move most of its physical infrastructure out of Switzerland, starting with Lumo in Germany, in response to proposed Swiss surveillance-ordinance changes. The era brought several trust lapses: the September 2025 suspension of Phrack journalists' accounts, a January 2026 Lumo marketing email that reached a user who had opted out, and a March 2026 report that Proton payment data reached the FBI via Swiss authorities. Product gains continued with rebuilt mobile apps, post-quantum encryption on all plans, Gmail connection and the Proton Workspace business suite, while August and September 2026 outages dented reliability.

Alternatives

Fastmail13/100

Australian privacy-focused email with custom domain support, import tools, and IMAP/SMTP access on eligible plans. The Basic business tier, priced at $3/month when billed annually, does not include third-party email client access; Standard and Professional do. Moderate switch — use Fastmail's import tool, then set up forwarding. No end-to-end encryption by default, but it supports standard third-party email clients.

Tuta15/100

German end-to-end encrypted email and calendar service with a free tier, 1GB storage, and open-source clients. Easy switch — similar privacy model to ProtonMail with encrypted mailbox storage. Lacks IMAP support by design and uses its own encryption implementation rather than OpenPGP.

Proton16/100

ProtonMail is part of the broader Proton suite — if you need encrypted email plus VPN, cloud storage, calendar, and password manager, the full Proton Unlimited plan bundles everything. Consider upgrading to the full suite before switching away from ProtonMail specifically.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Proton Mail's core encrypted email keeps improving: post-quantum encryption became available on all plans, including free, in May 2026; the v7 mobile apps rebuilt in September 2025 added offline mode; and Proton added Gmail connection (May 2026) and optional inbox categories (August 2026). The free tier is tight by design, with 500MB-1GB storage, a 150-message daily send limit and only 3 custom folders and 3 labels. IMAP/SMTP via Bridge and the desktop app are paid-only, the latter despite beta-era statements that access would expand to free users. A Frankfurt datacenter cooling failure on August 27, 2026 and a follow-on disruption on September 1 delayed mail for some users, but these are minor annoyances rather than degradation of the core product.
How It Got Here
ProtonMail launched in May 2014 as a beta with deliberately limited features but strong encryption fundamentals. Version 2.0 (August 2015) rewrote the codebase, and the March 2016 public launch added mobile apps. The Tor onion site (January 2017) and v4 web redesign (June 2021) steadily improved access and usability. The free tier, however, has stayed tight: 500MB-1GB storage versus Gmail's 15GB, a 150-message daily limit, and only 3 custom folders and 3 labels. IMAP/SMTP access via Bridge has always been paid-only, and when the desktop app launched in March 2024 it was restricted to paid subscribers despite beta-era statements that free users would get access. The July 2024 Scribe assistant and the September 2025 v7 mobile rebuild with offline mode continued the improvements, and in November 2025 Proton brought back features such as swipe navigation and sender blocking to the rebuilt apps. In 2026 Proton added post-quantum encryption for all plans including free (May), Gmail connection inside Proton Mail (May) and optional inbox categories (August). A Frankfurt datacenter cooling failure on August 27, 2026 and a follow-on disruption on September 1 briefly delayed mail. The core tension remains restriction rather than degradation: the product keeps improving, while features competitors offer free stay behind a paywall.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2014CERN Privacy Mission2016Freemium Growth Years2021Privacy Reckoning2022Unified Proton Ecosystem2024Foundation Era2025Lumo AI and RelocationUser Value111222Biz Exploit000111Shareholder011111Lock-in222333Algorithms000001Dark Patterns011112Advertising011112Competition000111Labor/Gov111122Regulatory122222
Timeline (69 events)
critical2014-05-16

ProtonMail enters public beta at CERN

ProtonMail was launched as a public beta by CERN-associated founders Andy Yen, Jason Stockman, and Wei Sun. The service offered end-to-end encrypted email. Beta signups had to be temporarily suspended after three days due to overwhelming demand.

major2014-06-30

PayPal freezes ProtonMail crowdfunding funds

During ProtonMail's Indiegogo crowdfunding campaign, PayPal froze the project's account without advance warning after $275,000 had been raised in two weeks. Proton reported that PayPal lifted the restrictions on July 1, allowing it to withdraw the funds.

