Substack

Substack is a newsletter publishing platform that enables writers to send email newsletters directly to subscribers with built-in paid subscription tools. The platform combines simple publishing with payment processing, providing writers with a 10% commission model on paid subscriptions.

31/ 100
Early Warning
1No Decay↓Worsening

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-25. Score revised 2026-10-25: 32 → 31.

Score History

MilestoneCriticalMajor
Writer-First Launch (2017–2020) · 5/100Writer-First LaunchPandemic Newsletter Boom (2020–2021) · 9/100PandemicPlatform Expansion (2021–2023) · 14/100Platform ExpansionSocial Network Pivot (2023–2025) · 21/100Social Network PivotUnicorn Monetization (2025–present) · 31/100UnicornMonetization100755025020182020202220242026-10Writer-First Launch (2017–2020) · 5/100Pandemic Newsletter Boom (2020–2021) · 9/100Platform Expansion (2021–2023) · 14/100Social Network Pivot (2023–2025) · 21/100Unicorn Monetization (2025–present) · 31/10059142131MilestonesLaunched (2017)Series A ($15.3M) (2019)Series B ($65M) (2021)Acquired Letter (2021)Series C ($100M) (2025)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Writer-First Launch
5/100
2017-10-16 – 2020-03-31

Substack launched its first publication, Bill Bishop's Sinocism, in October 2017 as a stripped-down newsletter tool that took 10% of paid subscriptions via Stripe, and opened its tools to all writers in February 2018. There was no feed, social layer or advertising, and writers could export their email lists at any time. The July 2019 a16z-led $15.3M Series A brought venture backing and plans to hire and build more writer tools.

Pandemic Newsletter Boom
9/100+4
2020-03-31 – 2021-03-18

The era opened with $100,000 in hardship grants for writers as pandemic media layoffs pushed journalists toward independent newsletters; paid subscribers passed 250,000 by December 2020. A July 2020 privacy-policy email exposed users' addresses in the CC field, and Substack's December 2020 moderation statement drew Lawfare scrutiny of its discovery tools and founder-controlled enforcement. The product stayed ad-free and email-first.

Platform Expansion
14/100+5
2021-03-18 – 2023-04-05

The March 2021 revelation of undisclosed Pro advances, followed by the $65M Series B at about a $650M valuation, opened a venture-funded expansion: acquisitions of People & Company, Letter, Cocoon's team and Yem, one million paid subscriptions by November 2021, and writer-curated Recommendations in April 2022. The 2022 downturn stalled it: Substack dropped a planned Series C, cut 14% of staff, and in March 2023 turned to a community fundraise at a lower $585M pre-money valuation.

Social Network Pivot
21/100+7
2023-04-05 – 2025-07-17

Notes turned Substack into a social network with an algorithmic feed, and a September 2023 app redesign made discovery the primary interface. CEO Chris Best's April 2023 Decoder interview and The Atlantic's November 2023 Nazi-newsletter investigation began a moderation controversy; Substack's refusal to proactively remove such content drove Platformer and others away. A February 2024 ad-sales pilot, live video, a $20M Creator Accelerator Fund and nearly 3,000 self-reported migrations to Beehiiv marked a broader, more contested platform.

Unicorn Monetization
31/100+10
2025-07-17 – present

The $100M Series C at a $1.1B valuation in July 2025 opened a monetization push: iOS in-app purchases with Apple's fee on top of Substack's 10%, a sequential-model feed, a December 2025 no-commission sponsorship pilot that became a national-brand program with a dedicated head of sponsorships in June 2026, and podcast dynamic ad insertion previewed in October 2026. A breach disclosed in February 2026, the Guardian's finding that recommendations surfaced Nazi newsletters, and a March 2026 Paris court penalty of €344,000 for failing to remove content as ordered also marked the period. Writers kept leaving over the 10% cut, while new feed controls and full email export remained counterweights.

