Tony's Chocolonely
Dutch mission-driven chocolate company focused on ending illegal child labor and modern slavery in the cocoa industry through its 5 Sourcing Principles, Fairtrade certification, and Tony's Open Chain initiative.
Score generated by AI agents based on publicly cited evidence and reviewed by the project maintainer. Not independently validated. Last assessed 2026-10-26. Score revised 2026-10-26: 18 → 16.
Score History
Timeline events are AI-curated from public reporting. Score trajectory is derived from documented events.
Founded by journalist Teun van de Keuken after his 'chocolate criminal' campaign, Tony's launched 5,000 Fairtrade milk chocolate bars in November 2005, processed by Barry Callebaut. A 2007 Amsterdam court ruling backed its slave-free claims, from 2008 1% of turnover funded the Chocolonely Foundation, and Henk Jan Beltman took the helm in 2010. Its cocoa was Fairtrade-certified but not yet traceable to specific cooperatives, so child labor in its supply chain went unmonitored.
In June 2013 Tony's launched its first bar made from fully traceable cocoa bought from ABOCFA in Ghana and Ecookim in Ivory Coast, and in December it became a certified B Corp. It entered the US through Portland in 2015, deployed CLMRS child labor monitoring at partner cooperatives from 2017, and by 2018 was the Netherlands' top-selling chocolate brand with about 19% of the market. Still founder-led and without paid media, it was scaling a direct-sourcing model.
Tony's opened its sourcing model to other brands through Tony's Open Chain, then took outside capital: Verlinvest and JamJar bought 28% in 2020, and Verlinvest became the largest shareholder in February 2022 when Beltman sold part of his stake. Expanded monitoring exposed 1,701 child labor cases in 2020/21, Slave Free Chocolate dropped Tony's over its Barry Callebaut ties, look-alike bars targeted big brands, and a 2021 UK campaign ended its no-paid-media policy. Douglas Lamont succeeded Beltman as CEO in October 2022 as inflation drove price changes.
Tony's introduced the Mission Lock golden share as Verlinvest moved to sole control, cleared by the Dutch ACM on 29 June 2023. Under investor majority ownership it scaled into mass retail (a national Walmart partnership in 2024), invested in paid media and a first TV ad, and passed record cocoa costs into price rises of about 20-30% while keeping its 180g bar. Revenue reached EUR 240M in 2024/25 with the US its largest market; expanded monitoring found 3,448 child labor cases while the rate at long-term co-ops stayed below 5%.
Alternatives
B Corp certified (since 2009), organic fair trade chocolate with a regenerative agriculture focus. Easy switch — available at same retailers. Slightly less aggressive on the activism front but strong on environmental sustainability.
Fairtrade chocolate part-owned by Kuapa Kokoo, a Ghanaian cocoa farmers' cooperative, which holds 20% of the shares and 40% board influence after manufacturer Ludwig Weinrich took a majority stake. Easy switch: widely available in the UK, growing US presence.
Fair Trade certified chocolate that donates 10% of net profits to wildlife conservation. Fairtrade cocoa, non-GMO, gluten-free options. Easy switch — available at major US grocery chains. Less focused on labor justice than Tony's but solid ethical alternative.
Dimensional Breakdown
Summaries below were written by AI agents based on the cited evidence. They are editorial interpretations, not independent research findings.
Dimension History
Timeline (51 events)
Founder reports himself as 'chocolate criminal'
Dutch journalist Teun van de Keuken reported himself to police as complicit in slavery for buying chocolate made with cocoa from Ivorian plantations, invoking Dutch law on receiving illegally obtained goods ('fencing'). P+ dates the televised police report to 12 February 2004. He reported himself again as a 'chocolate criminal' in March 2004, this time to the public prosecutor, according to Reformatorisch Dagblad. The stunt, part of a chocolate series on his consumer TV show Keuringsdienst van Waarde, was designed to show that consumers of mainstream chocolate were complicit in slavery. In April 2007 a court decided he would not be prosecuted on legal grounds, and the campaign led him to launch his own slave-free chocolate bars in November 2005.