major2015-03-18

ProtonMail raises $2M seed funding from CRV and FONGIT

ProtonMail received $2 million in seed funding from Charles River Ventures and the Fondation Genevoise pour l'Innovation Technologique (FONGIT), a non-profit backed by the Swiss Federal Commission for Technology and Innovation. This was the company's first institutional funding. ProtonMail had 350,000 beta signups at the time.

major2015-08-13

ProtonMail v2 launches with open-source web client

ProtonMail released version 2.0 with a completely rewritten codebase and made the entire web client open source. A bug bounty program was launched simultaneously. Proton said more than half a million people had signed up for the service. Boston Herald reporting republished by Government Technology in June 2015 quoted Andy Yen as saying ProtonMail had 500,000 users.

critical2015-11-03

Massive DDoS attack takes ProtonMail offline for days

ProtonMail suffered a sustained DDoS attack beginning November 3, 2015 that knocked the service offline for extended periods over the following days. The coordinated assault on its upstream ISP exceeded 100 Gbps and took down unrelated companies and banks. Proton worked with Swiss authorities on a criminal investigation with Europol assistance.

major2015-11-04

ProtonMail pays DDoS ransom before investing in mitigation

Under pressure from other companies affected by the attack's collateral damage, ProtonMail paid a ransom to the attackers. The attacks continued anyway, prompting ProtonMail to partner with IP-Max and Radware for professional DDoS mitigation. ProtonMail estimated long-term protection solutions would cost about $100,000 per year, and reported that the new infrastructure gave it the ability to resist future attacks.

major2016-02-26

ProtonMail introduces its first paid accounts and custom domains

ProtonMail 3.1 added paid accounts offering extra features and storage, along with support for custom domains. Proton said its revenue had until then consisted entirely of donations from its community, and that it was committed to keeping a free version available.

critical2016-03-17

ProtonMail v3 exits beta with global public launch

ProtonMail released version 3.0, officially exiting beta after two years. The release included a redesigned web client, iOS and Android beta apps, and removal of the invitation waitlist. The service was now available to anyone worldwide without restrictions.

major2016-10-27

ProtonMail accuses Google of suppressing search results

ProtonMail discovered it had been invisible in Google search results for queries like 'secure email' and 'encrypted email' since November 2015. The delisting lasted nearly a year and reduced ProtonMail's worldwide growth rate by over 25%, directly cutting income by 25%. Google acknowledged it had 'fixed something' without explanation. The incident was unique to Google; all other search engines returned ProtonMail normally.

major2017-01-19

ProtonMail launches Tor onion site for censorship resistance

ProtonMail launched a Tor hidden service (.onion address), becoming the largest email provider to officially support Tor. The move added a third layer of encryption on top of HTTPS and PGP, enabling users in countries with internet censorship to access encrypted email. The Tor Project assisted with the implementation.

major2017-06-20

Proton VPN launches with free tier

Proton launched its VPN service, ProtonVPN, to provide ProtonMail users with a trustworthy VPN. The service included a free tier. This marked Proton's first product expansion beyond email.

minor2017-08-03

Proton Mail launches Professional plan for organizations

Proton added Professional as a fourth plan alongside Free, Plus and Visionary, letting organizations host email on their own domain and create individual user accounts. Administrators could provision accounts, allocate organization storage and manage member accounts while email stayed end-to-end encrypted.

major2018-01-01

Apple demands Proton remove in-app payment independence

Apple demanded that Proton move in-app purchases to Apple's payment system or face removal from the App Store. Because Proton was forced to sell through the App Store and prohibited from directing customers to its website, the company had to raise iOS subscription prices to cover Apple's 30% commission, making the iOS app more expensive than direct signup.

minor2019-01-08

Proton introduces GDPR.eu compliance resource

Proton introduced GDPR.eu, a free resource site to help organizations understand and implement GDPR requirements. It included a compliance checklist, practical guidance, and sample forms including a Data Processing Agreement. Proton said the site drew on lessons from its own GDPR compliance work during 2018.

major2019-07-27

Russian-linked phishing campaign targets Bellingcat journalists

On July 24, phishing emails targeted Bellingcat journalists using ProtonMail, directing them to a fake mailproton.me login site. In its July 27 statement, Proton said the attempt failed because of the targets' vigilance and its anti-phishing measures. Proton said infrastructure used by the attackers had also been used by Fancy Bear (APT28), but Russian attribution was not conclusively proven.

