Psychology Today
Psychology Today is a media and mental health platform offering a therapist directory, magazine, and website with psychology-focused content. Its Therapist Finder is the dominant US therapist directory, claiming about 80,000 listings; therapists pay $29.95/month to be listed while consumers search for free.
Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-11. Score revised 2026-10-11: 47 → 37.
Score History
Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.
Sussex Publishers launched the Find a Therapist directory in 2003, a two-sided service in which therapists pay a monthly listing fee and consumers search for free; Psychology Today says its $29.95 monthly price dates from 2004. The directory was a new and useful way to find a clinician, and advertising was confined to the magazine and editorial site. The website was primarily a content platform with a growing blog network under Editor-in-Chief Kaja Perina, who took the role in 2003.
The era opened with the August 2010 call-tracking rollout, which opted therapists in without consent and logged prospective clients' caller ID and call duration. Through high-volume expert content (more than 1,100 bloggers by 2011), Psychology Today became the likely first search result for therapy-seekers and the dominant therapist directory, while the May 2011 Kanazawa post exposed weak editorial review. From 2018, rivals such as TherapyDen launched, criticizing its clunky search and Cayman Islands base, and in April 2019 a petition pushed it to add a non-binary gender option.
As therapy moved online during COVID-19, Psychology Today launched Sessions, a free video tool for paying members, which tied more of members' practices to their listings; its BAA did not cover the profile, whose contact messages became nonsecure emails, and in December 2020 Mentor Research Institute noted the directory offered no BAAs. Website traffic peaked during COVID and declined afterwards, according to Semrush data cited in 2025. SimplePractice's Monarch launched in 2021 as the first challenger with scale, TherapyDen urged therapists to quit, and a 2022 guide documented email-only cancellation.
By early 2024, venture-backed platforms such as Rula were creating and managing Psychology Today profiles for their therapists, often alongside the therapists' own, and platform and national-network profiles came to crowd local search results. Therapists reported unexplained ranking drops from 2025 and steep referral declines (ClearHealthCosts, December 2025 to March 2026), which Psychology Today denied at a system level. A privacy class action over Google Analytics on therapist searches survived dismissal in 2025 and closed in July 2026, and in June 2026 Grow switched its Psychology Today program to opt-in.
Alternatives
A nonprofit therapist network focused on affordable therapy (individual sessions $40-$70, or $30 with student interns), offering a fundamentally different model from Psychology Today's paid listings. Free for therapists to list; clients pay a one-time $65 membership fee. Smaller directory but strong for cost-conscious therapy seekers.
An inclusive therapist directory built as a direct alternative to Psychology Today, with search filters for identity categories such as gender identity and racial identity, free basic profiles and paid tiers starting at $10/month. Smaller consumer traffic than Psychology Today. Easy switch for therapists; for therapy-seekers, it's just a different search site.
A curated therapist directory with therapist intro videos and out-of-network benefits verification. Higher cost for therapists than Psychology Today, with more marketing tools and a polished search experience. Moderate switch for therapists; for consumers, it's a cleaner, smaller directory to search.
Dimensional Breakdown
Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.
Dimension History
Timeline (30 events)
Psychology Today Magazine Founded
Nicholas Charney founded Psychology Today magazine at age 25, teaming up with George Reynolds and Winslow Marston. The magazine aimed to make psychology research accessible to the general public, filling a gap between academic journals and popular media.
Sussex Publishers Acquires Psychology Today After APA Failure
Sussex Publishers acquired Psychology Today after a tumultuous ownership history. The magazine had been sold to Boise Cascade in the late 1970s, then to Ziff-Davis, then to the American Psychological Association in 1983, which sold it at a $16 million loss in 1987. The magazine then ceased to exist for a few years until New York-based Sussex acquired and revived it in 1991; Sussex has remained the sole owner since. The CiNii Journals catalog records publication suspended in 1990-1991 and resumed with the January/February 1992 issue, when its frequency became bimonthly.
Kaja Perina Appointed Editor-in-Chief
Kaja Perina became Editor-in-Chief of Psychology Today in 2003, succeeding Robert Epstein (1999-2003), and has led the magazine and its website since. Its contributor blog network became the foundation of the website's search visibility, producing high-volume psychology content.