First Tony's Chocolonely bars sold in Netherlands
Teun van de Keuken and the Keuringsdienst van Waarde crew produced 5,000 Fairtrade milk chocolate bars branded 'Tony's Chocolonely', launched on 29 November 2005, and sold 20,000 bars in two days. The name references Teun's feeling of being the only person in the chocolate industry interested in eradicating slavery.
Amsterdam court rules Tony's bars are slave-free
After a Dutch importer of Swiss chocolates sued Tony's Chocolonely, a court in Amsterdam ruled that there was sufficient evidence that Tony's products were manufactured without the help of slaves, validating the company's sourcing claims.
Chocolonely Foundation established with 1% turnover
When Tony's first turned profitable, the company established the independent Chocolonely Foundation, funded by 1% of annual turnover. The foundation supports cocoa farming communities with activities outside the direct supply chain, including education and community development programs in Ghana and Cote d'Ivoire. The foundation operates independently with its own board.
Henk Jan Beltman joins as Chief Chocolate Officer
Former Heineken, Vrumona and Innocent Drinks executive Henk Jan Beltman took the helm at Tony's Chocolonely in 2010 as Chief Chocolate Officer (CEO), bringing professional CPG management to the activist startup, and became majority shareholder in 2011. By 2021 his take-home pay was only six times that of an entry-level graduate. Under his leadership the company professionalized its operations while maintaining its mission-first approach.
Tony's launches first fully traceable Bean to Bar chocolate
In June 2013 Tony's launched its first Bean to Bar bar made from fully traceable cocoa, sourced from farmers in the ABOCFA cooperative in Ghana and Ecookim in Ivory Coast whom the company said it met personally. Tony's called it an important step towards 100% slave-free chocolate.
Tony's becomes a certified B Corp
Tony's Chocolonely achieved B Corp certification in December 2013, validating its governance, social, and environmental practices against third-party standards. Its overall B Impact score was 95.9 at certification and is 125.0 in its current assessment.
Tony's enters the United States through Portland
Tony's crossed into the US market in October 2015, starting in Portland, Oregon. Its first US bars were sold at fellow B Corp New Seasons Market, followed soon after by other supermarkets, delicatessens and gift shops.
CLMRS child labor monitoring deployed across cooperatives
Tony's implemented the Child Labour Monitoring and Remediation System (CLMRS), developed by the ILO and adapted for the cocoa industry by the International Cocoa Initiative and Nestle, at its partner cooperatives in Ghana and Cote d'Ivoire from 2017. Community facilitators visit households annually to identify child labor cases and arrange remediation, with follow-up visits to confirm a child has stopped working. In January 2023, Tony's told Confectionery Production that remediation and case closure had accelerated to 9-12 months. Its 2023/24 Open Chain Impact Report, registered as its UK modern slavery statement, records 18,747 cocoa-growing households participating in CLMRS in 2022/23, rather than in 2017.
Tony's becomes Netherlands' top-selling chocolate brand
Tony's Chocolonely captured about 19% of the Dutch chocolate market in 2018, surpassing established multinationals Verkade, Mars, and Nestle to become the biggest chocolate brand in the Netherlands. This milestone demonstrated that a mission-driven premium brand could outcompete incumbent industry players on the basis of ethical differentiation rather than price competition or shelf-space dominance.
Tony's Open Chain launched for industry-wide ethical sourcing
Tony's launched Tony's Open Chain, a B2B initiative inviting other chocolate makers to adopt its 5 Sourcing Principles: 100% traceable beans, a higher price, strong cooperatives, long-term partnerships, and better quality and productivity. Rather than hoarding its ethical supply chain as a competitive advantage, Tony's opened its sourcing model to the industry. Albert Heijn's Delicata range was the first to join.
Tony's endorses EU call for mandatory due diligence regulation
Tony's Chocolonely endorsed a public call to the European Union for stronger regulation of the cocoa industry, specifically supporting mandatory human rights and environmental due diligence legislation. The company lobbied alongside NGOs and civil society organizations, positioning itself as one of the few CPG companies actively advocating for increased government oversight of its own industry.