minor2019-10-31

ProtonMail iOS app goes fully open source

ProtonMail made its iOS app fully open source on GitHub after an independent security audit by SEC Consult. This followed the web client's open-sourcing in 2015. The move extended the company's transparency commitment to mobile platforms.

minor2019-12-30

Proton Calendar launches in beta as encrypted alternative

ProtonMail launched Proton Calendar as a public beta, initially available to paid subscribers. The service used client-side encryption for event titles, descriptions, locations, and participant lists, positioning it as the 'first fully encrypted calendar app' and an alternative to Google Calendar.

major2020-01-15

Apple threatens to remove ProtonVPN over anti-censorship language

Apple demanded that ProtonVPN remove language from its App Store description stating the app could be used to 'unblock censored websites.' Apple applied this restriction globally, requiring removal in all countries including those with protected free speech. ProtonVPN had been on the App Store since 2018 with the same functionality described.

minor2020-04-15

Proton Mail Bridge goes open source

Proton released the source code for Proton Mail Bridge on GitHub for macOS, Windows, and Linux. Bridge is the application that enables IMAP/SMTP access for third-party email clients. Open-sourcing it allowed independent verification of how the encryption handoff between Proton's servers and desktop clients works.

minor2020-04-24

ProtonMail Android app goes open source after security audit

ProtonMail's Android app was made open source on GitHub after passing an independent security audit by SEC Consult. This made the Android app the last ProtonMail client to go open source, completing the transparency commitment across web, iOS, Android, and Bridge platforms.

major2020-09-24

Proton co-founds Coalition for App Fairness against Apple and Google

Proton joined Epic Games and other companies to establish the Coalition for App Fairness, challenging Apple and Google's app store monopolies. The coalition targeted mandatory commissions on in-app purchases, which Proton argued disproportionately penalize subscription-based privacy services that cannot monetize user data.

minor2020-09-30

Proton Drive enters closed beta for Lifetime account holders

Proton opened Proton Drive beta to Lifetime account holders after months of internal testing, adding end-to-end encrypted cloud storage to the product suite. Proton said early access would extend to Visionary users before all paid users.

minor2020-10-22

Proton Mail adds Import Assistant for paid users

Proton introduced Import Assistant in beta, letting users transfer messages and folders from other providers into Proton Mail from the web app without installing anything. It was initially available only to users with paid plans.

major2021-03-23

Apple blocks ProtonVPN updates during Myanmar crisis

Apple rejected ProtonVPN security updates during Myanmar's military coup, when ProtonVPN signups in Myanmar had spiked to 250 times the previous average daily rate. The United Nations had recommended Proton Mail or Signal for reporting evidence of wrongdoing. Apple cited anti-censorship wording in the app description. Apple said it approved the latest update on March 19 after Proton modified the description.

major2021-03-26

CRV's Proton shares transferred to non-profit FONGIT

Proton said the shares held by venture investor CRV since its 2015 minority investment had been transferred earlier in 2021 to FONGIT, a non-profit foundation, to align its shareholders with its ethos of putting users ahead of profits.

minor2021-06-09

ProtonMail v4 web app redesign launches

ProtonMail released a major redesign of its web interface with customizable themes, improved keyboard shortcuts, quick filters, and better accessibility. The redesign aimed to bring ProtonMail's user experience closer to mainstream email clients while maintaining its security architecture.

critical2021-09-06

ProtonMail logs French climate activist's IP address for police

After French police arrested a climate activist, Proton acknowledged receiving a legally binding order from Swiss authorities that it could not appeal. Proton said Swiss law could compel it to collect information on specific accounts under Swiss criminal investigation, although it did not do this by default. Proton said it could not hand over the activist's encrypted messages. Contemporary reporting established that French authorities obtained an IP address and browser/device identifier via a request to Swiss authorities through Europol.

major2021-09-07

ProtonMail removes 'no IP logging' claim from website

Following the French activist IP disclosure, ProtonMail removed the claim 'We do not keep any IP logs which can be linked to your anonymous email account' from its homepage. The privacy policy was updated to state: 'If you are breaking Swiss law, ProtonMail can be legally compelled to log your IP address as part of a Swiss criminal investigation.'

