Tidal

Tidal is a subscription music streaming service offering lossless and hi-res audio quality. Originally relaunched by artist-owners including Jay-Z, it came under the majority ownership of Square (now Block) in 2021 in a deal announced at $297 million. Tidal pays artists the highest per-stream rate in the industry (~$0.013). It consolidated its tiers into a single plan in April 2024 at $10.99/month, raised to $11.99 in the US in August 2026. Block has announced it is scaling back investment in Tidal in favor of bitcoin mining initiatives.

31/ 100
Early Warning
2Squeezing Users↓Worsening

Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-24. Score revised 2026-10-24: 33 → 31.

Score History

MilestoneCriticalMajor
Aspiro Launch (2014–2015) · 8/100Jay-Z Celebrity Era (2015–2017) · 17/100Jay-Z EraCelebrityInflated Numbers & Scandals (2017–2021) · 23/100Inflated Numbers & ScandalsBlock Acquisition Optimism (2021–2023) · 17/100Block AcquisitionOptimismBlock Austerity Cuts (2023–2024) · 26/100BlockNeglected Subsidiary (2024–2025) · 29/100Negle…Artist Commerce Pivot (2025–present) · 31/100ArtistCommerce…10075502502016202020242026-10Aspiro Launch (2014–2015) · 8/100Jay-Z Celebrity Era (2015–2017) · 17/100Inflated Numbers & Scandals (2017–2021) · 23/100Block Acquisition Optimism (2021–2023) · 17/100Block Austerity Cuts (2023–2024) · 26/100Neglected Subsidiary (2024–2025) · 29/100Artist Commerce Pivot (2025–present) · 31/1008172317262931MilestonesLaunched (2014)Acquired by Jay-Z (2015)Sprint 33% stake (2017)Acquired by Square (2021)Events

Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.

Aspiro Launch
8/100
2014-10-28 – 2015-03-13

Norwegian company Aspiro launched Tidal in the US and UK on October 28, 2014, building on its WiMP service, as an ad-free lossless subscription with curated editorial content. It was a small challenger with few users, and the record shows no extraction, dark patterns or legal trouble. The period ended when Jay-Z's purchase of Aspiro closed in March 2015.

Jay-Z Celebrity Era
17/100+9
2015-03-13 – 2017-01-20

Jay-Z's purchase of Aspiro closed on March 13, 2015, and the March 30 relaunch with 16 artist-owners drew a backlash. CEO Andy Chen left within weeks and his interim successor about three months later. Exclusives such as The Life of Pablo drove sign-ups and piracy, Tidal charged ex-subscribers and reactivated their accounts in January 2016, and 2016 brought lawsuits over songwriter royalties, the Pablo exclusivity claim and the Prince catalog.

Inflated Numbers & Scandals
23/100+6
2017-01-20 – 2021-04-30

In January 2017 Dagens Naeringsliv reported that Tidal had inflated its subscriber numbers, and in May 2018 that about 320 million streams had been faked for Beyonce and Kanye West albums, diverting pro-rata royalties from other artists; Okokrim opened a criminal investigation. Sprint bought a 33% stake, Jay-Z pulled his catalog from Spotify and Apple Music, and a third CEO left in May 2017. The Prince estate and Life of Pablo suits were resolved in 2018 and 2019.

Block Acquisition Optimism
17/100-6
2021-04-30 – 2023-12-07

Square closed its majority purchase on April 30, 2021, paying $237.3 million for 86.2% after announcing a $297 million deal. Tidal launched a free tier and Direct Artist Payouts in November 2021, then shut the payouts in March 2023 after paying $500,000. A Delaware judge dismissed the shareholder suit over the deal in May 2023, Norway dropped the stream-manipulation probe in June 2023, and prices rose in August 2023.

Block Austerity Cuts
26/100+9
2023-12-07 – 2024-11-07

Austerity began with a cut of more than 10% of Tidal's staff on December 7, 2023, followed by a $132.3 million goodwill impairment. In 2024 Tidal removed its free tier while cutting the hi-res price to $10.99, lost Roku, Samsung TV and Plex support, and completed an MQA-to-FLAC transition that left MQA-derived files labeled as FLAC. In October 2024 Dorsey removed product management and product marketing.