Verlinvest and JamJar take 28% minority stake
Tony's Chocolonely accepted a EUR 36 million investment from Verlinvest (the investment vehicle of Belgium's de Spoelberch family, major AB InBev shareholders) and JamJar Investments (the fund of the Innocent Drinks founders), who together took a 28% minority stake. 51% of the voting power stayed with Chief Chocolate Officer Henk Jan Beltman. The money was to fund international growth and a planned chocolate factory and visitor centre. INSEAD's June 2021 case study described the USA, UK and DACH region as the focus of expansion following the investment.
Tony's files amicus brief in US Supreme Court child labor case
Tony's Chocolonely filed an amicus brief supporting the respondents in Nestle USA v. Doe, a US Supreme Court Alien Tort Statute case in which six Malian men alleged they were trafficked as children to Ivorian cocoa plantations. The brief argued that Tony's sourcing model shows effective due diligence is feasible and replicable. During oral argument on 1 December 2020, plaintiffs' counsel Paul Hoffman cited Tony's amicus brief, alongside a brief from small and midsized chocolate companies, as examples of doing business in Ivory Coast without facilitating child slave labor. In June 2021 the Court held the claims were an impermissible extraterritorial application of the ATS, without reaching the underlying labor practices.
Look-alike 'Sweet Solution' bars pulled after one day
Tony's launched four limited-edition chocolate bars modeled on Twix, Toblerone, Kit Kat and Ferrero Rocher to highlight child labor in those brands' supply chains. Tony's alleged that big chocolate makers pressured UK supermarkets to remove the bars, which were pulled from shelves after one day; Ferrero denied asking Sainsbury's to remove them. All profits were donated to 100WEEKS, a platform fighting extreme poverty through direct cash transfers to women.
Removed from Slave Free Chocolate ethical suppliers list
The American organization Slave Free Chocolate removed Tony's Chocolonely from its list of ethical chocolate suppliers, citing Tony's manufacturing partnership with Barry Callebaut. Founder Ayn Riggs said the Barry Callebaut link 'ties them to child slavery' and lets Tony's produce chocolate more cheaply than companies doing everything ethically. Tony's defended the partnership as necessary to show full traceability is possible at scale.
Tony's delivers 66,000-signature EU due diligence petition
Tony's Chocolonely and MEP Lara Wolters presented a petition signed by more than 66,000 consumers to EU Justice Commissioner Didier Reynders, pushing for ambitious human rights and environmental due diligence legislation. Tony's urged a directive holding companies across all sectors, including high-risk sectors such as chocolate, legally accountable for human rights and environmental standards aligned with UN Guiding Principles and OECD guidelines.
1,701 child labor cases disclosed in annual report
Tony's annual Fair Report for 2020/21, published in December 2021, revealed 1,701 cases of child labor in its supply chain, a dramatic increase from 387 the previous year. Most of the increase came from two newly onboarded cooperatives with child labor rates of about 50%, which accounted for 1,426 cases; the remaining 275 were at other partner cooperatives. When The Times reported the figures in February 2022, the disclosure prompted widespread media criticism questioning the gap between Tony's marketing and supply chain reality.
Verlinvest becomes Tony's largest shareholder
Verlinvest, the investment fund of AB InBev's De Spoelberch family, raised its stake in Tony's Chocolonely from 26% to 42% by buying shares from Chief Chocolate Officer Henk Jan Beltman, whose stake fell from 42% to 26%, according to Het Financieele Dagblad. Beltman used the sale to repay debts incurred when he bought out other co-founders.
Tony's raises Dutch webshop price of 180g bars to EUR 3.29
Tony's said it could not fully absorb a 13% increase in ingredient costs without jeopardising its mission, and set the webshop price of its 180 gram bars at EUR 3.29 from 1 June 2022. The company published the cost drivers behind the increase.
Tony's cuts UK recommended price of 180g bars
Tony's recommended a new UK retail price for its 180g bars, cutting it from £3.49 to £2.99 from 1 October 2022 as inflation squeezed shoppers. It noted that pricing always remains at the sole discretion of the retailer.