critical2021-10-22

Swiss court rules email services exempt from telecom data retention

The Swiss Federal Administrative Court ruled that email providers are not telecommunications providers under Swiss law, exempting them from data retention obligations imposed on telcos. Proton had appealed after the Swiss Post and Telecommunications Surveillance Service attempted to classify it as a telecom provider in September 2020. The ruling was a significant privacy victory for Swiss-based email services.

minor2021-10-26

Proton co-founds Coalition for Competitive Digital Markets

Proton co-founded the Coalition for Competitive Digital Markets with Open-Xchange and Element, advocating stronger interoperability and anti-bundling provisions in the EU Digital Markets Act. Proton's impact page says the coalition represents more than 50 companies from 16 countries as well as the European DIGITAL SME Alliance, a business association of more than 45,000 digital SMEs.

minor2021-11-13

Securitum completes security audit of all Proton apps

Proton said Securitum, a European IT security company, inspected all Proton apps in September 2021 and found no major issues or security vulnerabilities. Securitum had also audited the new Proton Mail and Proton Calendar web applications earlier that year.

major2022-04-08

Proton acquires email aliasing service SimpleLogin

Proton acquired SimpleLogin, a French email aliasing startup with over 100,000 users and 2 million email aliases created. SimpleLogin remained open source and continued operating from Paris with its own team. The acquisition complemented ProtonMail by letting users shield their real email addresses.

critical2022-05-25

ProtonMail rebrands to Proton with unified ecosystem

ProtonMail rebranded to Proton, unifying Proton Mail, Proton VPN, Proton Calendar, and Proton Drive under a single account and brand at proton.me. The rebrand included new logos, a visual overhaul, and restructured pricing tiers: Free, Mail Plus ($5/month), and Unlimited ($12/month). Existing users received storage upgrades at no extra cost. The move signaled a shift from a single email product to an integrated privacy ecosystem.

major2022-06-15

Proton Mail fixes SonarSource XSS vulnerabilities disclosed in June 2022

SonarSource researchers reported cross-site scripting vulnerabilities that could let attackers steal decrypted emails and impersonate users after victims interacted with malicious emails. The attack bypassed defenses built around the DOMPurify HTML sanitizer. Proton received the detailed report on June 3, 2022, pushed a public-repository fix on June 15, and deployed it on July 6. Sonar's September 2023 account said there were no signs of in-the-wild exploitation and that nearly 70 million users had been at risk.

minor2022-09-22

Proton Drive exits beta for general availability

Proton Drive officially launched for everyone after more than three years of development, offering end-to-end encrypted cloud storage. The launch expanded the Proton ecosystem, deepening users' investment in the platform.

minor2023-04-20

Proton Pass password manager launches in beta

Proton announced Proton Pass, an end-to-end encrypted password manager, initially in beta for loyal Proton customers such as Lifetime plan users, with Visionary users to gain access shortly. This was Proton's fifth major product, further expanding the ecosystem.

minor2023-06-26

Proton adds US arbitration and class-action waiver to its terms

Proton updated its terms so that US users could bring claims in Swiss courts or through individual arbitration in the US, with certain exceptions, and excluded class, representative and collective claims. Opting out of the arbitration provisions required a written notice sent by post within 30 days. Proton said there was no material change for users outside the US.

minor2023-07-01

Proton raises monthly Unlimited price to $12.99

Proton increased the monthly Unlimited subscription price from $11.99 to $12.99 for new subscribers. Annual and biennial plans were not affected, nor were existing monthly subscribers.

minor2023-12-14

Proton Mail desktop app beta initially limited to Visionary subscribers

Proton released a dedicated desktop email application in beta for macOS and Windows in December 2023, initially limited to Visionary subscribers. It said access would gradually expand to all users, including free users. At the March 2024 general launch, Proton instead restricted continuing use to paid subscribers after a 14-day trial, citing infrastructure and maintenance demands.

minor2023-12-15

Proton vows to fight Australia's draft encryption standards in court

CEO Andy Yen told Guardian Australia that Proton would fight the eSafety commissioner's draft online safety standards in court if they were not changed and Proton received an enforcement notice to break end-to-end encryption. He said Proton had not broken encryption in Iran or Russia and would not in Australia.

minor2024-03-14

Proton Mail desktop app officially launches as paid-only

After the beta period, Proton officially launched the Proton Mail desktop app for Windows, macOS, and Linux. The app remained restricted to premium subscribers despite community requests for free-tier access. A Proton spokesperson said the decision was made after 'a highly positive response during the beta phase' and cited significant infrastructure and maintenance demands.