Find a Therapist Directory Launches
Psychology Today launched its therapist directory in 2003, connecting consumers with licensed clinicians for free while therapists pay a monthly fee to be listed. The two-sided marketplace, run by Sussex Directories, would become the company's dominant revenue source.
Directory Listing Price Fixed at $29.95
Psychology Today set its directory listing fee at the level it still charges, $29.95/month. A Psychology Today spokesperson told ClearHealthCosts in 2026 that the listing price 'has remained unchanged since 2004' and that everyone pays exactly the same price, with no exceptions or preferential rates.
Call Tracking System Deployed Without Therapist Consent
Psychology Today rolled out a call tracking feature that replaced therapists' actual office phone numbers with auto-generated tracking numbers, recording call metadata including caller ID and call duration. Therapists were automatically opted in without consent or notification. The system raised significant privacy concerns because potential therapy clients' call information was stored on Psychology Today's servers without their knowledge.
Blog Network Exceeds 1,100 Contributors
By February 2011, Psychology Today's expert blog network had more than 1,100 bloggers, according to a post by contributor Satoshi Kanazawa marking three years of blogging on the platform. The high volume of expert content became the basis of the site's strong organic search rankings.
Racist Blog Post Published Without Editorial Review
Psychology Today published a blog post by Satoshi Kanazawa titled 'Why Are Black Women Rated Less Physically Attractive Than Other Women, But Black Men Are Rated Better Looking Than Other Men?' without editorial review. The post used pseudo-scientific claims to disparage Black women's appearance and was pulled the next day. More than 75,000 ColorOfChange members pressed the publication via petition signatures, emails and social media. Psychology Today apologized, said Kanazawa was no longer contributing, and Editor-in-Chief Kaja Perina committed to more rigorous oversight of blog content before publication.
Research Sampling Frame Shows Tens of Thousands of Directory Providers
In September 2015, researcher Heather Kugelmass compiled a sampling frame from Psychology Today directory profiles. After restricting eligibility to verified, licensed US psychologists, social workers and counselors and excluding providers who treated only children, lacked an email option, were not accepting new clients, had not updated their profiles since 2013 or earlier, lacked a photo, or represented treatment facilities or group contacts, the study still had approximately 30,000 eligible providers. This was a filtered research pool, not a count of all directory listings.
TherapyDen Lists Five Reasons to Cancel Psychology Today
TherapyDen published '5 Reasons to Cancel your Psychology Today Listing,' arguing that the directory's search is clunky and lacks useful filters, that its magazine features almost no people of color, that its website button redirects through Psychology Today instead of passing a backlink, that it omits local insurance companies, and that its owner Sussex Directories is based in the Cayman Islands and may not pay its fair share of taxes. It estimated that roughly 80,000 therapists paying about $30 a month bring Sussex Directories about $29 million a year. The author, who runs a competing directory, also listed reasons to keep a listing.
TherapyDen Launches as Inclusive Alternative Directory
TherapyDen launched as a direct response to Psychology Today's perceived shortcomings, with search filters for categories Psychology Today lacked, such as gender identity, racial identity, immigration and political climate. Its founder called the main existing directory dated and clunky and positioned TherapyDen as a more inclusive alternative.
Psychology Today Adds Non-Binary Gender Option After Petition
Psychology Today added non-binary to its directory's therapist gender options days after TherapyDen, Gaylesta and Bay Area Open Minds posted a petition asking for a third gender option, which neared 2,000 signatures. TherapyDen's founder, who wrote the petition, said earlier emails asking for the change had been ignored. The account comes from TherapyDen, a competing directory.
Sessions Telehealth Platform Launched During COVID
Psychology Today launched Sessions, an in-house HIPAA-compliant video therapy platform available exclusively to paying directory members. While the platform addressed a real need during COVID-19 telehealth expansion, it also deepened lock-in: therapists who built their telehealth practice on Sessions became more dependent on maintaining their Psychology Today listing. Psychology Today support staff said the BAA covered only Sessions itself, not the therapist profile, whose contact feature turned messages from prospective clients into conventional, nonsecure emails sent to the therapist.