Neglected Subsidiary
29/100+3
2024-11-07 – 2025-11-17

On November 7, 2024 Block said it was scaling back its investment in Tidal to redirect resources toward bitcoin mining and its Bitkey wallet, and it recorded $133.8 million more in Tidal impairments for Q4 2024. Block cut 931 jobs in March 2025 in a year it repurchased $2.3 billion of stock, and a May 2025 terms update locked the app until users accepted. Trade press openly asked whether Tidal was on the way out.

Artist Commerce Pivot
31/100+2
2025-11-17 – present

Tidal turned toward artist tools with Tidal Upload on November 17, 2025, direct-to-fan sales in June 2026 (platform fee cut to zero on August 31) and a June 2026 policy denying royalties to wholly AI-generated tracks. Its parent moved the other way on staff and capital: Block raised its buyback authorization by $5 billion in November 2025 and in February 2026 cut more than 40% of its workforce. US prices rose to $11.99 from August 2026.

Alternatives

Lossless, Hi-Res Lossless and Dolby Atmos audio at $10.99/month, a dollar less than Tidal's US Individual plan since its August 2026 increase to $11.99, on a platform that isn't being defunded in favor of bitcoin mining. Easy switch for Apple device users; moderate for others. Playlist transfer tools like SongShift make migration feasible in under an hour.

Spotify52/100

The largest music catalog (100M+ tracks) with the best discovery features and widest device support, at $12.99/month. Lossless streaming up to 24-bit/44.1kHz has been included in Premium since 2025, below Tidal's hi-res ceiling but enough for most listeners. Easy switch — services like Soundiiz can transfer your playlists in minutes.

Dimensional Breakdown

Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.

User Value Erosion
Tidal's core product, lossless and hi-res FLAC streaming with Dolby Atmos, is still strong, and the April 2024 consolidation put hi-res audio into a single $10.99 plan. Around that core the service has narrowed: the free tier was removed in April 2024, support for Roku (May 2024) and Samsung Smart TVs (July 2024) was dropped, Plex ended its integration in October 2024, and users found MQA-derived files labeled as FLAC. Prices rose in August 2023 and again from August 3, 2026, when the US Individual plan went from $10.99 to $11.99 and Family from $16.99 to $19.99. Trustpilot shows a 2.0 TrustScore, with complaints about billing and support.
How It Got Here
Tidal launched in October 2014 as a premium lossless streaming service under Aspiro, offering audiophile-grade quality few rivals matched. Under Jay-Z's ownership from 2015 the audio quality held, though exclusive releases fragmented what subscribers could hear. Square's 2021 acquisition at first added value: a free tier arrived in November 2021. Prices began to climb with the August 2023 increase of the HiFi plan from $9.99 to $10.99. From late 2023 the service narrowed. In April 2024 the free tier and military and first-responder discounts were eliminated, although the same consolidation gave every subscriber hi-res audio for $10.99, a cut from the old $19.99 HiFi Plus price. Platform support was stripped in quick succession: Roku in May 2024, Samsung Smart TVs in July 2024, and Plex's integration in October 2024. The July 2024 move from MQA to open FLAC was sound in principle, but users later found MQA-derived files labeled as FLAC. By 2025 trade press was asking whether Tidal was on its way out, and Trustpilot showed a 2.0 TrustScore. The newest change for listeners is price: from August 3, 2026 the US Individual plan rose to $11.99 and Family to $19.99. The core streaming experience remains strong, which keeps erosion in the moderate range.
Business Customer Exploitation
Shareholder Extraction
Lock-in & Switching Costs
Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
Dark Patterns
Advertising & Monetization Pressure
Competitive Conduct
Labor & Governance
Regulatory & Legal Posture