major2024-04-09

Proton updates inactive-account policy and removes prior-payment exemption

Proton updated its inactive-account policy on April 9, 2024. Free accounts could be deleted with their associated data after more than 12 months of inactivity across Proton services, with warnings 30, 15, and 7 days before deletion. Accounts created before April 9, 2024 received a temporary 24-month grace period. The previous exemption for accounts with any paid subscription history was removed; currently paid accounts remained exempt.

major2024-04-10

Proton acquires encrypted note-taking app Standard Notes

Proton acquired Standard Notes, an end-to-end encrypted note-taking app with over 300,000 users. Like the SimpleLogin acquisition, Standard Notes remained open source with existing subscription terms honored. Both companies emphasized shared values around encryption, open source, and independence from venture capital. This was Proton's second acquisition in two years.

major2024-05-08

Proton recovery email helps Spanish police identify pseudonymous Catalan activist

According to court documents obtained by TechCrunch, legal requests routed through Swiss police led Wire to provide a Proton Mail registration address and Proton to provide the account's iCloud recovery address. Apple then provided identity information to Spanish police. TechCrunch said the information helped identify a pseudonymous activist but could not confirm the alleged identity. Proton said it provides privacy by default rather than anonymity by default. Protos separately reported Proton's position that the recovery address was the only information it supplied. TechSpot subsequently reported that the disclosure led to an arrest; TechCrunch's court-document reporting established identification but did not report an arrest.

minor2024-06-06

Proton launches updated business plans with Mail Professional tier

Proton updated its business plans, introducing Mail Professional at $9.99/month per user on a 12-month subscription or $10.99/month per user on a one-month subscription. Proton Business was renamed Proton Business Suite, with a price increase for new subscribers while existing subscribers retained their price. The Mail Professional tier offered a mail-focused option alongside the broader suite.

critical2024-06-17

Proton establishes non-profit foundation as controlling shareholder

Proton founders and its first employee donated shares to the newly established Proton Foundation, making it Proton AG's primary shareholder; employees and FONGIT remained minority shareholders. The Swiss nonprofit's board included Tim Berners-Lee and Oxford professor Carissa Veliz. Its legally binding mission protects privacy, freedom, and democracy. No change of control can occur without the Foundation's consent, allowing it to block hostile takeovers and protect Proton's mission. Compiler reported in December 2024 that the founders had transferred a majority of the company's shares to the Foundation.

minor2024-07-18

Proton Scribe AI writing assistant launches with on-device option

Proton launched Proton Scribe, a privacy-first AI writing assistant based on the open-source Mistral 7B model. It can run entirely on-device, keeping user data on the device. Proton said its open-source assistant would not learn from user data. At launch, access was free for Visionary and Lifetime subscribers; business users could purchase it as an add-on.

minor2024-07-24

Proton launches self-custody Bitcoin wallet

Proton released Proton Wallet, a self-custody Bitcoin wallet integrated with the Proton ecosystem. Users could send Bitcoin to other Proton Wallet users via email address. The wallet was initially limited to Proton Visionary subscribers. A later Privacy Guides review criticized its Bitcoin-only support, lack of privacy-focused cryptocurrencies such as Monero, and absence of privacy-enhancing features including CoinJoin and Lightning Network.

minor2025-01-06

Proton lifetime fundraiser raises record $927K for digital rights

Proton's 2024 Lifetime Account Charity Fundraiser raised $927,470 from over 90,000 tickets sold to 43,631 participants. With Proton's additional $150,000 contribution, the total reached $1,077,470. Since 2018, the annual fundraiser has donated over $4 million to more than 40 organizations supporting privacy, press freedom, and digital rights worldwide.

major2025-01-28

CEO Andy Yen's Republican praise sparks political neutrality controversy

CEO Andy Yen's X post praising the Republican Party's antitrust position sparked a political neutrality controversy after Proton's official Reddit account posted a now-deleted comment saying Republicans were more likely to tackle Big Tech abuses. Proton said the Reddit comment was not an official statement and reiterated its rule against official accounts expressing personal political opinions. Yen described an internal miscommunication and said Proton's policy going forward would be to share no opinions of a political nature.