Therapist Advocates Question Lack of BAAs for Directory
Mentor Research Institute published an analysis arguing that therapist locator services that handle prospective patients' contact information should offer Business Associate Agreements, noting that many, including Psychology Today, do not. The authors warned that directory search and messaging data could identify people seeking mental health care, and noted that Psychology Today's directory operator was chartered in the Cayman Islands.
Monarch Directory Launches as Scaled Competitor
SimplePractice launched Monarch, a therapist directory with the scale to challenge Psychology Today. It was backed by SimplePractice's more than 100,000 provider subscribers, giving it a large base of listings from the start. Prospective clients could see real-time therapist availability and request an appointment instantly when a therapist enabled the optional schedule visibility and immediate booking features.
TherapyDen Campaign Exposes Directory Diversity Failures
TherapyDen published a critique titled 'Why Do Therapists Still Support the Incredibly Problematic Psychology Today?' pointing to the company's Cayman Islands base and its magazine's lack of diversity: a linked cover analysis found 86% of covers featured only young, thin, white people and 68% only young, white, thin women. The post urged therapists to cancel their listings and switch to alternative directories.
Cancellation Process Documented as Requiring Email Only
A cancellation guide documented that canceling a Psychology Today listing is done by emailing therapist@psychologytoday.com rather than through a self-service option on the website, with two confirmation emails following. It noted that deactivated members remain on Psychology Today's mailing list and keep receiving follow-up emails.
Rula Offers to Create and Manage Psychology Today Profiles for Its Therapists
Rula's therapist help center told its clinicians that it cannot take over their existing Psychology Today profiles but will create and manage a new one for them, listing Rula's support phone number and email as the contact details, and may deactivate such profiles at its discretion. Platform-managed profiles of this kind, run by Rula, Alma, Grow, Headway-linked practices and others, later came to crowd the directory's local search results alongside therapists' own listings.
Investigation Exposes Native Advertising as Editorial Content
An Autside Substack investigation documented how Psychology Today's contributor articles increasingly function as undisclosed advertisements. A highlighted example was an article about learning disabilities written by the CEO of Dysolve, a company selling a $389/month dyslexia product, published without any financial interest disclosure. The investigation characterized Psychology Today as having become 'a vehicle for undisclosed marketing, exploiting its audience under the guise of professional expertise.'
Therapists Report Unexplained Drops in Directory Ranking
By early 2025, therapists in online forums reported that their Psychology Today visibility had shifted without explanation. One wrote that after usually appearing on the first page or two for her zip code, she was 'buried to page 6 or 7, if I'm lucky.' Psychology Today gives therapists no explanation of how profiles are ranked.
Court Lets Privacy Class Action Over Google Analytics on Therapist Searches Proceed
In R.C. v. Sussex Publishers (N.D. Cal., removed to federal court in May 2024), plaintiffs alleged that Google Analytics, embedded on psychologytoday.com without IP anonymization, sent Google the filters they used to find a therapist, including symptoms, type of treatment, faith, zip code and insurer. Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley denied Sussex Publishers' motion to dismiss the California Medical Information Act, Penal Code 632 eavesdropping and state constitutional privacy claims, dismissed the CCPA claim without leave to amend, and dismissed the Penal Code 631 claim with leave to amend.
Consumer Review Site Shows 2.3-Star Rating
SmartCustomer (formerly Sitejabber) showed Psychology Today with a 2.3-star rating from 73 reviews. Most complaints came from people frustrated that therapists listed in the directory did not respond to calls or emails; one professional said Psychology Today charged her after refusing her membership.
Revenue Analysis Estimates $100M Annual Business
The Hemingway Report estimated that Psychology Today generates over $100 million a year across three revenue streams: about $81 million from roughly 225,000 therapist directory listings at $30 a month, about $10 million from print and website sponsorship and advertising, and about $16.5 million from magazine sales (275,000 circulation at $10 an issue, six issues a year). The figures are the newsletter's own estimates; it described the listings product as very high-margin. It also cited Michael Fulwiler's analysis that in February 2025, 35% of all outgoing traffic from Psychology Today went to Headway and a further 7% to Alma, and Semrush data showing the site's traffic peaked during COVID and declined after 2020.