Dimension History

2014Aspiro Launch2015Jay-Z Celebrity Era2017Inflated Numbers & Scandals2021Block Acquisition Optimism2023Block Austerity Cuts2024Neglected Subsidiary2025Artist Commerce PivotUser Value0111444Biz Exploit1231111Shareholder1112456Lock-in1222222Algorithms1141222Dark Patterns0221333Advertising0001222Competition1232111Labor/Gov2333567Regulatory1343233
Timeline (43 events)
major2014-10-28

Aspiro launches Tidal in US and UK

Norwegian company Aspiro launched its Tidal brand in the US and UK as a premium lossless streaming service, building on its WiMP platform launched in Norway in 2010. Tidal distinguished itself with CD-quality 1,411 kbps FLAC streaming and curated editorial content. Canada followed on December 8, 2014.

critical2015-01-30

Jay-Z bids $56M for Aspiro/Tidal

Jay-Z's Project Panther Bidco Ltd. made a SEK 464 million ($56 million) bid for Aspiro, developer of Tidal and WiMP. Despite some opposition from minority shareholders who believed the bid undervalued Aspiro's growth potential, over 90% of shareholders accepted the offer, which was finalized in March 2015.

critical2015-03-30

Celebrity relaunch with 16 artist-owners

Tidal was relaunched at an event in New York with Jay-Z, Beyonce, Madonna, Kanye West, Rihanna, and 11 other major artists presented as stakeholders. Billboard reported that each artist was offered a 3% stake in order to secure exclusive content, with the artists' combined equity at about 48%. The launch drew swift backlash, with a counter-hashtag (@TIDALforNOONE) trending as critics mocked wealthy artists asking fans to pay premium prices (Hypebot).

major2015-04-17

CEO Andy Chen departs weeks after relaunch

Tidal CEO Andy Chen left the company in April 2015, weeks after the March 30 relaunch, amid layoffs. Former Aspiro CEO Peter Tonstad was named interim CEO, and left about three months later in June 2015 (VentureBeat). This began a period of management instability, with Tidal burning through three CEOs in two years under Jay-Z's ownership.

major2016-01-18

Tidal charges ex-subscribers, reactivates accounts

Tidal was caught charging former subscribers who had cancelled their accounts. The company offered affected users three months of free service as compensation, but this reactivated closed accounts without permission and set them to auto-renew, potentially resuming unwanted charges. Tidal later updated its policy after public backlash.

major2016-02-14

Life of Pablo exclusive sparks piracy wave

Kanye West's The Life of Pablo launched as a Tidal streaming exclusive on February 14, 2016. It was pirated an estimated half a million times in its first 24 hours; TorrentFreak counted more than 10,000 people sharing the most popular copy at once (TechSpot). By some estimates the exclusive more than doubled Tidal's subscriptions, but it also drove massive piracy and drew criticism that streaming exclusivity harmed both fans and artists.

major2016-03-01

Songwriters sue Tidal for $5M over unpaid mechanical royalties

Yesh Music Publishing and John Emanuele of the band American Dollar filed a $5 million class action alleging that Tidal failed to register and pay mechanical royalties for compositions it streamed. Tidal said it was current on royalties and that it had removed their music from the service. The claims were allegations, not findings.

major2016-04-18

Subscriber sues over Life of Pablo 'only on Tidal' claim

A Kanye West fan filed a proposed class action against West and Tidal over the claim that The Life of Pablo would be available only on Tidal, alleging the claim induced people to subscribe. The album was later released on West's website and other streaming services.

major2016-11-16

Prince estate sues over Tidal's streaming of his catalog

Prince's estate and NPG Records sued Roc Nation in federal court in Minnesota over how much of Prince's music Tidal was licensed to stream. The estate said its agreement covered only a 90-day window for the 2015 album Hit N Run: Phase One and sought to stop Tidal streaming the back catalog, plus unspecified damages; Tidal said it had broader licenses.