major2025-04-29

Karnataka High Court directs proceedings to block Proton Mail in India

On April 29, 2025, the Karnataka High Court directed the Indian government to initiate proceedings under Section 69A of the Information Technology Act to block Proton Mail and to block specific URLs in the petition pending those proceedings. The case concerned allegations that employees of a Delhi firm received abusive emails including AI-generated deepfake images. Proton opposed blocking the service, saying it would prevent lawful secure communication, and said in a May 1 update that all Proton services remained available across India.

major2025-06-30

Proton joins antitrust class-action lawsuit against Apple

Proton joined an existing class-action antitrust lawsuit against Apple, filing its own complaint alleging that Apple's 30% commission, mandatory in-app payment system, and restrictions on alternative app stores violate U.S. antitrust law. Proton added a privacy-focused argument: Apple's pricing model penalizes subscription-based privacy services while incentivizing surveillance capitalism. Proton pledged to donate any monetary damages received.

minor2025-07-01

Proton passes SOC 2 Type II audit for enterprise credibility

Proton completed its first SOC 2 Type II attestation, conducted by Schellman. The audit verified that Proton maintains robust and consistent security controls across access management, incident response, system monitoring, and risk assessment. All Proton services were covered. SOC 2 Type II is a baseline requirement for many regulated industries considering new vendors.

minor2025-07-23

Proton launches Lumo privacy-first AI chatbot

Proton released Lumo, a zero-access encrypted AI chatbot running on open-source models from European data centers. Conversations are not logged and chats are stored with zero-access encryption. A 'ghost mode' makes sessions disappear entirely when closed. Lumo is free to use without a Proton account; Lumo Plus costs $12.99/month for additional features.

critical2025-07-23

Proton begins relocating infrastructure from Switzerland over surveillance law

In response to proposed Swiss surveillance-law revisions, Proton announced it was moving most of its physical infrastructure outside Switzerland, with Lumo first. Lumo's infrastructure would be located in Germany, and Proton was developing Norwegian facilities at a reported cost of CHF 100 million. The proposal included identification and data-retention duties for providers with over 5,000 users. Proton and its products remained under Swiss jurisdiction at the time, and its headquarters remained in Geneva.

major2025-09-12

Proton suspends Phrack journalist accounts at CERT request

Proton suspended email accounts of two journalists working on a Phrack article about North Korean state-sponsored hackers (Kimsuky). Proton cited a CERT alert about account misuse but did not identify the CERT or explain the criteria for suspension. One journalist's personal account was also disabled. Accounts were only reinstated after the Phrack X account posted publicly, garnering 150,000+ views. Proton provided no clear explanation for the reversal, raising concerns about abuse-response transparency.

minor2025-09-25

Proton Mail v7 mobile apps rebuilt with offline mode

Proton released completely redesigned iOS and Android apps built from the ground up with approximately 80% shared code. The v7 release added offline mode for reading, composing, and organizing email without a connection, with changes syncing automatically. Performance was doubled for scrolling, archiving, and replying compared to the previous version.

minor2025-11-19

Proton restores missing features to rebuilt Mail mobile apps

In the first feature update for the rebuilt Proton Mail mobile apps, Proton brought back auto-jump to the next message, swipe navigation between messages, sender blocking and conversion of inline images to attachments on iOS and Android, along with bug and performance fixes.

minor2026-01-06

Proton reports 9,301 Proton Mail legal orders for 2025

Proton's transparency report lists 9,301 legal orders for Proton Mail in 2025, of which it contested 988 and complied with 8,313, down from 10,368 complied with in 2024.

major2026-01-14

Lumo marketing email bypasses user opt-out preferences

On January 14, David Bushell received a Lumo promotional email despite having disabled Lumo product updates. Support initially distinguished Product Updates from Email Subscriptions and described the message as a Proton for Business newsletter. In a January 23 update, Bushell reported that support acknowledged overlapping notification categories, apologized, and said a bug was being fixed. Proton's CTO also acknowledged a bug. The incident drew hundreds of points and comments on Hacker News, where users questioned Proton's handling of consent. Other users alleged that a new email category had automatically opted them in without consent.

minor2026-02-11

Swiss Federal Council sends surveillance-ordinance revision to a second consultation

The Federal Council took note of the consultation results on the partial revisions of the VÜPF and VD-ÜPF surveillance ordinances, commissioned an external regulatory impact assessment, and said a second consultation was planned. Parliamentary motions filed in September 2025 had asked for the drafts to be fundamentally reworked.