Alternatives

Ghost10/100

Open-source newsletter and publishing platform with no platform revenue cut on paid subscriptions; payment-processing fees still apply, and managed hosting has a monthly fee. Supports ActivityPub federation, recommendations and social-web discovery. Moderate switch — Substack email-list export is straightforward, while setup and customization may take more work.

Simple, developer-friendly newsletter tool focused on email publishing and Markdown-based writing. Free for the first 100 subscribers, with paid plans based on active subscriber count and optional features. Buttondown takes no cut of paid subscriptions; credit-card processing fees apply. Easy switch for writers seeking an email-first publishing tool.

Beehiiv29/100

Substack alternative with a free tier, paid subscription tools and an opt-in ad network. Takes 0% of paid-subscription revenue, with hosting plans and Stripe processing fees charged separately. Easy switch — Substack allows email-list export. Beehiiv’s CEO said nearly 1,000 creators self-reported migrating from Substack between January and March 2025.

In the News

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Substack's core product, email newsletters readers subscribe to, is still free for readers and largely ad-free, and Substack keeps adding tools, including reply filtering, subscriber perks and, in October 2026, feed content preferences. The app now centers an algorithmic feed of Notes, video and recommended creators. Writer commentary describes exposure to unfollowed creators and steep growth drops in 2025, though these are creator accounts, not measured platform-wide findings. A breach disclosed in February 2026 exposed users' email addresses and phone numbers, and iOS app prices are raised by default to cover Apple's fee. These are minor-to-moderate annoyances; the core reading workflow is intact.
How It Got Here
Substack launched in 2017 as a minimal newsletter tool with no feed, no multimedia and a clean reading experience, and in February 2018 opened its tools to any writer. It stayed writing-focused through the 2020–21 pandemic boom, when simplicity was its selling point against social media. The shift began with Notes in April 2023 and a September 2023 app redesign that put discovery feeds ahead of inbox reading. Live video followed in September 2024 and a TV app with a TikTok-style 'For You' row in January 2026. In late 2025 Substack described a feed-retrieval model change, and writers reported more exposure to unfamiliar creators; Veronica Llorca-Smith reported that many writers had seen subscriber growth drop 80–90%, a creator account rather than a measured platform-wide finding. iOS app prices rise by default to cover Apple's fee, and a breach disclosed in February 2026 exposed users' email addresses and phone numbers. Against that, Substack has kept shipping tools: reply filtering, subscriber perks and, in October 2026, content preferences that let readers dial video, longform and topics up or down and mute keywords. The core email newsletter still works as it did; the app around it increasingly resembles the social media Substack was built to escape.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2017Writer-First Launch2020Pandemic Newsletter Boom2021Platform Expansion2023Social Network Pivot2025Unicorn MonetizationUser Value00123Biz Exploit11223Shareholder01223Lock-in11223Algorithms01134Dark Patterns00112Advertising00014Competition11122Labor/Gov12233Regulatory12234
Timeline (45 events)
major2017-10-16

Substack Launches as Simple Newsletter Publishing Tool

Substack launched its first publication, Bill Bishop's Sinocism, on October 16, 2017. Its founders were Chris Best, Hamish McKenzie, and Jairaj Sethi. The platform offered email newsletter publishing with a 10% commission on paid subscriptions via Stripe. Substack later reported that Bishop generated six figures of revenue on his first day. The company subsequently went through Y Combinator in 2018.

minor2018-02-06

Substack Opens Publishing Tools to All Writers

Substack opened its publishing, analytics and subscription tools to anyone wanting to create a free or paid newsletter, after working with a small invite-only group of writers.

major2019-07-16

Andreessen Horowitz Leads $15.3M Series A

Substack raised $15.3 million in a Series A round led by Andreessen Horowitz (a16z), with a16z partner Andrew Chen joining the board. Y Combinator also participated. Substack planned to hire a larger team and build more tools to support writers.

minor2020-03-31

Substack Launches $100K Writer Grants During Pandemic

On March 31, 2020, Substack announced $100,000 in grants of $500-$5,000 to independent writers experiencing financial hardship during the pandemic. Applications opened that day and closed April 7. The program positioned Substack as support for writers affected by the media industry's crisis.