critical2017-01-20

Norwegian report alleges inflated subscriber numbers

Norwegian newspaper Dagens Naeringsliv reported that Tidal had persistently inflated subscriber numbers. Internal reports reportedly showed 350,000 subscribers in September 2015, the month Jay-Z claimed one million (XXL). When Tidal claimed 3 million users in March 2016, label payments indicated about 850,000 subscribers. The report claims the inflation was achieved partly by reactivating tens of thousands of old accounts, and the numbers may also have included users on free trials.

major2017-01-23

Sprint buys 33% stake for $200 million

Sprint took a 33% stake in Tidal. TechCrunch said the price was not disclosed; Billboard and Music Business Worldwide reported $200 million, valuing Tidal at about $600 million. Sprint CEO Marcelo Claure joined Tidal's board, and the announcement described a marketing fund of $75 million a year for exclusive content and experiences, per Billboard. The deal aimed to offer exclusive Tidal content to Sprint's 45 million subscribers.

major2017-04-07

Jay-Z pulls catalog from Spotify and Apple Music

Jay-Z removed his entire music catalog from Spotify and Apple Music, making Tidal the exclusive streaming home for his discography. The move was widely seen as using artist catalog as a competitive weapon, forcing fans to subscribe to Tidal to hear Jay-Z's music. His music later returned to Apple Music but remained off Spotify until 2019.

major2017-05-26

Third CEO departs in two years

Jeff Toig, who became Tidal's CEO in 2016 after interim CEO Peter Tonstad, departed the company. This marked Tidal's third CEO departure in roughly two years under Jay-Z's ownership, reflecting significant governance instability and strategic confusion at the top of the organization.

minor2017-07-07

Kanye West ends Tidal exclusive deal amid payment dispute

Tidal and Kanye West, one of its original artist-owners, terminated their deal, ending Tidal's exclusive rights to stream his music. According to a TMZ report cited by Engadget, West said Tidal owed him a $3 million bonus for bringing in 1.5 million subscribers and had not reimbursed him for music videos; Tidal denied the reimbursement claim.

critical2018-05-10

Accused of faking 320 million streams

Dagens Naeringsliv reported that Tidal had fabricated approximately 320 million false streams for Beyonce's Lemonade and Kanye West's The Life of Pablo, affecting 1.7 million user accounts. Analysis by the Norwegian University of Science and Technology confirmed data manipulation targeting specific track IDs. Because streaming royalties use a pro-rata model, inflated streams diverted revenue from smaller artists.

D10D5D2
NPR ↗
minor2018-05-11

Tidal and Prince estate settle their legal disputes

Tidal and the Prince Estate announced an agreement for a previously unreleased Prince album to stream exclusively on Tidal for fourteen days, with downloads seven days after its debut. The announcement said the agreement, approved by the probate court on May 9, 2018, concluded the parties' previously unresolved legal matters; terms were not disclosed.

major2019-01-14

Norwegian criminal investigation launched into Tidal

Norway's National Authority for Investigation and Prosecution of Economic and Environmental Crime (Okokrim) confirmed a criminal investigation into Tidal's alleged data fraud. The investigation followed complaints from Norwegian copyright association Tono, artist organization Gramart, independent labels group Fono, and the Musicians' Union over the alleged stream manipulation.

minor2019-01-30

Life of Pablo exclusivity suit dismissed

Kanye West and lead plaintiff Justin Baker-Rhett agreed to dismiss the suit over claims that The Life of Pablo would be exclusive to Tidal: his individual claims with prejudice and the putative class claims without prejudice, each side bearing its own costs. Tidal, West and Baker-Rhett said they had resolved their differences amicably; terms were not disclosed.

critical2021-03-04

Square agrees to acquire majority Tidal stake for $297M

Square (now Block) announced a definitive agreement to acquire a significant majority stake in Tidal for $297 million in cash and stock. Jay-Z was expected to join Square's board subject to closing, and Square executive Jesse Dorogusker was to serve as interim lead of Tidal.