major2026-03-05

Proton Mail payment data reached the FBI in Stop Cop City case

404 Media reported that a court record showed Proton Mail provided payment data related to an anonymous account affiliated with the Stop Cop City movement in Atlanta to Swiss authorities, who passed it to the FBI, which used it to determine who was allegedly behind the account.

major2026-03-16

Karnataka High Court stays blocking of Proton Mail in India

On Proton's appeal, a Division Bench of the Karnataka High Court restrained authorities, including the central government, from blocking access to Proton Mail in India until further orders. The court granted interim relief, noting that Proton said it complied with formal orders received through Swiss authorities.

major2026-03-31

Proton launches Workspace business suite

Proton launched Proton Workspace, bundling Mail, Calendar, Drive, Docs, Sheets, Meet, VPN and Pass in two plans: Workspace Standard at $12.99 per user per month billed annually ($14.99 monthly) and Workspace Premium at $19.99 ($24.99 monthly). Existing Proton Business Suite customers received a free upgrade to Workspace Standard, and Proton said it had never raised prices on existing customers.

major2026-05-05

Proton Mail adds post-quantum encryption on all plans

Proton made post-quantum protection available in Proton Mail on all plans, including free. Once enabled, it generates post-quantum-ready keys for new encrypted emails, and Proton said it planned to re-encrypt older emails in the future.

minor2026-05-28

Proton Mail lets users connect Gmail accounts

Proton added a feature that imports a user's latest Gmail messages, shows new Gmail messages in the Proton Mail inbox and lets users send from their Gmail address inside Proton Mail. Proton presented it as a transition tool and noted that Google can still read email received by the Gmail account.

minor2026-08-20

Proton Mail adds optional automatic inbox categories

Proton Mail introduced Categories, which automatically sort incoming email into views such as Primary, Promotions and Updates. Categories are on by default for new users, existing users are asked whether to enable them, and users can move messages between categories or disable the view.

minor2026-08-27

Frankfurt cooling failure causes widespread Proton outage

A total failure of the cooling system at Proton's Frankfurt datacenter caused a widespread outage in the early hours of August 27. Proton said most services were back for most users by 01:30 CEST, no emails were lost, but email delivery in both directions was delayed.

minor2026-09-01

Database maintenance triggers second Proton service disruption

A subset of Proton users experienced intermittent service disruptions during exceptional database maintenance that followed the Frankfurt overheating incident. Affected components included Proton Mail's web app, incoming and outgoing mail, Bridge, and mobile and desktop apps.

Evidence (75 citations)

D10: Regulatory & Legal Posture

Swiss Federal Council plans second consultation on VÜPF surveillance-ordinance revisionSwiss Federal Council / Federal Department of Justice · 2026-02-11
Scoring Log (6 entries)
fact-audit2026-10-26FABRICATION FOUND

Checked 100 original items (52 timeline, 40 evidence, 5 milestones, 3 alternatives) plus all prose and product fields. 42 verified, 35 corrected (11 date-only), 23 re-sourced, 0 removed. Fixed 29 distinct prose claims. Preserved true miscited details with 21 supplemental evidence entries. Five contradicted specifics: (1) $100,000 incident cost was annual mitigation estimate (https://proton.me/blog/protonmail-ddos-attacks); (2) UN recommendation was Proton Mail/Signal, not ProtonVPN (https://protonvpn.com/blog/apple-blocks-app-updates); (3) Drive development was over three years, not two (https://proton.me/blog/proton-drive-launch); (4) purported direct Yen quotation is an unquoted paraphrase/different wording and attribution from the actual statements (https://theintercept.com/2025/01/28/proton-mail-andy-yen-trump-republicans/); (5) personal Gmail daily limit is 500, not 2,000 (https://support.google.com/mail/answer/22839). Dynamic ratings, revenue estimates, historical headcounts and HN counter snapshots are not classified invented merely because snapshots differ. Twelve unsupported distinct details trimmed after source/archive, exact-claim, origin and date-drift checks (with the guide’s limited competitor-check exception for Tuta’s comparative restrictions claim); source/search trails in work/early-findings.md, work/late-findings.md, work/prose-findings.md and operation reasons. No timeline event deleted; cross-dimensional reuse of sources is not duplication. All scores unchanged.