Tech Companies Found Creating Profiles Without Therapist Consent
Therapy Marketer reported that, according to a therapist on Reddit, Rula set up a Psychology Today profile in the therapist's name without their knowledge. The profile linked to the Rula website instead of the therapist's own site, so prospective clients searching for the therapist were sent to Rula.
ClearHealthCosts Reports Therapist Accounts of Falling Psychology Today Referrals
ClearHealthCosts reported that therapists in several regions saw sharp drops in Psychology Today referrals. One East Coast therapist reported a 50% drop and said she had called or emailed every senior person on Psychology Today's staff without getting answers; another noted referrals went from 5-10 monthly to 1 every other month. The article also described Grow Therapy's policy of creating a Grow-managed Psychology Today profile for its providers unless they opted out. Psychology Today denied a system-wide decline, saying 'overall traffic to the site — and total contacts to therapists — has remained strong throughout this period,' and that it periodically updates its algorithms to provide 'more balanced choice.' The reporting relies on anecdotes from therapists who spoke anonymously.
Follow-Up Investigation Documents Steep Drops in Therapist Contacts and Profile Views
A ClearHealthCosts follow-up drew on anonymous therapists' profile data. One California LMFT's contacts fell from 357 in 2021 to 40 in 2025, and her profile views fell from 32,000 in 2020 to 2,600 in 2025; she said spam calls from service providers now make up 90% of her Psychology Today referrals. A California PsyD who runs a group practice saw his profile views fall from 130 in 2021 to 28 in 2025. The article also reported that Octave required at least one job applicant to consent to having profiles created on external directories, including Psychology Today. Psychology Today said it does not give an advantage to platform therapists' profiles.
Judge Rejects Psychology Today Publisher's Bid to Escape Privacy Claim as an LLC
Judge Corley denied Sussex Publishers' motion for judgment on the pleadings, rejecting its argument that, as a limited liability company, it is not a 'person' that can be held liable under the California Invasion of Privacy Act for its use of Google Analytics. The ruling followed a June 2025 order letting the plaintiffs' amended wiretapping claim proceed.
Platform-Managed Profiles Crowd Listings and Linger After Therapists Leave
ClearHealthCosts reported that platforms such as Alma, Rula, Octave and Grow, along with national networks like LifeStance and Thriveworks, were filling Psychology Today listings with managed profiles, often in addition to therapists' own profiles. A Williamsburg, Va., social worker found hundreds of listings in her zip codes, many for therapists located elsewhere. A practice consultant said platform-managed profiles stay up for months after therapists leave the platform and that Psychology Today was not helpful in removing them. Psychology Today did not respond to a request for comment.
Grow Therapy Makes Its Psychology Today Profiles Opt-In
Grow Therapy, which sponsors and manages Psychology Today profiles for its providers, switched the program to opt-in from June 1, 2026, after earlier creating Grow-managed profiles unless providers opted out. Grow's help center describes the program as a 'partnership with Psychology Today,' says calls and emails to Grow-managed profiles are handled by its own booking team, and notes that Psychology Today labels such profiles 'Managed by Grow Therapy' and no longer allows virtual addresses.
Google Analytics Privacy Suit Against Psychology Today Publisher Closes
The federal docket for R.C. v. Sussex Publishers shows the case closed on July 22, 2026, after the court had set an early summary judgment schedule and parties had filed sealing motions in May 2026. The filings that closed it are not publicly available, so whether it settled or was dismissed is not known.