major2021-11-17

Tidal launches free tier and Direct Artist Payouts

Under Square ownership, Tidal launched a free ad-supported tier (US-only) and introduced Direct Artist Payouts, routing up to 10% of HiFi Plus ($19.99) subscribers' fees directly to their most-streamed artist via Cash App or PayPal. The company also announced plans for fan-centered (user-centric) royalties for 2022, departing from the industry pro-rata model.

major2023-03-01

Direct Artist Payouts program shut down

Tidal ended its Direct Artist Payouts program after enrolling only 70,000 artists and distributing just $500,000, far short of its goals. CEO Jesse Dorogusker acknowledged the program's structural flaw: it concentrated payouts on listeners' top artist, leaving less for emerging artists. Funds were redirected to TIDAL RISING, an emerging artist support program, which Tidal said would receive more than 10x what DAP had distributed.

major2023-05-10

Shareholder lawsuit dismissed; judge calls deal 'terrible'

Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick of the Delaware Court of Chancery dismissed a shareholder lawsuit brought by the City of Coral Springs Police Officers' Pension Plan over Block's Tidal acquisition, while noting the purchase 'seemed, by all accounts, a terrible business decision.' The ruling recounted that Dorsey came up with the idea while vacationing with Jay-Z in the Hamptons in August 2020, that Tidal had only 2.1 million paying subscribers by mid-2020 (versus Spotify's 138 million, Apple Music's 60 million and Amazon Music's 55 million), and that it had logged multimillion-dollar losses for each of the preceding ten quarters. The judge held that a board of mostly disinterested, independent directors is free to make a terrible business decision in good faith.

major2023-06-27

Norway drops fake streams criminal charges

After nearly five years of investigation, Norwegian prosecutors (Okokrim) dropped the fake streams case against Tidal, finding the evidence insufficient to bring charges. The investigation had examined allegations of manipulating more than 320 million streams for Beyonce and Kanye West albums in 2016.

major2023-08-01

Tidal raises HiFi and Family prices

Tidal raised its US HiFi price from $9.99 to $10.99 a month and HiFi Family from $14.99 to $16.99 from August 1, 2023, and told Music Business Worldwide that similar local-currency increases would follow in all 61 markets where the tiers were offered. HiFi Plus was not included.

major2023-12-07

Tidal cuts 10% of staff under Block austerity

Tidal laid off more than 10% of its staff, approximately 40 employees across various departments including the curation team. The cuts were part of Block's company-wide austerity measures, with Block capping total headcount at 12,000. This represented the first of multiple rounds of layoffs that would significantly reduce Tidal's workforce.

critical2024-02-23

Block records $132M goodwill impairment on Tidal

Block disclosed a $132 million goodwill impairment charge on Tidal in its Q4 2023 financials, suggesting it had overpaid considerably: after adjustments it had paid $237.3 million for an 86.2% stake in 2021. Block's 'Corporate and Other' segment, which it describes as primarily Tidal plus intersegment eliminations, reported revenue of $201M in 2023, down from $206M in 2022, after falling from $55.7M in Q4 2021 to $38M in Q4 2022 (Music Ally, Feb 2023).

major2024-04-10

Free tier eliminated; plans consolidated to $10.99

Tidal removed its free tier and merged HiFi and HiFi Plus into a single $10.99/month plan, giving former HiFi Plus ($19.99) subscribers a price cut, with the DJ Extension moved to a $9/month add-on. The elimination of the free tier created a higher barrier to entry. Military and first responder discounts were discontinued, with existing customers allowed to keep them until June 10, 2024.

minor2024-05-02

Tidal removed from Roku channel store

Tidal was removed from the Roku channel store, eliminating access for Roku device users. This was the first in a series of platform support removals in 2024 that would narrow Tidal's device compatibility and strand users who relied on specific hardware to access the service.

minor2024-07-08

Samsung Smart TV support dropped

Tidal ended support for Samsung Smart TVs, removing the app from Samsung's Tizen OS platform. Samsung TV owners who had been using Tidal on their TVs lost access with limited advance notice. The removal affected a large installed base, as Samsung is the world's largest TV manufacturer.