minor2020-07-28

Privacy Policy Email Exposes User Email Addresses via CC

Substack accidentally exposed users' email addresses when a privacy policy update email was sent with addresses in the CC field instead of BCC. One email chain forwarded to Gizmodo contained 500 addresses. Substack acknowledged the error, calling it 'a genuine mistake' and noting the irony of a privacy breach in a privacy policy notification. The incident highlighted basic data handling gaps at the rapidly growing platform.

minor2020-12-02

Substack Surpasses 250,000 Paying Subscribers

By early December 2020, Substack had more than 250,000 paying subscribers. Its number of active writers had doubled between March and June amid pandemic-era newsletter growth. Casey Newton left The Verge to start Platformer that fall, joining other journalists who had moved from established outlets to newsletters.

minor2021-01-04

Lawfare Analyzes Substack’s Content Moderation Philosophy

Lawfare analyzed Substack's December 2020 content moderation philosophy, questioning its account of virality and its financial incentives. The article discussed rule enforcement, founders' control of moderation decisions, and the need for greater transparency.

major2021-03-18

Substack Pro Advances Program Draws Transparency Criticism

Substack revealed that it paid select writers substantial advances through its Pro program, keeping 85% of subscription revenue in the first year. The company was criticized for not disclosing which writers received subsidies. Some writers accused the platform of subsidizing anti-trans rhetoric through advances to controversial writers.

major2021-03-30

Substack Raises $65M Series B at $650M Valuation

Andreessen Horowitz led Substack's $65 million Series B round at an approximately $650 million valuation. TechCrunch reported that the platform had reached 500,000 paying subscribers in February 2021. The round introduced significant venture capital growth expectations.

minor2021-05-13

Substack Acquires People & Company

Substack announced it had acquired People & Company, a community-building consultancy, to build educational and support programs for writers, including workshops, office hours and training.

minor2021-07-29

Substack Acquires Letter to Support Writer Collaboration

Substack announced that Letter's team had joined the company. Letter hosted written exchanges by authors including Noam Chomsky and Yuval Noah Harari. Its team would help build infrastructure and features for independent writers to collaborate.

major2022-04-01

Substack Launches Recommendation Network

Substack introduced Recommendations in April 2022, letting writers recommend other publications to readers during the signup flow. In its year-end review, Substack reported that Recommendations represented 20% of new free subscriptions. Writers controlled their recommendation lists, while the feature helped build network effects beyond direct email delivery.

major2022-05-27

Substack Abandons Series C Fundraising Plans Amid Market Headwinds

Substack dropped plans to raise a Series C round of $75-100 million at a $750 million-$1 billion valuation amid the 2022 tech downturn. The company had held discussions with potential investors but pulled back as venture investment cooled industrywide. In a March 29, 2023 retrospective analysis, TechCrunch concluded that the targeted $750 million-$1 billion valuation had not cleared the market.

major2022-06-29

Substack Lays Off 14% of Workforce

Substack cut 13 of its 94 employees, about 14% of the workforce, across human resources, support, and operations. CEO Chris Best said the goal was to make the company robust in tough market conditions without relying on raising more money. The layoffs followed its decision to pause fundraising amid the market downturn.

minor2022-09-29

Substack Acquires Newsletter-Growth Startup Yem

Substack acquired Yem, a small startup that helped newsletter writers grow their email lists through marketing campaigns; its fewer than 10 employees joined Substack. Co-founder Hamish McKenzie said the deal was part of an effort to help writers grow audiences through Substack's network.

minor2023-03-28

Substack Opens Community Crowdfunding Round

Following its abandoned 2022 Series C effort, Substack opened a community fundraising round with an initial $2 million target and a $585 million pre-money valuation, down from the $650 million Series B valuation. By TechCrunch's March 30 update, the round had $6,686,954 in pledges. Substack warned that it might reduce individual investments if the round was oversubscribed.