Douglas Lamont succeeds Beltman as CEO
After almost 12 years as Chief Chocolate Officer, Henk Jan Beltman stepped down and was succeeded by Douglas Lamont, who had spent nine years as CEO of Innocent Drinks. Beltman remained as shareholder and advisor on the supervisory board. Lamont, who brought experience scaling innocent internationally, also co-chairs the UK Better Business Act campaign.
Consumer Reports finds lead and cadmium in Tony's dark bar
Consumer Reports' 2022 testing found lead and cadmium in most popular dark chocolate products, including Tony's 70% dark chocolate bar. Tony's said the metals occur naturally in soil and during harvesting, that its levels are within EFSA and FDA safe ranges, and that the study used California OEHHA guidelines, which are not food safety standards.
Child labor at long-term partner co-ops 4.4% as revenue hits EUR 133M
Tony's 2021/22 FAIR report put child labor at 4.4% in its long-term partner cocoa communities, against an industry-wide average of 46.5%, while net revenue grew 21% to EUR 133.1 million. The company said its sourcing model substantially reduces child labor while the business grows.
Baronie & Cemoi join as second Open Chain processor
Chocolate processor Baronie & Cemoi became the second processing partner in Tony's Open Chain, alongside Barry Callebaut, which continues to produce Tony's own chocolate. With a cocoa production facility in Cote d'Ivoire and processing in Bourbourg, France, the addition gave Open Chain Mission Allies a choice of processors.
Tony's sets EUR 3.69 suggested price for 180g bar
Tony's introduced a new suggested retail price of EUR 3.69 for its 180-gram bar from 3 April 2023. It said the increase was needed to keep paying farmers a higher price towards a living income and to cover higher costs.
Mission Lock governance with golden share introduced
Tony's introduced Tony's Mission Lock, an independent legal structure holding a 'golden share' in the company. Three Mission Guardians were appointed, including Seth Goldman (founder of Honest Tea) as chair. The golden share prevents any legal changes to Tony's mission or 5 Sourcing Principles regardless of future ownership. Guardians can escalate concerns to the Enterprise Chamber of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal and publish concerns in national newspapers.
ACM clears Verlinvest to take sole control of Tony's
The Dutch Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) decided on 29 June 2023 that Verlinvest S.A. may acquire sole control of Tony's Factory B.V. (Tony's Chocolonely), finding no reason to expect the concentration to significantly impede competition. The approval followed a EUR 20M round from existing shareholders that lifted Verlinvest to a majority of shares and votes.
Tony's begins investing in paid media
Tony's, which had shunned paid media in favour of earned and organic channels, began investing in paid media to grow its reach. UK and Ireland head of marketing Nicola Matthews said the brand had become impatient with how fast it could spread its mission, contrasting experiential events reaching 10,000 people with paid media that might reach 15 million.
Tony's posts EUR 2.7M net loss despite 23% growth
Turnover rose 23% to more than EUR 150 million in the year to September 2023, helped by an average 10% price rise in the Netherlands, but Tony's recorded a net loss of EUR 2.7 million because it did not want to pass all higher costs on to consumers and invested in Open Chain and new products. CFO Jan Huij said shareholders had given Tony's several years of room before returning to profit, but 'it shouldn't last too long either'.
Mondelez sues over Milka look-alike packaging campaign
Mondelez International sued Tony's Chocolonely in Germany over a lilac wrapper mimicking Milka, one of four temporary 'Tony's Fair Alternative' wrappers parodying Ferrero, Mars, Milka and Nestle bars to highlight child labor in cocoa. A Hamburg court granted Mondelez's demand for a penalty payment for Tony's use of the colour. Tony's said it would appeal, stopped selling the lilac bars and replaced them on its campaign website with a grey wrapper marked 'formerly lilac'. In a 1 March 2024 MT/Sprout interview, creative director Arjen Klinkenberg welcomed the substantial media attention generated by the lawsuit. Tony's answered with a grey-wrapper poster urging it to pay farmers rather than lawyers; Klinkenberg described making the campaign and its message go viral as the desired marketing outcome.