major2024-07-24

MQA-to-FLAC transition completed with hidden flaws

Tidal announced the completion of its MQA-to-FLAC transition, dropping the proprietary MQA codec in favor of open FLAC and replacing Sony 360 Reality Audio with Dolby Atmos. Tidal's support page acknowledges that some FLAC streams are produced from MQA source files, and months later users discovered tracks labeled as FLAC that were MQA-derived. According to GoldenSound's investigation (Headphonesty), a major music publisher had not received any requests from Tidal for lossless masters, and Tidal reportedly closed inquiries about its transition without comment.

minor2024-10-28

Plex terminates Tidal integration

Plex shut down its Tidal music integration, ending a partnership that had allowed Plex users to stream Tidal content through the Plex interface. Users who relied on this integration for their home media setup lost access to their Tidal library within Plex, with FreeYourMusic offering migration tools as an alternative.

critical2024-10-30

Dorsey orders Tidal layoffs, removing product management and marketing

In a note to staff viewed by Fortune, Jack Dorsey told Tidal it needed to 'build like a startup again' and said the company would part ways with a number of team members. Product management and product marketing functions were to be removed entirely, and the design team reduced. Dorsey gave no headcount; company insiders speculated that as many as 100 employees, roughly a quarter of staff, could be laid off. Engineering reductions were to be considered over the following weeks.

critical2024-11-07

Block scales back Tidal investment for bitcoin mining

In a shareholder letter, Block announced it was 'scaling back its investment in TIDAL' and winding down its decentralized tech arm TBD to redirect resources toward bitcoin mining and the Bitkey self-custody wallet, signaling Tidal was no longer a strategic priority.

major2024-12-31

Block books $133.8M more in Tidal impairments for Q4 2024

In the fourth quarter of 2024 Block recognized a $73.5 million goodwill impairment for its TIDAL reporting unit, plus $60.3 million of impairment charges on certain TIDAL assets. Block attributed the goodwill charge to changes in TIDAL's strategic focus, including terminations of certain revenue arrangements and investment into new product areas.

major2025-03-25

Block cuts 931 more positions in third layoff round

Block laid off 931 employees, roughly 8% of its staff, its first major layoff since cutting about 1,000 roles in January 2024. Jack Dorsey's email cited 'shifting strategic needs' and 'performance' reasons. Block also closed 748 open roles, with unclear implications for Tidal staffing.

minor2025-05-01

Forced terms update blocks app until accepted

Tidal pushed updated terms of service that blocked the entire application until users accepted, with no explanation of changes and no option to decline. The update included expanded AI content rights, changed consumer withdrawal rights, and eliminated free subscription references. The arbitration opt-out required mailing a physical form to Block's Oakland, California office within 30 days, with no digital alternative available for the digital-only service.

major2025-11-17

Tidal Upload launches; uploaded tracks earn no streaming royalties

Tidal launched Tidal Upload, letting independent US artists publish tracks directly to the service without a distributor, at no cost. Tracks uploaded this way do not generate streaming royalties; earning opportunities come through playlist promotion with Cash App payments and an Upload Headliners contest with $1 million in prizes.

major2025-11-19

Block adds $5 billion to its stock buyback program

Block's board approved a $5.0 billion increase to its Class A share repurchase program; about $1.1 billion had remained under the prior $4 billion authorization as of September 30, 2025. Block said the goal of the program is to return capital to stockholders.

critical2026-02-26

Block cuts more than 4,000 jobs, over 40% of its workforce

Jack Dorsey announced that Block, which operates Square, Cash App and Tidal, was cutting more than 4,000 employees, taking its workforce from over 10,000 to just under 6,000; the stock rose more than 24% after hours. Block's 8-K put the cut at more than 40% of its workforce with $450-500 million in charges. No Tidal-specific count was reported.

major2026-06-04

Tidal launches direct-to-fan sales for independent artists

Independent US artists can sell tracks and albums directly to fans through Tidal Upload at prices they set, keeping 90% of each sale before payment processing fees and taxes, with payouts into their Square accounts. Fans can buy and download tracks without a paid Tidal subscription.