critical2023-04-05

Substack Announces Notes as Twitter Competitor

Substack announced Notes, a short-form social feed resembling Twitter that would let users post text, images, links, and 'restacks' analogous to retweets. The feature expanded Substack beyond newsletter infrastructure toward social networking. Notes became publicly available to all writers and readers on April 11.

major2023-04-08

Twitter Blocks Substack Links After Notes Launch

After Substack announced Notes, Twitter restricted engagement with Substack links, including likes and retweets, and displayed safety warnings. Musk claimed Substack was downloading Twitter data for its rival service; Substack CEO Chris Best denied the claim and said the links had been 'obviously severely throttled.' Matt Taibbi said on April 7 that he would leave Twitter over the restrictions despite his role in the Twitter Files.

major2023-04-13

CEO Refuses to Take Stance on Racist Content in Decoder Interview

In a Decoder podcast interview with Nilay Patel of The Verge, Substack CEO Chris Best refused to say whether he would remove explicitly racist content from Notes, stating he would not 'engage in speculation' about specific content moderation scenarios. The interview raised fundamental questions about whether Substack was prepared for content moderation demands of operating a consumer social network.

major2023-09-20

Substack Redesigns Mobile App to Prioritize Discovery

Substack overhauled its mobile app with a redesigned Home experience featuring a reading queue, discovery feed with Notes and post recommendations, and ability to follow writers without subscribing. The redesign prioritized engagement and content discovery over simple email consumption, moving the app closer to a social media experience.

critical2023-11-28

Atlantic Investigation Reveals Substack's Nazi Content Problem

Journalist Jonathan M. Katz published 'Substack Has a Nazi Problem' in The Atlantic, identifying at least 16 newsletters with overt Nazi symbols, including swastikas and the sonnenrad, alongside scores of white-supremacist, neo-Confederate, and explicitly Nazi newsletters.

critical2024-01-09

Substack Refuses to Proactively Remove Nazi Content

After weeks of pressure from writers, Substack co-founder Hamish McKenzie posted that 'we don't like Nazis either' but argued 'censorship makes the problem worse.' Substack removed a handful of newsletters for inciting violence but refused to change its content policy text or proactively remove neo-Nazi publications. The response triggered a wave of high-profile departures.

major2024-01-11

Platformer Leaves Substack Over Content Moderation Stance

Casey Newton's Platformer announced that it would leave Substack over its handling of pro-Nazi material and migrate to the nonprofit, open-source platform Ghost. Newton wrote that Substack had not changed its policy or committed explicitly to removing pro-Nazi material; subscribers would be transferred to the new platform.

major2024-02-06

Substack Pilots Ad-Sales Support for Creators

Axios reported that Substack confirmed an experimental pilot helping creators find advertisers and coordinate ad buys. For the Blocked and Reported podcast, Substack supplied host-read ads, with the hosts keeping veto power; a spokesperson said the test explored whether advertising and subscriptions could coexist.

major2024-09-18

Substack Launches Live Video Streaming Feature

Substack began rolling out live video in its mobile app, enabling creators to stream live to subscribers, paywall streams for paid subscribers, and co-host with other creators. Initially available to bestsellers, the feature expanded Substack further from its newsletter origins into a multimedia platform competing with YouTube and Patreon for creator engagement.

minor2024-11-12

Substack Raises About $10 Million from Strategic Investors

Axios reported that Substack had quietly raised around $10 million from strategic investors, including Omeed Malik and Nate Silver.

major2025-01-23

Substack Launches $20M Creator Accelerator Fund

Substack announced a $20 million Creator Accelerator Fund guaranteeing revenue for creators migrating from Patreon, Supercast, and other subscription platforms. Eligibility required U.S. residency and $2,000+ monthly recurring revenue, concentrating benefits among established creators. The fund launched amid the TikTok ban uncertainty, positioning Substack as an alternative for displaced creators.

major2025-04-01

Second Wave of Creator Departures Over Ideological Shift

Digiday reported a second wave of writers leaving or considering leaving Substack amid concerns about its association with politically extreme voices and its leadership’s ideological messaging. Beehiiv CEO Tyler Denk said nearly 3,000 creators had self-reported migrating from Substack to Beehiiv in the preceding year, including nearly 1,000 between January and March 2025.