Evidence (43 citations)
D1: User Value Erosion
D2: Business Customer Exploitation
D3: Shareholder Extraction
D4: Lock-in & Switching Costs
D5: Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
D6: Dark Patterns
D7: Advertising & Monetization Pressure
D8: Competitive Conduct
D9: Labor & Governance
D10: Regulatory & Legal Posture
Scoring Log (6 entries)
Checked all 20 candidates: 0 fully restored, 3 partly restored, 16 confirmed removed, 1 already present. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:remove:8: Heather Kugelmass Princeton working paper documents approximately 30,000 eligible directory providers in September 2015 after exclusions; no support for 2014 $15-20 million revenue, reinvestment or offshore routing. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:1: CiNii Journals confirms 1990-1991 suspension and January/February 1992 bimonthly resumption; exact December 1989 issue inaccessible. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:18: Psychotherapy Notes June 2021 confirms optional live availability and immediate booking; $49 inclusion is later, and rename already present. ALREADY PRESENT timeline:update:24: Grow opt-out management and Octave applicant consent are in separate ClearHealthCosts items; inflation of total listing count is unproved. Remaining dropped details stay out. The ad partner list, $29M TherapyDen estimate, inclusive filters, referral declines, ranking opacity and platform-managed listings remain documented in current items. Original pages read, archives attempted for unsupported sources; failed archive, captcha and 403/999 responses were treated as access limits. Search leads to individual reviews, commercial profile aggregators and vendor promotion did not qualify as restoring evidence. Per-candidate dropped details, verdicts and sources are in work/restore-verdicts.json.
47→37. Since Feb 2026: ClearHealthCosts follow-ups (Jan, Mar 2026) on referral declines and platform-managed profiles crowding results; Google Analytics privacy class action (R.C. v. Sussex Publishers) lost a judgment-on-pleadings bid Feb 2026 and closed July 2026 on undisclosed terms; Grow made its Psychology Today profiles opt-in June 2026; directory privacy policy updated Mar 2026; no fee change, no enforcement action. D1 5→4 (correction: ads on directory pages and the Choosing Therapy 'declining value' claim removed; '90% spam' is one therapist's), D2 6→5 (correction: 'soonest available' algorithm change was UnitedHealthcare's; fee flat since 2004, no take rate), D3 4→3 (correction: '21 employees' revenue-per-employee argument unsupported; no buybacks/layoffs), D4 5→4 (recalibration: monthly membership, multi-homing common, rivals exist; network effect only), D5 5→4 (correction: soonest-available change removed; remaining evidence is ranking-drop reports plus PT's 'periodic updates'), D6 4→3 (correction: no-phone, continued billing, 20-minute cancellation removed; email-only cancellation remains), D7 6→4 (correction: no ad tags on directory pages, 2016 ad expansion removed; ads confined to editorial site), D8 5→3 (recalibration: dominance from search, no acquisitions or exclusionary acts). D9, D10 unchanged (D10 now also rests on the class action). Eras: 'Directory Launch' kept; 'SEO Dominance Built' re-dated 2010-06-01→2010-08-05 (call-tracking rollout); 'COVID Demand Peak' re-dated 2020-03-01→2020-09-17 (Sessions launch) and relabeled 'Sessions Telehealth Era'; 'Platform Crowding' (2024-06-01) and 'Referral Collapse' (2026-02-28, an assessment date) merged, re-dated 2024-02-01 (Rula profile program) and relabeled 'Platform-Crowded Directory'. Trajectory kept worsening on continued referral-decline and crowding reports through 2026. Category 'Telehealth' fits poorly (product is a therapist directory plus magazine); flagging only.
Checked 68 items (28 timeline, 34 evidence, 3 milestones, 3 alternatives) + all prose. 13 verified, 39 corrected (19 date-only), 10 re-sourced, 6 removed. Invented (contradicted): Psychology Today 'soonest available' algorithm change (CHC Jan 2026 attributes it to UnitedHealthcare); Sitejabber '1.3-star' rating (SmartCustomer/Sitejabber shows 2.3 from the same 73 reviews); Choosing Therapy review 'documenting declining value' (review rates PT 4/5 and recommends it). Unsupported and trimmed: 96.2% top-Google rate, 21 employees, 4,000 contributors, 2014 $15-20M revenue, 2016 ad expansion and ads on directory pages, Glassdoor 4.1/85%, PissedConsumer figures, 20-minute cancellation, continued billing, no phone support, 95,000-to-6,000 view drop, TherapyDen 140+ filters, Zencare price. Fixed Monarch launch (2021, not 2024), Perina start (2003), Hemingway date (June 2025), Kanazawa petition (75,000 members), Open Path fee ($65).
Added 2 missing dimension narratives