major2026-06-29

Tidal demonetizes and labels wholly AI-generated music

Tidal published a policy that music it identifies as 100% AI-generated cannot earn royalties or be sold direct-to-fan, effective on publication, with listener-facing AI tags and removal of fraudulent tracks taking effect on July 15. Tidal's support page says users can turn off AI-labeled recordings in Settings.

major2026-08-03

Tidal raises subscription prices again

From each subscriber's first billing date on or after August 3, 2026, Tidal's individual price rose from £10.99 to £12.99 in the UK, and What Hi-Fi reported increases from $10.99 to $11.99 in the US and AU$12.99 to AU$15.99 in Australia. In the US, ecoustics reported, Family rose from $16.99 to $19.99 and Student from $5.49 to $6.99.

minor2026-08-31

Tidal drops its platform fee on direct-to-fan sales

Tidal's support page, updated August 31, 2026, states that it charges artists no platform fee for Direct-to-Fan Sales (at the June launch, artists kept 90% of each sale); artists remain responsible for Square's payment processing fees. Sellers must be US-based, while fans can buy in the US, Canada, the UK, Switzerland and the European Economic Area.

Evidence (54 citations)

D2: Business Customer Exploitation

D4: Lock-in & Switching Costs

Scoring Log (6 entries)
fact-audit2026-10-24FABRICATION FOUND

Checked 67 items (28 timeline, 33 evidence, 4 milestones, 2 alternatives) + prose. 23 verified, 31 corrected (11 date-only), 13 re-sourced, 0 removed; 11 evidence items added for true details split off multi-source timeline items. Invented: timeline[16] 'artist groups who filed the complaints expressed disappointment' at the 2023 dismissal, contradicted by complainant Tono's statement that it was confident Okokrim investigated properly (en.tono.no 2023-06-30). Unsupported (trimmed from prose): 'Tidal's Fair Trade Music Policy' (searched the exact phrase with Tidal and tidal.com; only Jay-Z's 2015 'fair trade' remark found); artists' 'full control over pricing'; '721,000 US users' (searched '721,000'/'721 thousand' with Tidal; not on Headphones Addict); Block 'over 2,000 positions' in three rounds Jan 2024-Mar 2025 (TechCrunch 2025-03-25 and CoinMarketCap 2026-02-09 give ~1,000 + 931). Main fixes: Chen left Apr 17 2015 weeks (not two months) after relaunch; Jay-Z's Aspiro purchase completed Mar 13 2015; Square (not Block) closed Apr 30 2021, paying $237.3M for 86.2% after a $297M announced price; Okokrim's fourth complainant was the Musicians' Union; revenue figures are Block's 'Corporate and Other' segment; Tidal Oct 2024 cut size was speculation; Block March 2025 cut was ~8% and its second major round since Jan 2024; 10% bitcoin buying began May 2024 not Nov 2024; HiFi was $10.99 not $9.99 before consolidation; Trustpilot 2.0 not 2.2; present-tense prices updated for Aug 2026 Tidal and Feb 2026 Spotify increases; junk sources (MyFix.IT, UkeySoft, ViWizard) replaced with Tidal Support, Headphonesty and Digital Music News.