critical2025-07-17

Substack Raises $100M Series C at $1.1B Unicorn Valuation

Substack raised $100 million in Series C funding at a valuation of more than $1.1 billion, with BOND, The Chernin Group, Andreessen Horowitz and other investors participating. Axios reported total funding of roughly $200 million. Substack had said earlier in 2025 that it surpassed 5 million paid subscriptions. BOND’s Mood Rowghani would join its board. The funding increased investor expectations for growth.

critical2025-08-18

Substack Enables iOS In-App Purchases Alongside U.S. Web Payment Links

Substack announced in-app purchases for all paid publications on iOS, alongside external web-payment links for U.S. readers. Apple collects a percentage of IAP payments in addition to Substack’s fee. By default, Substack raises iOS prices to preserve approximately the creator’s web-subscription earnings; creators can turn that adjustment off.

minor2025-10-20

Substack Adds Age Checks to Comply With UK and Australian Laws

Substack said it would label certain categories of content and require readers in the U.K. to verify their age before viewing it, under the Online Safety Act, with Australia following on December 10, 2025. Paid subscribers with a card on file count as verified. Substack said it cautions against such laws but complies where required, and applies the restrictions only in those countries.

major2025-10-29

Top Substack Writers Move to Patreon

Nieman Lab reported that Anne Helen Petersen, Lyz Lenz and Virginia Sole-Smith had moved their newsletters from Substack to Patreon. Lenz said she was about 70% of the way to her former Substack paid-subscriber rate within two weeks on Patreon.

major2025-10-31

Substack Describes Shift to Sequential Feed Recommendations

Substack’s head of machine learning Mike Cohen described a rebuild of the app feed’s recommendation system from static two-tower retrieval models to sequential models using the order of readers’ interactions. He said all core retrieval tasks had moved to sequential models and that migration of ranking models would continue in the coming months. The feed could recommend posts, Notes, publications and accounts to follow based on a reader’s current session as well as past interests.

critical2025-12-09

Substack Launches Native Sponsorship Advertising Pilot

Substack began testing a native sponsorship program allowing a small, selected group of writers to insert paid brand placements into newsletters. Participation was opt-in and creators retained control; Substack would take no revenue share during testing. It formalized sponsorships writers had previously arranged independently, while retaining subscriptions at the center of the business.

major2026-01-22

Substack Launches TV App with TikTok-Style Feed

Substack launched a TV app for Apple TV and Google TV, where subscribers could watch creators’ video posts and livestreams according to their subscription tier. It included a TikTok-like “For You” row with videos from subscribed creators and recommended videos. The app extended Substack’s multimedia presence into the living room as it competed with YouTube and Patreon.

major2026-02-05

Substack Confirms Breach of User Emails and Phone Numbers

Substack told users that an unauthorized third party had accessed email addresses, phone numbers and internal metadata in October 2025; it identified the issue only in February 2026. CEO Chris Best said the company had fixed the problem and begun an investigation; passwords, card numbers and financial data were not affected. Substack did not say how many users were affected.

critical2026-02-07

Guardian Investigation: Substack Algorithm Amplifies Paid Nazi Newsletters

A Guardian investigation revealed Substack continued to earn its ~10% cut from paid Nazi, Holocaust-denial, and antisemitic newsletters, including NatSocToday ($80/year, ~2,800 subscribers, swastika profile image). Critically, within two hours of subscribing to one such newsletter, Substack's recommendation algorithm surfaced 21 additional profiles featuring similar extremist content. The article recalled co-founder Hamish McKenzie's 2023 statement that 'we don't like Nazis either' and his argument against demonetization, and reported condemnation from the Holocaust Educational Trust and confirming the moderation problem first exposed by The Atlantic in 2023 remained unremediated. Substack did not respond to the Guardian’s request for comment.