regrade2026-10-26RESCORED

15→17. D5 0→1 (recalibration: Sept 2025 Phrack suspensions on an unnamed CERT alert with unexplained criteria show opaque enforcement; 0 means no evidence). D7 1→2 (recalibration: in-app upgrade/cross-product banners shown to paying users plus Jan 2026 Lumo promo email to opted-out user, and a deliberately limited free tier fit the 2-3 'moderate presence / minor limitations' row). Other 8 dimensions unchanged. Eras: first era re-dated 2014-05-01→2014-05-16 (beta launch); 'Public Launch' (2016-03-01) and 'Suite Expansion' (2019-01-01, no inflection event) merged → 'Freemium Growth Years' re-dated to 2016-03-17 (v3 public launch); 'Privacy Reckoning' re-dated 2021-09-01→2021-09-06 (IP-logging disclosure); 'Unified Ecosystem' re-dated 2022-05-01→2022-05-25 (rebrand) and relabeled 'Unified Proton Ecosystem'; 'Foundation Era' re-dated 2024-06-01→2024-06-17 (foundation established); current era 'Stable Maturity' re-dated 2026-02-12 (assessment date)→2025-07-23 (Lumo launch and infrastructure relocation announcement) and relabeled 'Lumo AI and Relocation'. All eras re-scored from criteria (era scores 5/9/9/13/14/17; old 5/7+9/12/13/14/15). Since Feb 2026: Proton Workspace replaced Business Suite (free upgrade for existing customers); post-quantum encryption on all plans; Gmail connection and inbox Categories; Stop Cop City payment-data disclosure reported (404 Media); Karnataka HC Division Bench stayed India blocking (Mar 2026; MLAT affidavit hearing listed Oct 2026); Swiss Federal Council sent VÜPF revision to a second consultation; 2025 transparency report 9,301 orders/8,313 complied; Aug 27 and Sep 1 2026 outages. Handoff leads: CRV exit added (event, milestone, evidence); Bellingcat follow-up and Apple suit found no new outcome; Spanish National Court closed the Tsunami Democràtic case in March 2025 (not added: does not concern Proton's conduct); Mail Professional no longer listed on business pricing page (Mail Essentials + Workspace). Not added (low scoring value or not Proton's conduct): Russia/Belarus government blocks, EFAIL statement, 2021 Irish defamation case against Proton, Family/Duo plan launches, Black Friday promotions, Born Private, Greenland offer, Oslo power incident, Apple developer-account Mac issue. Category 'Email' fine. Alternatives unchanged.

restore-check2026-10-26RESTORED

Checked all 9 restore candidates against the current record, original sources and Wayback before searches (at most 3 WebSearch calls per candidate). 1 restored, 2 partly restored, 5 confirmed removed, 1 already present. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:3 — Boston Herald / Government Technology (2015-06-16) quotes Yen reporting 500,000 users; restore earlier attributed count, not active usage or one-of-first-major-provider status. ALREADY PRESENT timeline:update:27 — provider-agnostic operation remains in evidence and D2 narrative; existing subscription terms remain in D8 narrative and the Standard Notes timeline comparison. No duplicate restoration; this verdict records pre-existing prose, not independent verification of every subscription term. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:32 — no reliable first-price-increase-since-2022 claim found. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:37 — TechSpot (2024-05-13, updated May 14) reports arrest; restore only attributed reporting, preserve narrower TechCrunch identification and unconfirmed identity. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:38 — no reliable source ties the June 2024 plan change to the asserted Google/Microsoft motive or dated email-only bundling complaint. RESTORED timeline:update:39 — Compiler / Peter Guest (2024-12-05), original interviews at Proton headquarters, explicitly reports majority-share transfer in 2024. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:51 — 384/241 counters and textbook-dark-pattern wording appear in byteiota, which does not meet the guide evidence standard; primary HN now shows 557/428, a different snapshot, not a contradiction. Preserve existing bug acknowledgement and category allegation without upgrading intent. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:update:15 — source is undated; exact-date and date-drift searches do not establish 2025-01-01. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:update:27 — no readable December 2025 source establishes 4.1/113; nearest-date archive fetch failed, which is not evidence against the claim; searches did not locate support, so preserve June 2025 snapshot. Three supplemental evidence entries identify the restoring sources. No removals or score changes. Research trail: work/restore-findings.json.

Deep Enrichment2026-03-15
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-12