Tony's announces national Walmart partnership in the US
Tony's Chocolonely announced a new national retail partnership with Walmart, putting it in 20% more US stores over the following year, adding to existing distribution through Whole Foods, Target, Safeway, and CVS. Since 2020, Tony's had nearly quadrupled its US business. The partnership marked a shift from premium specialty retail toward mass-market distribution.
Tony's raises UK recommended price to £3.50
Citing soaring cocoa prices, Tony's set a new recommended retail price for its classic UK bars of £3.50 in store and £3.98 in its own Choco Shop from 8 July 2024, reversing its 2022 cut to £2.99.
Tony's opposes EUDR deforestation regulation delay
Tony's Chocolonely urged against any further delays to the EU Deforestation Regulation (EUDR), calling the proposed 12-month postponement a further risk to farmers' livelihoods. It said its farms are '100% polygon mapped' and that it implements its 5 sourcing principles for all its cocoa.
Revenue hits EUR 200M with record growth across markets
Tony's Chocolonely reported 33.2% year-on-year growth in net revenue, to EUR 200.1 million, for the financial year ending 30 September 2024. US sales rose 85%, from EUR 27.5 million to EUR 50.8 million, helped by launches at Walmart and Kroger, and UK and Ireland combined revenue grew 45% to EUR 46.5 million. Gross margin slipped from 40.9% to 40.5% as cocoa prices outpaced its price adjustments.
Tony's recalls two bars that may contain small stones
Tony's Chocolonely Inc. voluntarily recalled seven lots of its Dark Almond Sea Salt Bar (6.35oz) and Everything Bar (6.35oz) in the US because the products may contain small stones. Batches of the same two products were also recalled in the UK and Ireland.
Tony's recalls hollow Easter eggs over metal fragments
Tony's recalled certain batches of its Milk Chocolate Large Hollow Easter Egg and Caramel Sea Salt Large Hollow Easter Egg from UK stores because of the potential presence of metal fragments. Asda told customers to return the products for a full refund.
Ranked #1 on Chocolate Scorecard for sixth consecutive year
Tony's Chocolonely earned the top spot on the 2025 Chocolate Scorecard published by Be Slavery Free, scoring 91% overall and ranking in the top two for every major category: traceability, living income, child and forced labor mitigation, climate and deforestation, and pesticide use. This marked the sixth consecutive year Tony's led the scorecard among over 60 assessed manufacturers.
Named to TIME100 Most Influential Companies
Under the descriptive subtitle 'Cocoa changemaker', TIME named Tony's Chocolonely to its 2025 TIME100 Most Influential Companies list. The recognition cited Tony's Open Chain, which gives other brands access to vetted cocoa partners; six more companies joined in the past year, for a total of 20 Mission Allies, including Ben & Jerry's and MrBeast's Feastables in the US.
UK shelf prices up 12.6% as Tony's vows not to shrink
The Grocer found pre-promotional prices of like-for-like Tony's products up an average 12.6% across the UK's big four grocers year on year, with Rainbow Mix 135g up 20% to £6 at Morrisons and 180g bars up 14.3% to £4 at Tesco, Sainsbury's and Morrisons. Tony's vowed not to shrink or reformulate its chocolate and said it had passed on some of 18 months of inflation while launching a cheaper 90g bar.
Tony's calls out Morrisons and M&S over 'dupe' bars
Tony's publicly called out Morrisons and M&S on social media over chunky own-label bars it said copied the look and flavours of its own, inviting both retailers to join Tony's Open Chain instead. The Grocer reported Tony's had no plans for further action, and both retailers rejected the claim.
FAIR report: 3,448 child labor cases found, 813 resolved
Tony's 2024/25 FAIR report said 32,133 cocoa farmers (+58%) were paid at least the Living Income Reference Price, yet 59.4% of farmers at its longest-term partner co-ops still do not earn a living income. It found 3,448 child labor cases as CLMRS monitoring expanded to 93.7% of households, resolved 813, and kept prevalence at its longest-term co-ops below 5% against an industry average of 46.7%.