major2026-03-18

Paris Court Orders Substack to Pay €344,000 for Ignoring Takedown Order

A January 24, 2024 Paris Court of Appeal ruling ordered Substack to remove private correspondence and defamatory passages, or make them inaccessible, under a €1,000-per-day penalty. Substack geo-blocked the content in France instead, and argued that VPN circumvention was beyond its control. The Paris judicial court found the content still accessible, held the order unmet, and liquidated the penalty at €344,000 for March 4, 2025 to February 11, 2026, plus €2,000 in costs.

major2026-05-10

The Verge Reports Writers Fleeing the 'Substack Tax'

The Verge reported a new wave of writers moving to Ghost, Beehiiv and other rivals, citing Substack's 10% cut of subscription revenue and its growing focus on social features. One creator said he paid $2,052 a year on Ghost with an add-on, versus $4,968 on Substack; the article also noted The Ankler's April move to Passport.

major2026-06-15

Substack Expands Native Sponsorship Program With National Brands

Substack announced a new stage of its native sponsorships program with advertisers including Uber, T-Mobile, Balenciaga, Whatnot, Polymarket, Granola and Yahoo Scout. CEO Chris Best said these brands would invest millions of dollars in participating creators and described direct partnerships in which creators choose partners and retain creative direction and editorial independence. Substack also launched Creator Kits, a media-kit tool for publishers to share publication details with potential sponsors. Specific agreement terms were not disclosed.

major2026-06-15

Substack Hires First Head of Brand Sponsorships

Substack hired Dan Robbins, who held senior advertising and commerce roles at PayPal, Roku and Nielsen, as its first head of brand sponsorships. The hire signaled advertising becoming a dedicated revenue stream alongside Substack’s 10% subscription commission, following the company’s $1.1 billion valuation. The appointment marked a strategic shift for a company that built its business championing subscriptions over advertising.

minor2026-09-29

Appeals Court Affirms Anti-SLAPP Win for Substack in Blackman Case

The California Court of Appeal affirmed orders granting anti-SLAPP motions by Substack, journalist Jack Poulson and Tech Inquiry in Maury Blackman's suit over the publication of a police report on his sealed arrest. It also affirmed the related attorney-fee award.

minor2026-10-06

Substack Terms Add Political-Contribution and Sales-Tax Rules

Substack's updated Terms of Use let U.S. candidates and political committees sell subscriptions as campaign contributions. Readers must provide their name, address, occupation and employer, which campaign law may require to be publicly disclosed. The terms also say local VAT, GST, sales or use tax may be added to subscription prices from December 1, 2026.

major2026-10-14

Substack Adds Feed Content Preferences

Substack launched content preferences that let readers see more or less video, audio, longform or community content, mute keywords and phrases, fine-tune followed topics and automatically label AI-generated material. It said the app had driven nearly 800,000 paid and more than 80 million free subscriptions in the previous six months.

major2026-10-21

Substack Previews Podcast Sponsorships and Dynamic Ad Insertion

Substack announced that sponsorships are coming to podcasts it hosts, and opened early-access signups for dynamic ad insertion so podcasters can run and update sponsor campaigns across back catalogs. It also said podcasters will soon be able to fill marked ad breaks through optional third-party sponsorship marketplaces.

Evidence (63 citations)