regrade2026-10-24RESCORED

33->31. Since Oct 2025: Tidal Upload (Nov 2025, no streaming royalties), Block's $5B buyback increase (Nov 19 2025) and >40% workforce cut (Feb 26 2026, $495M charges), direct-to-fan sales (Jun 2026, fee cut 10%->0% Aug 31), AI-music demonetization and labels (Jun-Jul 2026), US price rise to $11.99 / Family $19.99 (Aug 3 2026). D1 5->4 (recalibration: device removals, free-tier removal and price rises fit 4-5 but the core hi-res product improved in 2024; 4 not 5). D3 5->6 (event: Q4 2024 $73.5M goodwill + $60.3M asset impairments found in 10-K, $2.3B 2025 buybacks and $5B authorization increase concurrent with Block's >40% layoff). D4 3->2 (recalibration: no DRM library, comparable catalogs, playlist transfer tools, self-service deletion). D8 2->1 (recalibration: open FLAC, no exclusives, no rival acquisitions, small challenger matches 0-1). D9 6->7 (event: Feb 2026 >40% Block layoff during buybacks and 25% gross-profit growth, dual-class 53% Class B voting power). D10 4->3 (recalibration: old score rested on speculative 'potential consumer protection issues'; probe dropped 2023, Jay-Z-era suits resolved, only ToS/arbitration terms now). Eras: all six re-dated to inflection events (2014-10-01->2014-10-28 launch; 2015-04-01->2015-03-13 Jay-Z purchase closes; 2017-01-01->2017-01-20 DN subscriber report; 2021-04-01->2021-04-30 Square closing; 2024-01-01->2023-12-07 Tidal 10% layoff, relabeled 'Austerity & Abandonment'->'Block Austerity Cuts'; 'Neglected Subsidiary' 2026-02-15->2024-11-07 Block scales back investment); new era 'Artist Commerce Pivot' 2025-11-17 (Tidal Upload, with Block buyback/layoffs). Era 3 D5 raised to 4 for the subscriber and stream-count allegations. Historical gap-fills: 2016 Yesh royalty suit, 2016 Pablo consumer suit and 2019 dismissal, 2016 Prince estate suit and 2018 settlement, 2017 Kanye deal termination, Aug 2023 price rise, Q4 2024 impairments. Category 'Music Streaming' looks right.

restore-check2026-10-24NO CHANGE

Checked 2 removed/trimmed candidates: 0 restored, 0 partly restored, 2 confirmed removed, 0 already present. timeline:update:16 — CONFIRMED REMOVED: the dropped sub-claim was that Norwegian artist groups expressed disappointment at the June 2023 dismissal. The Local's June 27, 2023 article (https://www.thelocal.no/20230627/norway-drops-fake-stream-charges-against-tidal), read in full, reports the complaints and dismissal but no such reaction. Complainant TONO's June 30, 2023 statement (https://en.tono.no/okokrim-henlegger-tidal-etterforskning/) expresses confidence in the investigation and acknowledges the dismissal. Rett24's June 27, 2023 report (https://rett24.no/articles/okokrim-henlegger-saken-om-strommetall-hos-tidal) likewise supplies no disappointment statement. Three searches checked the exact English reaction, Norwegian skuffet/henlagt terms and the named complainants; no supporting reporting found. timeline:update:26 — CONFIRMED REMOVED: dropped sub-claims were a third significant layoff round by March 25, 2025, three rounds in 14 months, and a significantly hollowed-out parent. TechCrunch's March 25, 2025 original reporting (https://techcrunch.com/2025/03/25/read-the-email-jack-dorsey-sent-when-he-cut-931-of-blocks-staff/) identifies January 2024 as the previous major round and supplies no three-round or hollowed-out claim. Three searches checked the third-round wording, a possible intervening round and three-round wording with date drift. The Block's February 8, 2026 report (https://www.theblock.co/news/business/2026-02-08-jack-dorseys-block-reportedly-cutting-up-to-10-of-workforce-in-latest-efficiency-push-bloomberg-388971) dates the third significant reduction to February 2026, roughly two years after January 2024. CoinMarketCap's February 9, 2026 article, already an evidence item in the product, was also read (https://coinmarketcap.com/academy/article/jack-dorseys-block-cutting-10percent-of-staff-in-third-layoff-since-2024) and confirms that later timing. This does not establish the dropped March 2025 claim; no additional restoration is warranted. Both original URLs were read live before searches and explicitly attempted via Wayback; both archive requests failed with connection refused, which was not treated as evidence against either claim. Total research: 6 web searches and 11 fetch-page.py page calls. No items removed and no scores changed.

Deep Enrichment2026-03-13
Alternatives Review2026-02-21GOOD
Initial Scoring2026-02-15