Revenue hits EUR 240M as US becomes largest market
For the year to 30 September 2025 Tony's reported 20% revenue growth to EUR 240 million, with US revenue up 50% to overtake the Netherlands as its biggest market and volume up 4%. Operating profit (EBIT) was EUR 0.2 million, up EUR 3 million, as it reinvested in production and distribution.
CEO says prices rose 20-30% amid cocoa and tariff costs
CEO Douglas Lamont told Reuters the company had faced a 'cost tsunami' from cocoa and tariffs, and Tony's had raised its prices by some 20-30% over the previous 12-18 months after cocoa hit record highs in 2024.
Tony's airs its first-ever TV commercial on Sky
Tony's launched its first-ever TV commercial globally, 'There's Fight in Every Bite', across Sky channels in the UK from 10 February to 6 April 2026. It secured £500k worth of Sky Media advertising by winning the Champions category of the Sky Zero Footprint Fund.
Tony's urges rivals not to lower chocolate prices
As cocoa prices fell from their 2024 peaks, Tony's Chocolonely publicly urged rival chocolate brands not to cut retail prices. UK and Ireland head of marketing Nicola Matthews said chocolate 'shouldn't be cheap, because when it is cheap, the people at the start of the supply chain are paying the price', arguing that sustained prices leave room in the value chain to pay cocoa farmers more.
Tony's launches £2.25 price-marked 90g bars
Tony's launched 90g price-marked packs at £2.25 for UK convenience stores, available exclusively through Booker wholesale. It was the brand's first price-marked chocolate bar, designed for the convenience channel.
Tony's signs coalition letter against reopening the EUDR
Tony's Chocolonely was among the companies and NGOs, including ALDI South, Barry Callebaut, Ferrero, Nestle and Rainforest Alliance, that urged EU Environment Commissioner Jessika Roswall to oppose any reopening of the EU Deforestation Regulation after its April review. The letter said remaining uncertainties should be handled through guidance rather than a third reopening.
Tony's one of two green-rated firms on 2026 Chocolate Scorecard
Tony's was one of only two companies to achieve an overall green score in the 2026 Chocolate Scorecard coordinated by Be Slavery Free, with HALBA taking the top spot. It ranked first on living income and received the Gender Award, but scored yellow on pesticides (4th of 34) under stricter criteria.
Waitrose expands Tony's Open Chain cocoa sourcing
Waitrose expanded its Tony's Open Chain partnership so that over half of its seasonal chocolate will be sourced via Open Chain mass balance, increasing its Open Chain cocoa bean purchases by 53%. The move builds on Waitrose becoming the first UK retailer to join as a Mission Ally in 2024.
EU greenwashing rules force review of Open Chain logo
Tony's said the EU's Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition (EmpCo) Directive, which bans self-made labels implying environmental or social performance unless based on a certification scheme, affects how its Tony's Open Chain logo can be used on pack. It was reviewing and adapting the logo and its sustainability communications, and said it welcomed the rules.