D1: User Value Erosion

Scoring Log (7 entries)
regrade2026-10-25RESCORED

32→31. D5 5→4 (recalibration: limited transparency with published signal explanations and real user controls (Following feed, show-less, Oct 2026 content preferences) fits 4–5 low end; Guardian finding is a content harm, not undisclosed manipulation), D9 4→3 (recalibration: no layoffs during profits, labor disputes or pay-ratio issues; moderation-governance concern sits at top of 2–3 band), D10 3→4 (event: Mar 2026 Paris court €344,000 penalty for geo-blocking instead of removing ordered content; Feb 2026 breach detected months late). Eras: all 5 re-dated to inflection events — Writer-First Launch 2017-10-01→2017-10-16 (launch), Pandemic Newsletter Boom 2020-06-01→2020-03-31 (pandemic grants), Platform Expansion 2022-04-01→2021-03-18 (Pro advances/Series B; summary rewritten so Series B, Letter and Cocoon fall inside it), Social Network Pivot 2023-09-01→2023-04-05 (Notes), Unicorn Monetization 2026-06-29→2025-07-17 (Series C); every era re-scored. Since Jun 2026 (last rescore; 12-month sweep from Oct 2025): UK/Australia age checks (Oct 2025), breach disclosed (Feb 2026), Paris €344k penalty (Mar 2026), Verge-reported fee exodus and Ankler move (Apr–May 2026), Blackman anti-SLAPP affirmed (Sep 2026), ToS political-contribution/tax terms (Oct 6), feed content preferences (Oct 14), podcast dynamic ad insertion preview (Oct 21). Candidates skipped as minor or duplicate: Polymarket embeds, iOS branded spaces, design/Notes tooling, Reply Rules, subscriber perks, creator match, Pangram AI scan, privacy-policy/Publisher Agreement wording updates, Canada hire, CPJ Legal Defender case, N.D. Cal. Section 230 dismissal, duplicate breach and podcast/content-preference items. Category 'Publishing' looks right.

restore-check2026-10-25RESTORED

Checked all 3 candidates against the current regraded product. PARTLY RESTORED timeline:update:9 (current index 12): TechCrunch March 29, 2023 retrospective analysis says the 2022 target price did not clear; added an explicitly attributed sentence and its supporting evidence item. Quartz March 28, 2023 also describes fundraising struggles in 2022, but neither establishes inability to find any investors. CONFIRMED REMOVED timeline:update:11 (current index 15): read original TechCrunch March 28 report, Quartz March 28, and TechCrunch March 3 and March 29 analyses. They do not establish inability to raise traditional capital or continuing institutional skepticism; the March 29 valuation critique is the journalist's hypothetical, not reported investor sentiment. Pledges and the separate Quartz legal-cap evidence are already retained; no duplicate restoration. CONFIRMED REMOVED evidence:update:5 (current index 5): read Daigest February 11, 2026 marketing post, Digiday April 1, 2025 original interview, and The Verge May 10, 2026 reporting. Digiday attributes nearly 3,000 migrations to Beehiiv self-reports over the preceding year, with nearly 1,000 in January-March 2025; it does not attribute most migrations to fees. The Verge supports individual fee-related departures already covered by the regrade, not the disputed aggregate. Daigest marketing alone is ineligible evidence. Research: each original URL read live; explicit Wayback requests for all three failed and are not evidence; three search queries per candidate (exact phrase, phrase/company, origin and date drift). NYT original and Press Gazette fetches were blocked, so no factual conclusions rely on them. Added evidence verdict: PARTLY RESTORED, TechCrunch (Alex Wilhelm analysis), March 29, 2023. No removals or score changes.

fact-audit2026-10-24FABRICATION FOUND

Checked every original timeline, evidence, milestone and alternative item plus fields and prose; accepted 19 quote-check ACCEPT items without redundant review and resolved all 57 FIX/1 REVIEW. No events removed. Rescued misdated/miscited real details through re-sourcing and twelve evidence splits. Invented detail: Buttondown 5% revenue cut; official https://buttondown.com/features/paid-subscriptions explicitly says no revenue cut. Unsupported details trimmed: failure to find investors as established May 2022 outcome; continuing institutional skepticism in March 2023; most of the nearly 3,000 migrations caused by fees. Other apparent inventions were recovered, including 80–90%,30%-of-2024,one-million subscriptions, first-day revenue, grant/layoff/petition counts and $20,000 sponsorship economics. Thirty distinct prose claims corrected; duplicate review retained separate program-launch and executive-hire events.

Rescore2026-06-29
Previous score: 28

Periodic rescore: native sponsorship program moved from pilot to full launch with national advertisers and first head of brand sponsorships (D7 2→4); Feb 2026 Guardian investigation found algorithm amplifying paid Nazi newsletters (D5 4→5, D9 3→4). Extended Unicorn Monetization era. 28→32.

Deep Enrichment2026-03-13
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-11