Evidence (50 citations)
D1: User Value Erosion
D2: Business Customer Exploitation
D3: Shareholder Extraction
D4: Lock-in & Switching Costs
D5: Twiddling & Algorithmic Opacity
D6: Dark Patterns
D7: Advertising & Monetization Pressure
D8: Competitive Conduct
D9: Labor & Governance
D10: Regulatory & Legal Posture
Scoring Log (6 entries)
18→16. D8 2→1 (correction: the fact audit found no critic for the 'price signaling' framing of the 2026 Grocer item; remaining conduct is parody campaigns, one trademark injunction and Open Chain sharing, which fits the 0-1 row). D10 2→1 (recalibration: proactive pro-regulation lobbying and EmpCo compliance fit 0-1; one trademark injunction is not regulatory resistance). Other dims unchanged: D1 2 holds as 20-30% price rises track five-fold-plus cocoa costs with no shrinkflation, offset by two April 2025 recalls; D9 4 holds with 3,448 child labor cases found in 2024/25. Eras: 'Activist Startup' (2005-11-29) kept, re-scored (D9 6→5, D8/D10 lowered, no events supported them); 'Dutch Market Leader' re-dated 2013-01-01→2013-06-01 (first fully traceable bean-to-bar bar; no inflection near 1 Jan) and relabeled 'Bean-to-Bar Traceability' (market leadership came in 2018); 'Open Chain Era' (2019-03-01) kept; final era re-dated 2026-02-19 (assessment date)→2023-06-01 (Mission Lock and Verlinvest sole control, ACM 2023-06-29) and relabeled 'Global Scaling'→'Verlinvest Majority Scaling'. Since Oct 2025: UK shelf prices +12.6% (Grocer, Nov 2025) and CEO-reported 20-30% price rises; FY2024/25 revenue EUR 240M, EBIT EUR 0.2M; FAIR report 3,448 child labor cases, 813 resolved; first TV ad (Feb 2026); EUDR coalition letter (Mar 2026); 2026 Chocolate Scorecard green; Waitrose Open Chain expansion and EmpCo review of the Open Chain logo (Sep 2026). Mondelez appeal outcome: none found. Alternatives: Divine Chocolate ownership corrected (Kuapa Kokoo now 20%, Weinrich majority). Category Consumer Packaged Goods is correct.
Checked 17 removed/trimmed items: 1 restored, 5 partly restored, 9 confirmed removed, 2 already present. Restored: timeline[0] 12 February 2004 police-report date and fencing-law basis (P+, with RD chronology retained). Partly restored: timeline[8] 18,747 households in 2022/23 (UK-registered Open Chain Impact Report) and company-reported 9-12-month case closure in January 2023 (Confectionery Production); timeline[12] USA/UK/DACH expansion focus (INSEAD); timeline[13] counsel citing Tony's at oral argument (official transcript p.61); timeline[30] post-lawsuit media benefit and attributed viral-marketing intent (MT/Sprout); timeline[38] TIME's Cocoa changemaker subtitle. Added evidence: PARTLY RESTORED — Confectionery Production, 11 January 2023, company-reported 9-12-month remediation and closure. Already present: timeline[41] 32,133 farmers (+58%) in 2024/25 and timeline[33] 100% farm polygon mapping; evidence[8] 15% employee stake in 2020 (not current). Confirmed removed: timeline:update:2 legal precedent; timeline:update:5 B Corp rankings (support found only in excluded vendor marketing); timeline:update:16 June 2022 national Walmart launch/ethical pricing; timeline:update:18 resilience/credibility inference; timeline:update:26 critics alleging price signaling; evidence:update:5 no exclusivity demands; evidence:update:6 no aggressive trade practices; evidence:update:14 no deceptive sizing; evidence:update:21 no child marketing/no deceptive health claims. Unsupported 432 headcount stays excluded. Archive failures are not evidence of falsity. Per-candidate findings in work/restore-review.json. Scores unchanged.
Team audit: checked 67 timeline/evidence/milestone items + 3 alternatives + prose. 15 verified, 33 corrected (8 date-only), 22 re-sourced, 0 removed; 3 evidence items added for true details split off miscited items. Invented (contradicted): timeline[8] 'Ben & Jerry's among the first Open Chain partners' (ConfectioneryNews 2021: Albert Heijn Delicata first; tonysopenchain.com: B&J joined 2022); d2 narrative 'early days selling through Dutch specialty shops' (Tony's FAQ: first bars hit supermarket shelves in 2005). Major fixes: D3 ownership premise outdated (Verlinvest majority/sole control since 2023); Walmart national partnership was 2024 not 2022; price-rise blog was 2022 not 2024; Slave Free Chocolate quotes/figure were from 2022 coverage; 32,133 farmers was a 2024/25 figure; unsupported 432 employees, LIRP EUR 505-669, 18,747 households, B Corp rankings, oral-argument citation, 'viral' Mondelez campaign and 'critics noted price signaling' trimmed; removed a stray 'Forgejo maintainer' artifact from D9 summary.